You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Summer clear out
November 16 2026 12.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Summer clear out


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
EastEndPalace Flag WithHardNutsCosImAHardBastard 21 Apr 14 4.56pm

Quote Sg Bilko at 21 Apr 2014 4.43pm

Quote Willo at 21 Apr 2014 9.41am

Quote sidman at 21 Apr 2014 9.05am

Jose Campana, hasn't had the chance to show what he can do and everyone has to remember the PL is different to the Spanish so he will need time.

He hasn't settled in England and there is a good chance that he will be gone.I don't expect him to be with us next season.


Do you actually expect any players to be wit us next season.


I agree with him re Campana but in truth Willo just seems ultra sensitive with stupid views and allegedly bad knees.

 

est1905 Flag 21 Apr 14 4.58pm

Be a boring world if we all agreed all the time though eh?

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 21 Apr 14 5.18pm


Unless the current squad have peaked, there's no reason to suspect TP will not keep what he knows works. He's put lots of work into making this lot play coherently together. If he doesn't think its broke why would he want to fix his 1st 11 and back-up players? Expect him to take offers for any replaceable player though. Moxey, Parr, Murray, O'Keef and all those on loan or we never see, may well be out of the door. Sigh of regret for Price, Joniesta and Bannan, but bye, bye.

 

Hoof Hearted 21 Apr 14 5.57pm

I wouldn't be too quick to clear out Gabbidon, he is the next best central defender after Dann and Delaney and is good cover.

I would be tempted to try and get rid of McCarthy first and get in some young blood for our centre of defence. Marriappa is also in contention for a spot if Ward returns to right back and we get a decent left back as Parr is not quite good enough I feel, although better than Moxey.

Midfield is okay, if Zaha becomes available we should get him back.

We defo need better strikers. Jerome's goal tally is not good and Murray needs more time. Gayle not ready yet. Chamakh is okay.

 

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 21 Apr 14 6.29pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Apr 2014 5.57pm

I wouldn't be too quick to clear out Gabbidon, he is the next best central defender after Dann and Delaney and is good cover.

I would be tempted to try and get rid of McCarthy first and get in some young blood for our centre of defence. Marriappa is also in contention for a spot if Ward returns to right back and we get a decent left back as Parr is not quite good enough I feel, although better than Moxey.

Midfield is okay, if Zaha becomes available we should get him back.

We defo need better strikers. Jerome's goal tally is not good and Murray needs more time. Gayle not ready yet. Chamakh is okay.


Totally agree with you there. Harry Maguire of Sheffield United wouldn't be a bad buy, somebody young and he will learn from one of the best defences in the Premier League! Would be a hard opportunity for him to turn down.

 

EagleLegend97 Flag London 21 Apr 14 6.52pm

Sell: McCarthy, Bannan, Moxey, Kebe, Thomas, Dobbie, Garvan, Wilbraham, Campana, (Not renew Jerome's loan)

Loan: O'Keefe, Gayle, Jonny Williams, Hunt

New Contracts: Chamakh, KG, Speroni, (Sign Ince Permanently)

Think we should keep Guedioura, think he is capable but hasn't been given a chance yet. Gabbidon needed for cover, same goes for Parr and Murray.

I think we need a new LB (Cresswell form Ipswich?), another defender (Young one), another winger (2 if we don't sign Ince), another striker and possibly another midfielder (Sidwell?)

Edited by EagleLegend97 (21 Apr 2014 6.52pm)

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 21 Apr 14 8.04pm

Quote adrian b at 21 Apr 2014 5.18pm


Unless the current squad have peaked, there's no reason to suspect TP will not keep what he knows works. He's put lots of work into making this lot play coherently together. If he doesn't think its broke why would he want to fix his 1st 11 and back-up players? Expect him to take offers for any replaceable player though. Moxey, Parr, Murray, O'Keef and all those on loan or we never see, may well be out of the door. Sigh of regret for Price, Joniesta and Bannan, but bye, bye.


It's not about fixing it it's about improving on what you have got. Even the team that finishes top of the league will look to improve and if you don't you get left behind, which would mean relegation in our position.

 

george1212 Flag london 21 Apr 14 8.06pm

Quote EagleLegend97 at 21 Apr 2014 6.52pm

Sell: McCarthy, Bannan, Moxey, Kebe, Thomas, Dobbie, Garvan, Wilbraham, Campana, (Not renew Jerome's loan)

Loan: O'Keefe, Gayle, Jonny Williams, Hunt

New Contracts: Chamakh, KG, Speroni, (Sign Ince Permanently)

Think we should keep Guedioura, think he is capable but hasn't been given a chance yet. Gabbidon needed for cover, same goes for Parr and Murray.

I think we need a new LB (Cresswell form Ipswich?), another defender (Young one), another winger (2 if we don't sign Ince), another striker and possibly another midfielder (Sidwell?)

Edited by EagleLegend97 (21 Apr 2014 6.52pm)

This is sensible.

I think Jerome has done a great job for us and suits our counter attacking style of play. If we are to replace him, we need a player that has the ability to bring others into player, hold up the ball, has strength etc.

Can anyone honestly see Murray being a strong contender for next season? If we can, it would be great to buy a striker with class ie someone like W.Bony at Swansea.

Either way, basically keep the squad that have learnt to win under Pulis, check the rest out, and get 3 great players in. no more deadwood this time!

 

george1212 Flag london 21 Apr 14 8.11pm

Quote george1212 at 21 Apr 2014 8.06pm

Quote EagleLegend97 at 21 Apr 2014 6.52pm

Sell: McCarthy, Bannan, Moxey, Kebe, Thomas, Dobbie, Garvan, Wilbraham, Campana, (Not renew Jerome's loan)

Loan: O'Keefe, Gayle, Jonny Williams, Hunt

New Contracts: Chamakh, KG, Speroni, (Sign Ince Permanently)

Think we should keep Guedioura, think he is capable but hasn't been given a chance yet. Gabbidon needed for cover, same goes for Parr and Murray.

I think we need a new LB (Cresswell form Ipswich?), another defender (Young one), another winger (2 if we don't sign Ince), another striker and possibly another midfielder (Sidwell?)

Edited by EagleLegend97 (21 Apr 2014 6.52pm)

This is sensible.

I think Jerome has done a great job for us and suits our counter attacking style of play. If we are to replace him, we need a player that has the ability to bring others into player, hold up the ball, has strength etc.

Can anyone honestly see Murray being a strong contender for next season? If we can, it would be great to buy a striker with class ie someone like W.Bony at Swansea, but the point is, if we can't get a striker that is proven at this level, then I don't see the point in making changes. We need to spend big on a striker if we are to get someone good in.

Personally, I think Campana could bring something to the squad. Either way, I think if A) we want to stay in the premier league next season, and B) We want to finish comfortable mid-table or even higher, we need to bring in a midfielder that can provide what Jedi can't: technical ability. Free kicks. Shooting. Passing. Of course Jedi is one of our key players, possible the key player, but I believe we could do with another midfielder that could bring some more quality with regards to distrubution, free kicks and shooting.

Either way, basically keep the squad that have learnt to win under Pulis, check the rest out, and get 3 great players in. One central Mid (box to box kind of player) one striker, and a left back. no more deadwood this time!


 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Summer clear out