You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Euro 2024
November 6 2026 6.49pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Euro 2024


Page 12 of 39 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >
Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Jun 24 11.33am

Originally posted by Willo

I highlighted the stats.Having watched the game I have not been left with the feeling that Alexander-Arnold was an effective member of the midfield !

A dire performance all-round,however we were not defeated, have attained 4 pts from our opening 2 games and will almost certainly progress to the Round of 16.
I am reminded of the term "Slow burner" !

I am reminded of Italian 90 when the players revolted and told Bobby Robson what the team and tactics should be. I hope this current crop do the same.

 


One more point

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 21 Jun 24 11.47am

Originally posted by Badger11

I am reminded of Italian 90 when the players revolted and told Bobby Robson what the team and tactics should be. I hope this current crop do the same.

This is one of the issues for me - the players not taking responsibility. If the set up is wrong, it's up to senior players to change it - not just blindly go along with it. Go against the manager if they have to. Not sure any of them have the drive, ability or intellect to do it, frankly. Overcoached springs to mind. So coached there is no individuality or flair.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Jun 24 11.53am

Originally posted by silvertop

Undie wetters!

In the commentary, they described that we always draw the second group game. Guess what?

Walker said in interview after the game that this is tournament football. Clue?

They can't openly say we held back and did just enough, like a pre season friendly or Carabao Cup game. But obviously they did against Serbia and same again last night. Foden was clearly frustrated and escaped the leash for a moment but generally the team was tethered and the subs were made partly to appease the media, partly to freshen up the game but mainly to rest and protect the starting front line for later more important games.

Game ends. Top of group, only one (worldy) goal conceded, only one card (but that's Gallagher, so?) and no injuries unless there is anything residual from that pitch. But above all - no fatigue.

Much commentary is fixed on Shearer's co-commentary; but his comments were either deliberately misdirecting (still a team player?) or informed by how he did it as a player. Thing is, Southgate was also a player in a team that progressed far and he saw how he and his team mates were drained compared to the competition. Those who win are the best "team", the best defenders and who have the most energy at the end. They are rarely the team that plays high energy, high press and free scoring in the group stage.

The shackles at least partly come off for game 3. Slovenia have been a surprise package and the English will be predicting an ignominious defeat and England scraping through to face a high rank team. There will be the usual every two years gasp of "surprise" from fans and media when we cruise it leaving me to wonder if our beloved national team is supported by goldfish.

I hope this doesn't get lost in translation here, this is a genuine question with no emotion attached, but are you suggesting that the team look awful, lethargic, clueless etc. because that is the plan? To scrape by with minimum effort which will all suddenly change once we're into the KO stages?

I'm not ridiculing it at all in fact I could see some sense in that approach. Just seems a bit fanciful if not delusional to genuinely believe this.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

YT Flag Oxford 21 Jun 24 11.54am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I thought it was poor, obviously. I still maintain it doesn't suddenly mean the last 3 tournaments were crap, but clearly it was a poor performance.

Bellingham was incredibly quiet, and when the entire system is built around him performing, that's going to mean the team is flat.

Main issue for me tactically is the left side - we literally don't have anyone playing down the left so it's a complete non-factor in build-up. If Shaw isn't fit and it has to be Trippier (or another right-footer), then we need a proper winger in front of him to hold the width, and let Trippier tuck inside as he does naturally. Grealish should be there for exactly that role, but I guess Gordon is the next best option.

If Trent is going to play, he needs runners for his passing to be any good - neither Foden nor Kane ever run in behind, so his only outlet is Saka, who he found to decent effect a couple of times.

When he finally brought on runners yesterday (Bowen and Watkins), he took Trent off at the same time.

Assuming he wants to stick with Kane, Foden, Bellingham & Saka in the attack, then it's pointless playing Trent and it should be Wharton alongside Rice. If we need a goal, I'd chuck on Trent along with the Bowen and Watkins types who do run in behind, and I'd expect he'd be a lot more effective.


I still feel we're only a few tweaks away from something clicking and performances improving - long way to go and every chance we hit some form at the right time.


Thanks for replying. I hope your conclusion is correct.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 21 Jun 24 11.59am

Originally posted by Badger11

That England Manager Job description in full. Note all candidates must agree to these rules.

