You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tony Pulis
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tony Pulis


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
CroydonPenny Flag Croydon 09 Feb 14 8.13pm

Tbh it is very typical of Pulis to show the humility he did in his post match interview. At the moment he may have a special connection with Stoke but he is here to get the job set out at the start of the season. To keep Palace in the premiership. But once we stayed up and maybe if we become an established premier league side, who is to say Pulis won't be here for 10 years and then will have the same emotional connection the club that he currently shares with Stoke?

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 09 Feb 14 8.14pm

Quote est1905 at 09 Feb 2014 5.18pm

Quote Kermit8 at 09 Feb 2014 12.11am

Superb manager. Really good. He's gonna keep us up for sure.

But hearing his post-match interview it is obvious that he hasn't got an ounce of love for Palace and to him it is just a job and a great challenge.

Venables, Coppell and even Dowie......they somehow belonged even if short-lived for two of them.

Is this the reason why there are no TP songs? The fact that we all know that this relationship has zero to do with passion and everything to do with pragmatism?

I love the fact we are going to stay up but i don't like the other fact that I can't warm to our manager even though i admire him.

The drawback of success?

Edited by Kermit8 (09 Feb 2014 12.13am)

I agree, Instead of saying 'us' or 'we' he always refers to the club/team as 'the football club' which is a clear indication that there is no love there at all and its just a job.
I see that as a positive though in that he is clearly an honest man that finds it difficult to waltz in and after 5 minutes start acting like he's a life long fan. If he is enjoying the challenge, being well paid for it and not (yet) being courted by bigger clubs with bigger spending budgets I'm sure he'll stay and as time moves on I think he will grow to have affection for the club and then his feelings for Palace will be genuine and not just paying lip service to the fans (like one or two previous managers I could name!)



He'll love us when we are all dancing on the Craven Cottage pitch last game of the season after Chammers 90 + 5 penalty keeps us up

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

LeBoeuf Flag Bermondsey 09 Feb 14 9.00pm

cant say i noticed anything in his interviews to suggest that. He seems to show that same passion he had at stoke, while prowling the touchline during matches. Barking orders, remonstrating with officials, and getting excited when we score.

What has suprised me is the brand of football we're playing. I said to my dad when he first took charge, that i wouldnt watch "thug football", which is what i think stoke played, under his regime.

Direct football is def our style, and a pleasant suprise he's gotten us playing that way. Suits us and our players. The results are there to see. And we've still not taken a tonking off anyone yet.
Sure, there's areas we can improve, but i think we've got the best man to do that, and take us forward.

 


a rich man is only a poor man with an obscene amount of money

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Feb 14 9.08pm

Far too much sentiment here TP is here to do a job and he is focused and single minded. So what if he doesn't say that he 'loves' us. I don't look for that in a manager just doing the job he's paid for.

 


Bring back Brolin

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 09 Feb 14 9.29pm

I think he's turning already. He's already becoming more and more complimentary about the fans, even broke a smile a couple of times in the past week.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

FinchleyEagle Flag 10 Feb 14 7.41am

Kerms, Interesting post. However for me this is a case of be careful what you wish for. Surely if anyone, DF was 'one of us' and it didn't take much to turn his head. So those who are one of us are just as likely to do one so all you can get is someone good. James Beattie once said that loyalty in football is only for fans and I think that's the case. To get anything else from paid professionals is pipe dreaming and so rare, which is why Jules is rightly lauded. To expect it from a manager after 3 months is highly unrealistic.

But I don't think it has anything to do with any perceived lack of songs, a crowd just isn't that cerebral. And anyway there were 2 renditions of TP red and blue army on Saturday.

