This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Guedioura loan to Forest
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
blind eagle Covington.Tennessee 19 Feb 14 2.11pm |
|
Quote Pawson Palace at 19 Feb 2014 11.28am
Hope he doesn't go was one of best players until he got injured.
His physicality adds a different dimention to our midfield and is quite good in the advanced position.
Yes I would have thought Pulis could have used him. Some things are strange in football and I guess I do not always understand!.
|
Bill Glazier Mitcham 19 Feb 14 2.28pm |
|
Quote Baldfella at 19 Feb 2014 12.35pm
So if he leaves on loan can we put Johnny Williams or Tom Ince In our 25 man squad as they weren't listed before ?
Edited by Baldfella (19 Feb 2014 12.35pm)
Baldfella please be having a wind-up asking that question.!!! Ince played against WBA. WE PLAYED A RINGER.!!!!!!!!!
|
LABoxers Wallington 19 Feb 14 2.38pm |
|
Quote Bill Glazier at 19 Feb 2014 2.28pm
Quote Baldfella at 19 Feb 2014 12.35pm
So if he leaves on loan can we put Johnny Williams or Tom Ince In our 25 man squad as they weren't listed before ?
Edited by Baldfella (19 Feb 2014 12.35pm)
Baldfella please be having a wind-up asking that question.!!! Ince played against WBA. WE PLAYED A RINGER.!!!!!!!!!
Pretty sure he is pulling our leg here!lol
|
BigTimeCharlie Bogota 19 Feb 14 2.51pm |
|
Quote Baldfella at 19 Feb 2014 12.35pm
So if he leaves on loan can we put Johnny Williams or Tom Ince In our 25 man squad as they weren't listed before ?
Edited by Baldfella (19 Feb 2014 12.35pm)
Both U-21 at start of the season, so don't need to be registered to be able to play.
|
Gallery3 South Croydon 19 Feb 14 3.14pm |
|
Quote Baldfella at 19 Feb 2014 12.35pm
So if he leaves on loan can we put Johnny Williams or Tom Ince In our 25 man squad as they weren't listed before ?
Edited by Baldfella (19 Feb 2014 12.35pm)
This has been covered before - they do not need to be named in the 25 as they are under 21s. So there is no need to get rid of anyone on loan as they can play anyway.
|
sydtheeagle England 19 Feb 14 3.22pm |
|
Quote Part Time James at 19 Feb 2014 1.33pm
I think Gayle will be kept as 'one for the future' but might go out on loan.
/quote]
One thing nobody has mentioned here is money. My guess is that Guediora, as a deadline day deal, is probably being paid an inflated salary and if Forest are happy to pick up his wages for the rest of the season, then it offsets some of the expense incurred by bringing in Ince, Ledley, and Dann which I suspect are not small sums. This may be fuelling our willingness to let Guediora move; his disproportionately high salary for a now bit part player are not sensible.
I think the only future Gayle would conceivably have to be kept for is a Championship one, and that's the reason he wasn't sold in the last window. If we go down, he might be worth having so we hedged our best. If we stay up, I think he'll be gone in the summer. Pulis clearly doesn't think he's Premiership quality. The fact I don't either is neither here nor there. Someone in the Championship (if it's not us) will pick him up in the summer.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
regal_eagle somewhere 19 Feb 14 3.59pm |
|
|
Good player. Don't want to see him leave at all.
|
Bill Glazier Mitcham 19 Feb 14 4.10pm |
|
Quote sydtheeagle at 19 Feb 2014 3.22pm
Quote Part Time James at 19 Feb 2014 1.33pm
I think Gayle will be kept as 'one for the future' but might go out on loan.
/quote]
One thing nobody has mentioned here is money. My guess is that Guediora, as a deadline day deal, is probably being paid an inflated salary and if Forest are happy to pick up his wages for the rest of the season, then it offsets some of the expense incurred by bringing in Ince, Ledley, and Dann which I suspect are not small sums. This may be fuelling our willingness to let Guediora move; his disproportionately high salary for a now bit part player are not sensible.
I think the only future Gayle would conceivably have to be kept for is a Championship one, and that's the reason he wasn't sold in the last window. If we go down, he might be worth having so we hedged our best. If we stay up, I think he'll be gone in the summer. Pulis clearly doesn't think he's Premiership quality. The fact I don't either is neither here nor there. Someone in the Championship (if it's not us) will pick him up in the summer.
Yet was in the squad against West Brom. Pulis obviously has not written him off yet Syd.? Unlike yourself.
|
Kermit8 Hevon 19 Feb 14 4.34pm |
|
|
I've just seen an early press release from 2017 when Gayle's contract is up.
