You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who deserve the title?
November 16 2026 12.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who deserve the title?


scarlet Flag Turkey 30 Apr 14 12.48am

After watching Chelsea use all the professionalism's of time wasting, deliberate fouls and just plain old boring stuff any attack by putting all your players in front of goal and then two sucker punch goals I was sad for football.
With Man City and Liverpool continuing to play attractive, open football and their recent game was everything good about the game I really am torn with us possibly giving the title to Chelsea!

Who do you think deserves the title?

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

 

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 30 Apr 14 1.22am

Perhaps if we beat Liverpool and deny them the opportunity to be Champions then TP will be proclaimed Manager of the Year?!!! It's a nice thought.

I'm not really torn between Man. City and Chelski but I can't see the latter beating an in form Real Madrid side in the Champions League final if they do get through tonight.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

Buzzcock Flag In an underground lair near Bright... 30 Apr 14 1.54am

Whoever gets most points/ best goal difference deserves it. Style of football or tactics is immaterial.

 


In the woods there grew a tree. And a fine fine tree was he.

Kingvagabond Flag London 30 Apr 14 2.24am

Quote Buzzcock at 30 Apr 2014 1.54am

Whoever gets most points/ best goal difference deserves it. Style of football or tactics is immaterial.

Exactly. People all season have talked about our resolute defending and the fact we've scored very few goals. People have said that we waste huge amounts of time. Does that mean we don't deserve to stay up? Of course it doesn't. We have got the points we need because we played to our strengths. If Chelsea wins the league because they've got the most points at the end of the season or if they win the champions league because they've won the most games then good for them. If its Liverpool then they deserve it. If its Man City then they deserve it.

Edited by Kingvagabond (30 Apr 2014 2.28am)

 


Part of Holmesdale Radio: The Next Generation
@KingvagabondHOL

Quote cornwalls palace at 24 Oct 2012 9.37am

He was right!!!...and we killed him!!... poor Orpinton Eagles........

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 30 Apr 14 7.30am

"Football in this moment is full of philosophers, people who understand much more than me. Amazing.

"But the reality is the reality. A team that doesn't defend well doesn't have many chances to win."

Good point Jose.

Whoever comes top will deserve the title.

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 30 Apr 14 8.46am

Quote Buzzcock at 30 Apr 2014 1.54am

Whoever gets most points/ best goal difference deserves it. Style of football or tactics is immaterial.


Agreed. We don't always look pretty, but so long as the points are on the board I'm happy.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 30 Apr 14 8.47am

Quote Buzzcock at 30 Apr 2014 1.54am

Whoever gets most points/ best goal difference deserves it. Style of football or tactics is immaterial.


Agreed.

However you would NOT want to watch backs to the wall Football every week/every year etc.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

sydtheeagle Flag England 30 Apr 14 12.43pm

Quote scarlet at 30 Apr 2014 12.48am

After watching Chelsea use all the professionalism's of time wasting, deliberate fouls and just plain old boring stuff any attack by putting all your players in front of goal and then two sucker punch goals I was sad for football.

With Man City and Liverpool continuing to play attractive, open football and their recent game was everything good about the game I really am torn with us possibly giving the title to Chelsea!

Who do you think deserves the title?

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

TBH I couldn't disagree more with the sentiments expressed here. Writing off Mourinho on the above basis is the same as all the rubbish that's been written about Pulis over the years. Sports is about winning, not aesthetics, and until they start giving football teams marks for artistic impression, the team with the most points will deservedly win the title. Watching Mourinho time and time again outwit managers of supposedly more attractive (sic) football teams is hilarious. I mean Tan claims we knew all about Cardiff before the match. Do you think anyone in Liverpool didn't know Chelsea were going to park two buses at least a week before the game? Yet despite this, Rodgers was completely unable to devise a tactical plan to break it down despite having a side that included Luis Suarez, arguably the most dangerous individual attacking player in the country. Sucker punch goals my backside; that was victory by tactical design if ever I've seen it and Jose has done it time and time and time again. If you can't find entertainment in his sheer expertise then I'd recommend League 2 football; all blood, guts and attacking intent.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Lombardos barber Flag 30 Apr 14 1.01pm

Man Citys net spend since 2009 - £490m

Liverpools - £90m

City are a disgusting example of everything i hate about football.

