You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis: I've never heard of Bjelland and Makienok
November 16 2026 1.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pulis: I've never heard of Bjelland and Makienok


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
npn Flag Crowborough 28 Jan 14 10.43am

Quote sydtheeagle at 27 Jan 2014 5.45pm

Quote npn at 27 Jan 2014 5.10pm

long before the Adverstiser run with it, but I don't think he's done anything particularly wrong in posting it.

No wonder journalism is to all intents and purposes dead as a serious form of news reporting. Not only do we have journalists not doing their jobs properly. We have readers making excuses for them. I guess there's not really much incentive to research your stories and write proper news if your readers don't give a toss. Well, to be honest this is one warning I'm almost proud to have.


He didn't lift the story from here Syd, he was at (or had staff at) the press conference, and then reported it. As I say, slow off the mark (for reasons he explained here, which is fair enough) but not in any way bad journalism.

Don't worry, when there is bad journalism, I'll happily call him on it, but in this case, he was beaten to the punch by someone else who also saw the conference.

 

Hoof Hearted 28 Jan 14 10.49am

Quote Seth at 27 Jan 2014 5.02pm

I'm confused. Google thinks Bjelland is a real player, so why are people saying he's fictitious? [Link]

Also abusing the Adder journo is pointless. He's only reporting what TP said in his presser, calling him a f*cking moron is way over the top imo.


I agree.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (28 Jan 2014 10.52am)

 

Advertiser_Sport Flag London 28 Jan 14 11.38am

Quote npn at 28 Jan 2014 10.43am

Quote sydtheeagle at 27 Jan 2014 5.45pm

Quote npn at 27 Jan 2014 5.10pm

long before the Adverstiser run with it, but I don't think he's done anything particularly wrong in posting it.

No wonder journalism is to all intents and purposes dead as a serious form of news reporting. Not only do we have journalists not doing their jobs properly. We have readers making excuses for them. I guess there's not really much incentive to research your stories and write proper news if your readers don't give a toss. Well, to be honest this is one warning I'm almost proud to have.


He didn't lift the story from here Syd, he was at (or had staff at) the press conference, and then reported it. As I say, slow off the mark (for reasons he explained here, which is fair enough) but not in any way bad journalism.

Don't worry, when there is bad journalism, I'll happily call him on it, but in this case, he was beaten to the punch by someone else who also saw the conference.

I wasn't beaten to the punch! I was reporting it live on Twitter from the press conference, so lots of fans would have seen it in real time.

Then as I said, reporters have to then turn quotes into a story and file them, which is coming across as "slow" when in fact, it's not. I have stories up way before nationals or the likes of Sky Sports have them online following a press conference.

Before the club started filming it live on YouTube, there was no other way of knowing what was being said at a press conference unless it was on Twitter or then reported in a story online, say, 30 minutes later.

 


Croydon Advertiser Sports Reporter.

Follow me on Twitter @MR_LWMedia for live match tweets, news and interviews on Crystal Palace FC.

I do not run the @AdvertiserSport account any more.

If you're on Facebook, 'Like' our page for news and interviews at [Link]

Hoof Hearted 28 Jan 14 11.49am

Quote Advertiser_Sport at 28 Jan 2014 11.38am

Quote npn at 28 Jan 2014 10.43am

Quote sydtheeagle at 27 Jan 2014 5.45pm

Quote npn at 27 Jan 2014 5.10pm

long before the Adverstiser run with it, but I don't think he's done anything particularly wrong in posting it.

No wonder journalism is to all intents and purposes dead as a serious form of news reporting. Not only do we have journalists not doing their jobs properly. We have readers making excuses for them. I guess there's not really much incentive to research your stories and write proper news if your readers don't give a toss. Well, to be honest this is one warning I'm almost proud to have.


He didn't lift the story from here Syd, he was at (or had staff at) the press conference, and then reported it. As I say, slow off the mark (for reasons he explained here, which is fair enough) but not in any way bad journalism.

Don't worry, when there is bad journalism, I'll happily call him on it, but in this case, he was beaten to the punch by someone else who also saw the conference.

