You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough
November 22 2026 1.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough


Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12
legaleagle Flag 05 Jul 15 11.42am

Quote TheJudge at 05 Jul 2015 11.03am

You are an intelligent fellow and within your rather wordy posts I get the thrust of your thinking, but really old chap surely you can see that your impression of humanity might bot really apply to all.
Do you really think that the likes of ISIL care a jot for anyone else ? The are conditioned and desensitised to humanity. They are completely ruthless soldiers of a totally alien philosophy and their only objective is destruction. We did not create them. We have to stop blaming ourselves for all the worlds ills, stop second guessing ourselves and recognise that the World as a whole will breath a sigh of relief when these people are erased. Applying your left wing ideals to this situation will only prolong the pain.
Do you think Hitler would have come around if we had tried to win him over ? He was a pussycat compared to ISIL. You might even say he was one of us. Diplomacy fails when it falls on deaf ears.

You I think miss my main point through a "tunnel-visioned" pre-programmed "left/right" response to what I'm actually saying.As I've posted previously twice,"hearts and minds" is primarily about "those not actively engaged but who might become sympathetic or already are to some degree but not engaging in violence".Its not primarily about those already actively engaged in violence.

That's why "hearts and minds" is an element of counter-insurgency alongside other means,not as seemingly simplistically posited by you an alternative.

Also,I've already pointed out, I'm not primarily writing just about ISIS in Syria/Iraq.I'm focused more on the generality of "violent salafist jihadist insurgency",both inside and outside Europe.

You use the example of Hitler.That wasn't counter-insurgency.That was more the old-fashioned "traditional" model of conflict between nation states.Even then,our Government put a fair bit of resources,for example through BBC overseas broadcasting, into "hearts and minds";Vichy France being a good example.Counter-insurgency (which IMO the current situation is far more akin to) is a different ball game.

In passing, I see you suggest perhaps dear old Adolf was perhaps "one of us". He might have been "one of you"; He sure wasn't "one of me".Quite how the systematic industrialised extermination of 6 million (separate to the millions of "war" casualties and brutality of occupation) made him a "pussycat" compared to ISIS beggars belief.

You seem to suggest somehow that "hearts and minds" is appeasement as opposed to "taking it on". You couldn't be more wrong."Hearts and minds" is a core part of "taking on" an insurgency.To successfully "erase" the spread and attraction to impressionable minds of this pernicious ideology, and the violence wreaked by highly skilled proponents of it, requires a multi-faceted approach a bit more sophisticated than merely "lets blast the hell out of those we can".Afghanistan and Vietnam perhaps illustrating this proposition.

If you come at things through narrow terms of reference,it will likely IMO only (to utilise your phrase) prolong the "pain".


Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 12.13pm)

 

TheJudge Flag 05 Jul 15 1.08pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Jul 2015 11.42am

Quote TheJudge at 05 Jul 2015 11.03am

You are an intelligent fellow and within your rather wordy posts I get the thrust of your thinking, but really old chap surely you can see that your impression of humanity might bot really apply to all.
Do you really think that the likes of ISIL care a jot for anyone else ? The are conditioned and desensitised to humanity. They are completely ruthless soldiers of a totally alien philosophy and their only objective is destruction. We did not create them. We have to stop blaming ourselves for all the worlds ills, stop second guessing ourselves and recognise that the World as a whole will breath a sigh of relief when these people are erased. Applying your left wing ideals to this situation will only prolong the pain.
Do you think Hitler would have come around if we had tried to win him over ? He was a pussycat compared to ISIL. You might even say he was one of us. Diplomacy fails when it falls on deaf ears.

You I think miss my main point through a "tunnel-visioned" pre-programmed "left/right" response to what I'm actually saying.As I've posted previously twice,"hearts and minds" is primarily about "those not actively engaged but who might become sympathetic or already are to some degree but not engaging in violence".Its not primarily about those already actively engaged in violence.

