This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Will our fantastic support continue if relegated?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Beastie 10 Feb 14 4.51pm |
|
Quote We are goin up! at 10 Feb 2014 4.41pm
Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 2.13pm
Like all clubs, our traditional support comes from young working class males with roots in the local area and the more football is taken away from these sorts of people, the worse the atmosphere’s will become. Not a popular view but it’s true.
So what you're saying is that someone who is middle class is incapable of singing loudly?
Not incapable, less likely to.
I'm not singling out the posh - older people, women and kids are all highly unlikely to improve the atmosphere.
|
dicky boy Rainham.........Kent 10 Feb 14 5.15pm |
|
|
Say "it" does happen then those that leave will be those that probably didnt sing or cheer clap or interact anyways so......basically it'll be those that make the noise and as im in block Y of the Arfur i'll keep singing along with the HF n AW anyways......
ROY HODGSON's RED''BLUE ARMY
Ohhhh Lukaaaa ooooooh.... Ohhhhh Lukaaaa ooooooh.... He come's from Serbia........... He'll F**king Murdaaa Yaaa.......... Ohhhhh Lukaaaa ooooooh........
|
Mapletree Croydon 10 Feb 14 5.56pm |
|
|
It's housing class that matters
We should ban anyone new from applying for tickets from Purley, Woldingham and Carshalton Beeches.
The lads and ladies from New Addington, Thornton Heath Pond and Waddon should always take precedence.
|
blanksight Thornton heath 10 Feb 14 5.56pm |
|
|
It would get better. It has often been subdued this season.
I'd rather be a FREE MAN in my grave than living as a PUPPET or a SLAVE
|
Vaibow vancouver/croydon 10 Feb 14 6.36pm |
|
Quote eagle184 at 10 Feb 2014 9.16am
Our support has been awesome for a few seasons now, but this season has pushed on even further, with recognition for other fans, players, managers, plaudits, etc., etc. We have also attracted new supports, which is a good thing, But will this continue next season if we do get relegated?
judging by previous years, taking into account the highs and lows... well, this is a question that doesn't need to be asked... only a newbie would ask this... (not saying you are)
This was once a quality forum....
|
7@burnley79 Battersea 12 Feb 14 1.13am |
|
|
If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans will continue to generate the atmosphere we are now famous for. On the other hand if we continue in the Premier league we will be eventually sanitized by sky and fans who come for premiership football not Palace specifically. It may take a few years,but eventually peoples expectations will rise, they will start moaning for getting a draw at home to the wet spams and such like. Start calling for the managers head after 1 or 2 defeats. Prawns will be bought by the ton load, there be a separate car park for the rich fans limos. The true working class faithful will feel even more marginalised their enthusiasm will waver and 1 by 1 they won't be so vocal and we'll go down, because our support right now is what is keeping us afloat.
|
cornwalls palace Torpoint 12 Feb 14 1.48am |
|
Quote 7@burnley79 at 12 Feb 2014 1.13am
If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans will continue to generate the atmosphere we are now famous for. On the other hand if we continue in the Premier league we will be eventually sanitized by sky and fans who come for premiership football not Palace specifically. It may take a few years,but eventually peoples expectations will rise, they will start moaning for getting a draw at home to the wet spams and such like. Start calling for the managers head after 1 or 2 defeats. Prawns will be bought by the ton load, there be a separate car park for the rich fans limos. The true working class faithful will feel even more marginalised their enthusiasm will waver and 1 by 1 they won't be so vocal and we'll go down, because our support right now is what is keeping us afloat.
...has nothing to do with how the team is performing, or what league we are in, the HF are doing it as much for themselves as the team and see themselves as a shinning example for other clubs, I see them getting bigger, because they are bringing excitement and camaraderie through the singing... and they are being fed by knowing that they pee all over every other teams support.
.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 12 Feb 14 1.49am |
|
Quote 7@burnley79 at 12 Feb 2014 1.13am
If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans will continue to generate the atmosphere we are now famous for. On the other hand if we continue in the Premier league we will be eventually sanitized by sky and fans who come for premiership football not Palace specifically. It may take a few years,but eventually peoples expectations will rise, they will start moaning for getting a draw at home to the wet spams and such like. Start calling for the managers head after 1 or 2 defeats. Prawns will be bought by the ton load, there be a separate car park for the rich fans limos. The true working class faithful will feel even more marginalised their enthusiasm will waver and 1 by 1 they won't be so vocal and we'll go down, because our support right now is what is keeping us afloat.
