You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > kg
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

kg


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
bromleysteve01 Flag Bromley 06 Mar 14 11.43pm

I cannot believe he is ever picked! Can't pass, run or tackle and adds no value. Does not look fit! Jedi is the defensive destroyer. Kg is a poor nan's Jedi. We need to get footballers into midfield who can tackle, run, pass and create. Many are better than KG

 

seeweedhater Flag London 07 Mar 14 1.07am

Quote bromleysteve01 at 06 Mar 2014 11.43pm

I cannot believe he is ever picked! Can't pass, run or tackle and adds no value. Does not look fit! Jedi is the defensive destroyer. Kg is a poor nan's Jedi. We need to get footballers into midfield who can tackle, run, pass and create. Many are better than KG


Agree!

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 07 Mar 14 2.04am

Quote seeweedhater at 07 Mar 2014 1.07am

Quote bromleysteve01 at 06 Mar 2014 11.43pm

I cannot believe he is ever picked! Can't pass, run or tackle and adds no value. Does not look fit! Jedi is the defensive destroyer. Kg is a poor nan's Jedi. We need to get footballers into midfield who can tackle, run, pass and create. Many are better than KG


Agree!


Fortunately Tony Pulis is the manager and not you two.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 07 Mar 14 3.54am

I don't rate KG at this level, O'Keefe, Guedioura, Ward in midfield and Joe Ledley (granted not seen much of him) all offer much more to their game. The Arsenal and Swansea games made up my mind about him, he doesn't make many mistakes but he is god awful at going forward and I believe a PL player should have more to his game than KG for instance in the Arsenal game Palace were putting balls into Arsenal's area and trying to link up, Jedinak, Chamakh, Bolasie, Parr, Ward and Puncheon all going forward linking up and ******* KG is just standing there watching and not getting involved and without a doubt in my mind O'Keefe, Guedioura or Ledley would have been there helping out.

I'm Pro-Keefe!

 

Plane Flag Bromley 07 Mar 14 10.05am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2014 4.29pm

Quote Username at 06 Mar 2014 12.53pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 06 Mar 2014 11.27am

Quote Username at 05 Mar 2014 10.25pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 05 Mar 2014 2.37pm

Quote We are goin up! at 05 Mar 2014 11.47am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 05 Mar 2014 10.41am

Like the playoff final?

O'Keefe was immense when he came on.

Stats don't lie.... and for me bear out my gut feeling that he's out of his depth in the Prem.

I appreciate that he has had good games for us and his attitude and work rate are good.


Moronic post. KG played at Brighton away which was arguably tougher than Wembley, then went off injured after what ten minutes?!

Stats don't lie?! You're old enough and ugly enough to know that's bollocks, Hoof.


No need for insults, clearly we disagree, and opinion is divided on this thread about Kg's worth to the team.

Stats don't lie, Opta monitor every player in the Prem and know who is doing what. You can't argue with it, so it is not bollocks.

You can't record everything in stats though.

They don't record how many times per game he offers himself as an out ball for Gabbidon/Ward when they are stuck on the corner of our own penalty area.

They don't record how many times he shepherds players away from danger or puts pressure on people forcing them to make a loose pass.

That is his job.

But, I'm sure you are right. You and your stats clearly know better than every single manager who has picked a team while KG has been at the club. I mean, just look at the rankings that started this. Martin Demichelis has a higher rating than Vincent Kompany and Per Mertesacker. Robert Snodgrass better than Oscar? Stats don't lie...

Personally, I think in time Ledley will replace him in the team as he can offer the same protection and more going forward. I just think it's unfair to pick on a player who is only doing what his manager asks him to do.


No need for sarcasm either.

I didn't produce the stats, but they confirm my feelings (and a LOT of others on here) that he simply isn't good enough for the prem.

As I said I admire his attitude and work rate, but think we play better without him.

That was my point though, they don't confirm anything. Stats don't capture everything about a game of football, and you always need to put things into context.

