You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guedioura loan to Forest
November 16 2026 1.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Guedioura loan to Forest


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
BigTimeCharlie Flag Bogota 19 Feb 14 10.43am

Close, according to this ever so reliable source...

[Link]

Thoughts? Was he named in the 25?

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 19 Feb 14 10.45am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Guedoira back to Forest?' by staffie

[Link]

Not implausible given that he hasn't been playing lately. He's looked good whenever he's been on the pitch - I can only imagine that he's still far from full fitness and a relegation scrap is no time to ease him back in, especially as we now have Ledley to complement our midfield options. Would still be a very useful player for the run-in, I think.

 

leejaneagles Flag 19 Feb 14 11.00am

Pulis really didn't think much of Holloway's signings did he?

Only Puncheon and Chamakh have been somewhat successful. He clearly doesn't rate Bannan, Guerdiora, Kebe, Jerome, Gayle or Campana.

Damn, what a waste of money. No wonder 2010 were very reluctant to rebuild again in January (although they did eventually and I'm not complaining).

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 19 Feb 14 11.12am

Quote leejaneagles at 19 Feb 2014 11.00am

Pulis really didn't think much of Holloway's signings did he?

Only Puncheon and Chamakh have been somewhat successful. He clearly doesn't rate Bannan, Guerdiora, Kebe, Jerome, Gayle or Campana.

Damn, what a waste of money. No wonder 2010 were very reluctant to rebuild again in January (although they did eventually and I'm not complaining).

This. I think all in that list will be gone by August.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 19 Feb 14 11.25am

Well, TP has to run his own selections, the way he wants, or there would have been no reason to let Olly go. But Gladiola seems a skillful bloke amd will fit in at Forest, who like to play a bit. Bet they put in a bid for him eventually. Will be sorry to see him go, as with many on that list, especially Bannan. As for Joniesta, if TP wanted him gone he would have accepted Cardiff's offer in the window. But having kept him, why is he so reluctant to play the little gem?

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 19 Feb 14 11.28am

Hope he doesn't go was one of best players until he got injured.

His physicality adds a different dimention to our midfield and is quite good in the advanced position.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Crazy_Eagle Flag South London 19 Feb 14 11.42am

Quote Pawson Palace at 19 Feb 2014 11.28am

Hope he doesn't go was one of best players until he got injured.

His physicality adds a different dimention to our midfield and is quite good in the advanced position.


I agree.

Thought he'd be worth keeping.

 


R.I.P. DJ Hardline

CPFC2010

Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 19 Feb 14 11.54am

Quote leejaneagles at 19 Feb 2014 11.00am

Pulis really didn't think much of Holloway's signings did he?

Only Puncheon and Chamakh have been somewhat successful. He clearly doesn't rate Bannan, Guerdiora, Kebe, Jerome, Gayle or Campana.

Damn, what a waste of money. No wonder 2010 were very reluctant to rebuild again in January (although they did eventually and I'm not complaining).

How did you come to that conclusion.?

 

girvinator Flag Poole 19 Feb 14 12.02pm

Quote leejaneagles at 19 Feb 2014 11.00am

Pulis really didn't think much of Holloway's signings did he?

Only Puncheon and Chamakh have been somewhat successful. He clearly doesn't rate Bannan, Guerdiora, Kebe, Jerome, Gayle or Campana.

Damn, what a waste of money. No wonder 2010 were very reluctant to rebuild again in January (although they did eventually and I'm not complaining).


At the end of the season I can see Kebe, Jerome, Campana, Guedioura going regardless of survival or relegation.

I hope Chamakh renews his deal although I doubt we could satisfy his wage bill. Good news that Puncheon has signed on for the future.

 

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 19 Feb 14 12.20pm

Waste of squad place if true. He is in our 25.

 

louis01 Flag Llandudno 19 Feb 14 12.22pm

Bit gutted by this. Would have loved to see him play in front of Jedi and Ledley with Ince and Puncheon either side and Cham up front.

 


It's all fun and games until someone loses an eye!

Hansy Flag 19 Feb 14 12.27pm

Always rated him when he played for us. Thought he would link up well with Chamakh.

Would be sad to see him leave. Can't see Gayle leaving at the end of the season though, he has bags of potential but needs to beef up a bit.

 

Baldfella Flag Wigan 19 Feb 14 12.35pm

So if he leaves on loan can we put Johnny Williams or Tom Ince In our 25 man squad as they weren't listed before ?

Edited by Baldfella (19 Feb 2014 12.35pm)

 

The Dolphin Flag 19 Feb 14 12.36pm

That makes no sense to me as I thought he was very good.
However - Pulis knows what he wants to keep us up and he doesn't figure in those plans which is a shame.
I guess with Ince and Ledley he feels he doesn't need him

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 19 Feb 14 12.54pm

Quote Baldfella at 19 Feb 2014 12.35pm

So if he leaves on loan can we put Johnny Williams or Tom Ince In our 25 man squad as they weren't listed before ?

Edited by Baldfella (19 Feb 2014 12.35pm)


Why would we need to?

 

Mr_Flow Flag London 19 Feb 14 1.12pm

If he does go, I would imagine we'll have the option to recall him after 28 days similar to teh Ravel Morrison loan to QPR. He's not 100% match fit and this will give him the chance to play games, get form and fitness back and be ready to come back should we need him.

Win win situation in my opinion.

 

LeBoeuf Flag Bermondsey 19 Feb 14 1.12pm

Quote BigTimeCharlie at 19 Feb 2014 10.43am

Close, according to this ever so reliable source...

[Link]

Thoughts? Was he named in the 25?


yeah, saw something like this in one of last sundays papers. Dismissed it tho, as the story carried the line "escape from his palace hell". Wasnt aware he was having a hellish time here. Id be disappointed if he went, as i think he def has something to offer us, and has looked more than decent when he's played.

 


a rich man is only a poor man with an obscene amount of money

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 19 Feb 14 1.28pm

Would be a shame, I think he's a useful player to have on the bench at least

 


La la la your mum

Part Time James Flag 19 Feb 14 1.33pm

I think Gayle will be kept as 'one for the future' but might go out on loan.

I'd also be sad to see Bananaman go but I have to admit I can see it happening. If he was the sort of player TP wanted we'd have seen him play more already. Shame, he looks Premier League(IMHO).

 




pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 19 Feb 14 2.08pm

Quote Mr_Flow at 19 Feb 2014 1.12pm

If he does go, I would imagine we'll have the option to recall him after 28 days similar to teh Ravel Morrison loan to QPR. He's not 100% match fit and this will give him the chance to play games, get form and fitness back and be ready to come back should we need him.

Win win situation in my opinion.


This ^

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Guedioura loan to Forest