BigTimeCharlie Bogota 19 Feb 14 3.01pm |
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Feb 2014 10.43am
Quote BigTimeCharlie at 19 Feb 2014 10.36am
Quote BelfastEagle at 17 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Campana was a worse signing.
Young player, obvious talent, resale value, has assisted a couple of goals for us this season... Yeah, I see your point there mate.
With regards to Sow, someone above used the word proven... 12 goals in the Swedish regional 3rd league a couple of years ago, 3 goals in the Moldovan league the season after. Now that's what I call pedigree!
Agree with the majority here, absolutely pointless signing, especially aged 23.
Means nothing on its own, our top goal scorer last season was doing alright in the lower leagues, and Gayle, whos gotten a few and looked promising, was playing in non-league football.
Talent can be anywhere, and sometimes it pays to take a risk on a player you can get really cheap. Taken Calvin Andrew, much lamented, but in that Administration season his contributions were vital in keeping us up when Alan Lee was injured. Cheap as chips player who more than made up for his cost.
That was more to illustrate my issue with the word 'proven' in this case, but whilst I agree about sometimes taking a punt, with Gayle and Murray both had been prolific at a certain level, whereas Sow never has. He also didn't pull up any trees in pre-season for us either, so for me signing him has been a waste of both wages and a year of the bloke's career - even without hindsight that should have been obvious.
|
EagleEyedAlbert ...too far north of the water. 20 Feb 14 12.59pm |
|
Quote Hansy at 19 Feb 2014 1.00pm
Quote BelfastEagle at 17 Feb 2014 9.16pm
Campana was a worse signing.
Completely wrong. Never put a foot wrong in our games. Forgetting Grandin/Thomas etc?
He'd have to move his feet around a bit more to put one wrong.
Why there's still so much fuss about this guy, I have no idea...
"IS HE!!?"
-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:
Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]
Me on the Twitter: [Link]
"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"
|
hursteagle 20 Feb 14 1.09pm |
|
|
I thought that the original idea of him signing was because we didn't have anybody who played like Chamakh on the books. And because IH wanted to build a team around Chamakh he thought it was important to have a similar player in the 21s.
Whether that's still the case though in another matter...
|
Andy_G Wimbledon 20 Feb 14 1.10pm |
|
Quote olls at 17 Feb 2014 8.08pm
Aruna Dindane last year... Did he even get off the bench?!
Did he even get on the bench?
The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years
|
Mystery Man Willingdon 20 Feb 14 1.12pm |
|
|
I think it's a little unfair on Sow - have many of you seen him play in the Dev team? When he was signed Millen was quoted as saying that he wouldn't be for the first team or prem 25 he would be for the dev squad. He seems something of a target man. To my knowledge this is something we don't have in the dev squad (if you ignore Wilbs appearances for that squad).
Has anyone seen enough of the dev team fixtures to make an informed comment about him and not just taking out frustrations from Holloway's dealings on a lad most of you could probably not even pick out of a line up?
Kyle De Silva, Reise Allassani, Michael Chambers, Jerome Williams, Jake Gray, Gus Sow, Ryan Innis. The Kids are alright! Twitter @petecmsmith1977
|
BigTimeCharlie Bogota 20 Feb 14 3.17pm |
|
Quote Mystery Man at 20 Feb 2014 1.12pm
I think it's a little unfair on Sow - have many of you seen him play in the Dev team? When he was signed Millen was quoted as saying that he wouldn't be for the first team or prem 25 he would be for the dev squad. He seems something of a target man. To my knowledge this is something we don't have in the dev squad (if you ignore Wilbs appearances for that squad).
Has anyone seen enough of the dev team fixtures to make an informed comment about him and not just taking out frustrations from Holloway's dealings on a lad most of you could probably not even pick out of a line up?
Ha fair points, you've definitely called me (and probably a few others) on that one.
|
oghash 20 Feb 14 4.11pm |
|
Quote Mystery Man at 20 Feb 2014 1.12pm
I think it's a little unfair on Sow - have many of you seen him play in the Dev team? When he was signed Millen was quoted as saying that he wouldn't be for the first team or prem 25 he would be for the dev squad. He seems something of a target man. To my knowledge this is something we don't have in the dev squad (if you ignore Wilbs appearances for that squad).
Has anyone seen enough of the dev team fixtures to make an informed comment about him and not just taking out frustrations from Holloway's dealings on a lad most of you could probably not even pick out of a line up?
i get what you're saying but wouldn't it be better to find someone a little younger and use the development team to develop them into a first team player? That way they coul break into the first team with other similarly aged players who had the ability.
Why would anyone chose to be a Seagull? The Eagle is a far superior creature.
The Seagull lives under it's damp pier meekly looking out, blinded by the sheer quality of the Eagle's palace.
|
Mystery Man Willingdon 20 Feb 14 4.17pm |
|
Quote oghash at 20 Feb 2014 4.11pm
Quote Mystery Man at 20 Feb 2014 1.12pm
I think it's a little unfair on Sow - have many of you seen him play in the Dev team? When he was signed Millen was quoted as saying that he wouldn't be for the first team or prem 25 he would be for the dev squad. He seems something of a target man. To my knowledge this is something we don't have in the dev squad (if you ignore Wilbs appearances for that squad).
