You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who has the numbers needed to govern?
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who has the numbers needed to govern?


Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Apr 15 12.43pm

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 11.01am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Apr 2015 10.35am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)

What has happened in Greece isn't a 'product of democracy' it a product of economic disaster, which traditionally has always led to extremist parties capitalising (usually far right and far left). Arguably the real affect of democracy in the Greek situation is that it acts as a 'pressure valve'.

Of course Greece also actually has a democratic system based on proportional representation, rather than a our 'constitunency based first past the post' system that is effectively rigged to leave large parts of the population irrelivent to the democratic process.


Which is something we need desperately in this country.


A democratic system thats actually a) democratic in principle and b) creates representation in parliment for the vast majority of voters.

You know I don't think I've ever lived somewhere where my vote actually counted, everywhere I've lived has been a strong safe seat (either Labour or conservative).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Apr 15 12.48pm

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 10.59am

Quote We are goin up! at 01 Apr 2015 9.41am

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 8.39am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)


There are lots of crucial difference between what happened in Greece and the situation it found itself in and the upcoming UK election, one of which have outlined.

Conservatives v Marxists.

The Greeks had stark and completely divergent choices - we do not. We have two centrist parties who hardly have a fag papers worth of difference between them.

Completely going off topic but its arguable that there is such a thing as 'democracy' but that's for another day

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 8.41am)


But in essence democracy has worked... I'd say that most people's views in this country are quite centrist. I know I believe in low taxes if possible and essential, but not overblown, public services, and that's pretty much how most of the people I know would see it.

Do you hear many people calling for a return to a left-wing Labour being hamstrung by trade unions? Or for another Thatcherite Conservative party? Not many. Which means that, whilst we may moan about the lack of choice, can you blame the big parties for not veering off to the right/left when it will lose them votes? That's democracy actually at work.[/quote]


Well yes and no. 'Democracy' in principle and practice is entirely subjective and far too complex to throw out as an all encompassing statement, especially in the modern age.


You can argue that Robert Mugabe operates a democracy (or doesn't in equal measure) in the same way you can argue that the UK is or isn't.

If you take one of its many definitions of 'government by the people for the people' - it certainly isn't that and I would argue that it isn't in the UK.

Larry Diamonds definitions which I kind of agree with (and I had to Google cos I couldn't remember them)is

1 A political system for choosing and replacing the government through free and fair elections.

2 The active participation of the people, as citizens, in politics and civic life.

3 Protection of the human rights of all citizens.

4 A rule of law, in which the laws and procedures apply equally to all citizens

You could argue no country (or very few) afford that to all of its citizens - anyhoo like I said the nature and definition of true democracy is a whole new thread...and I would argue no country is fully democratic - there are just degrees of democracy to a point

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 10.59am)

Democracy is a good idea, that largely is then co-opted and designed to perpetuate a status quo of the privillaged class groups (ie the wealthy and the middle classes), typically white middle class men (who are massively represented in parliment compared to their demographic).

Typically its introduced as a means of 'acceptable degrees of change', ie those which preserve the power balance of the country.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 01 Apr 15 1.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Apr 2015 12.48pm

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 10.59am

Quote We are goin up! at 01 Apr 2015 9.41am

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 8.39am

Quote We are goin up! at 31 Mar 2015 11.14pm

Quote EricYoung'sSweatBand at 31 Mar 2015 1.40pm

Do people really think that all those Scottish people voting SNP will achieve nothing?

At the very worst, Labour will lose the election so will have to try and win those voters back and at the very best they will be in Government with Labour and will have a real say in their destinity.

To say a vote means nothing is idiotic.


This. Obviously. To say democracy changes nothing is moronic, look what's happened in Greece, a swing from centre right conservatives to 'f*ck-ze-Germans' Marxists, and blow me they may actually not be completely bent over and f*cked up the arse any more. I'm a conservative by nature and even I'd have voted for the Marxist if I was Greek. The X you put in the box is your decision about how you wish the country to be run. How can that not matter?!

