Catfish Burgess Hill 18 Dec 15 10.27am |
|
|
[Link]
How can people fall for this stuff - Hitchens called her right.
Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial
|
| Hoof Hearted 18 Dec 15 11.44am |
|
|
Someone in a really expensive fancy dress outfit in Rome bestows a meaningless honour to someone in a less attractive fancy dress outfit.
That's my take on it.
|
Superfly The sun always shines in Catford 18 Dec 15 11.59am |
|
Quote Catfish at 18 Dec 2015 10.27am
[Link]
How can people fall for this stuff - Hitchens called her right.
Can't really blame the public when they're fed guff from the media. It was beneficial to paint her as a saint, so that's what we were told.
Is it right that she publicly voiced doubts on her faith before she croaked? Seem to remember seeing that somewhere. Another snippet that's downplayed.
I've been watching a lot of Hitch's 'greatest hits' on youtube recently. I'm a big fan!
Lend me a Tenor
31 May to 3 June 2017
John McIntosh Arts Centre London Oratory School SW6 1RX
with Superfly in the chorus [Link]
|
Jacey 18 Dec 15 12.58pm |
|
|
My candidate would be Alan Pardew who pulled of a miracle , but then again ,I am biased!!
|
Hrolf The Ganger 18 Dec 15 3.54pm |
|
|
Don't get me started on religion... at Christmas.
|
NickRobinson 19 Dec 15 8.19pm |
|
|
She did a lot of good. She deserves recognition. What harm does it do calling her a saint?
|
Lakeview Lincoln 19 Dec 15 8.40pm |
|
|
The idea of "sainthood" is nowhere to be found in the Bible, which is why Protestants do not go along with this process. The idea of the dead having influence on who gets healed is also something I've never seen in the Bible, and, as the Bible should be the guide book of Christians, I agree with others above that the whole process is a mistake- from both a Christian and agnostic/atheist perspective.
|
pefwin Where you have to have an English ... 19 Dec 15 8.51pm |
|
|
Typical left footers and their backward religion.
"Everything is air-droppable at least once."
"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."
|
Mad4palace 19 Dec 15 9.51pm |
|
Quote NickRobinson at 19 Dec 2015 8.19pm
She did a lot of good. She deserves recognition. What harm does it do calling her a saint?
She pretended to do a lot of good.
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 20 Dec 15 9.34am |
|
Quote Lakeview at 19 Dec 2015 8.40pm
The idea of "sainthood" is nowhere to be found in the Bible, which is why Protestants do not go along with this process. The idea of the dead having influence on who gets healed is also something I've never seen in the Bible, and, as the Bible should be the guide book of Christians, I agree with others above that the whole process is a mistake- from both a Christian and agnostic/atheist perspective.
Saints stem from very early gnostic influences as angels and god, as 'dangerous to behold', as such saints served as a safe conduit between the divine and man. Protestantism never dealt with saints because they believed in a pre-destination of the soul, before birth, at least the founding protestants did.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
jamiemartin721 Reading 20 Dec 15 9.36am |
|
Quote Catfish at 18 Dec 2015 10.27am
[Link]
How can people fall for this stuff - Hitchens called her right.
Who'd have thought it, a nun, being a fanatic and fundamentalist....
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" [Link]
|
NickRobinson 20 Dec 15 11.28am |
|
Quote Mad4palace at 19 Dec 2015 9.51pm
Quote NickRobinson at 19 Dec 2015 8.19pm
She did a lot of good. She deserves recognition. What harm does it do calling her a saint?
She pretended to do a lot of good.
So she 'pretended' to found the Missionaries of Charity, active in 133 countries. They run hospices and homes for people with HIV/AIDS, leprosy and tuberculosis; soup kitchens; dispensaries and mobile clinics; children's and family counselling programmes; orphanages; and schools. All a sham then?
|
EaglesEaglesEagles 20 Dec 15 12.34pm |
|
|
I don't know why people are really bothered if Mother Teresa's going to be made a Saint.
The only people who will care are Catholics because that's the only church (apart from in some cases the Orthodox) who care about canonization. It's an entirely religious title with no secular recognition or significance.
So if people think she was a dreadful person who did more harm to the poor than good, this won't affect that or the reach of the movement promoting this idea (Christopher Hitchens' videos for example). The same goes for people who think she was great.
This thread is just a moaning session which has been activated by Mother Teresa's canonization consideration in the news. The fact that she's going to be made a Saint is secondary. It's fine to have a moan and express opinions. I dislike Christopher Hitchens' rhetoric (sorry Hitch fans). It's fine that I have that opinion.
Point being that her becoming a Saint won't really bring about anything new, she's been a 'blessed' for years after all. For non-Catholics it's just a reminder of the Church's absurd, pseudo-religious and nonsensical practices. Big deal.
I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.
|
| Hoof Hearted 20 Dec 15 12.41pm |
|
Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 20 Dec 2015 12.34pm
I don't know why people are really bothered if Mother Teresa's going to be made a Saint.
The only people who will care are Catholics because that's the only church (apart from in some cases the Orthodox) who care about canonization. It's an entirely religious title with no secular recognition or significance.
So if people think she was a dreadful person who did more harm to the poor than good, this won't affect that or the reach of the movement promoting this idea (Christopher Hitchens' videos for example). The same goes for people who think she was great.
This thread is just a moaning session which has been activated by Mother Teresa's canonization consideration in the news. The fact that she's going to be made a Saint is secondary. It's fine to have a moan and express opinions. I dislike Christopher Hitchens' rhetoric (sorry Hitch fans). It's fine that I have that opinion.
