You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wow! Look at our possible 2nd and 3rd XI's
November 16 2026 1.13pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wow! Look at our possible 2nd and 3rd XI's


tonymikejoe Flag UK 04 Feb 14 9.08pm

O.K. one or two out of position, but have you ever known a CPFC squad that could potentially put out three teams as strong as this?

Assuming the team that started against Arsenal last Sunday is our first XI here are our next two line-ups of players on our books.

Second XI:

HENNESSEY
MARIAPPA DANN MCCARTHY MOXEY
INCE LEDLEY WILLIAMS BANNAN
MURRAY GAYLE


Third XI:

ALEXANDER
HUNT RAMAGE MARANGE
THOMAS O'KEEFE GUEDIOURA CAMPANA DOBBIE
WILBRAHAM SEKJJA


And we still have people like g/k PRICE and GARVAN knocking about, plus others I am sure readers can suggest.

Does this give you all tremendous confidence in the CPFC squad? or do you think it needs urgent pruning?

Personally I believe 100% we will stay up - comfortably.


 

Purleyeagle22 Flag Purley 04 Feb 14 9.20pm

I thought marange had his contract terminated. That second 11 looks strong though.

 

paulose17 Flag Sutton 04 Feb 14 9.25pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 04 Feb 2014 9.08pm

O.K. one or two out of position, but have you ever known a CPFC squad that could potentially put out three teams as strong as this?

Assuming the team that started against Arsenal last Sunday is our first XI here are our next two line-ups of players on our books.

Second XI:

HENNESSEY
MARIAPPA DANN MCCARTHY MOXEY
INCE LEDLEY WILLIAMS BANNAN
MURRAY GAYLE


Third XI:

ALEXANDER
HUNT RAMAGE MARANGE
THOMAS O'KEEFE GUEDIOURA CAMPANA DOBBIE
WILBRAHAM SEKJJA


And we still have people like g/k PRICE and GARVAN knocking about, plus others I am sure readers can suggest.

Does this give you all tremendous confidence in the CPFC squad? or do you think it needs urgent pruning?

Personally I believe 100% we will stay up - comfortably.


Campana, Ramage are on loan for the rest of the season and Dobbie and Marange have left for good..unless I'm missing something? Price is also over 21 and not in the 25 man squad

 


Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.

Mapletree Flag Croydon 04 Feb 14 9.37pm

Quote paulose17 at 04 Feb 2014 9.25pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 04 Feb 2014 9.08pm

O.K. one or two out of position, but have you ever known a CPFC squad that could potentially put out three teams as strong as this?

Assuming the team that started against Arsenal last Sunday is our first XI here are our next two line-ups of players on our books.

Second XI:

HENNESSEY
MARIAPPA DANN MCCARTHY MOXEY
INCE LEDLEY WILLIAMS BANNAN
MURRAY GAYLE


Third XI:

ALEXANDER
HUNT RAMAGE MARANGE
THOMAS O'KEEFE GUEDIOURA CAMPANA DOBBIE
WILBRAHAM SEKJJA


And we still have people like g/k PRICE and GARVAN knocking about, plus others I am sure readers can suggest.

Does this give you all tremendous confidence in the CPFC squad? or do you think it needs urgent pruning?

Personally I believe 100% we will stay up - comfortably.


Campana, Ramage are on loan for the rest of the season and Dobbie and Marange have left for good..unless I'm missing something? Price is also over 21 and not in the 25 man squad

As far as I can tell Dobbie is on loan again, until the end of May.

 

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 04 Feb 14 9.37pm

Quote paulose17 at 04 Feb 2014 9.25pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 04 Feb 2014 9.08pm

O.K. one or two out of position, but have you ever known a CPFC squad that could potentially put out three teams as strong as this?

Assuming the team that started against Arsenal last Sunday is our first XI here are our next two line-ups of players on our books.

Second XI:

HENNESSEY
MARIAPPA DANN MCCARTHY MOXEY
INCE LEDLEY WILLIAMS BANNAN
MURRAY GAYLE


Third XI:

ALEXANDER
HUNT RAMAGE MARANGE
THOMAS O'KEEFE GUEDIOURA CAMPANA DOBBIE
WILBRAHAM SEKJJA


And we still have people like g/k PRICE and GARVAN knocking about, plus others I am sure readers can suggest.