Funny, I thought it was our team and manager who were doing that.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|
7@burnley79 Battersea 12 Feb 14 5.56am |
|
Quote Seth at 12 Feb 2014 1.49am
Quote 7@burnley79 at 12 Feb 2014 1.13am
If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans will continue to generate the atmosphere we are now famous for. On the other hand if we continue in the Premier league we will be eventually sanitized by sky and fans who come for premiership football not Palace specifically. It may take a few years,but eventually peoples expectations will rise, they will start moaning for getting a draw at home to the wet spams and such like. Start calling for the managers head after 1 or 2 defeats. Prawns will be bought by the ton load, there be a separate car park for the rich fans limos. The true working class faithful will feel even more marginalised their enthusiasm will waver and 1 by 1 they won't be so vocal and we'll go down, because our support right now is what is keeping us afloat.
Funny, I thought it was our team and manager who were doing that.
Of course Seth the team and manager are doing that, but I don't think we would be sitting 3 places above relegation without the help of both the HF and our vocal support. I'm responding to the OP question regarding atmosphere. I'm referring to group dynamics and how over a certain time frame atmosphere will change due to these dynamics. Its a certainty that over time what has helped us i.e atmosphere will waver. This is due to the sanitation that is Sky Sports and TV. There was a time not so long ago that if you wanted to watch Palace you had to go to watch Palace. Prolonged period in the premiership will change this. Personally i would take the premiership and this gamble all day long as I want to see palace play the top teams, but if we are still up in the top flight in say 4 years time mark my words it will be prawns and over exhausted expectations all round the ground come match days.
|
Midlands Eagle 12 Feb 14 7.33am |
|
Quote 7@burnley79 at 12 Feb 2014 1.13am
If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans will continue to generate the atmosphere we are now famous for. On the other hand if we continue in the Premier league we will be eventually sanitized by sky and fans who come for premiership football not Palace specifically. It may take a few years,but eventually peoples expectations will rise, they will start moaning for getting a draw at home to the wet spams and such like. Start calling for the managers head after 1 or 2 defeats. Prawns will be bought by the ton load, there be a separate car park for the rich fans limos. The true working class faithful will feel even more marginalised their enthusiasm will waver and 1 by 1 they won't be so vocal and we'll go down, because our support right now is what is keeping us afloat.
I think that you’re comments are a bit OTT as you’re implying that only those people that make a lot of noise are true Palace fans which is a load of nonsense.
Some people like to sing and shout and leap around all the time whilst others prefer to watch the football but both can be classified as true fans.
If you disagree then I guess that makes Steve Parish a plastic as I very much doubt whether he has ever spent his time at Selhurst Park leaping up and down and chanting.
Whilst no longer a regular at Selhurst Park I used to be for many years but wasn’t one for chanting or leaping but that didn’t make me any less of a fan than those that did and whilst the noise levels may have been less in those days it didn’t affect the team’s performance and we played well and won matches when we had a good team and played badly and lost when we didn’t.
The comments about prawns was also a bit daft as football ceased being a working class man’s sport many decades ago and quite right too. I started going to Selhurst 40 years ago and there were loads of middle classes there at the time – just as there are now and it’s unlikely to ever change
|
The Sash Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 12 Feb 14 8.37am |
|
Quote paperhat at 10 Feb 2014 11.42am
Quote Beastie at 10 Feb 2014 11.39am
I would say the longer we stay in the premier league, the worse our amosphere will be. Look at the other sets of supporters in the division, even the away fans don't sing.
It's embarrassing the amount of plaudits our support gets. It says much more about the typical premiership atmosphere than about how noisey we are.
only for the other teams.
Last week someone posted a comment from a woman at the Arsenal game "why don't they just sit down and watch the game", like we were in the wrong.
We should be proud of the noise we make, the players need it, it builds them up, and if it becomes even the slightest bit intimidating for the opposition then even better. If I want to sit in silence watching football, i'll get sky and watch it at home thanks.
The same Arsenal fans who the commentator mentioned on MOTD as starting to leave Anfield on Saturday when they went 3 or 4 down...
I may be wrong but I cant remember anyone leaving the night they pasted us 9-0
I think our vocal support hinges on the HF to be honest - take them away and we'd be like everybody else, if not worse.
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|
Ninjas Headband Biggleswade 12 Feb 14 9.30am |
|
Quote
The same Arsenal fans who the commentator mentioned on MOTD as starting to leave Anfield on Saturday when they went 3 or 4 down...