That's why "hearts and minds" is an element of counter-insurgency alongside other means,not as seemingly simplistically posited by you an alternative.

Also,I've already pointed out, I'm not primarily writing about ISIS in Syria/Iraq.I'm focused more on the generality of "violent salafist jihadist insurgency",both inside and outside Europe.

You use the example of Hitler.That wasn't counter-insurgency.That was more the old-fashioned "traditional" model of conflict between nation states.Even then,our Government put a fair bit of resources,for example through BBC overseas broadcasting, into "hearts and minds";Vichy France being a good example.Counter-insurgency (which IMO the current situation is far more akin to) is a different ball game.

In passing, I see you suggest perhaps dear old Adolf was more "one of us". He might have been "one of you"; He sure wasn't "one of me".Quite how the systematic industrialised extermination of 6 million (separate to the millions of "war" casualties and brutality of occupation) made him a "pussycat" compared to ISIS beggars belief.

You seem to suggest somehow that "hearts and minds" is appeasement as opposed to "taking it on". You couldn't be more wrong."Hearts and minds" is a core part of "taking on" an insurgency.To successfully "erase" the spread of this pernicious ideology and the violence wreaked by highly skilled proponents of it requires a multi-faceted approach a bit more sophisticated than merely "lets blast the hell out of those we can".Afghanistan and Vietnam perhaps illustrating this proposition.

If you come at things through narrow terms of reference,it will likely IMO only (to utilise your phrase) prolong the "pain".


Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 12.05pm)


I understand that you are speaking about the wider net of potential influence from extremism and how to combat it and I certainly am not suggesting that killing 6 million people is somehow relatively alright.
What I am saying is that you cannot kill an idea and winning hearts and minds might take a generation if it is possible at all,which I doubt. However, you can kill murderous savages hell bent on destruction much more quickly.
You might suggest that my attitude is tunnel vision politics but the complexities of the the world are not lost on me. I just won't spend an hour writing some nuanced and all encompassing post. Life is too short.
You presume that somehow we can do what others have failed to do for generations. In short. Some people you just can't reach. I mention Hitler, impling fascism, because the Nazis were European like ourselves and whether you like it or not had far more in common with Britain and all the other allies than so called Islamic Extremists will ever have. The traditional nature of that war is not relevant to my point. The fascist ideal was an idea which was not limited to nations. Nazi Germany was just the driving force and the sharp end much like Isil is for apparent Islamic extremism. The actual ambition of Nazi Germany was ultimately far less ideological and I expect the same can be said for these merceneries.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 15 1.45pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Jul 2015 11.03am

Its been made even more important by the internet..


No it hasn't old son.

Previous success stories related to 'hearts and minds' requires outputting.....essentially positive spins on a situation....Mild brainwashing if you will.

It cannot be achieved with a ideological competitor. It becomes a waste of money when compared to say family culture.

The Internet is a communication channel that can't be turned off.

'Hearts and Minds' anti radical programmes now are a waste of money....But then again the left are good at wasting other people's money on ventures they massively overstate the effectiveness of......Especially if its hard to measure.

Also internally this country has tried 'hearts and minds' programmes in the Islamic community......Fat load of good its been......There is already a mainstream Islamic base in this country against radicalisation.....It's a waste of time and money and also slightly insulting to the many in Islam who battle with these idiots all the time.

Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Jul 2015 1.56pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 05 Jul 15 2.56pm

I fear unfortunately you still completely miss the point,old son.

Simplistic and irrelevant digs at "the left" in the context of the counter insurgency "hearts and minds" I have been writing about reinforce this feeling.

"Hearts and minds" is precisely what is an important element with an "ideological competitor",which is exactly why,as one example, The "Soviet bloc" and "the West" both put so many billions into it between say 1947-1990,both in terms of insurgencies/counter-insurgencies and generally. The internet age of course presents new challenges since you can'y simply "jam" the radio signal.But new challenges do not mean the essence of "the game" does not remain unchanged.It requires IMO rather a greater degree of sophistication,rather than simplistic (however superficially attractive) knee-jerkism.

Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 3.08pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jul 15 3.14pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Jul 2015 2.56pm

I fear unfortunately you still completely miss the point,old son.

Simplistic and irrelevant digs at "the left" in the context of the counter insurgency "hearts and minds" I have been writing about reinforce this feeling.

"Hearts and minds" is precisely what is an important element with an "ideological competitor",which is exactly why,as one example, The "Soviet bloc" and "the West" both put so many billions into it between say 1947-1990,both in terms of insurgencies/counter-insurgencies and generally.


Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 3.01pm)

I'm afraid it's you who are missing the point.

Those billions were put in before the Internet age.

The effectiveness of that work is highly questionable ....The Soviets were kicked out of everywhere they went.

'Hearts and Minds' has been under operation for over a decade in many programmes...Government are obsessed with it.....It doesn't work...It never really has...It's a fig leaf to the chattering classes to show them something is being down.......In reality it's a bit insulting to the majority of Muslims anyway.....They don't need to be told this.

Lets repeat the point again.....You can't brainwash people when you don't have a monopoly on the information getting to them'.....Do I have to state it again?

People make up their minds to do something based upon many different factors. There isn't a magic bullet....There are already massive disincentives within this society acting against a person becoming radicalised.

You just don't get it.....But of course....You'd always support throwing good money after bad.


Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Jul 2015 3.17pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 05 Jul 15 8.51pm

And you are still carrying on down a completely different road to my overarching points, using your pre-set one dimensional GPS which took you off on a completely different route at the outset

Time to jump off now for me. We're going round in circles and that's a time to reset the GPS for a different journey...

 

TheJudge Flag 05 Jul 15 10.15pm

Looks like you haven't won many hearts and minds on this topic Legal.

 

legaleagle Flag 05 Jul 15 11.45pm

I might take failing to persuade you and Stirling et al as a given of the territory

Winning hearts and minds is all about winning over the the not yet (or not yet fully)ideologically committed Judge,You and Stirling fall firmly into the ideological zealot camp in that regard in this area,so its a bit like trying to persuade an inuit to install a swimming pool for those long hot summer days!

Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 11.57pm)

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 06 Jul 15 8.21am

I guess the government is trying to win hearts and minds (or at least confuse them) by pretending that the terrorism has nothing to do with Islam by changing the name of Islamic State to 'Daesh'!

[Link]

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Jul 15 10.08am

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 4.56am
Jamie, it sounds like you are about to launch into Sting's 'Russians'.

Also Jamie, all the egalitarians on their side will think like you won't they.....They won't have a side because they view themselves as above such petty human conflict.

The second world war left families with massive losses, as a population time heals....The hatred aspect is there but over-stated. The jobs and opportunities aspect isn't.

Opposition is the nature state of the human condition. Only those use to relative wealth could think otherwise. They have never had to fight to protect their possessions and consider them a right....Quite amusing really considering most of human history.

Opposition is the natural state, the best humanity can look to is the fair trading and production of resources between states and the maintenance of alliances and defense.


Its how capitalism always wins over it opposition, not militarily, not philosophically, but economically. Obviously, you'll always have some people who are ideologically driven and you'll never stop them, but if you look at the core support basis of fundermentalism, its almost always drawn from the poor, economically deprived areas of the middle east for its core support, and then been funded and led by wealthy middle and upper classes in countries like Saudi Arabia.

Its important to remember that IS pay a lot of its combatants, and about 12-15,000 of them were previously Iraqi Baathists. The media tends to distort the reality on the ground that IS consists entirely of suicidal fanatics, but that's not entirely true (and it wasn't true of the Afghan Mujahadeen or the Taliban). A lot of people are opportunists, IS pays well and has a lot of money, and that draws affiliate factions and movements to them (along with a shared objective).

