You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR and officials.
November 10 2026 5.58pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR and officials.


Page 8 of 15 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Dubai Eagle Flag 06 Nov 23 6.38am

Isnt there a sensor in the ball / fob arrangement to notify the ref (fob vibrates) if the ball crosses the goal line between the
posts ?

Originally posted by Fierybiscuits

What about when it’s the goal line?

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Nov 23 7.49am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Isnt there a sensor in the ball / fob arrangement to notify the ref (fob vibrates) if the ball crosses the goal line between the
posts ?

There is for if it crosses the goal line but not for throw-ins. The World Cup ball seems to have the technology but the League probably don't; which is fair enough - how many contentious throw-ins are there?
This rule would be a bit simpler if the ball had to be inside the line instead of partly overhanging from outside it like with corners.


[Link]

 

mars Flag Folkestone 06 Nov 23 12.28pm

Arsenal were robbed no doubt. Don’t blame Arteta and his club for fuming!
Maybe VAR should be ditched?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Nov 23 1.15pm

Originally posted by mars

Arsenal were robbed no doubt. Don’t blame Arteta and his club for fuming!
Maybe VAR should be ditched?

I've never heard them called unlucky before

 


One more point

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Nov 23 1.22pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I've never heard them called unlucky before

No. Quite a few things that almost rhyme with it though.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Nov 23 3.24pm

Originally posted by mars

Arsenal were robbed no doubt. Don’t blame Arteta and his club for fuming!
Maybe VAR should be ditched?

I concur with Simon Jordan who said the following :

"The on-field decision was a goal. VAR's objective after that is to look into the reality of a clear and obvious error. If they haven't got certain camera angles, each part of that conversation has a subjective view to it. If VAR can't categorically say the ball was out, you can't make that decision and you're staying with the on-field decision."

Subsequent photographs and analysis have indicated that the ball was in play.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 06 Nov 23 5.36pm

Originally posted by Willo

I concur with Simon Jordan who said the following :

"The on-field decision was a goal. VAR's objective after that is to look into the reality of a clear and obvious error. If they haven't got certain camera angles, each part of that conversation has a subjective view to it. If VAR can't categorically say the ball was out, you can't make that decision and you're staying with the on-field decision."

Subsequent photographs and analysis have indicated that the ball was in play.

I think the main moan from Arsenal was the push in the back rather than the ball going out of play . That to most observers WAS a clear error

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Nov 23 6.40pm

Originally posted by Elpis

I think the main moan from Arsenal was the push in the back rather than the ball going out of play . That to most observers WAS a clear error

On-field decision was no foul and I support the decision of the VAR who reviewed the incident in detail.

With respect the "Most observers" comment is a generalisation, most certainly those that I have spoken to have agreed with the VAR.The referee deemed the incident physical contact and I for one agree with his judgement.

Edited by Willo (06 Nov 2023 6.44pm)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 06 Nov 23 8.35pm

I’ve absolutely had it with VAR now. This Spurs v Chelsea game just highlights how it’s absolutely taken over and is just killing the game.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 06 Nov 23 8.49pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I’ve absolutely had it with VAR now. This Spurs v Chelsea game just highlights how it’s absolutely taken over and is just killing the game.

True, it should take no more than 30 seconds to come to a decision If you're having to dissect & almost have an autopsy type decision made it needs to go

 


Pro USA & Israel

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Nov 23 8.49pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I’ve absolutely had it with VAR now. This Spurs v Chelsea game just highlights how it’s absolutely taken over and is just killing the game.

It's some game to watch though. Like one of those crazy south American matches. This one would need a Ref Watch programme of its own.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 06 Nov 23 9.08pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

It's some game to watch though. Like one of those crazy south American matches. This one would need a Ref Watch programme of its own.

It is but it would be a million times better without VAR disruptions to play. The decisions are so marginal and cannot be relied upon because of the acknowledged margin of error with the freeze frame technology.

The Son goal looked onside from the conventional angle but no lines were drawn They then used the reverse angle to draw the lines and he looked offside.

The inconsistencies with decisions as well - such as the Udogie two footed challenge. Red card all day long but not given, yet the two Romero challenges…

Over twelve minutes of added time played

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Nov 23 9.26pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

It is but it would be a million times better without VAR disruptions to play. The decisions are so marginal and cannot be relied upon because of the acknowledged margin of error with the freeze frame technology.

The Son goal looked onside from the conventional angle but no lines were drawn They then used the reverse angle to draw the lines and he looked offside.

The inconsistencies with decisions as well - such as the Udogie two footed challenge. Red card all day long but not given, yet the two Romero challenges…

Over twelve minutes of added time played

He's got his red card now! The Spuds down to 9.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Nov 23 7.26am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I’ve absolutely had it with VAR now. This Spurs v Chelsea game just highlights how it’s absolutely taken over and is just killing the game.

I have had a plethora of conversations with passionate devotees of football and they have expressed the view that VAR has 'Destroyed' the game and has not added even a slither of value to the spectacle.

