You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Union bashing
November 22 2026 1.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Union bashing


Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6
derben Flag 21 May 15 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.24pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.09pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.03pm

Quote gambler at 21 May 2015 4.36pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 4.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 4.15pm

Am I right in thinking that those against unions are happy for workers not to have any say in how they are treated? Or recourse of action if they are treated unfairly?

I think the unions lost their way a while ago. More interested in issuing credit cards and supporting the 'rights' of various self-important minority interests.

Jack Jones - there was a proper union man.


My union most definitely hasn't lost its way lol. But i suppose it depends on what you mean by "lost their way"? If it means getting big pay rises, a reduction in the working week, and a four day week, then i suppose you're right!!!

I think they have 'lost their way' like the Labour party has. They no longer fully represent and work in the interests of ordinary British working people.


Edited by derben (21 May 2015 5.03pm)

Go on...

Why do you think union membership has halved since 1980.

Why do you think the gap between the highest and lowest paid increases when there is lower union membership?

Dodge the question then. Workers increasingly do not want to join unions.

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 21 May 15 5.29pm

I was unhappy in my last job.

I asked for a payrise.

I was offered an unsatisfactory one.

I went onto the job market.

One month later I got a 50% payrise elsewhere.

I didn't need anyone else, I didn't interfere with anyone else and I just got on with it rather than make a song and dance.

If you know what you're worth go and get it, don't bleat on about it and say how unfair everything is. If you can't get what you think you're worth then you need to work harder or improve your skill set it's that simple.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 May 15 5.33pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.24pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.09pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.03pm

Quote gambler at 21 May 2015 4.36pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 4.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 4.15pm

Am I right in thinking that those against unions are happy for workers not to have any say in how they are treated? Or recourse of action if they are treated unfairly?

I think the unions lost their way a while ago. More interested in issuing credit cards and supporting the 'rights' of various self-important minority interests.

Jack Jones - there was a proper union man.


My union most definitely hasn't lost its way lol. But i suppose it depends on what you mean by "lost their way"? If it means getting big pay rises, a reduction in the working week, and a four day week, then i suppose you're right!!!

I think they have 'lost their way' like the Labour party has. They no longer fully represent and work in the interests of ordinary British working people.


Edited by derben (21 May 2015 5.03pm)

Go on...

Why do you think union membership has halved since 1980.

Why do you think the gap between the highest and lowest paid increases when there is lower union membership?

Dodge the question then. Workers increasingly do not want to join unions.

There are a few reasons I can think of off the top of my head.

Political change. Since early 1980s, the government have introduced legislation making trade unions weaker (e.g. ending closed shops, banning secondary picketing)

De-industrialisation. Industries which were once the bedrock of the union movement have seen rapid falls in employment. For instance the coal industry only employs around 10000 people, it used to be hundreds of thousands.

More flexible labour markets. The new industries and sectors which have replaced heavy industry have not lent themselves to trade unions as well.

No history of unions in new industries. Industries like construction and info and communication have less tradition of trade unions, so it’s difficult to get a strong movement started.

Increased competitiveness of globalisation encouraged firms to adopt a stronger anti-union stance to try and increase competitiveness.

Higher long-term unemployment in UK since 1980s, means workers have less power and influence

Workers increasingly work in workplaces where organised unions are not allowed.

The media don't portray unions that well, for instance are labelled as 'holding the country to ransom' rather than defined as 'defending workers' rights'


Happy?

Now...Why do you think the gap between the highest and lowest paid increases when there is lower union membership?

Edited by nickgusset (21 May 2015 5.35pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 May 15 5.37pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 May 2015 5.29pm

I was unhappy in my last job.

I asked for a payrise.

I was offered an unsatisfactory one.

I went onto the job market.

One month later I got a 50% payrise elsewhere.

I didn't need anyone else, I didn't interfere with anyone else and I just got on with it rather than make a song and dance.

If you know what you're worth go and get it, don't bleat on about it and say how unfair everything is. If you can't get what you think you're worth then you need to work harder or improve your skill set it's that simple.

It's not that simple though is it?
Perhaps you live in that golden era when you could quit your job on a Wednesday and have found a new job within a couple of days.