You'll never put the genie back in the bottle, but most people are drawn into fundermentalism because it constructs an identity of belonging and importance, to people who have nothing and will never have anything.

We probably also have to accept certain disadvantageous change in the middle east (at least for us and the US). We cannot divorce our foreign policy.

In NI, the reality is that the growth of prospects and the decreasing poverty of Catholics increasingly undermined the Provisionals capacity to enact a violent conflict.

People tend towards being more reasonable when they have a participation in the functionality of state and some prospects, for them and their children (not everyone).

Where ever you look at the core support basis of fundermentalism, and extremism in general, its usually the poorest people who make up the numbers and they tend to be exploited by zeolots and opportunists.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 06 Jul 15 10.56am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Jul 2015 10.08am

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 4.56am
Jamie, it sounds like you are about to launch into Sting's 'Russians'.

Also Jamie, all the egalitarians on their side will think like you won't they.....They won't have a side because they view themselves as above such petty human conflict.

The second world war left families with massive losses, as a population time heals....The hatred aspect is there but over-stated. The jobs and opportunities aspect isn't.

Opposition is the nature state of the human condition. Only those use to relative wealth could think otherwise. They have never had to fight to protect their possessions and consider them a right....Quite amusing really considering most of human history.

Opposition is the natural state, the best humanity can look to is the fair trading and production of resources between states and the maintenance of alliances and defense.


Its how capitalism always wins over it opposition, not militarily, not philosophically, but economically. Obviously, you'll always have some people who are ideologically driven and you'll never stop them, but if you look at the core support basis of fundermentalism, its almost always drawn from the poor, economically deprived areas of the middle east for its core support, and then been funded and led by wealthy middle and upper classes in countries like Saudi Arabia.

Its important to remember that IS pay a lot of its combatants, and about 12-15,000 of them were previously Iraqi Baathists. The media tends to distort the reality on the ground that IS consists entirely of suicidal fanatics, but that's not entirely true (and it wasn't true of the Afghan Mujahadeen or the Taliban). A lot of people are opportunists, IS pays well and has a lot of money, and that draws affiliate factions and movements to them (along with a shared objective).

You'll never put the genie back in the bottle, but most people are drawn into fundermentalism because it constructs an identity of belonging and importance, to people who have nothing and will never have anything.

We probably also have to accept certain disadvantageous change in the middle east (at least for us and the US). We cannot divorce our foreign policy.

In NI, the reality is that the growth of prospects and the decreasing poverty of Catholics increasingly undermined the Provisionals capacity to enact a violent conflict.

People tend towards being more reasonable when they have a participation in the functionality of state and some prospects, for them and their children (not everyone).

Where ever you look at the core support basis of fundermentalism, and extremism in general, its usually the poorest people who make up the numbers and they tend to be exploited by zeolots and opportunists.


By your argument, shouldn’t the people who fund IS be happy as Larry and not want to supply arms and munitions (at great cost) to the terrorists.

This ideology that terrorists are skint is laughable, they are well supplied well trained and well motivated and all that comes at a cost, a bloody high one. Find where the money comes from, stop that source enabling the purchase of ammunition, guns, rockets, and bombs, and you stop the terrorist at the end of the weapon.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

TheJudge Flag 06 Jul 15 11.13am

Quote legaleagle at 05 Jul 2015 11.45pm

I might take failing to persuade you and Stirling et al as a given of the territory

Winning hearts and minds is all about winning over the the not yet (or not yet fully)ideologically committed Judge,You and Stirling fall firmly into the ideological zealot camp in that regard in this area,so its a bit like trying to persuade an inuit to install a swimming pool for those long hot summer days!


Edited by legaleagle (05 Jul 2015 11.57pm)

Ha ha. Funny, but I wouldn't consider myself a hardliner on this. The only area where I am immovable is religion. The two subjects are somewhat related of course. I am not interested in bending to religious groups of any kind.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Jul 15 12.08pm

Quote dannyh at 06 Jul 2015 10.56am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 06 Jul 2015 10.08am

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jul 2015 4.56am
Jamie, it sounds like you are about to launch into Sting's 'Russians'.