It's why the moneyball concept doesn't apply to football as much because you can't measure a player's impact as easily as you can in baseball.


The stats highlight that his passing is sh1t and he doesn't score which is what I noticed about him.


Unlike the rest of the team

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 07 Mar 14 10.17am

He has little skill, awareness, passing skill or positional sense. He is a blocker who adds nothing to our need to score some goals (as sure as mud is mud, if we don't improve here we will go down) However, if he keeps playing and we do survive then I'll bow to the Manager's superior judgement!

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

ADW1988 Flag Bromley 07 Mar 14 10.30am

Quote Username at 05 Mar 2014 11.43am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 05 Mar 2014 10.41am

Quote Username at 05 Mar 2014 10.34am

Christ. We're going purely by stats now are we? Why even bother playing games, we can just look at who has the highest rating like a game of top trumps.

KG has been in the starting XI more often than not under every manager he has had at Palace. People who work with the players every day and know more about football than anyone on this site have decided he is a valuable player and worth his place.

Personally, I do think the signing of Ledley will see his contribution get a bit smaller, but writing off a player who has been so key in some of our biggest results of the last three years is ridiculous.


Like the playoff final?

O'Keefe was immense when he came on.

Stats don't lie.... and for me bear out my gut feeling that he's out of his depth in the Prem.

I appreciate that he has had good games for us and his attitude and work rate are good.

If O'Keefe was the star performer, why did Freedman, Holloway, Millen and Pulis all overlook him in favour of KG?

If you want to pick out individual games how about the play semi second leg where KG was a colossus, or Everton at home?

SOK looks great when he comes on, harrying and chasing the ball down but positionally he is not as good as KG. That is why he gets picked, because he is nearly always in the right place at the right time and is a great partner for Jedinak. His positioning means Jedinak can come out and make those interceptions and challenges, knowing that KG is still there in behind him. Plus he's also physically more imposing than O'Keefe.


Spot on this!! Blinded and blinkered a lot of people are

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Mar 14 10.58am

As a central midfielder - I'd agree with the idea that KG is surplus, but he's not a central midfielder, he's a defensive back up, holding midfielder, who links the defence with midfield and restricts space available fo the attacking team. In order to play past him, into space, the opposition risk interception by the defence.

His role is more like an obstacle in a flow, to force play to diverge around him, allowing those behind him to predict play and to harry possession play.

He does exactly what he's done since he first came to us on loan, week in week out. Restrict space, close down players, force the play into channels, and to bring the ball back out through midfield.

He reminds me of a budget Makelele, never seems to do anything fancy, except pick up the ball, be in the right place and play out short passes.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Mar 14 11.00am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 05 Mar 2014 10.41am

Quote Username at 05 Mar 2014 10.34am

Christ. We're going purely by stats now are we? Why even bother playing games, we can just look at who has the highest rating like a game of top trumps.

KG has been in the starting XI more often than not under every manager he has had at Palace. People who work with the players every day and know more about football than anyone on this site have decided he is a valuable player and worth his place.

Personally, I do think the signing of Ledley will see his contribution get a bit smaller, but writing off a player who has been so key in some of our biggest results of the last three years is ridiculous.


Like the playoff final?

O'Keefe was immense when he came on.

Stats don't lie.... and for me bear out my gut feeling that he's out of his depth in the Prem.

I appreciate that he has had good games for us and his attitude and work rate are good.

Had we not been forced into that substitution, I firmly believe we would have won that in full time, as Bolaise would have been available and openned Watford right up.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Mar 14 11.02am

I think its telling how well KG does in that role that Ward had trouble adjusting to the role.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 07 Mar 14 5.17pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Mar 2014 11.02am

I think its telling how well KG does in that role that Ward had trouble adjusting to the role.


