You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > discipline and the little things
November 16 2026 12.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

discipline and the little things


hastingseagle67 Flag 12 May 14 11.33am

Correct me if I'm wrong, but since TP took over, I cannot remember one of our players taking off their shirt after scoring a goal. If TP has warned players not to do this, it is another stroke of genius that shows that all the little details matter. Last time I looked , we were in the top half of the fairplay league and i'm sure TP realised that although we have a large squad the depth of premiere league talent is quite shallow and losing players through poor discipline would be very frustrating.Once again the belief that a TP team has to knock lumps out of the opposition is diproved.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 12 May 14 11.39am

Quote hastingseagle67 at 12 May 2014 11.33am

Correct me if I'm wrong, but since TP took over, I cannot remember one of our players taking off their shirt after scoring a goal. If TP has warned players not to do this, it is another stroke of genius that shows that all the little details matter. Last time I looked , we were in the top half of the fairplay league and i'm sure TP realised that although we have a large squad the depth of premiere league talent is quite shallow and losing players through poor discipline would be very frustrating.Once again the belief that a TP team has to knock lumps out of the opposition is diproved.

It is a very stupid way of getting yourself carded and banned.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 12 May 14 4.19pm

Quote Catfish at 12 May 2014 11.39am

It is a very stupid way of getting yourself carded and banned.


It's a stupid thing anyway. Hardly spontaneous. As a manager, I'd fine every player who did this because it accumulates towards a suspension and puts you one (forward's) tackle away from a sending off.

Here's the most stupid example of it though: [Link]

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 12 May 14 4.36pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 12 May 2014 4.19pm

Quote Catfish at 12 May 2014 11.39am

It is a very stupid way of getting yourself carded and banned.


It's a stupid thing anyway. Hardly spontaneous. As a manager, I'd fine every player who did this because it accumulates towards a suspension and puts you one (forward's) tackle away from a sending off.

Here's the most stupid example of it though: [Link]


Omg that is pathetic.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Part Time James Flag 12 May 14 4.40pm

My only slight disciplinary gripe this season relates to a player who I absolutely love and have no other gripes with really, Chamakh.

I love his passion and have joked it a bit saying "get stuck in Chammers" but he's reacted to tackles he's not liked with hands in opponent's faces a few times and he's lucky not to have been sent off. If I was TP i'd try to keep him for doing that. As I say, I think it's an extension of just how passionate he is becoming about his game, but he won't get away with it forever.

Edited by Part Time James (12 May 2014 4.42pm)

 




blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 12 May 14 5.11pm

I believe Pulis is the complete disciplinarian who accepts no antics of a stupid nature and he therefore gets what he wants and when he wants it. We really do not have the time for highly paid players acting like schoolboys(myself included) as we have to keep focused on the task at hand. Score and prevent goals and win matches!.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 13 May 14 10.39am

Quote Part Time James at 12 May 2014 4.40pm

My only slight disciplinary gripe this season relates to a player who I absolutely love and have no other gripes with really, Chamakh.

I love his passion and have joked it a bit saying "get stuck in Chammers" but he's reacted to tackles he's not liked with hands in opponent's faces a few times and he's lucky not to have been sent off. If I was TP i'd try to keep him for doing that. As I say, I think it's an extension of just how passionate he is becoming about his game, but he won't get away with it forever.

Edited by Part Time James (12 May 2014 4.42pm)

Wasn't it the Norwich home game on New Years day when he tapped an opposition defender in the face? At the time I thought, oh no, he's off. As it was the ref. saw fit to just give a yellow, but he was a lucky man that day.

I can't remember, have we had any suspensions this season through accumulated yellow cards? Delaney, Jedi and Cham have been top of the league for yellows.

It is interesting to note that Ward ended with only 3 yellows ( he had none until March) which is I am sure a testament to his skill, timing and composure.


 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 13 May 14 10.51am

It's just as likely that he's injured, but we haven't seen Jerome Thomas since that awful dive in the box and subsequent yellow card. Can't remember the game.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Part Time James Flag 13 May 14 11.14am

Quote Pete53 at 13 May 2014 10.39am

Quote Part Time James at 12 May 2014 4.40pm

My only slight disciplinary gripe this season relates to a player who I absolutely love and have no other gripes with really, Chamakh.

I love his passion and have joked it a bit saying "get stuck in Chammers" but he's reacted to tackles he's not liked with hands in opponent's faces a few times and he's lucky not to have been sent off. If I was TP i'd try to keep him for doing that. As I say, I think it's an extension of just how passionate he is becoming about his game, but he won't get away with it forever.

Edited by Part Time James (12 May 2014 4.42pm)

Wasn't it the Norwich home game on New Years day when he tapped an opposition defender in the face? At the time I thought, oh no, he's off. As it was the ref. saw fit to just give a yellow, but he was a lucky man that day.

I can't remember, have we had any suspensions this season through accumulated yellow cards? Delaney, Jedi and Cham have been top of the league for yellows.

It is interesting to note that Ward ended with only 3 yellows ( he had none until March) which is I am sure a testament to his skill, timing and composure.


Yeah, it was the Norwich game. He put his head against one of the Fulham players after already having been booked on Sunday as well and I have a feeling there were other little snaps.

Regarding the stats....I don't think we had any suspensions as a result of accumulated cards.

 




Part Time James Flag 13 May 14 11.15am

Quote pstrutt at 13 May 2014 10.51am

It's just as likely that he's injured, but we haven't seen Jerome Thomas since that awful dive in the box and subsequent yellow card. Can't remember the game.


I thought he came on from the bench or started in the very next game. But since then...no, don't think we have seen him...

