You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Questions from a Liverpool fan
November 16 2026 12.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Questions from a Liverpool fan


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Mstrobez Flag 01 May 14 9.47am

Quote Kop Blocks at 29 Apr 2014 8.52pm

Alright all?

I've joined from a Liverpool site (kopblocks.com) - we're a fairly newish forum that's only been going for a few months. One of the things we've tried to get going is a 'View From That Lot' feature where we get the opinion of whoever our opposition for that week is. Obviously we're facing Palace at the weekend so if you've got a few minutes and don't mind asking a few questions I'd appreciate it!

1. You've made an impressive recovery from a terrible start to the season and already guaranteed your safety - do you think you can consolidate in the Premier League next season or will it be a case of a second season struggle? I think we will be ok next season but I just hope the fans don't start whinging and keep up the terrific support of the last few years.

2. I've not seen much of Palace this season (outside of occasional Match of the Day highlights) - Tony Pulis got a reputation for being a bit 'agricultural' at Stoke but how has he had Palace playing since he came to you? He gets us the points we need and does a job. I'm sure you would've heard/seen what we did at Goodison - that was no means as simple as "parking the bus"

3. As it's football's awards season - who are Palace's Player of the Year and Young Player of the Year?Has to be Joel Ward for both but it feels wrong Speroni not getting a mention too.

4. Who do you see as being Palace's main threats to Liverpool?Puncheon, Chamakh + Bolasie

5. What are your best and worst memories of Palace vs Liverpool over the years?I'm still young so my memories go back to the league cup "worthington cup" it was at the time - 2-1 home win and then come to you lot and lost 5-0 and even Igor Biscan scored a goal - awful night

6. When I was a kid (80s/early 90s) Palace seemed to have loads of players who ended up moving on and making big careers for themselves at some big clubs (Ian Wright's the obvious one but you seemed to have quite a conveyor belt for a while). If you could get one of your ex-players back in the Palace squad and in their prime today who would you pick and what would they add to today's side?People like to forget Wilf easily because he hasn't done great since he left but he was the most exciting talent I have ever seen at Selhurst and that includes the likes of Victor Moses etc. he was breathtaking at times last season

7. What have you made of Liverpool this season?Whether the rest of the board love it or hate it, Liverpool have always been my second team (when I used to play up front as little boy, I was always compared to Michael Owen, kinda took off from there) I think to keep me emotionally stable, I had to have a succesful team I followed whilst still devoting my complete support to Palace. I said you would be a force this season but never expected you to be in the position you were in. I thought Suarez was the best in the league last season anyway so wasn't surprised at his performances this year (although he has been out of this f***ing world). The only problem you have is you are a little one dimensional - you can play football as good as anyone in the world at the moment but when it comes to sitting back, breaking down teams and grinding out results - you struggle, and it could weel be costly for you lot this season.

8. If you could take any of Liverpool's players for Palace and dump your worst player onto us, who'd be packing their bags and filling the Bugatti's tank for the trips along the M6? Luis Suarez would be in for Aaron Wilbraham

9. Finally, predictions for Monday night? Difficult to predict this one but I think you might struggle


Thanks in advance for any answers!


 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Kop Blocks Flag NI 01 May 14 9.46pm

Thanks again lads. You can see the topic on our board at [Link] if you want to have a look.

 

MikeT Flag Burlington (Toronto Area) 02 May 14 3.22am

Quote sydtheeagle at 29 Apr 2014 10.12pm

1. You've made an impressive recovery from a terrible start to the season and already guaranteed your safety - do you think you can consolidate in the Premier League next season or will it be a case of a second season struggle?

Very much so. We had enough wit to use the January window to consolidate on our turnaround in November and December and with shrewd leaders in both the boardroom and the manager's office, I'm quite sure we'll consolidate on our second half improvement this season during the summer window. I look for a solid 9th-14 place finish next year.

2. I've not seen much of Palace this season (outside of occasional Match of the Day highlights) - Tony Pulis got a reputation for being a bit 'agricultural' at Stoke but how has he had Palace playing since he came to you?

Intelligently, given our resources. We defend in numbers and use a couple of highly competent midfield ball winners (Jedinak, Dikgakoi) to break up the opposition's play and spring our two wide men (Bolasie and Puncheon) who then use their considerable speed to counter attack. We are stout at the back to be sure but not agricultural and though we rarely have the possession to attack in waves, when breaking at speed we can be a joy to watch and we cause other teams problems. Net year, I expect to take another step forward and play a similar style but with more possession.

3. As it's football's awards season - who are Palace's Player of the Year and Young Player of the Year?

POTY would be Speroni or Jedinak; take your pick. YPOTY would be Ward if you think he's "young" (which is debatable in my book.)

4. Who do you see as being Palace's main threats to Liverpool?

I don't think we threaten in the deliberate manner you suggest, and in the way -- say -- that you rely on Suarez who in turn is clearly your biggest threat. We don't really threaten on an individual level: our main threat is team speed on the counter attack. If I had to name a player, Puncheon for his eye for goal allied to his speed and Bolasie, who until last week appeared to be rounding into form.

5. What are your best and worst memories of Palace vs Liverpool over the years?

Do you really need to ask for either? Clue: same season, about six month's apart. The 2-3 League Cup game in the 70s when Doris put us 1-0 up with a piledriver from 30 yards out before Keegan and co. responded with three is another fond memory of mine.

6. When I was a kid (80s/early 90s) Palace seemed to have loads of players who ended up moving on and making big careers for themselves at some big clubs (Ian Wright's the obvious one but you seemed to have quite a conveyor belt for a while). If you could get one of your ex-players back in the Palace squad and in their prime today who would you pick and what would they add to today's side?