Very good point. Very often we say, when a player is unnoticed it means he is doing a good job. But could it also mean that player is struggling to do his job and has not the time or ability to do better. I think if a player gets picked time and again by a manager who seems to know what he is doing, that may say enough about him. But there have been players in the past that really are crap and keep getting picked, like the manager wants to make his point, like over an expensive signing. I can think of one or two and Malcom Allison's obsessions with one or two come to mind. But with KG...I'm sure this is not the case.

 

est1905 Flag 07 Mar 14 6.24pm

I don't really rate him in the Premiership. Last season he had a few really good games and a few dire ones. At this level he flatters to deceive.
I believe if we stay up TP is going to replace him in the summer. Maybe he could go back to both the Championship and Fulham at the same time.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 07 Mar 14 6.38pm

Quote est1905 at 07 Mar 2014 6.24pm

I believe if we stay up TP is going to replace him in the summer. Maybe he could go back to both the Championship and Fulham at the same time.


 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 08 Mar 14 7.03pm

Given KG"s form in recent matches I just cannot understand why Pulis insists on playing him. Today against the Saints he was pathetic and I cannot believe that Okeefe would ever be as bad as KG was today. In fact, we really had no mid-field and just when we thought our lads would give us a second half rally there was nobody in mid-field capable of raising even a whimper. Today ,as far as midfield is concerned,was probably one of the worse displays I have seen perhaps with the exception of the Fulham match. I'm afraid Pulis has got to look very profoundly at our mid-field because we do not cut it and this situation could eventually be our undoing.With Puncheon having a very poor game we seemed thread bare as a team which does not look good for the final run in.

 

Ljb Flag Sutton 08 Mar 14 7.23pm

Quote blind eagle at 08 Mar 2014 7.03pm

Given KG"s form in recent matches I just cannot understand why Pulis insists on playing him. Today against the Saints he was pathetic and I cannot believe that Okeefe would ever be as bad as KG was today. In fact, we really had no mid-field and just when we thought our lads would give us a second half rally there was nobody in mid-field capable of raising even a whimper. Today ,as far as midfield is concerned,was probably one of the worse displays I have seen perhaps with the exception of the Fulham match. I'm afraid Pulis has got to look very profoundly at our mid-field because we do not cut it and this situation could eventually be our undoing.With Puncheon having a very poor game we seemed thread bare as a team which does not look good for the final run in.

We make like 3 passes per game and sit on the edge of our box for the entire game! That's the problem

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 08 Mar 14 7.31pm

Quote Ljb at 08 Mar 2014 7.23pm

Quote blind eagle at 08 Mar 2014 7.03pm

Given KG"s form in recent matches I just cannot understand why Pulis insists on playing him. Today against the Saints he was pathetic and I cannot believe that Okeefe would ever be as bad as KG was today. In fact, we really had no mid-field and just when we thought our lads would give us a second half rally there was nobody in mid-field capable of raising even a whimper. Today ,as far as midfield is concerned,was probably one of the worse displays I have seen perhaps with the exception of the Fulham match. I'm afraid Pulis has got to look very profoundly at our mid-field because we do not cut it and this situation could eventually be our undoing.With Puncheon having a very poor game we seemed thread bare as a team which does not look good for the final run in.

We make like 3 passes per game and sit on the edge of our box for the entire game! That's the problem

Is the right answer


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Gyro1780 Flag Leatherhead, Surrey 08 Mar 14 7.34pm

I was hoping Ledley was going to be KG's replacement but he still gets picked by Pulis. I sometimes forget that KG is even on the field as he never seems to be doing anything.

 

big_palace_fan Flag 09 Mar 14 3.02am

Ledley must play the kg role asap

KG is rubbish and overweight

Me saying he is not up to it at the vast majority of games is one thing, the stats also back me. Today

10/18 passes
3/5 headed duels
0 clearances
0 shots
56% pass completion
2 interception
0 tackles

Jedi:
20/30 passes
1/2 headed duels
5 interceptions
5/5 clearances
1/3 tackles

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > kg