Squad value January 2020

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

CharlesPaterson 16 Jan 20 2.48am
Just over 2 weeks to go till the end of another transfer window. Got me thinking, what is the realistic value of each player? I know we're not likely to get many bids but if we did, what could we realistically get for them? GK Vicente Henners Henderson DEF Wardy PVA Tomkins Dann Sakho Cahill Kelly Woods MID Schlupp Max Luka Andros Kouyate Jairo Brandon Jimmy Mac James Mac FOR Conor Wilf Jordan Benteke Sorloth Would be interesting to see what people's valuations are.
Alert a moderator to this post

CharlesPaterson

16 Jan 20 2.48am

Send a Private Message to CharlesPaterson

Just over 2 weeks to go till the end of another transfer window.

Got me thinking, what is the realistic value of each player?

I know we're not likely to get many bids but if we did, what could we realistically get for them?

Vicente
Henners
Henderson

DEF

Wardy
PVA
Tomkins
Dann
Sakho
Cahill
Kelly
Woods

MID

Schlupp
Max
Luka
Andros
Kouyate
Jairo
Brandon
Jimmy Mac
James Mac

FOR

Conor
Wilf
Jordan
Benteke
Sorloth

Would be interesting to see what people's valuations are.

Alert a moderator to this post

aj36094 Derbyshire 16 Jan 20 9.17am
[Link] My opinion: GK Vicente Ł12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age) Henners Ł3M Henderson Ł0 DEF Wardy Ł4M PVA Ł7M Tomkins Ł4M Dann Ł500K Sakho Ł6M Cahill Ł4M Kelly Ł1M Woods Ł300k MID Schlupp Ł7M Max Ł8M Luka Ł8M Andros Ł11M Kouyate Ł8M Jairo Ł5M (should rise if form continues) Brandon Ł1M Jimmy Mac Ł4M James Mac Ł2 FOR Conor Ł2M Wilf Ł50M Jordan Ł11M Benteke Ł4M Sorloth Ł4M (Based on performances in Turkey)
Alert a moderator to this post

aj36094

Derbyshire 16 Jan 20 9.17am

[Link]

My opinion:

Vicente Ł12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age)
Henners Ł3M
Henderson Ł0

DEF

Wardy Ł4M
PVA Ł7M
Tomkins Ł4M
Dann Ł500K
Sakho Ł6M
Cahill Ł4M
Kelly Ł1M
Woods Ł300k

MID

Schlupp Ł7M
Max Ł8M
Luka Ł8M
Andros Ł11M
Kouyate Ł8M
Jairo Ł5M (should rise if form continues)
Brandon Ł1M
Jimmy Mac Ł4M
James Mac Ł2

FOR

Conor Ł2M
Wilf Ł50M
Jordan Ł11M
Benteke Ł4M
Sorloth Ł4M (Based on performances in Turkey)

Alert a moderator to this post

Den1923 16 Jan 20 10.03am
Originally posted by aj36094 [Link] My opinion: GK Vicente Ł12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age) Henners Ł3M Henderson Ł0 DEF Wardy Ł4M PVA Ł7M Tomkins Ł4M Dann Ł500K Sakho Ł6M Cahill Ł4M Kelly Ł1M Woods Ł300k MID Schlupp Ł7M Max Ł8M Luka Ł8M Andros Ł11M Kouyate Ł8M Jairo Ł5M (should rise if form continues) Brandon Ł1M Jimmy Mac Ł4M James Mac Ł2 FOR Conor Ł2M Wilf Ł50M Jordan Ł11M Benteke Ł4M Sorloth Ł4M (Based on performances in Turkey) My only disagreement here would be Benteke, he just can’t score and as a striker that really effects his value SP must have been on something to extend his contract at 125K a week. His current value is a free just to get rid of him and save the wages sadly I fear even as a free there will be takers!
Alert a moderator to this post

Den1923

16 Jan 20 10.03am

Originally posted by aj36094

[Link]

My opinion:

Vicente Ł12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age)
Henners Ł3M
Henderson Ł0