 




adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 13 May 14 11.37am


Although getting a card for taking off your shirt is annoying, it shows the way the officiating of matches has gone. What's so bad about removing your shirt after scoring? Far more aggressive stuff is allowed to go. As for the clip of the player being booked (and subsequently being sent off) for removing his shirt shows how silly that ref is. That is more of a threat to the future of the discipline of the game as such actions can only reduce the esteem in which the refs are held. TP is clever enough to realise this.

 

Part Time James Flag 13 May 14 11.38am

Quote adrian b at 13 May 2014 11.37am


Although getting a card for taking off your shirt is annoying, it shows the way the officiating of matches has gone. What's so bad about removing your shirt after scoring? Far more aggressive stuff is allowed to go. As for the clip of the player being booked (and subsequently being sent off) for removing his shirt shows how silly that ref is. That is more of a threat to the future of the discipline of the game as such actions can only reduce the esteem in which the refs are held. TP is clever enough to realise this.


I think it should be actively encouraged, especially in women's football.

 




silvertop Flag Portishead 13 May 14 11.43am

Quote Part Time James at 13 May 2014 11.14am

Quote Pete53 at 13 May 2014 10.39am

Quote Part Time James at 12 May 2014 4.40pm

My only slight disciplinary gripe this season relates to a player who I absolutely love and have no other gripes with really, Chamakh.

I love his passion and have joked it a bit saying "get stuck in Chammers" but he's reacted to tackles he's not liked with hands in opponent's faces a few times and he's lucky not to have been sent off. If I was TP i'd try to keep him for doing that. As I say, I think it's an extension of just how passionate he is becoming about his game, but he won't get away with it forever.

Edited by Part Time James (12 May 2014 4.42pm)

Wasn't it the Norwich home game on New Years day when he tapped an opposition defender in the face? At the time I thought, oh no, he's off. As it was the ref. saw fit to just give a yellow, but he was a lucky man that day.

I can't remember, have we had any suspensions this season through accumulated yellow cards? Delaney, Jedi and Cham have been top of the league for yellows.

It is interesting to note that Ward ended with only 3 yellows ( he had none until March) which is I am sure a testament to his skill, timing and composure.


Yeah, it was the Norwich game. He put his head against one of the Fulham players after already having been booked on Sunday as well and I have a feeling there were other little snaps.

Regarding the stats....I don't think we had any suspensions as a result of accumulated cards.


Chamakh is a "defensive attacker". I am not surprised he has accumulated cards. Just cut out the petulant stuff.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 13 May 14 11.45am

Quote adrian b at 13 May 2014 11.37am


Although getting a card for taking off your shirt is annoying, it shows the way the officiating of matches has gone. What's so bad about removing your shirt after scoring? Far more aggressive stuff is allowed to go. As for the clip of the player being booked (and subsequently being sent off) for removing his shirt shows how silly that ref is. That is more of a threat to the future of the discipline of the game as such actions can only reduce the esteem in which the refs are held. TP is clever enough to realise this.


Just goes to show that the ref was following the laws of the game that FIFA have laid down.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Part Time James Flag 13 May 14 11.50am

Quote silvertop at 13 May 2014 11.43am

Quote Part Time James at 13 May 2014 11.14am

Quote Pete53 at 13 May 2014 10.39am

Quote Part Time James at 12 May 2014 4.40pm

My only slight disciplinary gripe this season relates to a player who I absolutely love and have no other gripes with really, Chamakh.

I love his passion and have joked it a bit saying "get stuck in Chammers" but he's reacted to tackles he's not liked with hands in opponent's faces a few times and he's lucky not to have been sent off. If I was TP i'd try to keep him for doing that. As I say, I think it's an extension of just how passionate he is becoming about his game, but he won't get away with it forever.

Edited by Part Time James (12 May 2014 4.42pm)

Wasn't it the Norwich home game on New Years day when he tapped an opposition defender in the face? At the time I thought, oh no, he's off. As it was the ref. saw fit to just give a yellow, but he was a lucky man that day.

I can't remember, have we had any suspensions this season through accumulated yellow cards? Delaney, Jedi and Cham have been top of the league for yellows.

It is interesting to note that Ward ended with only 3 yellows ( he had none until March) which is I am sure a testament to his skill, timing and composure.


Yeah, it was the Norwich game. He put his head against one of the Fulham players after already having been booked on Sunday as well and I have a feeling there were other little snaps.

Regarding the stats....I don't think we had any suspensions as a result of accumulated cards.


Chamakh is a "defensive attacker". I am not surprised he has accumulated cards. Just cut out the petulant stuff.


Agreed. I don't begrudge him the cards for being 'here, there and every f**king where' and I instantly forgave him for giving away that penalty for that reason. As you say, he just needs to hold back the red mist a little bit. I reckon if he hadn't been given a yellow in the Norwich game he would've received a retrospective red after a subsequent review.

 




spt46 Flag 13 May 14 11.58am

Talking of 'little things' - luckily for Suarez it was the end of the game before he tried to take his shirt off. Still should have been booked - 'Bringing the game into disrepute' or just for 'Being Suarez'

Suarez cries.jpg Attachment: Suarez cries.jpg (6.99Kb)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 13 May 14 1.28pm

Quote adrian b at 13 May 2014 11.37am

Although getting a card for taking off your shirt is annoying, it shows the way the officiating of matches has gone. What's so bad about removing your shirt after scoring? Far more aggressive stuff is allowed to go. As for the clip of the player being booked (and subsequently being sent off) for removing his shirt shows how silly that ref is. That is more of a threat to the future of the discipline of the game as such actions can only reduce the esteem in which the refs are held. TP is clever enough to realise this.


Deemed offensive in some prudish places. A theme park over here has just decided to ban it for the same reason.

Troy Deeney got away with it in the playoffs last year. Consistency issues again.

 


Optimistic as ever


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > discipline and the little things