They have earned none of their success.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 14 1.10pm

Quote Lombardos barber at 30 Apr 2014 1.01pm

Man Citys net spend since 2009 - £490m

Liverpools - £90m

City are a disgusting example of everything i hate about football.

They have earned none of their success.


Arguably they deserve the title, after all they paid a lot of money for it

Couldn't care less who wins the premier league - Liverpool has always been a horrible plastics team and probably invented the concept of 'plastic fans' back in the 80s, where as I know few Chelsea fans and a Man City fan who actually supported their clubs when they were s**t.

Anyone but Liverpool.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 30 Apr 14 1.19pm

Quote scarlet at 30 Apr 2014 12.48am

After watching Chelsea use all the professionalism's of time wasting, deliberate fouls and just plain old boring stuff any attack by putting all your players in front of goal and then two sucker punch goals I was sad for football.
With Man City and Liverpool continuing to play attractive, open football and their recent game was everything good about the game I really am torn with us possibly giving the title to Chelsea!

Who do you think deserves the title?

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

Completely disgaree - They can play that way because they spend an absolute fortune on wages, and then slate anyone who sets up anyone who deploys tactically to defeat them. Too many people seem to be enthralled by the thrill of the goal, but cannot seem to take pleasure in watching a good defence.

Rule 101 of Modern Football - Its about NOT conceeding goals. Managers who set out teams to score their way out of trouble invariably fail unless they can afford to spunk fortunes on a first XI of the best in the world.

Liverpool are doing well this season, on the basis of Sturridge and Suraez both having great seasons and avoiding injury. Their defence is poor, their midfield bar Coutino dull. They're largely lucky this season that both players have been in their best form and scoring for fun.

But thats a luxuary most teams never have, because if you do have those kind of players, Liverpool/Man City/Chelsea/Arsenal/Man Utd will just buy them from you.

Its like Man Utd last season, those goals from Van Persie covered up the weaknesses that were oh so apparent this season. Man Utd aren't any worse this season than last, they just miss the one player who made the difference.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

est1905 Flag 30 Apr 14 8.16pm

Quote scarlet at 30 Apr 2014 12.48am

After watching Chelsea use all the professionalism's of time wasting, deliberate fouls and just plain old boring stuff any attack by putting all your players in front of goal and then two sucker punch goals I was sad for football.
With Man City and Liverpool continuing to play attractive, open football and their recent game was everything good about the game I really am torn with us possibly giving the title to Chelsea!

Who do you think deserves the title?

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

The team who has the most points at the end


 

Vim Fuego Flag Haywards Heath 30 Apr 14 8.19pm

Quote scarlet at 30 Apr 2014 12.48am

After watching Chelsea use all the professionalism's of time wasting, deliberate fouls and just plain old boring stuff any attack by putting all your players in front of goal and then two sucker punch goals I was sad for football.
With Man City and Liverpool continuing to play attractive, open football and their recent game was everything good about the game I really am torn with us possibly giving the title to Chelsea!

Who do you think deserves the title?

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

We do. We are by far the greatest team the world has ever seen.

 

Palace4861 Flag Sevenoaks 30 Apr 14 9.10pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Apr 2014 1.10pm

Quote Lombardos barber at 30 Apr 2014 1.01pm

Man Citys net spend since 2009 - £490m

Liverpools - £90m

City are a disgusting example of everything i hate about football.

They have earned none of their success.


