You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best Result in our history, ever?
November 16 2026 12.39pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best Result in our history, ever?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Eggy Flag Sutton 01 Apr 14 12.56pm

Great result, but not the greatest. Too many other far more important games, plus of course 4-3 .v. Liverpool in the smae season they'd beaten us 9-0.

However, apparently it is the first time we've ever beaten the team top of the top division (Premier League, or Division 1 before), so that does give it a place in history !

 

PJH Flag Colchester 01 Apr 14 12.58pm

Quote Lombardos barber at 01 Apr 2014 12.41pm

Quote bubble wrap at 31 Mar 2014 7.29pm

If you only started supporting Palace this season then yes best result ever.
If not far too many, Liverpool at Villa Park 4-3, FA Cup final 3-3, Sheff Weds,Stockport,Play off finals x 2,Weed away x2,

Totally disagree with this. Ive supported Palace for over 20 years and for me, its be best reult we have ever had.

Here is why.

Play Offs are amazing; the victory against Shef Utd was one of the best days out ive ever had but these finals, like our victories against Brighton or the vital win against Shef Wed were achieved against mediocre opposition.

Granted, we were comparable in terms of quality to these teams and on these occasions but the gulf in squads between Palace and Chelsea is absolutely massive, as was the significance of Saturdays game. Staying in the Premierl League, which this victory may well make possible will do more for us us as a club than any other IMHO.

The 4-3 against Liverpool is clearly up there and defo the most famous of my lifetime; i just think the manner of the Chelsea victory achieved with the players we have when considering where we were 6 months ago is unprecedented in its geniusness.


I guess as posted before it really depends on what the question is. Best performance or best game for us the fans ? The performance was miles better than the one at Hillsboroguh but it felt alot better in Sheffield than it did on Saturday..and boy did it feel good in Saturday 1

 

wally2606 Flag Cheltenham 01 Apr 14 1.13pm

It was a fantastic result and performance but there's a good few to at least match or beat it. The 4 -3 Liverpool semi will always be the best result and day for me in my nearly 30 years following Palace, I can still feel the copper hitting my knuckles when I climbed the security fence to celebrate separating us from the scousers when Gray's goal went in lol. the Stockport and Sheff. Wed. games because what they meant. There was a game against Portsmouth which we needed to win to have any chance of staying up and if my memory serves me right we went down there and won 4 - 2 that was quite and evening, the 5 - 0 and last seasons 2 - 0 against the Weed and you would have to throw the 1979 Burnley promotion game in even though I wasn't at the last 2 to name a few ...

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 01 Apr 14 1.29pm

Quote PJH at 01 Apr 2014 12.58pm

Quote Lombardos barber at 01 Apr 2014 12.41pm

Quote bubble wrap at 31 Mar 2014 7.29pm

If you only started supporting Palace this season then yes best result ever.
If not far too many, Liverpool at Villa Park 4-3, FA Cup final 3-3, Sheff Weds,Stockport,Play off finals x 2,Weed away x2,

Totally disagree with this. Ive supported Palace for over 20 years and for me, its be best reult we have ever had.

Here is why.

Play Offs are amazing; the victory against Shef Utd was one of the best days out ive ever had but these finals, like our victories against Brighton or the vital win against Shef Wed were achieved against mediocre opposition.

Granted, we were comparable in terms of quality to these teams and on these occasions but the gulf in squads between Palace and Chelsea is absolutely massive, as was the significance of Saturdays game. Staying in the Premierl League, which this victory may well make possible will do more for us us as a club than any other IMHO.

The 4-3 against Liverpool is clearly up there and defo the most famous of my lifetime; i just think the manner of the Chelsea victory achieved with the players we have when considering where we were 6 months ago is unprecedented in its geniusness.


I guess as posted before it really depends on what the question is. Best performance or best game for us the fans ? The performance was miles better than the one at Hillsboroguh but it felt alot better in Sheffield than it did on Saturday..and boy did it feel good in Saturday 1


Neither. I think OP is asking is the best RESULT. i.e. where we've really gone against all odds and beaten a much bigger/ better team than us. And vs Chelsea is a great shout. The amount of money they have spent is ridiculous.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

cooleagle89 Flag Montrose 01 Apr 14 1.35pm

Loved the 5-0 Manure , i was on the Holmesdale, still watch it regularly on DVD. However they were rubbish at the time, and sacked their Manager , rFank O'Farrell the next day to make it even sweeter!!! I think Man Utd were relegated that season, so for me the Chelsea result is much better for stature


Quote est1905 at 31 Mar 2014 7.44pm

Before my time but I think Palace's debut season in the top division when we beat a full strength Man United 5 0 and Don Rodgers announced himself to the world would probably be listed as Palace's greatest ever result by outsiders.
My personal favourite match/result was the 1990 FA cup semi final. Liverpool 3 Palace 4!
That still has such a gorgeous ring to it!


 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 01 Apr 14 1.44pm

Quote est1905 at 31 Mar 2014 7.44pm

Before my time but I think Palace's debut season in the top division when we beat a full strength Man United 5 0 and Don Rodgers announced himself to the world would probably be listed as Palace's greatest ever result by outsiders.
My personal favourite match/result was the 1990 FA cup semi final. Liverpool 3 Palace 4!
That still has such a gorgeous ring to it!

Oh dear. I thought Palace drew 2-2 against Utd in their first season at the top and the great Donny Rogers signed in their 4th season up, scoring v Utd in a 5-0 victory. But the first match that came to mind among the many good victories Palace have enjoyed is the 4-3 v Liverpool. But the very best victory is the one next game up v Cardfiff.

 

Mstrobez Flag 01 Apr 14 2.37pm

Based on my young age it's Sheffield Wednesday and Brighton away for me.

Heard and seen alot about Liverpool though.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best Result in our history, ever?