You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dowie or Pulis?
November 16 2026 12.25pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dowie or Pulis?


slubglurge Flag welling 17 Apr 14 1.00pm

Both have had an incredible impact in their first season with us but who achievement is the best? I personally think TP purely because of the quality of the opposition but Dowie's was pretty spectacular too.

 

Stuart Shave Flag Hampshire 17 Apr 14 1.02pm

Dowie had players that were under performing. Pulis basically had mediocre players and made them better to compete at a higher level.

No contest, Pulis is the winner.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Apr 14 1.03pm

Pulis or Coppell, Dowie had one good season. Choked it in the Premiership, then choked it in the playoffs, before going off to choke on pikey co*k.

There's a reason why Pulis is still a manager, and Dowie is an occassional freak show pundit and roving reporter for Sky Sports.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

slubglurge Flag welling 17 Apr 14 1.06pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 17 Apr 2014 1.03pm

Pulis or Coppell, Dowie had one good season. Choked it in the Premiership, then choked it in the playoffs, before going off to choke on pikey co*k.

There's a reason why Pulis is still a manager, and Dowie is an occassional freak show pundit and roving reporter for Sky Sports.


I agree with you about Coppell but i only mean the first season impact.

 

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 17 Apr 14 1.22pm

Is this a serious question?

Pulis has achieved that which no other Palace manager has achieved in the Premiership era.

End of!

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 17 Apr 14 1.23pm

We'll only really know for sure after Pulis has had another season. Looking at TP's track record at Stoke, however, it's clear he's not a one trick pony like Dowie emphatically was.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

wally2606 Flag Cheltenham 17 Apr 14 1.30pm

Pulis every day of the week, that's not taking anything away from Dowie's achievement in his first season which was incredible but Pulis has done it against the best in the business and come up trumps. A great no nonsense football man ...

 

peterg Flag Anerley 17 Apr 14 1.42pm

Bear in mind that last night's starting team v Everton contained only two of the last transfer window signings - Dann and Ledley. So TP was largely working with the team he inherited. Shows either that he is a miracle worker, or the summer signings were quite good after all. Perhaps both.

 


The right place at the right time

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 17 Apr 14 1.47pm

As Cucking said, TP has demonstrated he's not a one trick pony, whereas Dowie....

Let's face it, apart from our first season with Dowie what the hell has he achieved?

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

PJH Flag Colchester 17 Apr 14 1.52pm

Quote peterg at 17 Apr 2014 1.42pm

Bear in mind that last night's starting team v Everton contained only two of the last transfer window signings - Dann and Ledley. So TP was largely working with the team he inherited. Shows either that he is a miracle worker, or the summer signings were quite good after all. Perhaps both.


It shows what a good man manager TP is. Dowie did it in the championship, a whole different ballgame. TP has taken a team that was all but relegated and given them confidence and belief.In the Prem.Incredible.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 17 Apr 14 1.58pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 17 Apr 2014 1.23pm

We'll only really know for sure after Pulis has had another season. Looking at TP's track record at Stoke, however, it's clear he's not a one trick pony like Dowie emphatically was.

Indeed, Dowie achieved a spectacular result on the basis of his capacity to motivate. He already had a very good squad, that was lacking belief, direction and confidence.

Its worth noting that without his brother, Dowie was judged a failure everywhere else he went. One trick pony is being generous. I suspect anyone with a basic knowledge of football, but good understanding of motivational psychology could have achieved similar results.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Holmesdale Nick Flag South Croydon 17 Apr 14 2.01pm

Dowie was giving the updates on sky sports news last night

 


Fitter Fans Group 2. No. 17

EAGLE DAVIES Flag 17 Apr 14 2.09pm

Dowie gave us some good times which must not be forgotten, dont forget he was 15 mins away from a second season in the prem. However, hands down its TP, he basically has had 24 (or whatever it is) games and has kept us up with what I would say is arguably one of, if not the weakest squad in the league (maybe bar Cardiff).

Another question, does what TP has done highlight how bad a mangager Holloway is?

 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 17 Apr 14 6.36pm

Quote peterg at 17 Apr 2014 1.42pm

Bear in mind that last night's starting team v Everton contained only two of the last transfer window signings - Dann and Ledley. So TP was largely working with the team he inherited. Shows either that he is a miracle worker, or the summer signings were quite good after all. Perhaps both.


No doubt Pulis is a miracle worker and dont't get carried away by the summer signings!.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 17 Apr 14 7.24pm

Quote blind eagle at 17 Apr 2014 6.36pm

Quote peterg at 17 Apr 2014 1.42pm

Bear in mind that last night's starting team v Everton contained only two of the last transfer window signings - Dann and Ledley. So TP was largely working with the team he inherited. Shows either that he is a miracle worker, or the summer signings were quite good after all. Perhaps both.


No doubt Pulis is a miracle worker and dont't get carried away by the summer signings!.

Yes, as I've mentioned in another thread, Mr Holloway had to get 16 players in just to find 4 or 5 that have really made a contribution.


 

The Lads got class Flag St Neots 17 Apr 14 7.26pm

Publish all day long 😋

 


God saves all but Mateta nets the rebounds !

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 17 Apr 14 7.44pm

Quote slubglurge at 17 Apr 2014 1.00pm

Both have had an incredible impact in their first season with us but who achievement is the best? I personally think TP purely because of the quality of the opposition but Dowie's was pretty spectacular too.


The rumour is TP is wanting to move north to be closer to home. I s'pose Charlton is north of Selhurst

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dowie or Pulis?