Arguably they deserve the title, after all they paid a lot of money for it


Couldn't care less who wins the premier league - Liverpool has always been a horrible plastics team and probably invented the concept of 'plastic fans' back in the 80s, where as I know few Chelsea fans and a Man City fan who actually supported their clubs when they were s**t.

Anyone but Liverpool.

City has spend that amount of money in 5 years.
How much have manure spend over the last 20 years.
In the recent manc derby the staring eleven for City totalled 185 million but manure total was 192 million .
On the transfer forum people are asking the board to spend 30/40 million on one player something we will never do.
I believe titles are not bought but the most consisted team will win so for me it's City.

 

maxipalace Flag in a box 30 Apr 14 9.21pm

It would be a greater achievement if Liverpool win for the financial outlay in comparison to city and chelski ; Sturridge who was not given much game time at city or chelski has at least proved a success if given a proper run in the team.

Lesson to be learned Maybe

 

deh1968 Flag sutton 30 Apr 14 9.44pm

Call me old fashioned, but does this subject need to be in Palace talk? Or as i suspect in football talk?
So, who deserves to win the play offs ?

 


WE ARE GOING UP SAY WE ARE GOING UP

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 30 Apr 14 10.26pm

Quote deh1968 at 30 Apr 2014 9.44pm

Call me old fashioned, but does this subject need to be in Palace talk? Or as i suspect in football talk?
So, who deserves to win the play offs ?

We did!!!! ....don't really care about this year though.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

lankygit Flag Lincoln 30 Apr 14 10.28pm

Quote Buzzcock at 30 Apr 2014 1.54am

Whoever gets most points/ best goal difference deserves it. Style of football or tactics is immaterial.


Agreed, this has always been the way I see it.

 


Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link]

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 30 Apr 14 11.02pm

I thought the question asked on this thread was who do you want to win the title, not who deserves to win. Of course we know the title will be won by the team with most points. The question is what team do you want to achieve this? For me Liverpool don't have the style to enthral , and City have cheated by taking a short cut through buying success. Conversely Chelsea seem to be the cheeky chappies who delight in fooling us all and consequently are a delight to follow. (In reality my desire is for the ol' Glaziers to win it...but you did ask)

 

Aray Flag South London 30 Apr 14 11.26pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Apr 2014 12.43pm

Quote scarlet at 30 Apr 2014 12.48am

After watching Chelsea use all the professionalism's of time wasting, deliberate fouls and just plain old boring stuff any attack by putting all your players in front of goal and then two sucker punch goals I was sad for football.

With Man City and Liverpool continuing to play attractive, open football and their recent game was everything good about the game I really am torn with us possibly giving the title to Chelsea!

Who do you think deserves the title?

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

Edited by scarlet (30 Apr 2014 12.51am)

TBH I couldn't disagree more with the sentiments expressed here. Writing off Mourinho on the above basis is the same as all the rubbish that's been written about Pulis over the years. Sports is about winning, not aesthetics, and until they start giving football teams marks for artistic impression, the team with the most points will deservedly win the title. Watching Mourinho time and time again outwit managers of supposedly more attractive (sic) football teams is hilarious. I mean Tan claims we knew all about Cardiff before the match. Do you think anyone in Liverpool didn't know Chelsea were going to park two buses at least a week before the game? Yet despite this, Rodgers was completely unable to devise a tactical plan to break it down despite having a side that included Luis Suarez, arguably the most dangerous individual attacking player in the country. Sucker punch goals my backside; that was victory by tactical design if ever I've seen it and Jose has done it time and time and time again. If you can't find entertainment in his sheer expertise then I'd recommend League 2 football; all blood, guts and attacking intent.

Liverpool or Man city. I don't agree that sport is only about winning. We need to be entertained. Well I do. Don't get me wrong - I'm happy or Palace to win ugly given our scarce resources. But if you spend the millions Chelsea have - parking the proverbial bus is a disgrace. Nowt wrong with smart tactics - like when they played Man City away but that win at Anfield is hardly inspirational is it?

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who deserve the title?