You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi the Weak Link
November 16 2026 12.54pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jedi the Weak Link


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
ADW1988 Flag Bromley 10 Mar 14 9.56am

Quote paperhat at 10 Mar 2014 9.13am

Quote ADW1988 at 10 Mar 2014 8.41am

Quote Mangopablo at 10 Mar 2014 7.42am

Quote skatman at 09 Mar 2014 4.17pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 09 Mar 2014 3.54pm

KG was better then Jedi yesterday. Just because it is Jedi does not make him immune to criticism the guy is a s*** footballer. When he takes set pieces that f***s me off to.


You do know who's who on the pitch right. KG's the big black fella, the one who's not as good as the funny haired white fella he plays next to. Just incase you're mixing the two up.


Jedi was not good on Saturday (and has not had a great season). He looks jaded to me. KG was absolutely abysmal: he offered us nothing. I would have subbed him after 25 mins.

so you quite clearly didn't notice that our midfield went from - a minor presence to absolutely NOTHING when he came off. Easy scapegoat. Not the best player we have but answer me this.. why does EVERY manager we have start him when fit? Some people like STATS and we've seen his name pop up in the worst midfielders. Not denying that.. BUT If you want a proper stat - go and look at games won with KG in the team last season and this season, and games won when he's not - INTERESTING to say the least!
Brighton semi final playoff - he was immense and catalyst to victory.. Short memories around here, that is if indeed some were (not directed at anyone in particular btw before I'm misunderstood)

Jedi was tired after int'l 90 mins and hasn't been at his best all season imo.. BUT still we all know he's got it and break up play is still pretty decent... Just takes too long on the ball (as does KG!!).. I think Ledley looked lively and won a lot of tackles (when Webb didn't blow up for a foul)..

Anyway, we weren't at our best but even our performance wasn't as bad as Webb and his officials.. 2 onside off sides and (when you see it from the fan video from Main Stand touchline) certain red, Clyne was getting nowhere near Yannick..

That's my thoughts anyway

It wasnt Clyne that tackled Yannick......


Erm did I say Clyne tackled YB... NOOO because it was Lovren, thought that was obvious to all already, obviously not in your case.. My point exactly, some not quite reading and understanding... A lot of people were saying Clyne was covering hence why no red card..

*Slaps head in amazement*

Because if you think about it even more, then me saying Clyne got nowhere near YB would almost incite me suggesting YB dived which I certainly am not!!! So in Layman's terms; quite clearly suggesting NC was nowhere near catching YB IF Lovren hadn't brought him down.

Edited by ADW1988 (10 Mar 2014 9.59am)

Edited by ADW1988 (10 Mar 2014 10.01am)

Edited by ADW1988 (10 Mar 2014 10.02am)

 

PalaceProf Flag Hove 10 Mar 14 11.33am

Yes, this is something I've been thinking for a while. Too many passes going astray. And as for his dead ball efforts...the less said about that the better!

I'm afraid to say I don't think he's quite up to it at this level???

 


Red and Blue Thru and Thru

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 10 Mar 14 11.42am

Quote crystal-purley at 09 Mar 2014 4.48pm

Watching games recently I had a look at where Jedi's passes mainly go and it is mainly to a Palace player but he has cut down on the long ball ones recently. Two of him in the side and we would be a place or two higher in the table.


10 like him in the side and Palace would win the league! Good, let's go and buy the other 9 then! Or should we write realistic things?

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 10 Mar 14 11.59am

Quote Gyro1780 at 09 Mar 2014 5.12pm

His passing is terrible, can't take a free kick & gives away silly fouls but his tackling, winning the ball back & strength in midfield is what we need. I think we're a much better team with him than without. It should be Jedi & Ledley in midfield. KG isn't good enough i'm afraid.

Agreed with this

 


La la la your mum

geoff Flag Midhurst 10 Mar 14 12.15pm

Ok he does play with plenty of blood and guts and he is without a doubt a leader on the pitch but he is error prone and does look tired. Perhaps a spell on the bench with SOK and Ledley as the holding midfield.

 

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 10 Mar 14 2.08pm

Mind you if Jedinak could pass, score freekicks and score more he'd still be in Turkey playing for Galatasaray or Fenerbache so be careful what you wish for.

Edited by Jordan555x (10 Mar 2014 2.09pm)

 

Skinster Flag 10 Mar 14 4.02pm

I dont think the man is a weak link, but i do think he is looking very tired and jaded.
he needs a rest he has played every minute of every league game.
We definitely need him but i can see us losing him to injury or suspension soon and that would be awful.
Id like to see jedinak rotated a bit more, he is sitting very very deep at the moment almost a 3rd centre back and thus we have no support for the likes of bolaise or puncheon when they do get forward.
He is giving away silly free kicks, he cant pass for a toffee and as for dead balls....why does he even attempt take them?
Give him rest put ledley in as holding midfielder, play bannon and kg infront of him and let bannon do his thing...
we need to start giving other teams something to worry about.