Amongst the criticisms was the all those pauses in play when incidents are dissected to the minutest detail and players, and supporters, have to wait to celebrate a goal.

There was a consensus that it is a pleasure to watch games from the lower divisions when VAR is not operation.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Nov 23 7.47am

Originally posted by Willo

I have had a plethora of conversations with passionate devotees of football and they have expressed the view that VAR has 'Destroyed' the game and has not added even a slither of value to the spectacle.

Amongst the criticisms was the all those pauses in play when incidents are dissected to the minutest detail and players, and supporters, have to wait to celebrate a goal.

There was a consensus that it is a pleasure to watch games from the lower divisions when VAR is not operation.

I still don't understand when VAR can and can't get involved. Dermot Gallagher goes to great lengths to explain what constitutes a clear and obvious error when fouls are or aren't investigated then goals are disallowed for a shoulder being marginally offside which isn't obvious to anybody.
Now they're talking about subjective offside which is another complication.
There is also the question of an infringement being too far back in the build up to a goal.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Nov 23 8.05am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

I still don't understand when VAR can and can't get involved. Dermot Gallagher goes to great lengths to explain what constitutes a clear and obvious error when fouls are or aren't investigated then goals are disallowed for a shoulder being marginally offside which isn't obvious to anybody.
Now they're talking about subjective offside which is another complication.
There is also the question of an infringement being too far back in the build up to a goal.

Rest assured you are not alone, there is total confusion about the whole VAR process.

Apropos "Clear and obvious", this is a subjective decision and subjectivity leads to inconsistency and confusion and indeed frustation.

Regards 'Offsides' we are reminded that this is an issue of FACT but we have witnessed incidents where the protocol in terms of the drawing of lines has not been followed due to human error.Furthermore "Subjective offsides" have added a further layer of complexity.

Indeed any "Infringement" being too far back in the build-up to a goal can be subjective and I suspect supporters and pundits etc etc are totally unclear as to this aspect of the VAR protocol as they are about 'Handball'.

Alas, the debate and discussion is now centred on VAR and not the actual game.

Finally I welcome the comments of Ange Postecoglu which were in stark contrast to the outburst from Arteta who behaved akin to a petulant child.

Edited by Willo (07 Nov 2023 8.07am)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 07 Nov 23 8.18am

Originally posted by Willo

Rest assured you are not alone, there is total confusion about the whole VAR process.

Apropos "Clear and obvious", this is a subjective decision and subjectivity leads to inconsistency and confusion and indeed frustation.

Regards 'Offsides' we are reminded that this is an issue of FACT but we have witnessed incidents where the protocol in terms of the drawing of lines has not been followed due to human error.Furthermore "Subjective offsides" have added a further layer of complexity.

Indeed any "Infringement" being too far back in the build-up to a goal can be subjective and I suspect supporters and pundits etc etc are totally unclear as to this aspect of the VAR protocol as they are about 'Handball'.

Alas, the debate and discussion is now centred on VAR and not the actual game.

Finally I welcome the comments of Ange Postecoglu which were in stark contrast to the outburst from Arteta who behaved akin to a petulant child.

Edited by Willo (07 Nov 2023 8.07am)

All true Willo. The whole situation seems to be getting worse rather than better as those responsible try to be more accurate and take longer and longer.
Maybe they should redefine and clarify the parameters and start again.
I like the suggestion that teams have a set number of challenges, as with cricket, which they retain if upheld rather than VAR being automatically involved in offsides.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Nov 23 9.22am

I heard some chap opine that VAR was supposed to be a "Safety Net" for the officials but the value it has added to the game as a spectacle is "Net zero".

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 07 Nov 23 9.26am

Last night's game was feisty enough without the VAR involvement - which added to the ill temper. VAR is spoiling a good match.

From my weary old point of view I so much preferred watching football pre VAR. It's not that I was always anti, I hung on to justification that it would eliminate refereeing inconsistencies. It's become a laughing stock.

I read I the paper this morning a quote by Pochettino which I thought sums up the issue perfectly: "I trust in VAR. I trust in the car - but not the driver. That's the problem." Very well put Mauricio.

Howard Webb is supposed to be sorting it out, but what surprises me is that there isn't a much louder voice of opposition coming from within the game.

Willo is quite right when he wrote that watching a game officiated by a mere referee is far more enjoyable.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Elpis Flag In a pub 07 Nov 23 9.27am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

I like the suggestion that teams have a set number of challenges, as with cricket, which they retain if upheld rather than VAR being automatically involved in offsides.

I hate that idea . Would lead to poor decisions at the end of games when teams have run out of 'challenges '. Sounds like more chaos to me .
I would go back to referee's actually refereeing the game ,linesmen flagging for offside and goals being goals when the ball is in the net and the ref ref indicates it is .

VAR could still have its use ,when and only when the referee decides he needs help ,if he is not sure on something he can ask VAR for clarification . Not what we had last night at Spurs where VAR was basically refereeing the match .
As Postor.....the Spurs manager said after , let the refs ref and lineman give offsides , we will take it on the chin if they make a mistake

 

Page 8 of 15 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR and officials.