Good news
It says 'Dwight will be offered another 4 year deal as we think he is one for the future'
Big chest and massive boobs
[Link]
|
Baldfella Wigan 19 Feb 14 5.37pm |
|
Quote LABoxers at 19 Feb 2014 2.38pm
Quote Bill Glazier at 19 Feb 2014 2.28pm
Quote Baldfella at 19 Feb 2014 12.35pm
So if he leaves on loan can we put Johnny Williams or Tom Ince In our 25 man squad as they weren't listed before ?
Edited by Baldfella (19 Feb 2014 12.35pm)
Baldfella please be having a wind-up asking that question.!!! Ince played against WBA. WE PLAYED A RINGER.!!!!!!!!!
Pretty sure he is pulling our leg here!lol
Yes it's a wind up ! Wanted to get in there before anyone asked the question but meant it !
|
sydtheeagle England 20 Feb 14 6.50am |
|
Quote Bill Glazier at 19 Feb 2014 4.10pm
Yet was in the squad against West Brom. Pulis obviously has not written him off yet Syd.? Unlike yourself.
We will see. But "In the squad" is a hardly a ringing endorsement, is it, given that he has spent the whole season falling further and further down the pecking order. Of course, you may be right and Pulis rates him. Or I may be right and he doesn't. But I would say the evidence is fairly clear. An out of position Ince, an injured Murray and a career substitute in Jerome all get on the pitch comfortably ahead of him. You can count the minutes he's actually played since Pulis arrived on a couple of hands and feet.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.
|
Andy_G Wimbledon 20 Feb 14 6.56am |
|
Quote leejaneagles at 19 Feb 2014 11.00am
Pulis really didn't think much of Holloway's signings did he?
Only Puncheon and Chamakh have been somewhat successful. He clearly doesn't rate Bannan, Guerdiora, Kebe, Jerome, Gayle or Campana.
Damn, what a waste of money. No wonder 2010 were very reluctant to rebuild again in January (although they did eventually and I'm not complaining).
Probably true except for Gayle. What a fook up we made last summer!
The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years
|
BelfastEagle 20 Feb 14 8.39am |
|
Quote Andy_G at 20 Feb 2014 6.56am
Quote leejaneagles at 19 Feb 2014 11.00am
Pulis really didn't think much of Holloway's signings did he?
Only Puncheon and Chamakh have been somewhat successful. He clearly doesn't rate Bannan, Guerdiora, Kebe, Jerome, Gayle or Campana.
Damn, what a waste of money. No wonder 2010 were very reluctant to rebuild again in January (although they did eventually and I'm not complaining).
Probably true except for Gayle. What a fook up we made last summer!
To be honest nobody forced 2010 to agree with Holloways requests, they were quick enough to stop TP buying a number of players. I think 2010 were as liable for any fook ups as Holloway.
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 20 Feb 14 3.38pm |
|
|
If Gayle does go before fulfilling any kind of potential it will reflect badly on Palace. He was a good player before he came, so what's changed? Cost loads too. Only the likes of Arsenal write off a player too quickly. Alternativley, Palace have always allowed time for young players and made the corresponding profit as well as providing internationals.
|
MPE Maidstone 20 Feb 14 4.57pm |
|
|
Plenty of players i would like to see go out on loan, before him, and he is in the 25! My fear is if called upon, due to injuries or suspensions, he would do a good job, and we need that cover for our run in!
Edited by MPE (20 Feb 2014 4.59pm)
Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in
|
est1905 20 Feb 14 5.33pm |
|
Quote MPE at 20 Feb 2014 4.57pm
Plenty of players i would like to see go out on loan, before him, and he is in the 25! My fear is if called upon, due to injuries or suspensions, he would do a good job, and we need that cover for our run in!
Edited by MPE (20 Feb 2014 4.59pm) I like him and if it were up to me I'd keep him but if he is to go out on loan I think I'd definitely make sure Forest accept a 24 hour recall clause to cover ourselves against injuries/suspensions. As said he is in our 25 after all!
|
WelshEagle London 20 Feb 14 5.39pm |
|
|
Is there anything behind this or is it just idle rumour. I hope it's the latter in the cases of both Gayle and Guedioura. They both have the type of quality we need in terms of squad players. I'd go as far as to say Gayle has match winning potential off the bench. Letting him go on loan would be insane.
|
ambrose77 wallington 20 Feb 14 5.47pm |
|
|
I really do struggle to see how he's not in the team ahead of kg seen him alot for forest and for us and has always done very well with a rocket of a shot on him. Pulis is doing alot of good things but I did predict players like gayle, Williams and bannan would slowly get taken away from the first team and eventually sold and that is looking likely. Bit sad a good manager should get the best out of every type of player and not just strong powerful quick players. Players like Williams and bannan hold the key to quality an unlocking defences and gayle has the pace and an eye for a goal if he didn't get a start with Jerome not scoring there is no chance now we have Murray back.
|