Has anyone seen enough of the dev team fixtures to make an informed comment about him and not just taking out frustrations from Holloway's dealings on a lad most of you could probably not even pick out of a line up?
i get what you're saying but wouldn't it be better to find someone a little younger and use the development team to develop them into a first team player? That way they coul break into the first team with other similarly aged players who had the ability.
Oh of course and I have no idea if he is any good. I guess someone must have seen some potential but at 23 (I think) he is a little long in the tooth for the dev squad I would have thought. Possibly bought alongside the short term prem deals as an insurance policy for relegation. Should we go down and our single yearers all leave at least we may be left with some that can step up and have had a season under their belt within the club.
Just a thought and yes I am playing a bit of devils advocate as I am no more knowledgeable about Osman than any of you.
Kyle De Silva, Reise Allassani, Michael Chambers, Jerome Williams, Jake Gray, Gus Sow, Ryan Innis. The Kids are alright! Twitter @petecmsmith1977
|
oghash 20 Feb 14 4.57pm |
|
Quote Mystery Man at 20 Feb 2014 4.17pm
Quote oghash at 20 Feb 2014 4.11pm
Quote Mystery Man at 20 Feb 2014 1.12pm
I think it's a little unfair on Sow - have many of you seen him play in the Dev team? When he was signed Millen was quoted as saying that he wouldn't be for the first team or prem 25 he would be for the dev squad. He seems something of a target man. To my knowledge this is something we don't have in the dev squad (if you ignore Wilbs appearances for that squad).
Has anyone seen enough of the dev team fixtures to make an informed comment about him and not just taking out frustrations from Holloway's dealings on a lad most of you could probably not even pick out of a line up?
i get what you're saying but wouldn't it be better to find someone a little younger and use the development team to develop them into a first team player? That way they coul break into the first team with other similarly aged players who had the ability.
Oh of course and I have no idea if he is any good. I guess someone must have seen some potential but at 23 (I think) he is a little long in the tooth for the dev squad I would have thought. Possibly bought alongside the short term prem deals as an insurance policy for relegation. Should we go down and our single yearers all leave at least we may be left with some that can step up and have had a season under their belt within the club.
Just a thought and yes I am playing a bit of devils advocate as I am no more knowledgeable about Osman than any of you.
My fantasy teams are the worst in the world so I'm going to come out and say he is rubbish just to keep to my known ability at judging wrongly so he knocks 50 in for us next season.
Why would anyone chose to be a Seagull? The Eagle is a far superior creature.
The Seagull lives under it's damp pier meekly looking out, blinded by the sheer quality of the Eagle's palace.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Feb 14 5.47pm |
|
|
I saw him play in the pre-season matches and he was average enough. He may well need time to get used to English football. Haven't heard that he has particularly ever been much more than adequate in the development squad. Seems pretty unlikely he would be a premier league first team regular. However, if he plays I will support him as much as I supported Calvin Andrew.
Red and Blue Army!
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 20 Feb 14 5.59pm |
|
|
My point is osman sow will never come close to playing a league game for us whether it be in the premiership or championship. For me, pointless signing. Can't see us why he would be signed just for the development team. 23 years old, I'd rather the likes of Kaikai, sekajja, tieku and any other young player get there chance at development level.
|
Mystery Man Willingdon 21 Feb 14 10.07am |
|
Quote rossboss29 at 20 Feb 2014 5.59pm
My point is osman sow will never come close to playing a league game for us whether it be in the premiership or championship. For me, pointless signing. Can't see us why he would be signed just for the development team. 23 years old, I'd rather the likes of Kaikai, sekajja, tieku and any other young player get there chance at development level.
I know that was your point but based on what? Quite a statement to make unless you have some inside knowledge of course.
Kyle De Silva, Reise Allassani, Michael Chambers, Jerome Williams, Jake Gray, Gus Sow, Ryan Innis. The Kids are alright! Twitter @petecmsmith1977
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 21 Feb 14 10.10am |
|
|
I would put money on it? would you bet against me?
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 21 Feb 14 10.10am |
|
|
How can you justify given him an extension on his contract, based on not featuring for the first team, or barely featured for the U21s?
|
Mystery Man Willingdon 21 Feb 14 10.30am |
|
|
I don't have to justify anything. I have not made any unfounded bold statements about someone I have very very little knowledge of. I suggested it was a little unfair to state that he is not even good enough for a Championship outing. I agree that he most likely wouldn't be up to prem level but Millen did state when they were negotiating that he was being signed for the dev squad and I have suggested that perhaps he was signed with an eye on planning for a short term future in the Champ.
This is a non argument. I was interested to know more about him but in this thread I have learned nothing except rossboss thinks he will never play a competitive game for us unless in a much lower division.
Kyle De Silva, Reise Allassani, Michael Chambers, Jerome Williams, Jake Gray, Gus Sow, Ryan Innis. The Kids are alright! Twitter @petecmsmith1977
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 21 Feb 14 12.15pm |
|
|
Yeah in fairness, I have been using bold and sweeping statements. Good luck to the fella. If he does ever play for us, I wish him well, and hope he does well.
|
Mystery Man Willingdon 21 Feb 14 12.50pm |
|
|
Have any of us considered whether he may be related to Gus? And bought in as a family favour? 
Kyle De Silva, Reise Allassani, Michael Chambers, Jerome Williams, Jake Gray, Gus Sow, Ryan Innis. The Kids are alright! Twitter @petecmsmith1977
|