1. Always take a player who has been injured, what could possibly go wrong.

2. Pick the best players available and then try to fit them into the team out of position to their club role.

3. Always prefer top 6 players other smaller clubs.

4. Players must not run beyond the defence, cross the ball into the penalty area or even keep possession.

5. Once selected the manager must stick with the same team even though they are paying badly as "the lads have never let England down".

6. Should it come to penalties, key attacking players are allowed to skive off and leave the responsibility for missing to players who don't normally take penalties. This is known as the David Batty clause.

7. Once the England Manager has failed offer him a job at club level preferably with Crystal palace. This is known as the Steve Parish clause.

8. Under no circumstances are lessons to be learned, Managers and the Sweet FA must rinse and repeat at the next tournament.

9. Managers who like attacking footballer and picking players for their natural position not their Top 6 reputation need not apply. This is known as the Brian Clough clause.

Surely it's the Gareth Southgate clause. I'll never forget that night in 1996. Probably the only time Mrs YT ever watched a football match. When I saw that GS was going to take the next penalty, I said to Mrs YT "that's it. Game over" and she asked "how do you know that?". I said "I just know. There isn't a hope in Hell of him scoring a penalty; just look at his body language..."

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 21 Jun 24 12.06pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Post script: there was a bloke on the wireless this morning who appeared to be a professor of football pitches (niche!). If you thought the sweat on the players was a consequence of effort think again. In a closed roof venue, it was the exhaled breath of 56,000 fans.

Yuck! As bad as a long haul flights.

You're not wrong there ST, even the bbc have pick up on it . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Jun 24 12.53pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I hope this doesn't get lost in translation here, this is a genuine question with no emotion attached, but are you suggesting that the team look awful, lethargic, clueless etc. because that is the plan? To scrape by with minimum effort which will all suddenly change once we're into the KO stages?

I'm not ridiculing it at all in fact I could see some sense in that approach. Just seems a bit fanciful if not delusional to genuinely believe this.

It's the same schtick every 2 years (including the al but identical media/fan backlash - I'm sure the press just cut and paste their raging articles). Not only am I saying it isn't fanciful and/or delusional - to me it's OBVIOUS!

If we get beat by Slovenia I'll get me coat. Otherwise, if we cruise through with barely a drop of sweat (unless acquired from the fans exhalations - ugh) then...

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Jun 24 1.01pm

Originally posted by silvertop

It's the same schtick every 2 years (including the al but identical media/fan backlash - I'm sure the press just cut and paste their raging articles). Not only am I saying it isn't fanciful and/or delusional - to me it's OBVIOUS!

If we get beat by Slovenia I'll get me coat. Otherwise, if we cruise through with barely a drop of sweat (unless acquired from the fans exhalations - ugh) then...

Fair enough, any indication of this must have passed me by.

I sincerely hope you're correct however I am more of the toys out of the pram type so I'll stick to my hysterics for now

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 21 Jun 24 1.04pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I thought it was poor, obviously. I still maintain it doesn't suddenly mean the last 3 tournaments were crap, but clearly it was a poor performance.

Bellingham was incredibly quiet, and when the entire system is built around him performing, that's going to mean the team is flat.

Main issue for me tactically is the left side - we literally don't have anyone playing down the left so it's a complete non-factor in build-up. If Shaw isn't fit and it has to be Trippier (or another right-footer), then we need a proper winger in front of him to hold the width, and let Trippier tuck inside as he does naturally. Grealish should be there for exactly that role, but I guess Gordon is the next best option.

If Trent is going to play, he needs runners for his passing to be any good - neither Foden nor Kane ever run in behind, so his only outlet is Saka, who he found to decent effect a couple of times.

When he finally brought on runners yesterday (Bowen and Watkins), he took Trent off at the same time.

Assuming he wants to stick with Kane, Foden, Bellingham & Saka in the attack, then it's pointless playing Trent and it should be Wharton alongside Rice. If we need a goal, I'd chuck on Trent along with the Bowen and Watkins types who do run in behind, and I'd expect he'd be a lot more effective.


I still feel we're only a few tweaks away from something clicking and performances improving - long way to go and every chance we hit some form at the right time.


I think there's a lot of sense in this post and sincerely hope you're correct at the end there.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 21 Jun 24 1.24pm

I've avoided all football talk since the 70th minute last night when I gave up with the game, and this dreadful team.

