This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 17 Nov 2015 8.41pm
Quote nickgusset at 17 Nov 2015 6.41pm
Quote Mr Palaceman at 17 Nov 2015 6.21pm
Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 17 Nov 2015 2.01pm
Quote Mr Palaceman at 17 Nov 2015 1.52pm
Haven't heard his latest comments, haven't seen a lot of UK news. Can someone put up a link? Like other posters have said, I think his lack of experience of the front benches has found him wanting. The Guardian Thanks Y Ddraig Goch.. Having read the article, it doesn't seem to me that he is saying a lot. For me, it's not that complicated. If you have suspected terrorists in a flat and there is "some evidence" that they are plotting an attack. Get any bystanders out of the way and do what you can to arrest them, if you can. If they are alive then you can question them to find out more details of any networks or further plots, that could save lives. If you have some guy in a bar, holding hostages and you get a clear shot, take it as soon as you can and you shoot to kill.
"...any armed action by the police has to be proportionate to the threat” Covers all of the above. However, in addition, there are going to be times when as in the case of the IRA suspects shot in Gibraltar (I think it was), the authorities have to make a decision as to whether, they can justify what they do, when they are held to account. I don't think you need to negotiate in every circumstance. The immediate threat to the public needs to be negated first and everything else is secondary. In regards to the now Jilted John, we have a legal process in this country and if questions need to be asked, ask them.
The killing of Alan Henning in particular, just over a year ago, still upsets me to this day. I regards to what Cameron has said about "shoot to kill" I don't think it makes a lot of difference. He has to say something and the law is still the same. Post Paris, a lot of these stories will be in the papers from now on. Is that the same Cameron who wanted to bomb Syria about a year or so ago (if my memory serves me right) to aid Al quaeeda in Iraq (who became ISIS) to depose the president? Al Qaeda and ISIL are two very different organisations. IF we had bombed Syria who knows what the world would look like now? (Personally I don't think it would be much different but we don't know that) Yesterday when I first heard that Coebyn had said what he did I assumed the press were s*** stirring. Having actually listened to hi, they clearly were not. Shoot to Kill in reality is a non argument for all the reasons I've mentioned before. Should we try and stop a scenario where a police officer or soldier has to make that split second decision? Of course but once that decision has been made then that's it. Shoot to Kill policy in the UK generally means the police would operate without the need to justify reasonable force in relation to an operation or arrest of a subject, essentially it a 'green light to killing suspects'. UK Law is pretty clear that you can use lethal force in the protection of the self and of others, provided its reasonable to do so. Any policy that removes that 'reasonable' to do so aspect is a recipe for disaster. Every civilised country in the world would have allowed their police, armed forces and even citizens to use lethal force when faced with people armed with guns shooting people or reasonable acting like they intend to do so. People seem to forget that the police here have killed people who weren't even armed and done so legally. Al-Qaeda in Iraq and ISIL / IS and ISIS however are the same group (or rather Al-Qaeda in Iraq and the Sunni Insurgency were a fundermental feed into the basis of what would become IS).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 18 Nov 2015 2.14pm
Quote pefwin at 17 Nov 2015 1.48pm
Quote dannyh at 17 Nov 2015 1.34pm
Quote Alexi_the_Eagle at 17 Nov 2015 1.28pm
Labour are going nowhere with calamity Corbyn the clown and his namby pamby pacifist views in charge. He thinks talking to ISIS will solve everything, just like any typical p*ssy would say, The world isn't one big liberal arts college campus. He needs to wake up. Where's Harold Shipman when you need him. That is over the top. So what ? I think he might be a bit young for The Old Dear hunter.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.