This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Chamakh Penalty
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 14 9.07am |
|
Quote sidman at 24 Feb 2014 8.30am
Clumsy, but was never a penalty as it was outside the box and if you look at Evra after his 100th turn he slows down and looks at the ref.
Once again Man Utd have to cheat.
[Link]
NO, it was a penalty !
It was on the line, the referee had a great view of it and I don't recall any mass complaints from our players !
|
redpalace91 Bromley 24 Feb 14 9.55am |
|
|
Not a penalty - Chamakh has a reputation for easily going down in the box. I remember him diving at the Southampton game, trying to win a cheap penalty when he should have just scored. Same thing against West Brom - my first instinct was that it wasn't a penalty as it looked like a carbon copy of the Southampton incident - the replay showed it was one of those that could be given if the ref is generous. If he were a natural goal scorer, he would have just put the ball in the net without the need to go down.
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 24 Feb 14 2.42pm |
|
|
Redpalace said it all. If Chemakh was a natural goal scorer there would never be a need for him to go down. But the previous criticism of him because a newspaper gives him 4/10. Well that's the opinion of a newspaper who sells to a public constantly reared on the values of the few, its not a surprise. Check the match out, Champers was very credible. A true Palace supporter would not need the skewed view of a paper to formulate an opinion on one of Palace's best players.
|
Bert's Boys 24 Feb 14 2.52pm |
|
|
One of our best players? you need a trip to specsavers! I was at the game and completely agree with the media ratings on Chamakh. He doesn't have a clue when he's on the ball and tamely passes it like a rabbit caught in headlights! that's if he doesn't fall over first!
|
adrian b Landrindod, Wales 24 Feb 14 4.34pm |
|
Quote Bert's Boys at 24 Feb 2014 2.52pm
One of our best players? you need a trip to specsavers! I was at the game and completely agree with the media ratings on Chamakh. He doesn't have a clue when he's on the ball and tamely passes it like a rabbit caught in headlights! that's if he doesn't fall over first!
I must need new specs. Watching it again now. 22 mins in and chamakh has touched the ball 14 (!) times and the ball has reached its destination 12 times, even with a very accomplished Vidic up him. I s'pose my new glasses will tell me the truth!
|
Ljb Sutton 24 Feb 14 4.52pm |
|
|
Chamakh is probably our best player but did have a bit of a shocker Saturday
|
Bert's Boys 24 Feb 14 8.58pm |
|
|
did you also count the number of times he fell over? and the number of tackles he won? There's a good optician in Shirley I can recommend.
|
TomThePalaceFanatic 24 Feb 14 9.00pm |
|
|
Chamakh is probably one of the most technically gifted players we've ever had.
|