But that's the point, it's not a dreadful team. The Manager has them forced into a system and style that doesn't suit any of them. except defenders, who are involved quite a bit.
He's hamstrung himself with the Squad that he's selected, picking on form and not on tactical nous, of which he has none.
To suggest there is no replacement for Kalvin Phillips would be laughable if it wasn't quite so true; we have no combative DM, but that infers that he, an international manager, can't produce a match winning team without one. and that is laughable.

I was a massive critic of Foden after Serbia, but he was one of the only decent performers last night. Bellingham was having his worst game in an England shirt, so what does Southgate do? Take Foden off, leaving Bellingham on.
TAA was Again shocking. The amount of times he gave the ball away was shocking, offering nothing in defense either.

The Answer from many is we have is to 'Play X from the bench' but in this system and style, none of them are going to work. Wharton is not the golden goose, neither is Palmer. The secret to succeeding is for Southgate to get possessed by the ghost of Johann Cruyff, or even someone who actually watches the game.

Of all the games played in the tournament so far, the 2 england games have been the worst, in performance and spectacle. In possession we're boring, out of possession were conservative and invite the oppo on.
Seriously considering switching allegiances to the Netherlands. if their first game is anything to go on; great attacking play - nearly always ending in a Depay hoof into the crowd - and comedy defending. 100% entertainment.

Up the Oranjes!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

dreamwaverider Flag London 21 Jun 24 2.09pm

It will be interesting to see the starting 11 for game 3.

Unchanged again?

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 21 Jun 24 3.33pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

It will be interesting to see the starting 11 for game 3.

Unchanged again?

If it is, I shan't be waiting til the 70th minute to stop watching. TAA at RB (or even More unlikely, RWB) or not at all.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 21 Jun 24 4.01pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I've avoided all football talk since the 70th minute last night when I gave up with the game, and this dreadful team.

But that's the point, it's not a dreadful team. The Manager has them forced into a system and style that doesn't suit any of them. except defenders, who are involved quite a bit.
He's hamstrung himself with the Squad that he's selected, picking on form and not on tactical nous, of which he has none.
To suggest there is no replacement for Kalvin Phillips would be laughable if it wasn't quite so true; we have no combative DM, but that infers that he, an international manager, can't produce a match winning team without one. and that is laughable.

I was a massive critic of Foden after Serbia, but he was one of the only decent performers last night. Bellingham was having his worst game in an England shirt, so what does Southgate do? Take Foden off, leaving Bellingham on.
TAA was Again shocking. The amount of times he gave the ball away was shocking, offering nothing in defense either.

The Answer from many is we have is to 'Play X from the bench' but in this system and style, none of them are going to work. Wharton is not the golden goose, neither is Palmer. The secret to succeeding is for Southgate to get possessed by the ghost of Johann Cruyff, or even someone who actually watches the game.

Of all the games played in the tournament so far, the 2 england games have been the worst, in performance and spectacle. In possession we're boring, out of possession were conservative and invite the oppo on.
Seriously considering switching allegiances to the Netherlands. if their first game is anything to go on; great attacking play - nearly always ending in a Depay hoof into the crowd - and comedy defending. 100% entertainment.

Up the Oranjes!

He obviously cant do it all himself, but what he would bring is calmness and control in the middle of hte park, which is where 90% of football matches are won and lost


 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 21 Jun 24 4.04pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I've avoided all football talk since the 70th minute last night when I gave up with the game, and this dreadful team.

But that's the point, it's not a dreadful team. The Manager has them forced into a system and style that doesn't suit any of them. except defenders, who are involved quite a bit.
He's hamstrung himself with the Squad that he's selected, picking on form and not on tactical nous, of which he has none.
To suggest there is no replacement for Kalvin Phillips would be laughable if it wasn't quite so true; we have no combative DM, but that infers that he, an international manager, can't produce a match winning team without one. and that is laughable.

I was a massive critic of Foden after Serbia, but he was one of the only decent performers last night. Bellingham was having his worst game in an England shirt, so what does Southgate do? Take Foden off, leaving Bellingham on.
TAA was Again shocking. The amount of times he gave the ball away was shocking, offering nothing in defense either.

The Answer from many is we have is to 'Play X from the bench' but in this system and style, none of them are going to work. Wharton is not the golden goose, neither is Palmer. The secret to succeeding is for Southgate to get possessed by the ghost of Johann Cruyff, or even someone who actually watches the game.