Edited by FinchleyEagle (10 Feb 2014 8.11am)

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

slubglurge Flag welling 10 Feb 14 9.47am

TP was and is the only manager who can keep us up, if we had gone for Karanka, Meulensteen or Petrescu, we'd be dead in the water now. I remember Stoke fans coming on here and telling us that he is ultra professional and very hands on. I think we can all see that they were very true words. How he has got this group of players to where we are now is nothing short of miraculous. The good thing as well is that the new signings are players that the manager really wanted which will keep him happy. He is the complete opposite of Holloway and boy does it show.
He was the expensive option and his salary did seem on the high side but he's been worth every penny and its the going rate for a quality manager. I was one of many against the appointment but i'm more than happy to get indigestion while i eat my words.

 

Part Time James Flag 10 Feb 14 9.59am

We'll just have to work on him. I mean, he's already bought a Palace baseball cap. In a couple of years he will have had such a fun time he'll have a replica shirt and an eagle tattooed on his back :-)

 




thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 10 Feb 14 10.12am

He is not here to love the club, he's here to make us a competitive unit and keep us in the PL. Peter Taylor and Ian Holloway loved the club, but....

 

Alexi_the_Eagle Flag Newton-le-Willows 10 Feb 14 10.42am

Pulis knows what he's doing. If he guided Stoke to Premier League stability over the last 6 years, who's to say he can't do it with Palace?

If he keeps us up (and I know he will) at the end of the season, then he should get the Manager of the Year award.

 


"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!"

Leicestershireeagle Flag South Leicestershire 10 Feb 14 12.29pm

When he's interviewed, win, lose or draw, he always seems have his feet firmly planted on the ground. He knows he can't get carried away, or be over-expectant.

It's his levelheaded-ness and pragmatism that will keep us up. If the results aren't going our way, then by all means question his commitment, but he is delivering the results and is fully committed to the job at hand. He may learn to love the club, but as long as he continues to provide results, I don't think we can complain! Many of us treated Dougie being our manager as a fairy tale waiting to happen, and look how that turned out?

He is unbelievably professional, and that's what matters at the end of the day. You can't expect someone to join a club and instantly buy into every aspect of it, but he has an opportunity here to become a historic manager and who knows where he will lead us. If we stay up, he has to be retained for aslong as he delivers results, because he can help grow the club like he did at Stoke.

 


RED AND BLUE ARMY!

seeweedhater Flag London 10 Feb 14 12.59pm

Fairs fair ,thought it was only decent of me to post whilst not being a T.P.lover as many of are aware.

Good result sat,but glad to see Ince,Ledley score on their debuts.

But here's my bug with him C.J has been woeful for most of his games and Gayle could have performed in that roaming role like Ince did on saturday all along.
And Ledley has got to be more an asset in m/f pushing forward rather than L/b very strange?

Anyway great to have FFS back.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Feb 14 1.13pm

Tony Pulis is an excellent manager, and probably close to achieving a Palace historical achievement - Remaining in the premiership, despite being handed a team that were rightly written off as relegated.

It might not be the most attractive football, but its tactically asute and adept, based on exploitation of strengths and minimising of weaknesses. A lot of managers could learn a thing or two about adaptability in football from him, and Martinez. Other managers talk tactics, but they base their theory on what they know. Martinez and Pulis have an almost mathematical approch to a game where 'possession' is vaunted as the ideal, they play a guerilla football.

Pulis's achievements in the premier league are probably only eclipsed by Wenger and Ferguson. Other managers have achieved more, such as Muarino, but they did it backed by huge cash reserves and the pick of the worlds best.

Pulis is the Viet Cong to the Premier League 'American US Military'. The very fact he's got us in competition for premiership survival should be greated with applause and respect. If he achieves it, then he should be raised up to the same kind of status reserved for the likes of Ferguson.

It might not be the prettiest, but its not about how good you look, its entirely about points.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Feb 14 1.15pm

Quote The Sash at 09 Feb 2014 8.14pm

Quote est1905 at 09 Feb 2014 5.18pm

Quote Kermit8 at 09 Feb 2014 12.11am

Superb manager. Really good. He's gonna keep us up for sure.