 

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 10 Mar 14 4.15pm

Quote dynamicdick at 09 Mar 2014 8.23pm

Response to Finchley Eagle...

I didn't realise it was played at The New Den but it has made me chuckle. Must do my homework next time! Perhaps the traffic was bad!!


dick, just to let you know if you click the little quote mark icon in the bottom right corner of someone's post then you can reply to that post without having to put "response to..." at the top of your post.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

cpj Flag Kent 10 Mar 14 4.21pm

Quote madcap_v2 at 10 Mar 2014 11.59am

Quote Gyro1780 at 09 Mar 2014 5.12pm

His passing is terrible, can't take a free kick & gives away silly fouls but his tackling, winning the ball back & strength in midfield is what we need. I think we're a much better team with him than without. It should be Jedi & Ledley in midfield. KG isn't good enough i'm afraid.

Agreed with this

I agree too - he's not the weak link, he's just not as good as a lot of people think he is. But then again that's always true about fans and people who play for their team.

 

james03 Flag Bangkok 11 Mar 14 3.38am

Quote cpj at 10 Mar 2014 4.21pm

Quote madcap_v2 at 10 Mar 2014 11.59am

Quote Gyro1780 at 09 Mar 2014 5.12pm

His passing is terrible, can't take a free kick & gives away silly fouls but his tackling, winning the ball back & strength in midfield is what we need. I think we're a much better team with him than without. It should be Jedi & Ledley in midfield. KG isn't good enough i'm afraid.

Agreed with this

I agree too - he's not the weak link, he's just not as good as a lot of people think he is. But then again that's always true about fans and people who play for their team.

What a very condescending remark to make. Most of us know a considerable amount about the game, how it is played and what certain players are capable of. I have watched football since 1958 with my first Palace game being the following year. I was involved in the game from 1978 to 1987. There are thousands of others who have been going as long or longer then I.

Just because some of us actually see the good in players, Jedinak in particular, you take a supercillious attitude and suggest we are blinded by our love of the team.

Whilst your remark may, in some instances, be relevant in the main I think you will find, away from the arena, most people make sensible and balanced judgements.

If you cannot see the benefit in what Jedinak brings to us then it is perhaps you who are blinded; blinded by negativity.

We are Crystal Palace not Manchester City. We cannot go out and spend fifty million on a world class player. Jedinak cost us nothing, the man has been a rock the past two seasons and he is the likely captian of his country going in to the World Cup. He has been picked every game he has been available for by Freedman, Holloway and now TP. But, of course, you and others know better.

Yes, maybe one day as the club evolves and finances improve we will find a better player for the position. However, right now he is far and away our best option.

Stop believing we should have a wonder side with a player in Jedi's role able to win every header, come away with the ball from every tackle, make every pass with most of them setting up a goal and scoring thirty goals as season themselves.

Also WATCVH the games. See how Jedi falls back to protect the defence when a winger has the ball out wide and count the number of times he is the one who heads the cross out. Count the number of times he puts in a tackle stopping an opposition attack, actually look at the number of passes he makes and count those that go astray. Watch his positioning, watch how he organises those around him and stop bleeting on that he is not good enough!

 


The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made. Groucho Marx

ChrisPalace Flag 11 Mar 14 5.55am

[Link]

Not seen this posted in this topic yet. Not that I necessarily agree with it.

KG's a tough one. Whenever he doesn't play well, I instinctively want him dropped. I can appreciate the argument that he does important but unglamorous things well. But he - like Jedinak, or any player for that matter - has shortcomings. Perhaps part of the problem is that the team can't afford to compensate for both of their shortcomings at the same time.

 

Sir James Hird Flag Mount Martha 11 Mar 14 7.20am

Quote james03 at 11 Mar 2014 3.38am

Quote cpj at 10 Mar 2014 4.21pm

Quote madcap_v2 at 10 Mar 2014 11.59am

Quote Gyro1780 at 09 Mar 2014 5.12pm

His passing is terrible, can't take a free kick & gives away silly fouls but his tackling, winning the ball back & strength in midfield is what we need. I think we're a much better team with him than without. It should be Jedi & Ledley in midfield. KG isn't good enough i'm afraid.

Agreed with this

I agree too - he's not the weak link, he's just not as good as a lot of people think he is. But then again that's always true about fans and people who play for their team.

What a very condescending remark to make. Most of us know a considerable amount about the game, how it is played and what certain players are capable of. I have watched football since 1958 with my first Palace game being the following year. I was involved in the game from 1978 to 1987. There are thousands of others who have been going as long or longer then I.

Just because some of us actually see the good in players, Jedinak in particular, you take a supercillious attitude and suggest we are blinded by our love of the team.