Well, we lack two things now. A left back, and we produced arguably the best English one of those in history: Kenny Sansom. So he'd be in with a shout. And a goalscorer, and you'd really have to go with Ian Wright there although we've had a few good ones over the years (Trevor Aylott comes to mind. Not.) But even though we have a great keeper, the answer is John Jackson simply because he's the best footballer to ever walk the face of the earth. Late 60s early 70s, in case you were wondering. Some say God...

7. What have you made of Liverpool this season?

Impressive on the pitch. If Brendan Rogers was chocolate, he'd eat himself and I really don't warm to him personally for that reason. But he's a damn good manager. I spent the better part of half a decade in Boston so I am deeply familiar with John Henry, the Red Sox and FSG. When they bought Liverpool I spent a lot of time re-assuring fans of yours in my orbit that they needn't worry; they were in good hands. And so it's proved. Basically, in a perfect world we'd thrash you Monday night but you'd win the league the following week. And if you hadn't folded against Chelsea, it might have happened that way, too!

8. If you could take any of Liverpool's players for Palace and dump your worst player onto us, who'd be packing their bags and filling the Bugatti's tank for the trips along the M6?

One of yours? Let me think...name begins with an "s" and it ain't Sturridge or Skrtel (though to be fair, I'd have the latter's wife.) As for who you can have in return, you'll need a replacement for Suarez so it seems only fair to offer you Aaron Wilbraham. And before you start complaining, a few weeks ago it'd have been Eliot Grandin so things are definitely moving in the right direction for you.

9. Finally, predictions for Monday night?

Hot chocolate before bed, sex if I'm lucky and I get in at a decent hour, and 1-1.


We've had many a trip to Fenway to watch the Blue Jays play the Red Sox. Fenway's a wonderful quirky ground that had echoes of Selhurst for me. From their Boston experience I'm sure FSG will be well aware of the need to maintain a lively atmosphere as they redevelop Anfield.

Just wonder if the Gerrard slip will ultimately be viewed in the same category as the Bill Buckner blunder that saw the Red Sox lose the World Series to the Mets after essentially having it all sown up.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 May 14 10.17am

1. We will be favourites for relegation but a lot will depend on who we buy - we did have luck with injuries this season with what is essentially a wafer thin squad


2. Something I was worried about and it one thing I have been really happy with (bar a couple of games where we essentailly played 'anti-football against teams who where there for the taking). We defend deep and in numbers and cede possession for sure, but play on the break quickly and at times do play some nice stuff.

3. Speroni has won games and points for us and Damien Delaney has stepped up amazingly so its hime for for me with Joel Ward as Young Player

4. Yala - Quick as lightening - If he is on he will give the FB problems

5. The 4-3 without a doubt is the high with the 0-9 a real downer that proved to have a silver lining - it actually re-inforced for what the players needed to do to stay up at the highest level

6. Kenny Sansom - we need a LB and he is arguably the best one England have ever had let alone Palace.

7. What have you made of Liverpool this season?
Have been really explosive and have been very adaptable in suiting systems to games - I did think you would be top 4 but have been a little surpsrised you have managed to keep it going as title contenders for so long

8. Sturridge for me - really like him as a player and we could swap for Wilbrahimovic

9. Heart says 0-0 Draw - Head says 2-1 Liverpool

Edited by The Sash (02 May 2014 10.19am)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 02 May 14 7.19pm

Quote MikeT at 02 May 2014 3.22am


We've had many a trip to Fenway to watch the Blue Jays play the Red Sox. Fenway's a wonderful quirky ground that had echoes of Selhurst for me. From their Boston experience I'm sure FSG will be well aware of the need to maintain a lively atmosphere as they redevelop Anfield.

Just wonder if the Gerrard slip will ultimately be viewed in the same category as the Bill Buckner blunder that saw the Red Sox lose the World Series to the Mets after essentially having it all sewn up.

The "Bucknor Blunder" didn't lose the World Series for the Red Sox in '86 because the score was tied when it happened. It was also Game 6, the Sox could have still won the Series in Game 7 and in fact had a lead until the Mets came back on the battered Sox bullpen. Bucknor is often described as the best player not in the Hall of Fame, a marvelous hitter and solid fielder until his legs gave out from constant injuries. He is now a hero in Boston, a player who gave his all even when he was in constant pain.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Shoot the runner Flag Addiscombe 03 May 14 1.20pm

funniest memory was out singing the kop at 9-0 down, best memory a non brainer, worst memory was having to come home by coach after the 9-0 because feck all trains leave lime street for london after 8pm

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 03 May 14 2.21pm

Quote kenbarr at 02 May 2014 7.19pm

The "Bucknor Blunder" didn't lose the World Series for the Red Sox in '86 because the score was tied when it happened. It was also Game 6, the Sox could have still won the Series in Game 7 and in fact had a lead until the Mets came back on the battered Sox bullpen. Bucknor is often described as the best player not in the Hall of Fame, a marvelous hitter and solid fielder until his legs gave out from constant injuries. He is now a hero in Boston, a player who gave his all even when he was in constant pain.


Thank you! It bugs the crap out of me how this is remembered - mostly because of how the media portray it. Same as the Bartman incident with Alou for the Cubs. That was in game 6 too, and the pitch immediately afterwards dribbled under the shortstop's glove for an error.

Both teams had plenty of time to play around the incidents. They didn't, which is their own faults.

End of rant.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Questions from a Liverpool fan