This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
tonights Ref.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
harrymc Auckland 29 Jan 14 12.15am |
|
Quote black eagle. at 28 Jan 2014 10.51pm
In a word shocking.discuss He was absolutely excellent. You wouldn't know a good referee if he came up and bit you on the bum. Just what are your refereeing qualifications?
Why can't people spell 'definitely'?
|
SirPeanut Keston 29 Jan 14 12.22am |
|
Quote EagleLee79 at 29 Jan 2014 12.13am
Quote SirPeanut at 29 Jan 2014 12.07am
Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 11.58pm
Quote SirPeanut at 28 Jan 2014 11.56pm
Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.
Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.
He'd have conned you then. Not at all a pen, he dived by running into Gabbidons legs - if anything it should have been a free kick to us.
I was about 10m away from the incident and when I got home I watched the highlights on sky. 9 times out of 10 that is given, because it was a penalty!
Put it this way, if that was Jerome being brought down in the box like that, everyone on here would be going mental.
I agree 9/10 a penalty would be given because in real-time it DID look like a penalty. As ive said if u analyse the slo-mo Long has tried to con the ref.
If it was Jerome who went down, sure i would be screaming for a penalty but after the game id have viewed it differently.
Anyway, chillout mate it werent a penalty and we won! Im sure we'll get a dodgy penalty given against us next week at Arsenal.
Well, I guess we will agree to disagree on that one. But as you say, who cares! We won!
There are two kinds of person in this world: 1) Those who can extrapolate from incomplete data
|
sueagle2012 29 Jan 14 12.31am |
|
Quote harrymc at 29 Jan 2014 12.15am
Quote black eagle. at 28 Jan 2014 10.51pm
In a word shocking.discuss He was absolutely excellent. You wouldn't know a good referee if he came up and bit you on the bum. Just what are your refereeing qualifications?
Agree..I was in upper holmsdale and I think the referee was fine..if you think this was shocking...either you are misusing the word "shocking" or really dont understand the game or havent really come across really shocking referee...
|
sprites Auckland 29 Jan 14 12.36am |
|
|
haha and Bruce is whinging that they were hard done by. Dunno how he can say their keeper didn't deserve red for kicking out like that....and what penalties? Unbelievable.
[Link]
|
Tstack Rolling Prarie, Indiana 29 Jan 14 12.53am |
|
|
I thought the ref was pretty good to be fair...
Oct 26 2002-- Palace 5 Weed 0!!!
|
black eagle. south croydon. 29 Jan 14 12.54am |
|
Quote FinchleyEagle at 28 Jan 2014 11.58pm
Quote SirPeanut at 28 Jan 2014 11.56pm
Lots of pie eyed palace fans on here. The first Shane Long incident was a definite pen! Gabbidon clattered into the back of him nowhere near the ball. Lucky to get away with that.
Rest of his decisions were pretty accurate though.
He'd have conned you then. Not at all a pen, he dived by running into Gabbidons legs - if anything it should have been a free kick to us.
Spot on Finchley i had a great view in the Holmesdale Long ran into Gabbidon and went over very easily another ref would've given Long a yellow.
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 29 Jan 14 1.25am |
|
|
I guess a benefit of watching it on tv is that you get 3 replays from different angles. Wasn't a pen.
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 29 Jan 14 1.37am |
|
|
At the match, I thought the ref was shocking.
At home, watching the highlights, he actually didn't have that bad a game.
Shows how different it can look a) when you're there, all fired up and into it and, b) when you've calmed down and get 5 different angles in slo-mo of the same incident.
Whatever, we got 3 points and one over on the flat-nose judas c*nt so all in all a good night
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
paulose17 Sutton 29 Jan 14 1.43am |
|
Quote Seth at 29 Jan 2014 1.37am
At the match, I thought the ref was shocking.
At home, watching the highlights, he actually didn't have that bad a game.
Shows how different it can look a) when you're there, all fired up and into it and, b) when you've calmed down and get 5 different angles in slo-mo of the same incident.
Whatever, we got 3 points and one over on the flat-nose judas c*nt so all in all a good night
Agreed, thought he was shocking at the game but on reflection not so bad. Shane long is a shlong however
Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.
|
james03 Bangkok 29 Jan 14 2.39am |
|
|
The referee was average at the end fo the day but it was a terrific piece of judgement not to give Long the penalty. Watched it several times now and Gabbidon never veers from his line. Long was to his left and then cut across him, slowed down letting the ball get away from him and then put his right leg across DG and went to ground. He should have got a booking for that - it was cheating.
The handball from our corner was most certainly a penalty and the ref missed that. He also missed the clipping of Wards heels when he was clear through and their player should have been booked.
The sending off was correct. Whether the player made contact or not with O'Keefe, whether he pulled out of kicking harder is irrelevant. He had lost the plot and was just getting angrier and angrier - he should have received a yellow card along with Jerome fifteen minutes or so earlier.
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx
|
doublesuited77 London (Camden) 29 Jan 14 3.10am |
|
|
the missed handball was atrocious. That could have been the difference.
Other than that, the ref was competant, but needed to prevent chippy play earlier.
Be Loud, Be Proud, Be Palace
|
Mapletree Croydon 29 Jan 14 8.41am |
|
Quote doublesuited77 at 29 Jan 2014 3.10am
the missed handball was atrocious. That could have been the difference.
Other than that, the ref was competant, but needed to prevent chippy play earlier.
Don't see it as competent when you don't give a yellow for blatant diving, don't give a yellow for a deliberate hand ball (on the half-way line) and give a free kick the wrong way when the attacker baulks the defender. Amongst other things. Oh and don't get me started on the spat between Cameron Jerome and their goalkeeper. OK Jerome should have walked away but the keeper started it, carried it on and didn't get a yellow. I reckon the ref knew he had done wrong on that one, affecting his later red card decision.
Edited by Mapletree (29 Jan 2014 8.41am)
Edited by Mapletree (29 Jan 2014 8.43am)
|
Lyons550 Shirley 29 Jan 14 8.46am |
|
Quote Slimey Toad at 28 Jan 2014 10.58pm
Agreed. The Long penalty scenario was a brilliant judgement and will earn him points on the referee panel.
Delaney and O'Keefe deserved yellows and it was totally justified to send Mcgregor off. Yeah, he'd been harrassed a couple of times but his reactions were totally over the top.
I'm happy to give him the benefit of the doubt saying it was an excellent decision...but maybe he bottled it and got lucky seeing as it was in front of the HF 
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
|
cpj Kent 29 Jan 14 9.34am |
|
|
Lack of consistency - Delaney booked for a strong challenge on Long, then their bloke does the same on Chamakh and doesn't even get spoken to.
|