Whilst your remark may, in some instances, be relevant in the main I think you will find, away from the arena, most people make sensible and balanced judgements.

If you cannot see the benefit in what Jedinak brings to us then it is perhaps you who are blinded; blinded by negativity.

We are Crystal Palace not Manchester City. We cannot go out and spend fifty million on a world class player. Jedinak cost us nothing, the man has been a rock the past two seasons and he is the likely captian of his country going in to the World Cup. He has been picked every game he has been available for by Freedman, Holloway and now TP. But, of course, you and others know better.

Yes, maybe one day as the club evolves and finances improve we will find a better player for the position. However, right now he is far and away our best option.

Stop believing we should have a wonder side with a player in Jedi's role able to win every header, come away with the ball from every tackle, make every pass with most of them setting up a goal and scoring thirty goals as season themselves.

Also WATCVH the games. See how Jedi falls back to protect the defence when a winger has the ball out wide and count the number of times he is the one who heads the cross out. Count the number of times he puts in a tackle stopping an opposition attack, actually look at the number of passes he makes and count those that go astray. Watch his positioning, watch how he organises those around him and stop bleeting on that he is not good enough!


A balnced view succinctly put.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 11 Mar 14 7.57am

Quote james03 at 11 Mar 2014 3.38am

Quote cpj at 10 Mar 2014 4.21pm

Quote madcap_v2 at 10 Mar 2014 11.59am

Quote Gyro1780 at 09 Mar 2014 5.12pm

His passing is terrible, can't take a free kick & gives away silly fouls but his tackling, winning the ball back & strength in midfield is what we need. I think we're a much better team with him than without. It should be Jedi & Ledley in midfield. KG isn't good enough i'm afraid.

Agreed with this

I agree too - he's not the weak link, he's just not as good as a lot of people think he is. But then again that's always true about fans and people who play for their team.

What a very condescending remark to make. Most of us know a considerable amount about the game, how it is played and what certain players are capable of. I have watched football since 1958 with my first Palace game being the following year. I was involved in the game from 1978 to 1987. There are thousands of others who have been going as long or longer then I.

Just because some of us actually see the good in players, Jedinak in particular, you take a supercillious attitude and suggest we are blinded by our love of the team.

Whilst your remark may, in some instances, be relevant in the main I think you will find, away from the arena, most people make sensible and balanced judgements.

If you cannot see the benefit in what Jedinak brings to us then it is perhaps you who are blinded; blinded by negativity.

We are Crystal Palace not Manchester City. We cannot go out and spend fifty million on a world class player. Jedinak cost us nothing, the man has been a rock the past two seasons and he is the likely captian of his country going in to the World Cup. He has been picked every game he has been available for by Freedman, Holloway and now TP. But, of course, you and others know better.

Yes, maybe one day as the club evolves and finances improve we will find a better player for the position. However, right now he is far and away our best option.

Stop believing we should have a wonder side with a player in Jedi's role able to win every header, come away with the ball from every tackle, make every pass with most of them setting up a goal and scoring thirty goals as season themselves.

Also WATCVH the games. See how Jedi falls back to protect the defence when a winger has the ball out wide and count the number of times he is the one who heads the cross out. Count the number of times he puts in a tackle stopping an opposition attack, actually look at the number of passes he makes and count those that go astray. Watch his positioning, watch how he organises those around him and stop bleeting on that he is not good enough!

Bit of overkill on a comment that agreed we are a better team with him in. The thing is, an awful lot of fans think he is the messiah and whilst he started the season playing out of his skin, his performances are gradually dipping. Now don't get me wrong, I wouldn't drop him as he's a great leader and a real fighter but it's frustrating as hell to watch him rake a 60 yard pass into the run of Bolasie one minute and scuff a 10 yard pass to the opposition the next.

We've also had better players in that position that didn't cost the earth. Derry, Aki and Hughes spring to mind. Good player, yes. Great player, no. Best player we have in that position at present, without a doubt and his mentality is vital in our current position but, should we stay up and look to progress then a better player will be needed, like, for instance, Wanyama at Southampton.


Edited by Icepick Tony (11 Mar 2014 7.58am)

Edited by Icepick Tony (11 Mar 2014 8.00am)

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Mar 14 8.39am

He is always a rock and has had outstanding games. His strength in the air is important to us, even though his accuracy is often lacking.

He isn't a play maker and neither is KG and that is where the rub comes for me. They disrupt play but they don't have much ability to start new plays. And yes, he isn't at his best right now.

I still think have SOK or Bannan playing with him, letting him win the ball and then lay it off to a creative player, would work better. But that means the rest of the defence being bullet proof and not needing so much cover.

In the end, in football you have to be robust. You can watch Jedi dominating the opposition players, they don't like getting near him. That is what he is for.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi the Weak Link