I may be wrong but I cant remember anyone leaving the night they pasted us 9-0
I think our vocal support hinges on the HF to be honest - take them away and we'd be like everybody else, if not worse.
If you took the HF out of the equation our support would still be one of the more vocal support in the Premier but certainly would not stand out from all of the rest in the country.
Quality photos of Palace on Flickr; [Link]
|
7@burnley79 Battersea 12 Feb 14 11.36am |
|
Quote Ian J at 12 Feb 2014 7.33am
Quote 7@burnley79 at 12 Feb 2014 1.13am
If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans will continue to generate the atmosphere we are now famous for. On the other hand if we continue in the Premier league we will be eventually sanitized by sky and fans who come for premiership football not Palace specifically. It may take a few years,but eventually peoples expectations will rise, they will start moaning for getting a draw at home to the wet spams and such like. Start calling for the managers head after 1 or 2 defeats. Prawns will be bought by the ton load, there be a separate car park for the rich fans limos. The true working class faithful will feel even more marginalised their enthusiasm will waver and 1 by 1 they won't be so vocal and we'll go down, because our support right now is what is keeping us afloat.
I think that you’re comments are a bit OTT as you’re implying that only those people that make a lot of noise are true Palace fans which is a load of nonsense.
Some people like to sing and shout and leap around all the time whilst others prefer to watch the football but both can be classified as true fans.
If you disagree then I guess that makes Steve Parish a plastic as I very much doubt whether he has ever spent his time at Selhurst Park leaping up and down and chanting.
Whilst no longer a regular at Selhurst Park I used to be for many years but wasn’t one for chanting or leaping but that didn’t make me any less of a fan than those that did and whilst the noise levels may have been less in those days it didn’t affect the team’s performance and we played well and won matches when we had a good team and played badly and lost when we didn’t.
The comments about prawns was also a bit daft as football ceased being a working class man’s sport many decades ago and quite right too. I started going to Selhurst 40 years ago and there were loads of middle classes there at the time – just as there are now and it’s unlikely to ever change
Let me try and clear up some of your assumptions.
"If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans " I think if you read it properly i'm implying that both our vocal support and our true fans (whether they sing or not). When regarding to the prawn brigade i'm referring to the fan of premiership football not Crystal Palace. This type of fan will surely leave us if we go down and quite frankly good riddance and please take your sandwiches with you. You are entitled to support your team as you see fit Ian, but thank god we don't all share in your boisterous approach to supporting Palace otherwise frankly it would be a bore to go to games.
|
Seth On a pale blue dot 12 Feb 14 3.37pm |
|
Quote 7@burnley79 at 12 Feb 2014 5.56am
Quote Seth at 12 Feb 2014 1.49am
Quote 7@burnley79 at 12 Feb 2014 1.13am
If we go down our vocal support and those true Palace fans will continue to generate the atmosphere we are now famous for. On the other hand if we continue in the Premier league we will be eventually sanitized by sky and fans who come for premiership football not Palace specifically. It may take a few years,but eventually peoples expectations will rise, they will start moaning for getting a draw at home to the wet spams and such like. Start calling for the managers head after 1 or 2 defeats. Prawns will be bought by the ton load, there be a separate car park for the rich fans limos. The true working class faithful will feel even more marginalised their enthusiasm will waver and 1 by 1 they won't be so vocal and we'll go down, because our support right now is what is keeping us afloat.
Funny, I thought it was our team and manager who were doing that.
Of course Seth the team and manager are doing that, but I don't think we would be sitting 3 places above relegation without the help of both the HF and our vocal support. I'm responding to the OP question regarding atmosphere. I'm referring to group dynamics and how over a certain time frame atmosphere will change due to these dynamics. Its a certainty that over time what has helped us i.e atmosphere will waver. This is due to the sanitation that is Sky Sports and TV. There was a time not so long ago that if you wanted to watch Palace you had to go to watch Palace. Prolonged period in the premiership will change this. Personally i would take the premiership and this gamble all day long as I want to see palace play the top teams, but if we are still up in the top flight in say 4 years time mark my words it will be prawns and over exhausted expectations all round the ground come match days.
It's great we have a good atmosphere and fans who like to sing but I think you're giving it too much credit for what's happening on the pitch. Sure it helps encourage the players but it's not a given that the noisiest fans = the most successful teams by any stretch.
Our most successful time ever was before the HF were around and I'd say the fans don't make as much difference as you'd like to think.
"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down" FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16
|