Point being that her becoming a Saint won't really bring about anything new, she's been a 'blessed' for years after all. For non-Catholics it's just a reminder of the Church's absurd, pseudo-religious and nonsensical practices. Big deal.
I refer you to my post - the very first reply to the thread!
|
Mad4palace 20 Dec 15 1.20pm |
|
Quote NickRobinson at 20 Dec 2015 11.28am
Quote Mad4palace at 19 Dec 2015 9.51pm
Quote NickRobinson at 19 Dec 2015 8.19pm
She did a lot of good. She deserves recognition. What harm does it do calling her a saint?
She pretended to do a lot of good.
So she 'pretended' to found the Missionaries of Charity, active in 133 countries. They run hospices and homes for people with HIV/AIDS, leprosy and tuberculosis; soup kitchens; dispensaries and mobile clinics; children's and family counselling programmes; orphanages; and schools. All a sham then?
The motive behind her work was devotional, it wasn't to alleviate suffering it was to wallow in it and perversely see it as a gift. The poor standards of medical care, allegations of misusing of funds and her opposition to concraception sort of gives one the indication that she was more obsessed with working for 'god' and the politics of her religion, rather than the poor or sick.
|
NickRobinson 20 Dec 15 1.41pm |
|
Quote Mad4palace at 20 Dec 2015 1.20pm
Quote NickRobinson at 20 Dec 2015 11.28am
Quote Mad4palace at 19 Dec 2015 9.51pm
Quote NickRobinson at 19 Dec 2015 8.19pm
She did a lot of good. She deserves recognition. What harm does it do calling her a saint?
She pretended to do a lot of good.
So she 'pretended' to found the Missionaries of Charity, active in 133 countries. They run hospices and homes for people with HIV/AIDS, leprosy and tuberculosis; soup kitchens; dispensaries and mobile clinics; children's and family counselling programmes; orphanages; and schools. All a sham then?
The motive behind her work was devotional, it wasn't to alleviate suffering it was to wallow in it and perversely see it as a gift. The poor standards of medical care, allegations of misusing of funds and her opposition to concraception sort of gives one the indication that she was more obsessed with working for 'god' and the politics of her religion, rather than the poor or sick.
So the 'untouchables' in India would have been better off without her then? "Poor standards" - at least she took practical steps to help people whatever her motives. I'm not religious, but recognise people doing good when I see it. A lot of the people that criticise her for helping people, do so because of her religious convictions. If, say Nelson Mandella, had set up similar help-organisations, the same critics would be hailing him as a 'saint', albeit a secular one.
|
Hrolf The Ganger 20 Dec 15 3.19pm |
|
Quote NickRobinson at 20 Dec 2015 1.41pm
Quote Mad4palace at 20 Dec 2015 1.20pm
Quote NickRobinson at 20 Dec 2015 11.28am
Quote Mad4palace at 19 Dec 2015 9.51pm
Quote NickRobinson at 19 Dec 2015 8.19pm
She did a lot of good. She deserves recognition. What harm does it do calling her a saint?
She pretended to do a lot of good.
So she 'pretended' to found the Missionaries of Charity, active in 133 countries. They run hospices and homes for people with HIV/AIDS, leprosy and tuberculosis; soup kitchens; dispensaries and mobile clinics; children's and family counselling programmes; orphanages; and schools. All a sham then?
The motive behind her work was devotional, it wasn't to alleviate suffering it was to wallow in it and perversely see it as a gift. The poor standards of medical care, allegations of misusing of funds and her opposition to concraception sort of gives one the indication that she was more obsessed with working for 'god' and the politics of her religion, rather than the poor or sick.
So the 'untouchables' in India would have been better off without her then? "Poor standards" - at least she took practical steps to help people whatever her motives. I'm not religious, but recognise people doing good when I see it. A lot of the people that criticise her for helping people, do so because of her religious convictions. If, say Nelson Mandella, had set up similar help-organisations, the same critics would be hailing him as a 'saint', albeit a secular one.
Selfless acts are their own reward. They do not require recognition because those seeking it are not really committing selfless acts.
Besides that, all talk of saints is just medieval religious mumbo jumbo, and it is shameful that the Catholic church, or any other, perpetuates such superstitious garbage.
|
EaglesEaglesEagles 20 Dec 15 6.57pm |
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Dec 2015 12.41pm
Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 20 Dec 2015 12.34pm
I don't know why people are really bothered if Mother Teresa's going to be made a Saint.
The only people who will care are Catholics because that's the only church (apart from in some cases the Orthodox) who care about canonization. It's an entirely religious title with no secular recognition or significance.
So if people think she was a dreadful person who did more harm to the poor than good, this won't affect that or the reach of the movement promoting this idea (Christopher Hitchens' videos for example). The same goes for people who think she was great.
This thread is just a moaning session which has been activated by Mother Teresa's canonization consideration in the news. The fact that she's going to be made a Saint is secondary. It's fine to have a moan and express opinions. I dislike Christopher Hitchens' rhetoric (sorry Hitch fans). It's fine that I have that opinion.
Point being that her becoming a Saint won't really bring about anything new, she's been a 'blessed' for years after all. For non-Catholics it's just a reminder of the Church's absurd, pseudo-religious and nonsensical practices. Big deal.
I refer you to my post - the very first reply to the thread!
Fair. I was reiterating what others had ignored for the sake of enjoying their own annoyance. I may have perhaps even enjoyed my own self-righteousness of effectively expanding upon what you said!
I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.
|