You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who will make way for Murray
November 16 2026 1.03pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who will make way for Murray


Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 09 Feb 14 12.59pm

With Murray so near to a full match return, Being a 30 goal a season man, We are desperate for him to come back. Who do you think will make way for him, My opinion is I think he will play the jerome role in front of Chamakh, with Balasie losing his place. Views and opinions please

 

YoDougie Flag London 09 Feb 14 1.02pm

I'm not entirely sure. For the next few games I'd imagine he's going to be used from the bench. But the Ince behind Chamakh worked so well yesterday, he's not going to just walk into the team. He'll have to work hard. I think Jerome's place is gone. Ince has it and Murray would be next to slot in there(maybe Chamakh would go behind Murray playing uptop)

Or maybe we'll see Bolasie dropped with Ince on the wing, putting chamakh in the hole and Murray furthest forward.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 09 Feb 14 1.03pm

I don't think anyone will make way for Murray. It's going to take him the rest of the season to get anywhere near full-pace given the severity of his injury and I suspect that his role yesterday is exactly what it'll be between now and May. The right approach will be using him off the bench in the hope he'll net a couple to turn games late on while priming him for a full return in August. With Ince and to a lesser extent Jerome, we have the luxury of not needing to rush him.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 10 Feb 14 3.28pm

I don't think we'll see much of Jerome, but I'd imagine that most of Murray's time on the pitch will come from the bench, or if Chamakh gets injured - and mostly he'll replace Chamakh if we're winning.

If we're going to go two upfront, ie we're losing, then he'll likely be coming on for KG. But I don't expect him to be starting too many games.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

hasper259 Flag London 10 Feb 14 3.37pm

Quote Medway Eagle at 09 Feb 2014 12.59pm

With Murray so near to a full match return, Being a 30 goal a season man, We are desperate for him to come back. Who do you think will make way for him, My opinion is I think he will play the jerome role in front of Chamakh, with Balasie losing his place. Views and opinions please


It really annoy me how people think Murray is just going to bounce back from a 9 month injury and play like he was last season. You cant seriously believe he is going to be banging in goals for the next 13 games at the same rate as last season in the championship?!?

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 10 Feb 14 3.42pm

Quote hasper259 at 10 Feb 2014 3.37pm

Quote Medway Eagle at 09 Feb 2014 12.59pm

With Murray so near to a full match return, Being a 30 goal a season man, We are desperate for him to come back. Who do you think will make way for him, My opinion is I think he will play the jerome role in front of Chamakh, with Balasie losing his place. Views and opinions please


It really annoy me how people think Murray is just going to bounce back from a 9 month injury and play like he was last season. You cant seriously believe he is going to be banging in goals for the next 13 games at the same rate as last season in the championship?!?


If Murray gets 3/4 they could make the difference. It will take him 4 or 5 games to get properly match fit so that only gives him 8 or 9 games and he has never played in this league before, several of those games are against the top clubs where chances will be very limited. 3/4 would be a one in two/three ratio which would be brilliant.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 10 Feb 14 4.54pm

If out of our four defenders Ledley isn't one of them, you have six outfielders left to pick

Which for me these are from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

So is it two from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, or Ledley as defensive midfielders with Ledley playing more 'box to box'. For me Ledley plus other.

Then four from Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray. For me Ince, Chamakh & Murray then one from Puncheon & Bolasie. For me Bolasie, Ince, Chamakh & Murray.

So for me its GK + 4 defenders, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

As TP seems to have a good understanding with players that they may have to play out of position this will change with who we are playing. A lesser version (standard) of total football or am I going OTT?


 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

Midlands Eagle Flag 10 Feb 14 5.28pm

Quote PALACE FOR EVER at 10 Feb 2014 4.54pm

If out of our four defenders Ledley isn't one of them, you have six outfielders left to pick

Which for me these are from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

What happened to Guedioura?


 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 10 Feb 14 5.34pm

he's also not that close to returning to full fitness! he's had 1 and a half games in 9 months. no pre season. he'll be lucky to start a game this season.

 


@sxp55555

9eagle Flag 10 Feb 14 11.51pm

Couldn't we play Ince up front with bolasie, chamakh and punch behind him.
If he can score a s***load of goals from the wing in the championship surely he'd get a few (definitely more than Jerome) in the prem.

 

9eagle Flag 10 Feb 14 11.53pm

Quote 9eagle at 10 Feb 2014 11.51pm

Couldn't we play Ince up front with bolasie, chamakh and punch behind him.
If he can score a s***load of goals from the wing in the championship surely he'd get a few (definitely more than Jerome) in the prem.

Then when bringing on Murray let Ince take bolasie or puncheon's place.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Feb 14 12.21am

Bolasie, unfortunately.

Jedinak

Puncheon Bannan Ince

Chamakh Murray

...is how i see it.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Feb 14 12.22am

Quote sprites at 11 Feb 2014 12.21am

Bolasie, unfortunately.

Jedinak

Puncheon Bannan Ince

Chamakh Murray

...is how i see it.


Sorry - i should add i know Pulis aint gonna play Bazza. Just what i would do.

 

MikeT Flag Burlington (Toronto Area) 11 Feb 14 2.57am

Quote PALACE FOR EVER at 10 Feb 2014 4.54pm

If out of our four defenders Ledley isn't one of them, you have six outfielders left to pick

Which for me these are from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

So is it two from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, or Ledley as defensive midfielders with Ledley playing more 'box to box'. For me Ledley plus other.

Then four from Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray. For me Ince, Chamakh & Murray then one from Puncheon & Bolasie. For me Bolasie, Ince, Chamakh & Murray.

So for me its GK + 4 defenders, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

As TP seems to have a good understanding with players that they may have to play out of position this will change with who we are playing. A lesser version (standard) of total football or am I going OTT?

This is close. Mine would be:

Jedinak Ledley
Puncheon Ince Bolasie
Chamakh

Murray on as a late sub replacing Puncheon or Bolasie.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Feb 14 3.29am

Quote MikeT at 11 Feb 2014 2.57am

Quote PALACE FOR EVER at 10 Feb 2014 4.54pm

If out of our four defenders Ledley isn't one of them, you have six outfielders left to pick

Which for me these are from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

So is it two from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, or Ledley as defensive midfielders with Ledley playing more 'box to box'. For me Ledley plus other.

Then four from Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray. For me Ince, Chamakh & Murray then one from Puncheon & Bolasie. For me Bolasie, Ince, Chamakh & Murray.

So for me its GK + 4 defenders, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

As TP seems to have a good understanding with players that they may have to play out of position this will change with who we are playing. A lesser version (standard) of total football or am I going OTT?

This is close. Mine would be:

Jedinak Ledley
Puncheon Ince Bolasie
Chamakh

Murray on as a late sub replacing Puncheon or Bolasie.


But why start Chamakh leading the line when clearly his best position is just behind the main striker?

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 11 Feb 14 7.53am


Speroni

Ward / Gabbs / DD / Murray

Bolasie / Jedi / Ledley / Puncheon

Ince / Chamakh

Try it TP. IT.MIGHT.WORK!

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

MikeT Flag Burlington (Toronto Area) 11 Feb 14 9.27am

Quote sprites at 11 Feb 2014 3.29am

Quote MikeT at 11 Feb 2014 2.57am

Quote PALACE FOR EVER at 10 Feb 2014 4.54pm

If out of our four defenders Ledley isn't one of them, you have six outfielders left to pick

Which for me these are from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

So is it two from Dikgacoi, Jedinak, or Ledley as defensive midfielders with Ledley playing more 'box to box'. For me Ledley plus other.

Then four from Ince, Puncheon, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray. For me Ince, Chamakh & Murray then one from Puncheon & Bolasie. For me Bolasie, Ince, Chamakh & Murray.

So for me its GK + 4 defenders, Jedinak, Ledley, Ince, Bolasie, Chamakh & Murray.

As TP seems to have a good understanding with players that they may have to play out of position this will change with who we are playing. A lesser version (standard) of total football or am I going OTT?

This is close. Mine would be:

Jedinak Ledley
Puncheon Ince Bolasie
Chamakh

Murray on as a late sub replacing Puncheon or Bolasie.


But why start Chamakh leading the line when clearly his best position is just behind the main striker?

Given Murray is unlikely to be fit enough for a full 90 minutes for quite a few games, Chamakh leading the line with Ince in the hole is the best option and worked well against West Brom. Ince was prepared to go beyond Cham and they often exchanged positions.

 

Arthur Blackpudding Flag 11 Feb 14 10.16am

If and when Murray is fully fit, which won't be for a few games I can see the midfield and attack being like this.

------Jedi Ledley
Punch------------Ince
-----Chamakh
----------Murray

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 11 Feb 14 3.33pm

Although the knives are out for Jerome I can't help thinking just how much on the ball skill he has to offer. Sometimes it's so smooth that I take it a step further and see him as the main man with Glen up front. Thankfully this unpopular scenario wont happen for a long time as Mr 30 goals will not be ready for some time yet.

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who will make way for Murray