DEF

Wardy Ł4M
PVA Ł7M
Tomkins Ł4M
Dann Ł500K
Sakho Ł6M
Cahill Ł4M
Kelly Ł1M
Woods Ł300k

MID

Schlupp Ł7M
Max Ł8M
Luka Ł8M
Andros Ł11M
Kouyate Ł8M
Jairo Ł5M (should rise if form continues)
Brandon Ł1M
Jimmy Mac Ł4M
James Mac Ł2

FOR

Conor Ł2M
Wilf Ł50M
Jordan Ł11M
Benteke Ł4M
Sorloth Ł4M (Based on performances in Turkey)

My only disagreement here would be Benteke, he just can’t score and as a striker that really effects his value SP must have been on something to extend his contract at 125K a week. His current value is a free just to get rid of him and save the wages sadly I fear even as a free there will be takers!

Alert a moderator to this post

Fatherken 16 Jan 20 12.10pm
I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him Back to the thread I agree with most of this except Ward Ł2m Cahill Ł6m Andros Ł5m Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best Benteke Ł6m
Alert a moderator to this post

Fatherken

16 Jan 20 12.10pm

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward Ł2m
Cahill Ł6m
Andros Ł5m
Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best
Benteke Ł6m

Alert a moderator to this post

ARGILE OLD GEEZER PORTIMAO 16 Jan 20 12.47pm
Originally posted by aj36094 [Link] My opinion: GK Vicente Ł12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age) Henners Ł3M Henderson Ł0 DEF Wardy Ł4M PVA Ł7M Tomkins Ł4M Dann Ł500K Sakho Ł6M Cahill Ł4M Kelly Ł1M Woods Ł300k MID Schlupp Ł7M Max Ł8M Luka Ł8M Andros Ł11M Kouyate Ł8M Jairo Ł5M (should rise if form continues) Brandon Ł1M Jimmy Mac Ł4M James Mac Ł2 FOR Conor Ł2M Wilf Ł50M Jordan Ł11M Benteke Ł4M Sorloth Ł4M (Based on performances in Turkey) Tomkins Ł4M, you would have a dozen clubs biting your hand off for anything under 15ŁM
Alert a moderator to this post

ARGILE OLD GEEZER

PORTIMAO 16 Jan 20 12.47pm

Send a Private Message to ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Originally posted by aj36094

[Link]

My opinion:

Vicente Ł12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age)
Henners Ł3M
Henderson Ł0

DEF

Wardy Ł4M
PVA Ł7M
Tomkins Ł4M
Dann Ł500K
Sakho Ł6M
Cahill Ł4M
Kelly Ł1M
Woods Ł300k

MID

Schlupp Ł7M
Max Ł8M
Luka Ł8M
Andros Ł11M
Kouyate Ł8M
Jairo Ł5M (should rise if form continues)
Brandon Ł1M
Jimmy Mac Ł4M
James Mac Ł2

FOR

Conor Ł2M
Wilf Ł50M
Jordan Ł11M
Benteke Ł4M
Sorloth Ł4M (Based on performances in Turkey)

Tomkins Ł4M, you would have a dozen clubs biting your hand off for anything under 15ŁM

Alert a moderator to this post

Tequila Sunrise 16 Jan 20 1.03pm
Tomkins is a bit injury prone but definitely worth more than Ward, who is in my opinion a championship player at best.
Alert a moderator to this post

Tequila Sunrise

16 Jan 20 1.03pm

Send a Private Message to Tequila Sunrise

Tomkins is a bit injury prone but definitely worth more than Ward, who is in my opinion a championship player at best.

