This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
New signings first impressions
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Baldfella Wigan 11 Feb 14 3.13pm |
|
|
Are the three we've seen better than what we already had ?
Absolutely !
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 11 Feb 14 3.19pm |
|
Quote james03 at 09 Feb 2014 5.18am
Ince - Great debut, good goal, plenty of skill and a lot of hard work - the latter point coming as a bit of a surprise to me. Good signing and, should we stay up, hopefully on a long term contract from July.
Ledley - Very intelligent, an okay left back but far, far better in midfield. He makes space for himself and went unnoticed for his goal. Not too many teams expect the oppositions left back to be on the near post for a corner taken from the right.
Dann - Looked okay but understandably still at an early stage in getting an understanding with DD. This was the reason we were more shaky than usual at the back but I have no doubt he will become a very good signing.
Murray - Well he seems like a new signing to me. Stood up and applauded the TV as he came on - great moment.
Murray the new boy? Even at half-cock he looked well at home. If Ledley can speed up and Dann gives way to the better Gabbidon and Ince knows where he is, we can expect Murray 'Minty' to score a whole lot more soon.
|
skj Bedale, North Yorkshire (Ex-Carsha... 11 Feb 14 3.22pm |
|
|
Can't wonder why Ledley was positioned at 'Left Back' for the Baggies match. Everyone on here has mentioned it's not his natural position. Don't we have at least 2 adequate Left Back defenders already who aren't injured.
It just seems an odd choice when Ledley hadn't even played a competitive match with the team and his knowledge of the players around him are limited.
I'm not knocking it because it turned out to be a good decision to put him there. Having said that I would have put him in a more natural position for him in these early games.
I'm not TP though lol.
|
FinchleyEagle 11 Feb 14 3.38pm |
|
|
Ince was good - a bit lightweight but he plans to hit the gym apparently, other than that he stepped up well.
Ledley looked ok but I also thought it strange he was LB and reserve judgement until he plays in midfield.
Didn't think Dann did any better than Gabbidon, who didn't deserve to lose his place.
Nice look of depth about the squad especially when you consider that Guedioura and Williams didn't even make the bench.
You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue Yours sincerely Mile Jedinak
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 11 Feb 14 3.40pm |
|
Quote skj at 11 Feb 2014 3.22pm
Can't wonder why Ledley was positioned at 'Left Back' for the Baggies match. Everyone on here has mentioned it's not his natural position. Don't we have at least 2 adequate Left Back defenders already who aren't injured.
It just seems an odd choice when Ledley hadn't even played a competitive match with the team and his knowledge of the players around him are limited.
I'm not knocking it because it turned out to be a good decision to put him there. Having said that I would have put him in a more natural position for him in these early games.
I'm not TP though lol.
Shows what a good player he is!
|
girvinator Poole 11 Feb 14 4.36pm |
|
|
Not only is it clear that Ince is quality and has lots of talent but I'm really impressed with his attitude. He knows he has to work really hard, he knows his place isn't guaranteed and he's really bought into the club.
As for the Zaha v Ince debate, I think Zaha has more skills, natural ability and flair but Ince is more clinical I think and seems like a more well rounded professional. Would love to have both in the team but would happily settle for Incey boy.
Ledley seems solid and he has champions league experience and experience of playing for a top club in a big stadium. Good footballer and intelligent I think.
Scott Dann, still on the fence about him but I'd imagine as a centre back / centre back partnership he will become better each week he plays.
|
james03 Bangkok 12 Feb 14 8.32am |
|
|
Ince has a much better all round game and has very good support from his father both as a father and, until recently, as his club manager. He is more of a goalscorer than Wilf and can, as we have already seen, play out wide or behind the main striker.
Wilf is much more of a flair player with tricks aplenty. He will change some games and have little impact in others. His goal scoring record is poor for a player of his undoubted talent. He has also stalled in his progress by being left in the cold at Moan U and it will take him a couple of months to get up to speed in this league - fortunately he is unlikely to make a significant impact for Cardiff!
The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx
|
cornwalls palace Torpoint 12 Feb 14 8.59am |
|
Quote james03 at 12 Feb 2014 8.32am
Ince has a much better all round game and has very good support from his father both as a father and, until recently, as his club manager. He is more of a goalscorer than Wilf and can, as we have already seen, play out wide or behind the main striker.
Wilf is much more of a flair player with tricks aplenty. He will change some games and have little impact in others. His goal scoring record is poor for a player of his undoubted talent. He has also stalled in his progress by being left in the cold at Moan U and it will take him a couple of months to get up to speed in this league - fortunately he is unlikely to make a significant impact for Cardiff!
...he played well last night and scored (offside), taken off stupidly on the hour, we all know what he can do!
.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 12 Feb 14 4.50pm |
|
Quote cornwalls palace at 12 Feb 2014 8.59am
Quote james03 at 12 Feb 2014 8.32am
Ince has a much better all round game and has very good support from his father both as a father and, until recently, as his club manager. He is more of a goalscorer than Wilf and can, as we have already seen, play out wide or behind the main striker.
Wilf is much more of a flair player with tricks aplenty. He will change some games and have little impact in others. His goal scoring record is poor for a player of his undoubted talent. He has also stalled in his progress by being left in the cold at Moan U and it will take him a couple of months to get up to speed in this league - fortunately he is unlikely to make a significant impact for Cardiff!
...he played well last night and scored (offside), taken off stupidly on the hour, we all know what he can do!
Can't believe the above was posted by anyone who has seen Wilf play. A magnificent player who can beat opponents and score easily. I think Cardiff must be under orders from Utd not to play the boy too much. Anyway he was getting beaten up and made the agrieved Cardiff full back look a real hacker. If only Wilf had stayed with us, a sentiment I bet he is thinking himself.
|