I wasn't beaten to the punch! I was reporting it live on Twitter from the press conference, so lots of fans would have seen it in real time.

Then as I said, reporters have to then turn quotes into a story and file them, which is coming across as "slow" when in fact, it's not. I have stories up way before nationals or the likes of Sky Sports have them online following a press conference.

Before the club started filming it live on YouTube, there was no other way of knowing what was being said at a press conference unless it was on Twitter or then reported in a story online, say, 30 minutes later.


I appreciate what you did and what you're doing.

There seems to be a hard core of people on here wanting to have a pop at you and your paper at every opportunity.

As far as I can see you are providing us with info and for that we should be grateful.

Ignore the detractors, keep calm and carry on!

 

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 28 Jan 14 1.09pm

Quote Palace15eagle at 27 Jan 2014 9.54pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 27 Jan 2014 5.45pm

Quote npn at 27 Jan 2014 5.10pm

long before the Adverstiser run with it, but I don't think he's done anything particularly wrong in posting it.

No wonder journalism is to all intents and purposes dead as a serious form of news reporting. Not only do we have journalists not doing their jobs properly. We have readers making excuses for them. I guess there's not really much incentive to research your stories and write proper news if your readers don't give a toss. Well, to be honest this is one warning I'm almost proud to have.

I tell you what, why don't you call someone else a "f**king moron" but this time, maybe someone who can defend themselves properly without fear of losing their job? I'd like to see you call someone a "f**king moron" face to face but I bet you wouldn't! Plenty of people who say things on here they'd never dream to in public to someone...


There is NO WAY Syd would repeat his abuse to someone's face! The classic keyboard warrior.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Jan 14 1.16pm

Great journalism is surely defined by accuracy, not speed? The point is to get the story right, not to get a half-arsed version out first. I note that Advertiser said having to have your copy cross an editor's desk could result in unnecessary delays. Some would say having to have your copy cross an editor's desk first is the hallmark of a better quality publication that cares about what it prints. There was a time when this was standard practice.

Like everything else in the age of "I demand everything now," media thoroughness has fallen by the wayside in pursuit of speed. Ironic that many of those who criticised (and in some cases rightly) my own impatience over our transfer activity are now defending a similar lack of patience but in another arena. You can't have it both ways.

I don't have much respect for the modern media but I come by my disrespect far more honestly than I come by judgments on how to run a football club having at least been there, seen that, and got the t-shirt. And I'd quite happily debate my conclusions face-to-face (since someone asked).

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards so many memories Flag basingstoke 28 Jan 14 1.24pm

I think the monkey who reported this deserves spanking.

 


Get it on-get it in-F**K OFF ALAN HANSEN!!

npn Flag Crowborough 28 Jan 14 1.27pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 1.16pm

Great journalism is surely defined by accuracy, not speed? The point is to get the story right, not to get a half-arsed version out first. I note that Advertiser said having to have your copy cross an editor's desk could result in unnecessary delays. Some would say having to have your copy cross an editor's desk first is the hallmark of a better quality publication that cares about what it prints. There was a time when this was standard practice.



It was accurate though - he reported what TP said at his conference

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Jan 14 1.36pm

As you've hopefully surmised, my last post was pretty clearly about general industry standards/trends and not a specific instance or article. Therefore, while the instance you quote may stand up, it's irrelevant in the context of my broader point -- which there is plenty of evidence to support.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Plane Flag Bromley 28 Jan 14 1.40pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 1.16pm

Great journalism is surely defined by accuracy, not speed? The point is to get the story right, not to get a half-arsed version out first. I note that Advertiser said having to have your copy cross an editor's desk could result in unnecessary delays. Some would say having to have your copy cross an editor's desk first is the hallmark of a better quality publication that cares about what it prints. There was a time when this was standard practice.

Like everything else in the age of "I demand everything now," media thoroughness has fallen by the wayside in pursuit of speed. Ironic that many of those who criticised (and in some cases rightly) my own impatience over our transfer activity are now defending a similar lack of patience but in another arena. You can't have it both ways.

