You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the 16 signings - Your top 3 for the season
November 16 2026 12.08pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rate the 16 signings - Your top 3 for the season


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Bangell Flag Oxford 06 May 14 12.56pm

Puncheon
Dann
Mariappa/Jerome

I put those last two over Chamakh because of the effort they put in every time they've played.

 

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 06 May 14 1.28pm

Quote Hansy at 06 May 2014 12.26pm

You can't put Gayle in there after last night. I judge it over the season.

3. Chamakh
2. Puncheon
1. Pulis

Last night is part of the season though, yeah?

...and on a lighter note, good shout on Pulis. If we're talking all signings and not just players, he should be all of our #1

 

sxp55 Flag South Norwood 06 May 14 1.54pm

1)Dann, 2)Ledley,3)Mariappa,

 


@sxp55555

Only one Salako Flag London 06 May 14 1.59pm

1) Punch
2) Ledley
3) Dann

 


"they gave it everything, every ounce of blood, sweat and guts. They battled, they never ducked a challenge and, as their fans ripped their T-shirts off in the stands, creating the kind of heady atmosphere that has turned Selhurst Park into an amphitheatre" Matthew Syed

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 May 14 2.04pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 May 2014 12.33pm

Quote Eager eagle at 06 May 2014 12.13pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 May 2014 9.58am

A reminder - Puncheon, Ledley, Ince, Guediora, Campana, Hennessy, Dann, Mariappa, Gayle, Chamakh, Bannan, Kebe, Jerome, Dobbie, Hunt, Thomas.

I'll work out who comes out on top overall once we've had a fair few votes.

3)Chamakh

2)Dann

*drum roll......*

1)Puncheon


Was it you who said you didn't rate Dann that much,as your mate is a Blackburn fan who said he wasn't all that?
Just asking.


He he

I really thought he knew his football. He's been told.


To be fair, a Blackburn fan I know said the same thing. Described him as a pretty average defender with very limited ability. He's been anything but average since January.

I'd probably go:

Chamakh
Puncheon
Dann

Ledley, mariappa, jerome and Gayle have all made telling contributions as well. Oh and Grandin.

 

Gameover Flag 06 May 14 2.49pm

1) Puncheon

2) Chamakh

3) Dann

4) Ledley

5) Gayle

 


" AN AMAZING NIGHT AT SELHURST PARK LIVERPOOL HAVE CAVED IN"

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 06 May 14 2.59pm

I was speaking to a liverpool fan I know last night and he admitted that three of our back four were better than theirs I wonder if can guess what three.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 06 May 14 3.26pm

just curious which of their back four was he considering better than any of ours?

Edited by EagleRider (06 May 2014 3.26pm)

 

wainesworld Flag west wickham 06 May 14 3.30pm

1, Anthony

2, Richard

3, Pullis

The mans a marvel.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 06 May 14 3.33pm

Surely you are better off differentiating those that you would like to keep and those that should go. I would keep:

Puncheon, Ledley, Ince, Guediora, Hennessy, Dann, Mariappa, Gayle, Chamakh, Bannan, Jerome, Hunt.

So actually 12 of those signed I would retain. Not a bad return.
However if Pulis believe he can improve I would be happy to stick with his judgement in trading up.
Time still on the side of Gayle, Bannan and Hunt.

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 06 May 14 3.33pm

Quote EagleRider at 06 May 2014 1.28pm

Quote Hansy at 06 May 2014 12.26pm

You can't put Gayle in there after last night. I judge it over the season.

3. Chamakh
2. Puncheon
1. Pulis

Last night is part of the season though, yeah?

...and on a lighter note, good shout on Pulis. If we're talking all signings and not just players, he should be all of our #1

If Speroni signs a new deal does he count as a signing?

 

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 06 May 14 3.40pm

Without Puncheons goals, how many points would we have dropped?

Has to JP. Match winner.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 06 May 14 4.18pm

1. Ledley
2. Puncheon
3. Dann

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

girvinator Flag Poole 06 May 14 4.26pm

1) Puncheon
2) Gayle
3) Chamakh

Those three contributed 17 of our 31 league goals.

 

DBCPFC Flag 06 May 14 4.39pm

1) Puncheon. Was decent as a loanee, then amazing as a full time player.

2) Gayle. Last night and Villa, definitely one for now and the future.

3) Hennessey. Look at what he's don't to Julian, he may not have played a minute...but look at how he affected him.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 06 May 14 4.51pm

It's tough, there have been more than a few successes (as well as some abject failures!) I'll go with

1. Chamakh - Tireless and has a great touch
2. Puncheon - I didn't rate him but his goals and effort have been spectacular for the last quarter if the seasin
3. Dann - Solid, and one of the reasons we have such a tight defense.

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 06 May 14 7.37pm

1. Dann
2. Chamakh
3. Puncheon

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the 16 signings - Your top 3 for the season