Alert a moderator to this post

taylors lovechild 16 Jan 20 1.31pm
Given how much players are going for in today's market I would say some of the valuations are pretty low here. if fit then my estimates would be something like: GK Vicente 10m Henners 5m Henderson 0 DEF Wardy 4m PVA 15m Tomkins 15m Dann 4m Sakho 15m Cahill 4m Kelly 5m Woods 500k MID Schlupp 10m Max 8m Luka 15m Andros 20m Kouyate 10m Jairo 7m Brandon ? Jimmy Mac 6m James Mac 6m FOR Conor 5m Wilf 60m Jordan 9m Benteke 10m Sorloth 6m
Alert a moderator to this post

taylors lovechild

16 Jan 20 1.31pm

Send a Private Message to taylors lovechild

Given how much players are going for in today's market I would say some of the valuations are pretty low here. if fit then my estimates would be something like:

Vicente 10m
Henners 5m
Henderson 0

DEF

Wardy 4m
PVA 15m
Tomkins 15m
Dann 4m
Sakho 15m
Cahill 4m
Kelly 5m
Woods 500k

MID

Schlupp 10m
Max 8m
Luka 15m
Andros 20m
Kouyate 10m
Jairo 7m
Brandon ?
Jimmy Mac 6m
James Mac 6m

FOR

Conor 5m
Wilf 60m
Jordan 9m
Benteke 10m
Sorloth 6m

Alert a moderator to this post

Den1923 16 Jan 20 4.40pm
Originally posted by Fatherken I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him Back to the thread I agree with most of this except Ward Ł2m Cahill Ł6m Andros Ł5m Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best Benteke Ł6m No one hates Benteke, I just think based on form he has no value, if you can get 6mil for him, I’m sue SP will be happy to give you 10%,
Alert a moderator to this post

Den1923

16 Jan 20 4.40pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward Ł2m
Cahill Ł6m
Andros Ł5m
Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best
Benteke Ł6m

No one hates Benteke, I just think based on form he has no value, if you can get 6mil for him, I’m sue SP will be happy to give you 10%,

Alert a moderator to this post

CharlesPaterson 17 Jan 20 2.44pm
I will surprise a few and say that I think we only have 10 players who'd fetch more than Ł5m
Alert a moderator to this post

CharlesPaterson

17 Jan 20 2.44pm

I will surprise a few and say that I think we only have 10 players who'd fetch more than Ł5m

Alert a moderator to this post

Rachid Rachid Rachid 17 Jan 20 10.12pm
Originally posted by Fatherken I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him Back to the thread I agree with most of this except Ward Ł2m Cahill Ł6m Andros Ł5m Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best Benteke Ł6m Is it the system that led to him missing 20 from 23 "good" chances in 2017-18 (ie the season his problems began) and his head falling off ?
Alert a moderator to this post

Rachid Rachid Rachid

17 Jan 20 10.12pm

Send a Private Message to Rachid Rachid Rachid

Originally posted by Fatherken

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward Ł2m
Cahill Ł6m
Andros Ł5m
Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best
Benteke Ł6m

Is it the system that led to him missing 20 from 23 "good" chances in 2017-18 (ie the season his problems began) and his head falling off ?

Alert a moderator to this post

southnorwoodhill 17 Jan 20 10.21pm
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid Is it the system that led to him missing 20 from 23 "good" chances in 2017-18 (ie the season his problems began) and his head falling off ? It was the system that made him take the ball off Luka for that penalty, honest guv!
Alert a moderator to this post

southnorwoodhill

17 Jan 20 10.21pm

Send a Private Message to southnorwoodhill

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Is it the system that led to him missing 20 from 23 "good" chances in 2017-18 (ie the season his problems began) and his head falling off ?

It was the system that made him take the ball off Luka for *that* penalty, honest guv!

Alert a moderator to this post

Shifty97 Croydon 18 Jan 20 10.11am
Originally posted by Fatherken I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him Back to the thread I agree with most of this except Ward Ł2m Cahill Ł6m Andros Ł5m Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best Benteke Ł6m It’s not the system we play, he misses many chances, is lazy, movement is poor, nothing to do with the system, he still gets a lot of chances in the system we play but he just can’t score
Alert a moderator to this post

Shifty97

Croydon 18 Jan 20 10.11am

Originally posted by Fatherken

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward Ł2m
Cahill Ł6m
Andros Ł5m
Jorden Ł11m no chance Ł5m at best
Benteke Ł6m

It’s not the system we play, he misses many chances, is lazy, movement is poor, nothing to do with the system, he still gets a lot of chances in the system we play but he just can’t score

Alert a moderator to this post

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

Previous Topic | Next Topic

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Squad value January 2020

Site Map

Sponsors