 

derben Flag 21 May 15 5.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.33pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.24pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.09pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.03pm

Quote gambler at 21 May 2015 4.36pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 4.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 4.15pm

Am I right in thinking that those against unions are happy for workers not to have any say in how they are treated? Or recourse of action if they are treated unfairly?

I think the unions lost their way a while ago. More interested in issuing credit cards and supporting the 'rights' of various self-important minority interests.

Jack Jones - there was a proper union man.


My union most definitely hasn't lost its way lol. But i suppose it depends on what you mean by "lost their way"? If it means getting big pay rises, a reduction in the working week, and a four day week, then i suppose you're right!!!

I think they have 'lost their way' like the Labour party has. They no longer fully represent and work in the interests of ordinary British working people.


Edited by derben (21 May 2015 5.03pm)

Go on...

Why do you think union membership has halved since 1980.

Why do you think the gap between the highest and lowest paid increases when there is lower union membership?

Dodge the question then. Workers increasingly do not want to join unions.

There are a few reasons I can think of off the top of my head.

Political change. Since early 1980s, the government have introduced legislation making trade unions weaker (e.g. ending closed shops, banning secondary picketing)

De-industrialisation. Industries which were once the bedrock of the union movement have seen rapid falls in employment. For instance the coal industry only employs around 10000 people, it used to be hundreds of thousands.

More flexible labour markets. The new industries and sectors which have replaced heavy industry have not lent themselves to trade unions as well.

No history of unions in new industries. Industries like construction and info and communication have less tradition of trade unions, so it’s difficult to get a strong movement started.

Increased competitiveness of globalisation encouraged firms to adopt a stronger anti-union stance to try and increase competitiveness.

Higher long-term unemployment in UK since 1980s, means workers have less power and influence

Workers increasingly work in workplaces where organised unions are not allowed.


Happy?

Now...Why do you think the gap between the highest and lowest paid increases when there is lower union membership?

You forgot to add, supporting immigration that takes British workers' jobs and lowers wages.
Being more concerned with gay and other minorities rights than those of the majority of their members.
Failing to support women sacked for wearing a crucifix.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 May 15 5.41pm

As contrary as it will sound I dislike unions and believe that they are largely archaic and full self interested people. However as with most things, there does need to be a counter balance so they are almost a necessary evil.

Most seem less relevant than ever now and if they want to succeed probably need to reinvent themselves.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 May 15 6.11pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.41pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.33pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.24pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.18pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.09pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 5.03pm

Quote gambler at 21 May 2015 4.36pm

Quote derben at 21 May 2015 4.27pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 4.15pm

Am I right in thinking that those against unions are happy for workers not to have any say in how they are treated? Or recourse of action if they are treated unfairly?

I think the unions lost their way a while ago. More interested in issuing credit cards and supporting the 'rights' of various self-important minority interests.

Jack Jones - there was a proper union man.


My union most definitely hasn't lost its way lol. But i suppose it depends on what you mean by "lost their way"? If it means getting big pay rises, a reduction in the working week, and a four day week, then i suppose you're right!!!

I think they have 'lost their way' like the Labour party has. They no longer fully represent and work in the interests of ordinary British working people.


Edited by derben (21 May 2015 5.03pm)

Go on...

Why do you think union membership has halved since 1980.

Why do you think the gap between the highest and lowest paid increases when there is lower union membership?

Dodge the question then. Workers increasingly do not want to join unions.

There are a few reasons I can think of off the top of my head.

Political change. Since early 1980s, the government have introduced legislation making trade unions weaker (e.g. ending closed shops, banning secondary picketing)

De-industrialisation. Industries which were once the bedrock of the union movement have seen rapid falls in employment. For instance the coal industry only employs around 10000 people, it used to be hundreds of thousands.

More flexible labour markets. The new industries and sectors which have replaced heavy industry have not lent themselves to trade unions as well.

No history of unions in new industries. Industries like construction and info and communication have less tradition of trade unions, so it’s difficult to get a strong movement started.

Increased competitiveness of globalisation encouraged firms to adopt a stronger anti-union stance to try and increase competitiveness.