Edited by We are goin up! (31 Mar 2015 11.16pm)


There are lots of crucial difference between what happened in Greece and the situation it found itself in and the upcoming UK election, one of which have outlined.

Conservatives v Marxists.

The Greeks had stark and completely divergent choices - we do not. We have two centrist parties who hardly have a fag papers worth of difference between them.

Completely going off topic but its arguable that there is such a thing as 'democracy' but that's for another day

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 8.41am)


But in essence democracy has worked... I'd say that most people's views in this country are quite centrist. I know I believe in low taxes if possible and essential, but not overblown, public services, and that's pretty much how most of the people I know would see it.

Do you hear many people calling for a return to a left-wing Labour being hamstrung by trade unions? Or for another Thatcherite Conservative party? Not many. Which means that, whilst we may moan about the lack of choice, can you blame the big parties for not veering off to the right/left when it will lose them votes? That's democracy actually at work.[/quote]


Well yes and no. 'Democracy' in principle and practice is entirely subjective and far too complex to throw out as an all encompassing statement, especially in the modern age.


You can argue that Robert Mugabe operates a democracy (or doesn't in equal measure) in the same way you can argue that the UK is or isn't.

If you take one of its many definitions of 'government by the people for the people' - it certainly isn't that and I would argue that it isn't in the UK.

Larry Diamonds definitions which I kind of agree with (and I had to Google cos I couldn't remember them)is

1 A political system for choosing and replacing the government through free and fair elections.

2 The active participation of the people, as citizens, in politics and civic life.

3 Protection of the human rights of all citizens.

4 A rule of law, in which the laws and procedures apply equally to all citizens

You could argue no country (or very few) afford that to all of its citizens - anyhoo like I said the nature and definition of true democracy is a whole new thread...and I would argue no country is fully democratic - there are just degrees of democracy to a point

Edited by The Sash (01 Apr 2015 10.59am)

Democracy is a good idea, that largely is then co-opted and designed to perpetuate a status quo of the privillaged class groups (ie the wealthy and the middle classes), typically white middle class men (who are massively represented in parliment compared to their demographic).

Typically its introduced as a means of 'acceptable degrees of change', ie those which preserve the power balance of the country.


No argument from me other than a slight deviation - we are typically (perhaps more so these days) represented by a career political 'class' who may be a white male majority but have little in common or shared experience with the majority of other white men....a lot gets made of that, when you might as well say Diane *spit* Abbott is wholly representative of the experience and outlook of black women.

'Democracy' in whatever definition you care to choose, like most political systems is a wonderful idea in theory - being left in the hands of human beings to nurture it is where it tends to f*ck up


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Apr 15 3.39pm

Quote The Sash at 01 Apr 2015 1.20pm

No argument from me other than a slight deviation - we are typically (perhaps more so these days) represented by a career political 'class' who may be a white male majority but have little in common or shared experience with the majority of other white men....a lot gets made of that, when you might as well say Diane *spit* Abbott is wholly representative of the experience and outlook of black women.

'Democracy' in whatever definition you care to choose, like most political systems is a wonderful idea in theory - being left in the hands of human beings to nurture it is where it tends to f*ck up

Problem with the likes of Dianne Abbot is a tendency to forget the suffix of White Middle Class (and upper class) male.

The experience of the ethnic middle classes, all ethnic working classes (regardless of gender) is that they're equally unrepresented (although arguably one can make a case that among the middle classes ethnicity is less of a division than for the working classes - Discrimination among the elite usually has more to do with professed values, lower classes and lifestyles.

And by middle class I mean the real middle class, not those upper working class fools who've deluded themselves.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

imbored Flag UK 01 Apr 15 3.40pm

On his last Clegg: Lib Dem leader to lose seat
[Link]

 

Page 11 of 11 << First< 7 8 9 10 11

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Who has the numbers needed to govern?