You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gov spending review
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gov spending review


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Nov 15 11.29am

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 25 Nov 2015 4.23pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Nov 2015 4.16pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 25 Nov 2015 4.06pm

Glad he has scrapped tax Credits, he was right to identify the problem but the solultion was arse about face.

Haven't seen much other than the headlines, seems to have done quite well.


Is there a problem with tax credits? It's a financial lifeline for low-paid workers (and family) and definitely not a benefit p1ss take.


There is a massive problem in my opinion. Why are the government subsidising companies paying low wages?

Because the state works for corporate interests, not the people who elect the government (Labour did the same). Government has the capacity to control wages at least at the low end of the spectrum but hasn't. It never even linked minimum wage to inflation (unlike benefits which are influenced by inflation).

This incidentally is why many people are worse off working, than being on welfare. Not because they're feckless or workshy, they just can't afford to work.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Nov 15 11.40am

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Nov 2015 5.07pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 25 Nov 2015 4.23pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Nov 2015 4.16pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 25 Nov 2015 4.06pm

Glad he has scrapped tax Credits, he was right to identify the problem but the solultion was arse about face.

Haven't seen much other than the headlines, seems to have done quite well.


Is there a problem with tax credits? It's a financial lifeline for low-paid workers (and family) and definitely not a benefit p1ss take.


There is a massive problem in my opinion. Why are the government subsidising companies paying low wages?


It's a tough one, to be sure. The cost of living, with uncontrolled rents, profit-driven energy companies, high water bills, mad rail fares etc, is pretty high these days and it won't generally be the employers fault for that, so making them pay higher wages, especially small businesses with low profit margins, would just be papering over the economic cracks as would have been taking away the tax credits for so many. Both disastrous.

Companies that cannot afford to actually employee their employees, aren't viable businesses, and are retaining a market share and profitability based on a false premise that they are a viable business (and surviving on state welfare payments).

Companies that operate on low profit margins are doomed

Keeping them in business isn't viable as a long term goal.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Apollofuzz Flag On the edge of reason 26 Nov 15 12.44pm

Quote becky at 25 Nov 2015 11.00pm

One rotten cut sneaked in there - trainee nurses, midwives and OPD's will lose their bursary (£400 per month) and be put on a student loan basis.

Now given that as well as their academic studies (degree course for all disciplines) they have to spend 37.5 hours per week on placement in the hospital, they simply have no time to take on additional paid work to fund themselves through training. Given that the NHS is already constantly bemoaning the lack of properly qualified nurses (and having to run recruitment sessions to bring on overseas staff), how is this going to help the situation?

My Goddaughter has just started her OPD course and has said that she will not be doing year 2 if this comes in - with 3 children she simply cannot afford a student loan - and apparently over half of those on her course have said the same!

Nice one, George!

Well said and spot on, My daughter is applying for a midwifery course for next September and is now having second thought because of this. It is a full time 5 days a week course (Which will involve shift work), you are advised not to take part time work to fund yourself as it is so full on. Please sign the petition below. Thank you.

[Link]


 


I ride a GS scooter with my hair cut neat
I wear my war time coat in the wind and sleet.

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 26 Nov 15 4.12pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Nov 2015 11.40am

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Nov 2015 5.07pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 25 Nov 2015 4.23pm

Quote Kermit8 at 25 Nov 2015 4.16pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 25 Nov 2015 4.06pm

Glad he has scrapped tax Credits, he was right to identify the problem but the solultion was arse about face.

Haven't seen much other than the headlines, seems to have done quite well.


Is there a problem with tax credits? It's a financial lifeline for low-paid workers (and family) and definitely not a benefit p1ss take.


There is a massive problem in my opinion. Why are the government subsidising companies paying low wages?


It's a tough one, to be sure. The cost of living, with uncontrolled rents, profit-driven energy companies, high water bills, mad rail fares etc, is pretty high these days and it won't generally be the employers fault for that, so making them pay higher wages, especially small businesses with low profit margins, would just be papering over the economic cracks as would have been taking away the tax credits for so many. Both disastrous.

Companies that cannot afford to actually employee their employees, aren't viable businesses, and are retaining a market share and profitability based on a false premise that they are a viable business (and surviving on state welfare payments).

Companies that operate on low profit margins are doomed

Keeping them in business isn't viable as a long term goal.