Of all the games played in the tournament so far, the 2 england games have been the worst, in performance and spectacle. In possession we're boring, out of possession were conservative and invite the oppo on.
Seriously considering switching allegiances to the Netherlands. if their first game is anything to go on; great attacking play - nearly always ending in a Depay hoof into the crowd - and comedy defending. 100% entertainment.

Up the Oranjes!

Imagine people reacted like this every time Palace had a bad game.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Jun 24 4.16pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Fair enough, any indication of this must have passed me by.

I sincerely hope you're correct however I am more of the toys out of the pram type so I'll stick to my hysterics for now

And without wishing to over-egg my point:

England have an army of staff with specialist credentials usually ending in "-ist". They would include those who have the skill to set out formations that are not inducive to thrashing opponents in an exciting way, but to achieving the minimum required to top the group (as I think we have done every tournament Southgate has been at the head?) by exerting the least effort with the lowest cost in terms of goals conceded (the best defences win tournaments, not the best attacks), suspensions and injuries. It ain't pretty at this early stage but who cares if we get to express fully in the final game(s).

Denmark could only muster a draw with lowly Slovenia and had to get a win. They played a game against a country whose football they grew up with, most of the team play here, and they played it like the proverbial final. Of course they were more progressive and exciting. And all they got was another draw; and they now need to beat Serbia to be sure of going forward.

In whose shoes would you prefer to be? Go and support Netherlands, Spain or whoever if you wish. You'll be back when England are in the final games.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 21 Jun 24 4.42pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

He obviously cant do it all himself, but what he would bring is calmness and control in the middle of hte park, which is where 90% of football matches are won and lost


agreed, and I would be starting him in the next game next to Rice.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 21 Jun 24 4.44pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Imagine people reacted like this every time Palace had a bad game.

If only it Was just one bad game.

I honestly don't know why this england team, makes me so rant-y!!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 21 Jun 24 4.46pm

Originally posted by silvertop

And without wishing to over-egg my point:

England have an army of staff with specialist credentials usually ending in "-ist". They would include those who have the skill to set out formations that are not inducive to thrashing opponents in an exciting way, but to achieving the minimum required to top the group (as I think we have done every tournament Southgate has been at the head?) by exerting the least effort with the lowest cost in terms of goals conceded (the best defences win tournaments, not the best attacks), suspensions and injuries. It ain't pretty at this early stage but who cares if we get to express fully in the final game(s).

Denmark could only muster a draw with lowly Slovenia and had to get a win. They played a game against a country whose football they grew up with, most of the team play here, and they played it like the proverbial final. Of course they were more progressive and exciting. And all they got was another draw; and they now need to beat Serbia to be sure of going forward.

In whose shoes would you prefer to be? Go and support Netherlands, Spain or whoever if you wish. You'll be back when England are in the final games.

Bit of a strange one that, no matter how bad they play, you’re sort of stuck with your national team arn’t you? I’m certainly not planning on becoming Van Der Monkey or Senor Monkey just because England are crap

 

YT Flag Oxford 21 Jun 24 4.48pm

Originally posted by silvertop

And without wishing to over-egg my point:

England have an army of staff with specialist credentials usually ending in "-ist". They would include those who have the skill to set out formations that are not inducive to thrashing opponents in an exciting way, but to achieving the minimum required to top the group (as I think we have done every tournament Southgate has been at the head?) by exerting the least effort with the lowest cost in terms of goals conceded (the best defences win tournaments, not the best attacks), suspensions and injuries. It ain't pretty at this early stage but who cares if we get to express fully in the final game(s).

Denmark could only muster a draw with lowly Slovenia and had to get a win. They played a game against a country whose football they grew up with, most of the team play here, and they played it like the proverbial final. Of course they were more progressive and exciting. And all they got was another draw; and they now need to beat Serbia to be sure of going forward.

In whose shoes would you prefer to be? Go and support Netherlands, Spain or whoever if you wish. You'll be back when England are in the final games.

Assuming you are ignoring the Nations League which presumably doesn't fit your narrative, oh and the 2018 World Cup where Belgium in England's group won all 3 of their matches, then yes; you are right!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 21 Jun 24 4.50pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Imagine people reacted like this every time Palace had a bad game.

Yes it would be much better to only react badly to (say) every other bad England game or perhaps one in every three.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 12 of 39 < 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Euro 2024