Higher long-term unemployment in UK since 1980s, means workers have less power and influence

Workers increasingly work in workplaces where organised unions are not allowed.


Happy?

Now...Why do you think the gap between the highest and lowest paid increases when there is lower union membership?

You forgot to add, supporting immigration that takes British workers' jobs and lowers wages.
Being more concerned with gay and other minorities rights than those of the majority of their members.
Failing to support women sacked for wearing a crucifix.


And you forgot to answer my question.

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 21 May 15 10.31pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 May 2015 5.37pm

Quote Pawson Palace at 21 May 2015 5.29pm

I was unhappy in my last job.

I asked for a payrise.

I was offered an unsatisfactory one.

I went onto the job market.

One month later I got a 50% payrise elsewhere.

I didn't need anyone else, I didn't interfere with anyone else and I just got on with it rather than make a song and dance.

If you know what you're worth go and get it, don't bleat on about it and say how unfair everything is. If you can't get what you think you're worth then you need to work harder or improve your skill set it's that simple.

It's not that simple though is it?
Perhaps you live in that golden era when you could quit your job on a Wednesday and have found a new job within a couple of days.

This was a month ago- so i'll let you decide if its golden or not.

My point is the people who complain the most in my experience are always the last ones to leave.

If the rail workers really believe they are hard done by they'd be off in a shot. It's just illogical to keep fighting all the time surely you'd think I dont need this and move on to something better. Enough people do it and then the rail companies or whoever would have to fix up.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Stuk Flag Top half 22 May 15 4.10pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 May 2015 2.58pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 15 May 2015 2.04pm

It's also to ensure strikes are no longer called for frivolous reasons like protecting a train driver who was pissed while driving a train

I'm sure that's exactly what the Conservatives agenda in going after the Unions is, making sure they don't do things like that.

Also the strike was over the use of only a breathaliser to determine whether someone was drunk, without corroborating evidence (urine sample or blood test). Breathalisers can produce false positive results in certain situations - Which is why the police don't rely entirely on just a breath test .(they take a secondary sample to corroborate evidence in accordance with legal advice.

And I agree, before dismissing someone for an offence its best to be certain. I'd probably fail a drug test as my medication will give a false positive result in many tests for MDMA as it is a serotonin Specific Reuptake Inhibitor.

I'd object to being fired without a reliable second measure to eliminate a false positive.

But don't let the facts get in the way.



Not anymore.

A DfT spokesman said: "We have strengthened enforcement by removing the automatic right for drivers who fail a breathalyser test to demand a blood or urine test. This has denied people the chance to sober up while waiting for the test to be taken.

Edited by Stuk (22 May 2015 4.11pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 22 May 15 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Which will thankfully get far tougher........

 


Bring back Brolin

TUX Flag redhill 22 May 15 9.06pm

Quote dynamicdick at 22 May 2015 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Which will thankfully get far tougher........

Someone wants to change the world because his train didn't turn up?
What will you do when they come for you?


 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 22 May 15 9.13pm

Quote TUX at 22 May 2015 9.06pm

Quote dynamicdick at 22 May 2015 8.53pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 6.01pm

Quote derben at 14 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 May 2015 5.31pm

Make it impossible to strike, then hit people with cuts to work rights.

Cunds

Impossible? Why impossible?

50% of those eligible to vote must vote, and 40% of those eligible to vote must vote for the strike.
So if the workforce numbered a 100, 50 of them must vote and 40 of those must vote to strike. So you could still have your strike although 60% do not want it or have no opinion.

Hardly communist-block suppression of union rights is it.

Not Communist block suppression. No. But still suppression. We already have among the harshest anti union laws in the western world as it is.


Edited by nickgusset (14 May 2015 6.03pm)

Which will thankfully get far tougher........

Someone wants to change the world because his train didn't turn up?
What will you do when they come for you?


Don't travel by train and please explain your second line?

 


Bring back Brolin

johnfirewall Flag 26 May 15 8.37pm

Removing free travel from TfL staff's relatives could lead to industrial action apparently, but what doesn't?

[Link]

 

Page 6 of 6 << First< 2 3 4 5 6

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Union bashing