You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need someone greedy in front of goal. Puncheon?
November 16 2026 1.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We need someone greedy in front of goal. Puncheon?


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
paperhat Flag croydon 28 Jan 14 3.35pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 28 Jan 2014 2.00pm

Problem with most of these ideas is that whilst Puncheon probably does have a better eye for goal than Jerome, he isn't physically capable of performing the role that Jerome does up front for the team.

Ideally we want Jerome to do what Jerome does, but with the chances falling to Chamakh or well anyone else really. Problem is, what Jerome does for the team is generally what creates those chances. He's a big target man, strong in the air etc. Gayle is about a foot too small, and built like a 8 year old girl by comparison. No way he is out musculing or jumping a six foot and change center back.

We'd be stretchering either one off by half time.


what role is this then? missing open goals?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 28 Jan 14 4.50pm

Anyone on the books who can hit a bull in the arse with a banjo can play up front as far as I am concerned!.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 29 Jan 14 6.46pm

Quote benchharp at 27 Jan 2014 9.07pm

Bound to divide opinion but hear me out.

I absolutely love Chamakh, he wins a lot of headers, rarely loses the ball and is ridiculously unselfish, what we lack is someone who can do something with his little lay offs, neither Jerome nor Gayle seem to be that person.[Gayle too weak, Jerome shoots like a donkey, Wilbs can't finish either, please do not call his goal against Wigan "finishing"]

I can't see this happening in a month of Sundays but would love to see Puncheon in front of Chamakh, he has a thirst for scoring, perhaps to the point of annoyance, we've all seen him try and take that extra man just to make space for a shot and he has got a good strike on him, if he was in that advanced position i think he could hit the back of the net at least as an interim solution.

This would also allow Bannan a place back in the team who i believe is just about the only player we have who can put in a quality cross.


This is massive. After the Hull game and I can confirm the above post as possibly the most significant. Such an apologetic and self-demeaning post that in fact has proved to be 100% correct. Where did the germ of this idea originate? Who'd have thought it, a crazy idea of a winger made into a centre forward and a highly skilled forward used as a battering ram. But it worked. Expect more goals. Like the arrival of full back Malcom McDonald, this temporary measure will come permanent.

 

kersal Flag London 29 Jan 14 7.02pm

I can't believe there is such a large group of people here that don't appreciate Jerome's massive contributions to this team. It is because of his endless runs that the opposition defense becomes unsettled, clears the ball into touch, etc. He's not slow either; he chases and catches up on loose balls. He is a very useful player in my opinion and everytime I see him lined up with Chamakh, I am happy.

I agree that his finishing is sub-standard, but given how hard he works and effectively disrupts opposition play, I am willing to wait for the goals to come from somewhere else.

As for Gayle, I thought he could be a better sub than Wilbs on Tuesday, but it worked - so nothing to complain about.

Sorry for drifting away from the OP, but I really feel that some are not doing just to Jerome here.

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need someone greedy in front of goal. Puncheon?