This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 23 Mar 2015 5.20pm
Quote serial thriller at 23 Mar 2015 12.33am
My overrall point though was we in this country treat asylum seekers woefully, and there really is no need to. I thought your overall point was that half of people in "poverty" are in work? You didn't actually respond to what I put to you. You said, "my ideology isn't focused on the very top exclusively" but that wasn't what I said. I said I think you are obsessed with equality as an ideal and that you would, given the chance, impose equality on everyone even if it meant that people in aggregate were worse off. "But those progressions [in the 'Third World'] show that with modern capabilities, legitimate redistribution could far more realistically happen on a global scale, leaving 80, maybe 90% of the global population better off (including people in Britain!). So a few bankers or whatever have to compromise their own living standards, based on the exploitation of labour which reinforces the refinement of wealth, I can live with that." I disagree strongly that the "progressions" in the developing world are an argument for "legitimate redistribution". On the contrary, they are an argument for enterprise, entreprenuerialism and the market. Ask your average Chinese or Nigerian what he'd rather: hand-wringing handouts from well-intentioned Westerners with a guilty conscience or a level playing field to try and make the most of himself? Your comments about "a few bankers or whatever" reveals either your prejudice or your naivete, I'm not sure which. Edited by Johnny Eagles (23 Mar 2015 5.22pm)
So not only are we in a position to provide people with the basic necessities, we could very easily allow people to live very comfortable lives the world over. yet what we see is a total inversion of that, where successive financial crises of Capitalism have refined global wealth in to fewer and fewer hands. Post-2007 we have seen global wealth concentration increase, where 1% of the world's population control 48% of its wealth. You may roll your eyes at yet another leftist cliché, but that is a staggering increase given that we were hours from ATMs not giving out money ( [Link] ) due to corruption and insecurity in two of the most profitable elements of our economy: housing and finance. The point in red also seems to suggest you view me as some sort of charitable egalitarian. I'm not. I think equality stems from the means of producing wealth being democratised and representative of its workers, thus securing that their vested interests are protected. If you look at what's happening in Nigeria and China, two of the fastest growing economies in the world, the exact opposite is happening, where multi-national companies are exploiting a cheap labour source with incredibly low levels of unionisation or political representation, thus leading to frighteningly low wages, low job security, practically no personal safety and ludicrous hours. I imagine if you asked the average worker in an Apple factory in China, or some oil company in Nigeria, whether they felt that they were in the optimum position to 'make the most of himself' they would laugh in your face! Given that we're going for the aggressive approach to posting Johnny, I put it to you that your idealisation of the Free Market neglects to fully appreciate the tremendous human and natural destruction its proponents have caused - particularly in the Third World. Edited by serial thriller (23 Mar 2015 7.08pm)
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
| Hoof Hearted 24 Mar 15 3.41pm | |
|---|---|
|
I hate it when 2 posters have a bore-off.
Ruins the thread for good. Lock it Mods.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.