This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 3.54pm
Quote Cucking Funt at 18 Aug 2015 1.54pm
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 1.22pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 12.56pm
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 10.36am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 9.43am
Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.47am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Aug 2015 10.17am
Quote TheJudge at 15 Aug 2015 10.04am
A very silly article. Firstly, it assumes that everyone is like the person commenting, which they are not. In fact the vast majority don't smoke or want to be anywhere near someone who does. Why do some people want to take the wingeing of an addict seriously ? Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.05am) Isn't a carcinogen.
When it comes to people hooked on addictive substances telling me how they should have the right to pollute the air, I am very intolerant. Smoking has no use other than to facilitate self indulgence. Edited by TheJudge (15 Aug 2015 10.47am) All existence is an exercise in self indulgence but they have the right to pollute the air, provided they are not causing you any harm. They have this right, because as citizens they are entitled to use public space, as all citizens are.
Our rights are balanced against the good of our society. That's what laws are for. Surely you know this. Smoking doesn't harm the 'good of society', in any real meaningful way, and contributes a large amount of revenue. The good of society is protected better by allowing freedom of individuals to make decisions for themselves, than dictating acceptable behavior, especially where consensus of right is divided among the populace. Plus of course, you weren't presenting an argument based on social good and social well being, but on personal distaste and personal opinion.
You state as if a fact that smoking doesn't harm society and then say that my view is just an opinion. News alert. Your assertion is just an opinion as well. The difference is that there is scientific proof that passive smoking is bad for the health. In any case, smoking is not harmless a past time, it is a genuine addiction. It boils down to a group of addicts and their enablers telling us, the majority of non smokers, that we should tolerate their disgusting unhealthy stink because we are mean and small minded not to. Poppycock. Maybe we should allow pubs to open a crack house next to the kiddies play area. That will boost their turnover. Edited by TheJudge (18 Aug 2015 1.23pm)
Sure, smoking can be harmful on a personal level and possibly to those in the immediate vicinity but, then again, so is the amount of air pollution generated by cars, buses, lorries, aircraft etc. and numerous industrial installations. In fact, the effect of second-hand smoke on the environment is negligible by comparison. Your view on this is totalitarian and you don't even seem to realise it.
In case you weren't aware, society is made up of people. Things that affect people affect society. By definition, murder is always unacceptable, as its the unjustifiable homicide on another person and has never been accepted. Presumably you mean killing each other. And yes, in some cases, that is perfectly accepted by society. Its also perfectly legal to kill yourself. Society is indeed made up of people, lots of very different people, all with different needs, desires and ideas, all of whom combine to make up society; including smokers and non-smokers.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 4.32pmI mean that just because something has been going on for ages it does make it desirable or acceptable.
If smoking didn't harm you, we could all smoke our arses off and it wouldn't matter. It does, if there is a significant percentage of the population who are into it, and the health risks are moderated to be 'their own'. Doesn't actually matter that it harms the individual, their choice, their responsibility - sufficient warnings and provision are made by society to assist them if they so desire to stop. But it is pleasurable, the stimulation of nicotine on the ACL receptor sites, nicotine is unusual in that its both a stimulant and a relaxant. It has a very well established psychoactive affect.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 8.51pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 5.09pm
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 4.32pmI mean that just because something has been going on for ages it does make it desirable or acceptable.
If smoking didn't harm you, we could all smoke our arses off and it wouldn't matter. It does, if there is a significant percentage of the population who are into it, and the health risks are moderated to be 'their own'. Doesn't actually matter that it harms the individual, their choice, their responsibility - sufficient warnings and provision are made by society to assist them if they so desire to stop. But it is pleasurable, the stimulation of nicotine on the ACL receptor sites, nicotine is unusual in that its both a stimulant and a relaxant. It has a very well established psychoactive affect.
I think this is where we differ, I see people as individuals capable of agency and responsibility and that its their choice, both to start and to stop. Everything in life has one inevitable outcome, death. If an individual smokes, or doesn't, they still die. If they enjoy smoking, they know the risks and the problems, that's their choice. Certainly I've been a casual smoker, a non-smoker and a proper full on smoker (all at different times). The one defining feature is that I actually like smoking (even nicotine free). Similarly a lot of smokers also aren't addicts in the classic sense, as they experience no real problems in giving up. The cost to the NHS is definitely an issue, but as it costs less over the average individuals lifespan to treat smokers and non-smokers, its an issue because you'd need to establish revenue.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
It's estimated £12 billion tax revenue came from tobacco in 2012-13 (direct and VAT).
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 19 Aug 2015 9.49am
Quote jamiemartin721 at 19 Aug 2015 9.30am
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 8.51pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 18 Aug 2015 5.09pm
Quote TheJudge at 18 Aug 2015 4.32pmI mean that just because something has been going on for ages it does make it desirable or acceptable.
If smoking didn't harm you, we could all smoke our arses off and it wouldn't matter. It does, if there is a significant percentage of the population who are into it, and the health risks are moderated to be 'their own'. Doesn't actually matter that it harms the individual, their choice, their responsibility - sufficient warnings and provision are made by society to assist them if they so desire to stop. But it is pleasurable, the stimulation of nicotine on the ACL receptor sites, nicotine is unusual in that its both a stimulant and a relaxant. It has a very well established psychoactive affect.
I think this is where we differ, I see people as individuals capable of agency and responsibility and that its their choice, both to start and to stop. Everything in life has one inevitable outcome, death. If an individual smokes, or doesn't, they still die. If they enjoy smoking, they know the risks and the problems, that's their choice. Certainly I've been a casual smoker, a non-smoker and a proper full on smoker (all at different times). The one defining feature is that I actually like smoking (even nicotine free). Similarly a lot of smokers also aren't addicts in the classic sense, as they experience no real problems in giving up. The cost to the NHS is definitely an issue, but as it costs less over the average individuals lifespan to treat smokers and non-smokers, its an issue because you'd need to establish revenue.
I was talking about people who had quit, and did so with little or no problem. Happens all the time. I find it pleasurable, and the neurochemical reaction does stimulate a pleasurable effect. Generally people don't get addicted to things they find displeasurable (and quit easily). May not be non-smokers experience, but I liked it from the first one to the last one. There is a difference between smoking because you're on the edge of 'withdrawls' and smoking for pleasure. I suspect its similar to 'maintenance fixing' and getting high with drug addicts. The vape isn't the same, but its an still a joy.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.