But hearing his post-match interview it is obvious that he hasn't got an ounce of love for Palace and to him it is just a job and a great challenge.

Venables, Coppell and even Dowie......they somehow belonged even if short-lived for two of them.

Is this the reason why there are no TP songs? The fact that we all know that this relationship has zero to do with passion and everything to do with pragmatism?

I love the fact we are going to stay up but i don't like the other fact that I can't warm to our manager even though i admire him.

The drawback of success?

Edited by Kermit8 (09 Feb 2014 12.13am)

I agree, Instead of saying 'us' or 'we' he always refers to the club/team as 'the football club' which is a clear indication that there is no love there at all and its just a job.
I see that as a positive though in that he is clearly an honest man that finds it difficult to waltz in and after 5 minutes start acting like he's a life long fan. If he is enjoying the challenge, being well paid for it and not (yet) being courted by bigger clubs with bigger spending budgets I'm sure he'll stay and as time moves on I think he will grow to have affection for the club and then his feelings for Palace will be genuine and not just paying lip service to the fans (like one or two previous managers I could name!)



He'll love us when we are all dancing on the Craven Cottage pitch last game of the season after Chammers 90 + 5 penalty keeps us up

We're in a position where that game could be irrelivent. We have the potential to be safe by then. As opposed to when he took over, where we might have been relegated with dubious 'Derby county' honours.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

sydtheeagle Flag England 10 Feb 14 1.26pm

I don't really understand those who denigrate Pulis. The purpose of football is to win matches and reach, then remain in, top flight. The size of your budget can either aid or abet this goal. Pulis has consistently led his teams to both success and survival. Surely it is those outcomes that define his position as an absolutely top-class manager?

Playing "Arsenal-style" possession football versus "Pulis-style" power football certainly involves two different kettles of fish but why is one better than the other and who is to say it is, anyway? No one says Monet is a better artist than Leonardo is a better artist than Picasso because one group of people finds one's style more aesthetically pleasing than another's. They are all world-class artists who just depict things in different ways; not better or worse, just different. The same with music; no one can say Mozart is better than Beethoven is better than Mahler. They all compose music recognised as sublime in vastly different styles. Did someone appoint Alan Hansen or whoever the definitive arbiter of taste while I was out of the room?

The "Pulis football is coarse" argument is absolutely pathetic. His teams are organised, powerful, near impossible to break down, well coached, responsible and, dare I say it, even exciting. I don't know about you, but winning on a regular basis in the Premiership is pretty exciting in my book, and with two genuine wingers at that. The fact that without a big-four budget, Pulis is doing it by making a silk purse out of a sow's ear makes it even more impressive.

In reality, any idiot can manage a team with a Chelsea-sized budget. Even Moyes, who is pathologically useless, has Man. Utd. in the top seven in spite of his lack of competence rather than because of it. I don't see that we're playing a brand of football that's any better or any worse than any other team in our area of the table except possibly Swansea. And with better players having come in during the last window, I'm sure Pulis will have us playing a more attacking brand of football too. Anyone want Holloway and his "prettier football" back? Thought not.

Edited by sydtheeagle (10 Feb 2014 1.27pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

seeweedhater Flag London 10 Feb 14 1.31pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 10 Feb 2014 1.13pm

Tony Pulis is an excellent manager, and probably close to achieving a Palace historical achievement - Remaining in the premiership, despite being handed a team that were rightly written off as relegated.

It might not be the most attractive football, but its tactically asute and adept, based on exploitation of strengths and minimising of weaknesses. A lot of managers could learn a thing or two about adaptability in football from him, and Martinez. Other managers talk tactics, but they base their theory on what they know. Martinez and Pulis have an almost mathematical approch to a game where 'possession' is vaunted as the ideal, they play a guerilla football.

Pulis's achievements in the premier league are probably only eclipsed by Wenger and Ferguson. Other managers have achieved more, such as Muarino, but they did it backed by huge cash reserves and the pick of the worlds best.

