The decision to promote Paddy surely rests on the recommendation of Dougie as Director of Football.

Now, over the years there have been people on here moaning about the lack of succession planning within the Club.

So we presently have a situation where Palace are doing just that. And guess what….people are moaning.

We don’t know for certain what the plan is, but hey, it’s another thing to moan about. If Paddy is to be Roy’s successor, it would be nice for people to embrace the idea and give the guy some support.

It will either work out or it won’t - just the same as if we recruit outside of the club.

Old, Ungifted and White

In the Premier no, in the Championship possible due to lack of money.

A very good point. L'pools boot room produced, what, 4 title winning managers & not one of them had any managerial experiance. So, why not 'Paddy'?

I'm a blind man, i'm a blind man, now my room is cold,
When a blind man cries, Lord, he feels it from his soul.
[Link]

OMG, Are you seriously comparing the Liverpool boot room that had world class knowledge passed from Paisley to Shankly to Fagan etc to Paddy Macarthy managing our youth team?

You seem very certain.? You could say he is in the picture already, just needs to prove himself , before the big question is asked.

Are you suggesting that Hodgson with all his experience doesn't have 'world class knowledge'?

No-one (as far as I can tell) is suggesting that McCarthy is ready to take over now, but then he's not being asked to. He's being asked to continue his apprenticeship as Hodgson's assistant for at least the next season. Time will tell whether he develops sufficiently to be considered as our next manager.

As an aside, the order at Liverpool was Shankly, Paisley, Fagan and, if my memory serves me right a lot of football pundits were sceptical when Liverpool appointed Fagan but he proved them wrong.