Does this give you all tremendous confidence in the CPFC squad? or do you think it needs urgent pruning?

Personally I believe 100% we will stay up - comfortably.


Campana, Ramage are on loan for the rest of the season and Dobbie and Marange have left for good..unless I'm missing something? Price is also over 21 and not in the 25 man squad

Dobbie is on loan for the season, not permanent.

 

Loldavis Flag Canterbury 04 Feb 14 9.46pm

Ince Ledley will be in the first team

 

WelshEagle Flag London 04 Feb 14 9.46pm

There's no way Ledley or Ince will be second XI and in the longer run neither will Dann.

At the mo a 2nd XI would look more like:

Hennesey
Mariappa
Dann
McCarthy
Moxey
KG
Guedioura
Bannan
Bolasie
Thomas
Gayle

Our first XI IMO is:

Speroni
Ward
Gabbidon
Delaney
Parr
Jedinak
Ledley
Ince
Puncheon
Chamakh
Murray

Not quite enough for a third but we have the likes of:

Wilbrahim
SOK
Price
Ramage
Garvan
Kai Kai
Jerome
Hunt
Boateng

Sadly no point including campana. He will be gone if he has half decent loan. Disappointed about option to buy.

That second XI is a class side


Edited by WelshEagle (04 Feb 2014 9.49pm)

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 04 Feb 14 9.52pm

Let's not get nit-picky on this people, I make it clear the players are only on our books, so not necessarily in the 25-man squad.

The point is that however impressive the squad is do you think we can possibly carry this wage-bill? I think not.

As for the rush of pre-season signings under IH to be honest they have been absolutely vital if you look at the players who have contributed.

First-team regulars Chamakh, Jerome, Puncheon, Mariappa and for a spell Bannan have all been very important.

Where would we be without them?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 04 Feb 14 9.57pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 04 Feb 2014 9.52pm

Let's not get nit-picky on this people, I make it clear the players are only on our books, so not necessarily in the 25-man squad.

The point is that however impressive the squad is do you think we can possibly carry this wage-bill? I think not.

As for the rush of pre-season signings under IH to be honest they have been absolutely vital if you look at the players who have contributed.

First-team regulars Chamakh, Jerome, Puncheon, Mariappa and for a spell Bannan have all been very important.

Where would we be without them?


Don't you think that's rather up to the directors to decide?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

andrewravesax Flag cowbridge 04 Feb 14 10.33pm

Dann, Ince, Ledley and Murray will play.

 

Halfwayline Flag Waddon 05 Feb 14 4.07pm

We still have 34 "first team" players in the squad. You would expect at least 11 to go in the summer allowing a couple or three
to come in.

I would guess at Dobbie, Price, Moxey, McCarthy, Ince, Chamakh, Ramage, Jerome, Garven, Kebe, Wilbraham.

A striker and left back and another centre back would come in.

PS If we were to be relegated I would expect Ward and Jedinak, possibly Bolaise would get offers from Prem clubs.

Edited by Halfwayline (05 Feb 2014 4.09pm)

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 05 Feb 14 4.16pm

Pullis said he cld never afford chamakh when at stoke.

The thhnk if we stay up abd chamakh wants to stay....pullis will keep him.

 

jpegnall Flag Surrey 05 Feb 14 4.20pm

Quote bexleydave at 04 Feb 2014 9.57pm

Quote tonymikejoe at 04 Feb 2014 9.52pm

Let's not get nit-picky on this people, I make it clear the players are only on our books, so not necessarily in the 25-man squad.

The point is that however impressive the squad is do you think we can possibly carry this wage-bill? I think not.

As for the rush of pre-season signings under IH to be honest they have been absolutely vital if you look at the players who have contributed.

First-team regulars Chamakh, Jerome, Puncheon, Mariappa and for a spell Bannan have all been very important.

Where would we be without them?


Don't you think that's rather up to the directors to decide?


That is a stupid comment. If you take that approach then 95% of the posts on here would be pointless as ultimately who plays, who we buy and every other decision we all talk about on here are for the manager or owners to decide...

Edited by jpegnall (05 Feb 2014 4.20pm)

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wow! Look at our possible 2nd and 3rd XI's