Pulis is the Viet Cong to the Premier League 'American US Military'. The very fact he's got us in competition for premiership survival should be greated with applause and respect. If he achieves it, then he should be raised up to the same kind of status reserved for the likes of Ferguson.

It might not be the prettiest, but its not about how good you look, its entirely about points.


Dunno about that,reckon we are like the kamikaze pilots, Tora,Tora ,Tora.

Wish we was like THE RED ARROWS!

Oh well.

 

chad scfc Flag 10 Feb 14 2.51pm

Glad to see the majority are appreciating TP.

You can understand why he still has a soft spot for Stoke. His achievement with us was nothing short of miraculous and it looks like he may achieve a miracle at Palace as well. You were dead and buried before he joined and now youre level with us (didn't want him to do that well but never mind). Like people have hinted in terms of what he does hes every bit the manager that Mourinho, Wenger and Ferguson are. In reality do you believe any of them could have turned your season around ? Don't think he ever won a manager of the month in ten years, which says more about how the awards are distributed rather than anything about TP

Ok his football isn't always that good to watch but in the situation youre in surely its better than watching pretty tippy tappy stuff but losing every week.

Just to correct a couple of misconceptions though

I don't think that he was sacked. Rumour is he had a strong disagreement with a couple of clowns who took charge of our transfer policy and it was genuine agreement by both parties that he left.

Althuough at the beginning he worked on a very tight budget the last two years saw us spend near on £80million.

Anyway I genuinely hope he keeps you up (goodbye Fulham, Cardiff and West Brazil). Would really like him to bring you back to the Brit, Im sure he would get a fantastic reception

 

spt46 Flag 10 Feb 14 3.38pm

It would be good for CPFC to celebrate a second consecutive season in the PL this August for the first time, with TP still with us.
With 9 managers in 9 years, a bit of management stability would be nice.

Doesn't TP know the 'curse of the ex-Palace manager?

Holloway: heading downwards with Millwall.
Freedman: same direction with Bolton.
Burley: fired from Limassol, now unemployed.
Hart: at ClownTown, favourites for relegation.
Colin: no proper job, a 'rent-a-quote' troll.
Taylor: at Gillingham again trying to keep them in L1.
Dowie: a SkySports 'rentamouth'.
Francis: not managed anywhere since CPFC in 2003.

A quick glance at the current CV of the previous eight should be enough to keep TP at Selhurst for a while.


 

pax3908 Flag 10 Feb 14 11.32pm

Quote Kermit8 at 09 Feb 2014 12.11am

Superb manager. Really good. He's gonna keep us up for sure.

But hearing his post-match interview it is obvious that he hasn't got an ounce of love for Palace and to him it is just a job and a great challenge.

Venables, Coppell and even Dowie......they somehow belonged even if short-lived for two of them.

Is this the reason why there are no TP songs? The fact that we all know that this relationship has zero to do with passion and everything to do with pragmatism?

I love the fact we are going to stay up but i don't like the other fact that I can't warm to our manager even though i admire him.

The drawback of success?


Are you neurotic man,your worrying about something for the sake of it,for goodness sake enjoy the football and winning for a change,with a manager who knows what he is doing!!!


Edited by Kermit8 (09 Feb 2014 12.13am)


 

aquickgame2 Flag Beni = summer,Caribbean = winter 11 Feb 14 7.17am

The man is here to do a job and at the moment he is doing more than expected.

True or not I dont know but I heard he's on a bonus of a Mill to keep us up.

He doesn't have to love the club or the fans (that may come in the future)just let him do his business,keep us up if possible,then we shall see.

By the way I like the bloke,even when he was a Stokie,put out a strong team and not one club liked playing them and the Brittania was a fcking noisey place then,gone a bit quieter now....maybe they did stick Delhila up there arse

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tony Pulis