You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We will go down without Joniesta
November 16 2026 12.53pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We will go down without Joniesta


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
PJH Flag Colchester 26 Mar 14 3.57pm

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 3.40pm

Quote The Sash at 26 Mar 2014 11.08am

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 12.38pm

Quote cheswickeagle at 23 Mar 2014 11.32am

What a stupid post.

I don't see why people rate him so highly. Yes he is a talented young player but he is very raw and is yet to prove himself in a big game or over a number of games. Looking back at last season, when he was fit, Jonny never really stood out that much. I can probably only count two or three games where he had a really good game.

It does seem that any fan hates it when a young player from the academy doesn't get played, as if the manager is damaging our academy.

They way we are playing under Pulis means Williams would not have seen a lot of the ball and he isn't the type of player to sit deep and defend so him going on loan doesn't mean that's why we may go down


Mate we are the lowest scores in the league. Anybody who dosent rate Williams knows nothing about football. When he went on loan i feared that we will be in big trouble. Im sticking to my belief we will go down without him.


Your stock standard answer to any old negative drivel you post - to disagree with you means 'you know nothing about football'

No-one has said they dont rate Williams, what they have said is that he has done nothing in the brief chanmces he has had to suggest he would make any difference to us staying up or going down at the moment - and thats correct


brief chances? - he hasnt started under Pulis ffs. Thats my prediction and im sticking by it. Its dangerous game to just go for a certain type of player and ignore the short, pacey and skillful (Williams, Bannan, Gayle).

i was bored sh**less watching us v man utd and saints. I want to be entertained and i want a player with red and blue blood busting a gut for the team. If i want a aimless load of drivel i can watch eastenders.


Or you could re-read alot of your posts on here.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 26 Mar 14 4.14pm

Quote PJH at 26 Mar 2014 3.57pm

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 3.40pm

Quote The Sash at 26 Mar 2014 11.08am

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 12.38pm

Quote cheswickeagle at 23 Mar 2014 11.32am

What a stupid post.

I don't see why people rate him so highly. Yes he is a talented young player but he is very raw and is yet to prove himself in a big game or over a number of games. Looking back at last season, when he was fit, Jonny never really stood out that much. I can probably only count two or three games where he had a really good game.

It does seem that any fan hates it when a young player from the academy doesn't get played, as if the manager is damaging our academy.

They way we are playing under Pulis means Williams would not have seen a lot of the ball and he isn't the type of player to sit deep and defend so him going on loan doesn't mean that's why we may go down


Mate we are the lowest scores in the league. Anybody who dosent rate Williams knows nothing about football. When he went on loan i feared that we will be in big trouble. Im sticking to my belief we will go down without him.


Your stock standard answer to any old negative drivel you post - to disagree with you means 'you know nothing about football'

No-one has said they dont rate Williams, what they have said is that he has done nothing in the brief chanmces he has had to suggest he would make any difference to us staying up or going down at the moment - and thats correct


brief chances? - he hasnt started under Pulis ffs. Thats my prediction and im sticking by it. Its dangerous game to just go for a certain type of player and ignore the short, pacey and skillful (Williams, Bannan, Gayle).

i was bored sh**less watching us v man utd and saints. I want to be entertained and i want a player with red and blue blood busting a gut for the team. If i want a aimless load of drivel i can watch eastenders.


Or you could re-read alot of your posts on here.


 

Plane Flag Bromley 26 Mar 14 4.16pm

Quote The Sash at 26 Mar 2014 3.55pm

Quote maxipalace at 26 Mar 2014 3.40pm

Quote The Sash at 26 Mar 2014 11.08am

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 12.38pm

Quote cheswickeagle at 23 Mar 2014 11.32am

What a stupid post.

I don't see why people rate him so highly. Yes he is a talented young player but he is very raw and is yet to prove himself in a big game or over a number of games. Looking back at last season, when he was fit, Jonny never really stood out that much. I can probably only count two or three games where he had a really good game.

It does seem that any fan hates it when a young player from the academy doesn't get played, as if the manager is damaging our academy.

They way we are playing under Pulis means Williams would not have seen a lot of the ball and he isn't the type of player to sit deep and defend so him going on loan doesn't mean that's why we may go down


Mate we are the lowest scores in the league. Anybody who dosent rate Williams knows nothing about football. When he went on loan i feared that we will be in big trouble. Im sticking to my belief we will go down without him.


Your stock standard answer to any old negative drivel you post - to disagree with you means 'you know nothing about football'

No-one has said they dont rate Williams, what they have said is that he has done nothing in the brief chanmces he has had to suggest he would make any difference to us staying up or going down at the moment - and thats correct


brief chances? - he hasnt started under Pulis ffs. Thats my prediction and im sticking by it. Its dangerous game to just go for a certain type of player and ignore the short, pacey and skillful (Williams, Bannan, Gayle).

i was bored sh**less watching us v man utd and saints. I want to be entertained and i want a player with red and blue blood busting a gut for the team. If i want a aimless load of drivel i can watch eastenders.


I didnt mention Pulis - He was hardly a first choice under Holloway but we saw him and he looked short of what we need... in his time will hopefully be a good PL player, but he isnt that yet.

His goal for Ipswich was wonderful, but would he get that much space and defenders back off him at this level - of course he wouldnt and thats the key. Its the same logic that gets imbeciles calling for Kwesi Appiah to be given a go because he plays well for Cambridge.

This PL mallarkey is a whole different kettle of fish and although I would love to see creativity and moaned like f*** about our negativity and lack of creativity at Swans, Saints and Sunderland I can also see how Joniesta isnt some magic bullet that would make everything rosy


Anyhoo you stick to what you like it makes no matter to me.