I don't have much respect for the modern media but I come by my disrespect far more honestly than I come by judgments on how to run a football club having at least been there, seen that, and got the t-shirt. And I'd quite happily debate my conclusions face-to-face (since someone asked).

Why not show some humility and apologise to the advertiser guy that you abused, it's there in black and white, he was correct and you weren't.

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 28 Jan 14 1.49pm

Quote Plane at 28 Jan 2014 1.40pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 1.16pm

Great journalism is surely defined by accuracy, not speed? The point is to get the story right, not to get a half-arsed version out first. I note that Advertiser said having to have your copy cross an editor's desk could result in unnecessary delays. Some would say having to have your copy cross an editor's desk first is the hallmark of a better quality publication that cares about what it prints. There was a time when this was standard practice.

Like everything else in the age of "I demand everything now," media thoroughness has fallen by the wayside in pursuit of speed. Ironic that many of those who criticised (and in some cases rightly) my own impatience over our transfer activity are now defending a similar lack of patience but in another arena. You can't have it both ways.

I don't have much respect for the modern media but I come by my disrespect far more honestly than I come by judgments on how to run a football club having at least been there, seen that, and got the t-shirt. And I'd quite happily debate my conclusions face-to-face (since someone asked).

Why not show some humility and apologise to the advertiser guy that you abused, it's there in black and white, he was correct and you weren't.

I think an explanation of what humility means is probably needed here planey...

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

sydtheeagle Flag England 28 Jan 14 1.59pm

Quote Plane at 28 Jan 2014 1.40pm

Why not show some humility and apologise to the advertiser guy that you abused, it's there in black and white, he was correct and you weren't.

Plane - That's fair enough, actually. I think if nothing else I have consistently apologised on this board when I've been wrong about something (amazingly, it's happened once or twice) so whatever other criticisms can be levelled at me, a failure to admit when I'm wrong isn't one of them.

TBH I had not apologised because I lost track of/interest in the thread and only just returned to it (hence the last post). It's also quite dense and I didn't really have time to decode it all. But point taken...you're right. And I apologise.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Plane Flag Bromley 28 Jan 14 2.00pm

Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 1.49pm

Quote Plane at 28 Jan 2014 1.40pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 1.16pm

Great journalism is surely defined by accuracy, not speed? The point is to get the story right, not to get a half-arsed version out first. I note that Advertiser said having to have your copy cross an editor's desk could result in unnecessary delays. Some would say having to have your copy cross an editor's desk first is the hallmark of a better quality publication that cares about what it prints. There was a time when this was standard practice.

Like everything else in the age of "I demand everything now," media thoroughness has fallen by the wayside in pursuit of speed. Ironic that many of those who criticised (and in some cases rightly) my own impatience over our transfer activity are now defending a similar lack of patience but in another arena. You can't have it both ways.

I don't have much respect for the modern media but I come by my disrespect far more honestly than I come by judgments on how to run a football club having at least been there, seen that, and got the t-shirt. And I'd quite happily debate my conclusions face-to-face (since someone asked).

Why not show some humility and apologise to the advertiser guy that you abused, it's there in black and white, he was correct and you weren't.

I think an explanation of what humility means is probably needed here planey...

Bloody hell, some people...Here ya go [Link]

 

Plane Flag Bromley 28 Jan 14 2.01pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 28 Jan 2014 1.59pm

Quote Plane at 28 Jan 2014 1.40pm

Why not show some humility and apologise to the advertiser guy that you abused, it's there in black and white, he was correct and you weren't.

Plane - That's fair enough, actually. I think if nothing else I have consistently apologised on this board when I've been wrong about something (amazingly, it's happened once or twice) so whatever other criticisms can be levelled at me, a failure to admit when I'm wrong isn't one of them.

TBH I had not apologised because I lost track of/interest in the thread and only just returned to it (hence the last post). It's also quite dense and I didn't really have time to decode it all. But point taken...you're right. And I apologise.


Good post

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pulis: I've never heard of Bjelland and Makienok