Agree - Also 'subsidies' discourages efficiency.
Many businesses in Germany are successful as they have to be very efficient because of high employee costs.
A few businesses may go to the wall - but many more will not.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 26 Nov 15 4.29pm

George didn't mention this in his statement...

[Link]

Hidden retrospective hike in student loan repayments. There's talk of taking him to court over this!

Martin Lewis, founder of MoneySavingExpert.com and former head of the Independent Taskforce on Student Finance Information, says: "This is a disgraceful move and a breach of trust by the Government that betrays a generation of students. It has chosen to freeze the repayment threshold even though 95% of the consultation responses did not support the freeze – what was the point of a consultation if when there's huge objection it does it anyway?

"It is risking fundamentally threatening any trust people have in the student finance system. It is one thing to set up a system that is unpopular but it is entirely different to make retrospective changes that mean you cannot even rely on what you were promised at the time you started to study. Even though it was warned of the huge dangers of doing this, it’s still blundering ahead, ignoring all right thinking concern.

"The fact that the Chancellor didn't even have the balls to put it in his Autumn Statement speech shows that he knew how unpopular it would be. If a commercial company made retrospective changes to their loan terms in this way they’d be slapped hard by the regulator – the Government shouldn’t be allowed to get away with it either.

I wonder how many other things weren't mentioned.

Edited by nickgusset (26 Nov 2015 4.30pm)

 

Holmesdale Nick Flag South Croydon 26 Nov 15 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?

 


Fitter Fans Group 2. No. 17

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 26 Nov 15 4.44pm

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?


No, they'll be paying extra interest.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 26 Nov 15 4.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Nov 2015 4.44pm

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?


No, they'll be paying extra interest.

No they won't, it's still 9% on any earnings above £21K.

Heaven forbid people should actually repay their loans, or even some of them.

If you leave the country with outstanding student loan debt you should have to pay it in full with the interest added.

 


Optimistic as ever

Holmesdale Nick Flag South Croydon 26 Nov 15 4.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Nov 2015 4.44pm

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?


No, they'll be paying extra interest.


Ah ok, that's not good then.

 


Fitter Fans Group 2. No. 17

Hoof Hearted 27 Nov 15 9.55am

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.58pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Nov 2015 4.44pm

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?


No, they'll be paying extra interest.


Ah ok, that's not good then.


See Stuk's reply to nick above........

 

DanH Flag SW2 27 Nov 15 10.07am

Quote Stuk at 26 Nov 2015 4.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Nov 2015 4.44pm

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?


No, they'll be paying extra interest.

No they won't, it's still 9% on any earnings above £21K.

Heaven forbid people should actually repay their loans, or even some of them.

If you leave the country with outstanding student loan debt you should have to pay it in full with the interest added.


You still have to repay it as if you were living here.

 

Hoof Hearted 27 Nov 15 10.26am

Quote DanH at 27 Nov 2015 10.07am

Quote Stuk at 26 Nov 2015 4.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Nov 2015 4.44pm

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?


No, they'll be paying extra interest.

No they won't, it's still 9% on any earnings above £21K.

Heaven forbid people should actually repay their loans, or even some of them.

If you leave the country with outstanding student loan debt you should have to pay it in full with the interest added.


You still have to repay it as if you were living here.


Is this monitored and audited as effectively as the NHS chase up foreigners for the cost of treatment here when they return home?

WE're pretty lax on recovering fines to foreigner owners of vehicles that break our motoring laws too.

I doubt that we would recover one penny of any loans when the loanee has fled the country!

 

Stuk Flag Top half 27 Nov 15 12.23pm

Quote DanH at 27 Nov 2015 10.07am

Quote Stuk at 26 Nov 2015 4.57pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Nov 2015 4.44pm

Quote Holmesdale Nick at 26 Nov 2015 4.41pm

Isn't that a good thing as it means students will have repaid their loans more quickly?


No, they'll be paying extra interest.

No they won't, it's still 9% on any earnings above £21K.

Heaven forbid people should actually repay their loans, or even some of them.

If you leave the country with outstanding student loan debt you should have to pay it in full with the interest added.


You still have to repay it as if you were living here.


You're supposed to but non-repayment of those who move overseas is a big problem.

[Link]

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 27 Nov 15 12.38pm

14 years on I'm still paying my student loan off.!

 

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gov spending review