Edited by The Sash (26 Mar 2014 4.01pm)


Or just rewind a year and there were some saying we should get Banton back as he scored a few goals for Fvckknowswhatteam FC

Edited by Plane (26 Mar 2014 4.22pm)

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 26 Mar 14 4.21pm

I have never been that impressed really. Looks good on the ball but has no end product, especially in the Premier League, where you have to be a bit more street wise. Having said that, we are not blessed with creative midfielders. Barry Bannan is a similar player to Williams but has much better dead ball skills. He's not Pulis's type of player either. He prefers someone stronger like Ledley or Guadiora.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 26 Mar 14 6.09pm

Everybody had been crying out for Bannan recently but when we saw him last week he had little influence on the game.
There must have been a good reason why JW was only loaned for one month and not till the end of the season. And if, as reports suggest, he has found top form and is playing out of his skin then perhaps he may be recalled.
He would make a fantastic hero.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 26 Mar 14 6.52pm

confidence in a footballer can make all the difference.

Walking into a championship side from a premiership team, i imagine it makes you feel lifted, it may give you that extra bit of confidence as mentally you may think 'i usually play at a higher standard'

Not saying JW is like this, but it seems he is loving the opportunity

 


This was once a quality forum....

Bondy Flag 26 Mar 14 7.07pm

Quote maxipalace at 25 Mar 2014 11.38pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Mar 2014 11.11pm

Quote Firegut at 25 Mar 2014 9.01pm

Where would you play JW in this side Maxi? I don't disagree that it's a shame to see him loaned out, just not sure where you see him in this current side increasing our chances of goals.

At attacking mid/behind the striker, he isn't going to be tenacious enough for this side. There's too much of a gap between Jedinak and KG/Ledley. I could see Jonny getting isolated too much and not providing for the striker. For me, the best player we have for that position is Chamakh. Not his 'natural' position maybe, but he impresses me regularly with hold up play and ability to find a decent pass in a very pressurised part of the field.

Problem was, Johnny Williams wasn't making a huge difference back when he was playing for us, and he'd taken a few knocks. Better he gets first team action and confidence, than 20 mins a week if were losing.



He is making a huge difference at ipswich because he is starting and a manager has faith in him. Pulis did neither

Probably posted elsewhere, sorry if it has been, but TP was at Portman Road last night..... wonder who he was watching?? Back with us in two weeks ???

 

so_palace_are_losing Flag Holmesdale Lower, Block F, Row 15,... 26 Mar 14 7.34pm

Williams hasn't looked good in the prem because he has been stuck out on the wing. Has not played his true position all season

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 26 Mar 14 8.05pm

Quote so_palace_are_losing at 26 Mar 2014 7.34pm

Williams hasn't looked good in the prem because he has been stuck out on the wing. Has not played his true position all season


I have never seen him play in said true position except for maybe Dougie. Holloway used him on the wing. Chamakh plays in Williams "True Position" is Williams better then Chamakh?

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 26 Mar 14 8.09pm

Williams would have known Pulis was there, the lad has been loaned out, he is young, Hungry and enthusiastic. He has been loaned out for a month not for the rest of the season but a month, this means to me Jonny has a month to show Pulis what he can do and he has been doing it. When his month is up I can imagine Pulis walking over and saying to him "I've seen what you can do here now, do it for me Jonny boy". Then Jonny scores the winning goal at Fulham in the 93rd minute to keep us up he jumps into the crowd and is thrown about like a rag doll in celebration. WE CAN ONLY HOPE.

 

merganser Flag 26 Mar 14 8.31pm


Please, please, please don't let our fate hinge on the last kick of the last match of the season!!

Can't bear the thought of another nerve-shredding finale - last year was bad enough.

We must win our next four games, then we can all enjoy a relaxing time over Easter

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 26 Mar 14 8.47pm

Quote merganser at 26 Mar 2014 8.31pm


Please, please, please don't let our fate hinge on the last kick of the last match of the season!!

Can't bear the thought of another nerve-shredding finale - last year was bad enough.

We must win our next four games, then we can all enjoy a relaxing time over Easter

Oh come on Merganser, you know how it works. You knew from the day the fixtures list was announced. Live with it, last minute of last match on last day of the season. Guaranteed.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 26 Mar 14 8.49pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 26 Mar 2014 8.05pm

Quote so_palace_are_losing at 26 Mar 2014 7.34pm

Williams hasn't looked good in the prem because he has been stuck out on the wing. Has not played his true position all season


I have never seen him play in said true position except for maybe Dougie. Holloway used him on the wing. Chamakh plays in Williams "True Position" is Williams better then Chamakh?


He could be a game changer, coming on when Chammy has worn himself out. His energy in the last 20 could be worth a couple of wins.

 

EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 26 Mar 14 9.00pm

Quote Mapletree at 26 Mar 2014 8.49pm

Quote EastEndPalace at 26 Mar 2014 8.05pm

Quote so_palace_are_losing at 26 Mar 2014 7.34pm

Williams hasn't looked good in the prem because he has been stuck out on the wing. Has not played his true position all season


I have never seen him play in said true position except for maybe Dougie. Holloway used him on the wing. Chamakh plays in Williams "True Position" is Williams better then Chamakh?


He could be a game changer, coming on when Chammy has worn himself out. His energy in the last 20 could be worth a couple of wins.


Yeah that's fair enough, don't get me wrong I think he has potential to be a top player and can compete now tbh. But a loan is a good move IMO

 

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We will go down without Joniesta