You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sunderland points deduction
November 16 2026 12.39pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sunderland points deduction


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Lucas Oliver Flag Miles away 03 Apr 14 8.42pm

Quote The Pork Bolter at 03 Apr 2014 8.40pm

Yes but if you read the whole article it says they were fined "a substnatial amount under the radar" ie they have got away with it and the matters all over and done with.There will be no points deduction even though he played in one game in which they got a draw. Other leagues like the Championship - which is technically a different league and setup to the Premiership - take a different line and points get deducted if found guilty.

I read the whole article and.....it's just a fine

 


Nope it's not my name

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 03 Apr 14 8.47pm

Just read bbc.co.uk and they've already paid it. Non story in the end.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 03 Apr 14 8.53pm

Thought there must be a good reason no one else was reporting it. Perversely glad they haven't been deducted points. Sounds like an honest enough administrative slip up. Would feel very aggrieved if the boot was on the other foot and we were deducted points.

 

Mr Fenandes Flag 03 Apr 14 8.57pm

Quote Harry Beever at 03 Apr 2014 8.53pm

Thought there must be a good reason no one else was reporting it. Perversely glad they haven't been deducted points. Sounds like an honest enough administrative slip up. Would feel very aggrieved if the boot was on the other foot and we were deducted points.


Agree with this; they had international clearance as their player, left on loan and returned. Wouldn't want to stay up just because of something like that.

 


Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'!
All episodes available FREE here: [Link]

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 03 Apr 14 9.12pm

If Sunderland stay up by only a point or two there'll be law suits a plenty. Not heard the last of this me thinks

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jeeagles Flag 03 Apr 14 9.35pm

As soon as I saw it I thought the premier league would bottle it and just issue a fine. The president for football league clubs and lower divisions is a points deduction and it should be the same.

Having said that, I'd prefer to beat them on merit rather than a technicallity.

 

Bitter Flag Harpenden 03 Apr 14 9.47pm

Quote jeeagles at 03 Apr 2014 9.35pm

As soon as I saw it I thought the premier league would bottle it and just issue a fine. The president for football league clubs and lower divisions is a points deduction and it should be the same.

Having said that, I'd prefer to beat them on merit rather than a technicallity.

Doesn't it just sum up the Premier League? The only thing that matters in the PL is money, so the only penalty they issue is financial.

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 04 Apr 14 8.14am

Talk about double standards.

2007 AFC Wimbledon were deducted 18pts for exactly the same reason when they fielded Jermaine Darlington without international clearance.

We were deducted the point gained for fielding Rui Fonte against Sheff U in 2009 when his registration ran out the day before the game.

Also did they not knock MK Dons out of the League Cup with him in the side, they surely must have grounds for complaint.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Apr 14 9.13am

There is a slight difference in the Sunderland case, in that they had international clearance when he joined the club, they sent him on loan to a German, and then failed to realise they needed international clearance again when he returned, even though he was in the same contract period.

Whilst I'd like them to be deducted points, I don't think it really is the same as other cases. Especially as it was Sunderland who first alerted to the Premiership to the situation.

During that period they gained one point and no advantage.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Apr 14 9.15am

Quote Southampton_Eagle at 03 Apr 2014 8.08pm

Quote Lucas Oliver at 03 Apr 2014 7.59pm

Happened to us a few years back - 1 pt deduction for fielding Rui Fonte against Sheff U in I think was a meaningless last game of the season.

That was one game and a point deducted, would love the FA to deduct them pts.


Beat me to it. The point made no difference whatsoever.

Rui Fonte's loan period had expired.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 04 Apr 14 10.24am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Apr 2014 9.13am

There is a slight difference in the Sunderland case, in that they had international clearance when he joined the club, they sent him on loan to a German, and then failed to realise they needed international clearance again when he returned, even though he was in the same contract period.

Whilst I'd like them to be deducted points, I don't think it really is the same as other cases. Especially as it was Sunderland who first alerted to the Premiership to the situation.

During that period they gained one point and no advantage.

It is a slight difference and I'm amazed that they were not deducted a point. That both sides have hushed it up for so long also raises questions.

The fact that he wasn't any good and probably cost them more points is irrelevant. I don't for one moment think that the PL favour Sunderland over any other club but they (the PL) are more interested in not making a fuss and the money they can make out of it.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

andysmithcpfc1983 Flag Selsdon 04 Apr 14 10.41am

What made him ineligible? He has played in 7 league games since the start of February. 25 man squad is decided at the end of January isn't it?