Also Jamie, all the egalitarians on their side will think like you won't they.....They won't have a side because they view themselves as above such petty human conflict.

The second world war left families with massive losses, as a population time heals....The hatred aspect is there but over-stated. The jobs and opportunities aspect isn't.

Opposition is the nature state of the human condition. Only those use to relative wealth could think otherwise. They have never had to fight to protect their possessions and consider them a right....Quite amusing really considering most of human history.

Opposition is the natural state, the best humanity can look to is the fair trading and production of resources between states and the maintenance of alliances and defense.


Its how capitalism always wins over it opposition, not militarily, not philosophically, but economically. Obviously, you'll always have some people who are ideologically driven and you'll never stop them, but if you look at the core support basis of fundermentalism, its almost always drawn from the poor, economically deprived areas of the middle east for its core support, and then been funded and led by wealthy middle and upper classes in countries like Saudi Arabia.

Its important to remember that IS pay a lot of its combatants, and about 12-15,000 of them were previously Iraqi Baathists. The media tends to distort the reality on the ground that IS consists entirely of suicidal fanatics, but that's not entirely true (and it wasn't true of the Afghan Mujahadeen or the Taliban). A lot of people are opportunists, IS pays well and has a lot of money, and that draws affiliate factions and movements to them (along with a shared objective).

You'll never put the genie back in the bottle, but most people are drawn into fundermentalism because it constructs an identity of belonging and importance, to people who have nothing and will never have anything.

We probably also have to accept certain disadvantageous change in the middle east (at least for us and the US). We cannot divorce our foreign policy.

In NI, the reality is that the growth of prospects and the decreasing poverty of Catholics increasingly undermined the Provisionals capacity to enact a violent conflict.

People tend towards being more reasonable when they have a participation in the functionality of state and some prospects, for them and their children (not everyone).

Where ever you look at the core support basis of fundermentalism, and extremism in general, its usually the poorest people who make up the numbers and they tend to be exploited by zeolots and opportunists.


By your argument, shouldn’t the people who fund IS be happy as Larry and not want to supply arms and munitions (at great cost) to the terrorists.

This ideology that terrorists are skint is laughable, they are well supplied well trained and well motivated and all that comes at a cost, a bloody high one. Find where the money comes from, stop that source enabling the purchase of ammunition, guns, rockets, and bombs, and you stop the terrorist at the end of the weapon.

IS fulfills their objectives and goals, similar to how any number of countries and organisation fund and support groups and factions overseas. Syria used to be a major player in the Middle East political arena and a curious ally of Iran (the new big player), who are have been a long hated enemy of the Saudi's (and of course the Saudi prime supporter the US).

Also it buys good will, in theory, for the Saudi's from groups like IS. Saudi Arabia has big political objectives in the Middle East, which Arab secularism was hampering (Saudi's hated Baathists).

So for a lot of the people with money pouring it into groups like IS more about politics, and keeping Islamic extremists focused outside of Saudi Arabia, than any real belief in the cause. Of course it also plays well with the group itself (Don't bite the hand that feeds you, and it plays well with the poor majority of Saudi Arabia who are prone to fundamentalism). Essentially for many of the big contributors, its 'Dane Gold'.

Of course, you have to eliminate the financial life blood of a group like IS, but unless you address the key issues that feed into the appeal of Islamic Fundamentalism, other groups simply will take their place. Whilst that includes our own foreign policy to some degree, the root causes that excaberate extremism tend to be found in poverty (the same is true of Facism and Communism, both exploit poverty to their own political ends, whilst tending to be led by either zeolots or politically manipulative individuals, outside of the main stream).

Whilst you can't point at a single factor, history generally has demonstrated that 'extreme politics' has always existed, but that it thrives in poverty and oppression.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 12 of 12 << First< 8 9 10 11 12

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough