You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mariappa v Assaidi today
November 16 2026 1.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mariappa v Assaidi today


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 20 Jan 14 12.21pm

He did and does OK but lets not go overboard - he isnt a RB and it does show.

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 20 Jan 14 12.26pm

Quote The Sash at 20 Jan 2014 12.21pm

He did and does OK but lets not go overboard - he isnt a RB and it does show.

I totally agree, and we've come a cropper because of it - most obviously against Spurs.

Will be interesting to see if he ever gets a fair go for us at CB, or whether he remains a versatile backup option. Or even if TP does persevere with him at RB and tries to convert him fully? Hunt may be on the way back but he is still an unknown quantity for us.

 

Ashford Eagle Flag Folkestone, Kent 20 Jan 14 12.30pm

I must admit one thing my mate and I picked up on Saturday was how different the crossing was for both teams. I don't know of the exact stats but the majority of our crosses were blocked and certainly didn't create danger. Stoke seemed to whip a cross in at every opportunity and although they may not have found their player everytime, they did at least beat the first man. I think Bolasie and Puncheon were pretty good at attacking on Saturday, but they do need to work on that final ball into the box. Even if we buy a top quality striker, he will need decent service into the box.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 20 Jan 14 12.36pm

Quote ambrose7 at 18 Jan 2014 8.16pm

As the person who also started the anti-Wilbraham thread (a minute apart), you are such a sad human being.

The team wins, restricts the opposition to two shots on target, and you choose to batter two guys who are working bloody hard to get into the team. Mariappa had to deal with Assaidi (a liverpool player), and then a fresh Arnautovic (ex-Inter) (their two biggest threats) and still Crouch had no aerial service. And he's being played out of position. Wilbraham created chances, held up the ball exceptionally well and worked so hard to try and restrict their time on the ball.

I'm not saying people are ever devoid of criticism, but compare the value of their side to ours. I cannot imagine what you'd be like after a defeat. Sort out your priorities, your pure negativity is horrendous.

Edited by ambrose7 (18 Jan 2014 8.19pm)

Well Bloody Said !!


 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

akiisalegend Flag Croydon 20 Jan 14 2.28pm

Not that I agree with it but i personally think Ward will stay as a DM with Marriappa at RB and then hunt will be given the chance to be first choice rb when fit again

 

jamescroydon09 Flag croydon 20 Jan 14 3.44pm

just to prove i I was right . this is s copy and paste from a states website this weekend and look what it says and note how meny mins he was on the pitch compaid to the other players
Accurate Crosses

Player Club Pos Accurate Cross Apps Mins
Robert Snodgrass Norwich MF 4 1 90
Charlie Adam Stoke MF 3 1 90
Oussama Assaidi Stoke MF 3 1 72
Santiago Cazorla Arsenal MF 3 1 90
Ahmed Elmohamady Hull MF 3 1 90
The two Stoke names on this list are worth focusing on because although the side lost at Crystal Palace, Adam and Assaidi both showed great precision to deliver the ball to teammates from difficult areas. Stoke are not a side that always play slick, passing football and crossing the ball for their forwards and attacking runners from midfield is one of their main tactics.

 

jamescroydon09 Flag croydon 20 Jan 14 3.45pm

[Link]

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 20 Jan 14 5.09pm

Quote jamescroydon09 at 20 Jan 2014 11.51am

yes i to think he has done well going from a cb to a rb . but i disagree that he done his job well on the day he was good going forward

im not saying that he could have stopped every cross but from my recolection he did not block one of them from getting in the box , just feel that if he is to carry on as a rb then one of his man jobs is to prevent crosses comming in , and for my likeing he seemed like he staned off allowing the cross to come in ....you can not do this as a rb time and time agin as eventually one will land in ht right place and the cb will not be able to head it out

Yes, but if the player putting over the centre has not done the job with accuracy which Assaidi obviously didn't, then Mariappa has done his job in preventing a very good player from doing his job.

 

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 20 Jan 14 5.16pm

Quote jamescroydon09 at 20 Jan 2014 3.44pm

just to prove i I was right . this is s copy and paste from a states website this weekend and look what it says and note how meny mins he was on the pitch compaid to the other players
Accurate Crosses

Player Club Pos Accurate Cross Apps Mins
Robert Snodgrass Norwich MF 4 1 90
Charlie Adam Stoke MF 3 1 90
Oussama Assaidi Stoke MF 3 1 72
Santiago Cazorla Arsenal MF 3 1 90
Ahmed Elmohamady Hull MF 3 1 90
The two Stoke names on this list are worth focusing on because although the side lost at Crystal Palace, Adam and Assaidi both showed great precision to deliver the ball to teammates from difficult areas. Stoke are not a side that always play slick, passing football and crossing the ball for their forwards and attacking runners from midfield is one of their main tactics.

So an American website says that Assaidi, playing as a winger, put in 3 accurate crosses in 72 minutes. And this is to prove that Mariappa had a bad game? I'm not sure I get your point here. That sounds a pretty average return to me, particularly considering that he had Crouch to aim for in the middle!

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 20 Jan 14 5.23pm

Fair one, stats to back up. their strikers must have had a poor game, or gabbs and delaney were solid enough to counter their threat.

 

Hansy Flag 20 Jan 14 5.26pm

Gabbs and Delaney were solid. Gabss was even beating Crouch to headers!

Says it all really

 

MikeT Flag Burlington (Toronto Area) 20 Jan 14 5.27pm

Quote ambrose7 at 18 Jan 2014 8.16pm

As the person who also started the anti-Wilbraham thread (a minute apart), you are such a sad human being.

The team wins, restricts the opposition to two shots on target, and you choose to batter two guys who are working bloody hard to get into the team. Mariappa had to deal with Assaidi (a liverpool player), and then a fresh Arnautovic (ex-Inter) (their two biggest threats) and still Crouch had no aerial service. And he's being played out of position. Wilbraham created chances, held up the ball exceptionally well and worked so hard to try and restrict their time on the ball.

I'm not saying people are ever devoid of criticism, but compare the value of their side to ours. I cannot imagine what you'd be like after a defeat. Sort out your priorities, your pure negativity is horrendous.

Edited by ambrose7 (18 Jan 2014 8.19pm)

I was surprised Arnautovic didn't target Mariappa more agressively, after his two assists from the left wing against Liverpool. He seemed to be playing more centrally where he was ineffective against Ward and Jedinak. Think Sparky missed a trick there.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 20 Jan 14 6.24pm

Remind me how many goals did the new Messi that is Assaidi get, come to think of it how many assists did he get, he may have over crosses, but not a single one was telling.

Why is it so hard for some people to give credit to our players when it's due, and actually I thought Delaney was carried a bit today by Gabbidon who was immense.

I do think that moving Ward in midfield may have affected any chances of appearing in the England 21 team.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 21 Jan 14 11.39am

Ward is a bit old for the u21s.

 

CPFC-NAC Flag London 21 Jan 14 6.15pm

agree, marriapas not a RB, but too small to be CB

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 21 Jan 14 7.43pm

Quote CPFC-NAC at 21 Jan 2014 6.15pm

agree, marriapas not a RB, but too small to be CB

He did a very good job for Reading at CB, plus Danny Gabbidon not exactly a giant.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Mariappa v Assaidi today