 

andysmithcpfc1983 Flag Selsdon 04 Apr 14 10.43am

Quote andysmithcpfc1983 at 04 Apr 2014 10.41am

What made him ineligible? He has played in 7 league games since the start of February. 25 man squad is decided at the end of January isn't it?

Hadn't seen JM's post before posting. Must pay more attention

 

cheswickeagle Flag 04 Apr 14 11.13am

[Link]

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 04 Apr 14 1.14pm

Quote homes at 03 Apr 2014 7.47pm

Quote girvinator at 03 Apr 2014 7.46pm

Potentially, but to be honest I think it'll more likely be a hefty fine.

How many points did they get with him I'm the side?


Hasn't this happened before with Tevez and Westham? Can't remember the outcome


No this wasn't for an illegible player. More a question of how he was signed if I remember. But he was sort of signed.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 04 Apr 14 1.17pm

Quote jeeagles at 03 Apr 2014 9.35pm

As soon as I saw it I thought the premier league would bottle it and just issue a fine. The president for football league clubs and lower divisions is a points deduction and it should be the same.

Having said that, I'd prefer to beat them on merit rather than a technicallity.

The precedent is points deduction. But if they lose ,say, 3 points but are 4 points clear then they are OK with that.

 

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 04 Apr 14 5.06pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Apr 2014 9.13am

There is a slight difference in the Sunderland case, in that they had international clearance when he joined the club, they sent him on loan to a German, and then failed to realise they needed international clearance again when he returned, even though he was in the same contract period.

Whilst I'd like them to be deducted points, I don't think it really is the same as other cases. Especially as it was Sunderland who first alerted to the Premiership to the situation.

During that period they gained one point and no advantage.

Sorry Jamie but that makes no difference, it's an oversight that should never have happened, and there's no difference between that and our oversight with Rui Fonte, clubs in theirs and our positions should not make those errors, that's why clubs employ lawyers.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 04 Apr 14 5.13pm

Quote adrian b at 04 Apr 2014 1.14pm

Quote homes at 03 Apr 2014 7.47pm

Quote girvinator at 03 Apr 2014 7.46pm

Potentially, but to be honest I think it'll more likely be a hefty fine.

How many points did they get with him I'm the side?


Hasn't this happened before with Tevez and Westham? Can't remember the outcome


No this wasn't for an illegible player. More a question of how he was signed if I remember. But he was sort of signed.

It was for 3rd party ownership.

Which they then ignored when Tevez went to ManUre and Joorabchian still owned him.

 


Optimistic as ever

Username Flag Horsham 04 Apr 14 5.22pm

Quote Stuk at 04 Apr 2014 5.13pm

Quote adrian b at 04 Apr 2014 1.14pm

Quote homes at 03 Apr 2014 7.47pm

Quote girvinator at 03 Apr 2014 7.46pm

Potentially, but to be honest I think it'll more likely be a hefty fine.

How many points did they get with him I'm the side?


Hasn't this happened before with Tevez and Westham? Can't remember the outcome


No this wasn't for an illegible player. More a question of how he was signed if I remember. But he was sort of signed.

It was for 3rd party ownership.

Which they then ignored when Tevez went to ManUre and Joorabchian still owned him.

United didn't buy Tevez it was a two year loan deal, so there was no 3rd party issues.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Stuk Flag Top half 04 Apr 14 6.23pm

Quote Username at 04 Apr 2014 5.22pm

Quote Stuk at 04 Apr 2014 5.13pm

Quote adrian b at 04 Apr 2014 1.14pm

Quote homes at 03 Apr 2014 7.47pm

Quote girvinator at 03 Apr 2014 7.46pm

Potentially, but to be honest I think it'll more likely be a hefty fine.

How many points did they get with him I'm the side?


Hasn't this happened before with Tevez and Westham? Can't remember the outcome


No this wasn't for an illegible player. More a question of how he was signed if I remember. But he was sort of signed.

It was for 3rd party ownership.

Which they then ignored when Tevez went to ManUre and Joorabchian still owned him.

United didn't buy Tevez it was a two year loan deal, so there was no 3rd party issues.


Wham and manure both effectively rented him from Joorabchian. Neither club ever owned him so who did manure get him on loan from?

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sunderland points deduction