This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| Hoof Hearted 16 May 16 10.29am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I think you will agree that I'm not a liberal namby pamby and although I fully understand your point of view, I don't agree with it. Not a problem Hrolf.... I appreciate my views on this are pretty hardcore for some. The suggestion to use them as guinea pigs for experimentation that I concurred with was tongue-in-cheek... at least on my part! Edited by Hoof Hearted (16 May 2016 10.31am)
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by fed up eagle
You could use them for testing life saving drugs or operations but the oh so precious pharmaceutical companies will get all moral about it. That's not how medical trials work. You need as diverse a population study as possible. They serve as an example. People in prison, often have contributed to society. Prisoners contribute quite a lot to society, as they form the basis by which we establish acceptable behaviour and our own social morality. The problem of a death penalty, from a moral and ethical stand point has always been that its retribution, not justice. The second major issue is that it doesn't serve as a deterrent to very serious crimes either, as murders tend to occur in the 'heat of the moment' or tied to very powerful incentives. Next of course, its applied somewhat arbitrarily and disproportionately across socio-economic grounds. As a note, the US spends more in getting to execution than it does on keeping prisoners in prison without parole, because the system of appeals and constitutional requirements to determine the legality of an execution are exhaustive in the extreme. Finally of course, there is a worrying level of questionable convictions, and incidents of people being exonerated. Most disturbing is the way that since re-introducing the death penalty to the US, the systems have become geared towards making executions easier to achieve by restricting the appeals processes and legal responsibilities of bodies involved towards a specific outcome (i.e. executions, over reviews of new evidence). Finally, in the US, there is no fair and impartial legal system.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
I didn't advocate Pfizer not being able to do that did I ? I just rejoiced in the fact that some really nasty serial killers like Bundy and Manson had some of their own "medicine" served up to them rather than a soft death sentence. Not the first time you've put words in my mouth Rumpole! Manson wasn't executed. Bundy was. Manson, in fact was given a death sentence, but it was commuted when California removed the death penalty.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by fed up eagle
Yes but the American government was also using European drugs companies too due to a shortage. They have pulled out of supplying these drugs, this has caused a domino effect amongst other drug companies. T'is well known that the EU are putting on pressure regarding the death penalty in America, why? It's out of their sphere of influence but they still feel they have the right to poke their noses in, outrageous! Edited by fed up eagle (15 May 2016 12.28pm) It wouldn't. It might free up one or two cells in about 10-20 years time. Firstly, because you'd have 10-20 years of appeal and referrals through the court system before you could establish that the death penalty was fairly and arbitrarily applied in the case. Not to mention the legal issues revolving around comparisons to other sentences in other cases, rights appeals, appeals on evidence and procedure etc. The amount of hassle its proven in the states is staggering (it costs more to execute someone than it does to keep them in prison for the rest of their life). Of course if you mean arbitrarily just killing people convicted of certain crimes, then yes, it would free up prison spaces, but that will never happen and is a total fantasy. And, yes, its the right decision not to supply the US with drugs utilised in executions, as these are medical drugs, produced from medical research - As such it betrays the Hippocratic oath of those doctors involved in research to allow their work to be used to cause harm.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by glory
Clearly even US drug companies are uncomfortable with their drugs being used for lethal injections so, if what you say is true, it's not all that unusual that others would feel the same way. The US don't give two s***s about what the EU thinks about the death penalty there. It just so happens that it's something that's very polarising within US society, so what has happened with Pfizer isn't surprising. I know, and it puts them in such good company as a result. Problem the US has, is that its morally and ethically an indefensible position. It can only maintain public support by using a 'medical' illusion that lethal injection is quick and painless. If they were to return to non-medical methods that are quick and painless (such as beheading or shotgun to the back of the head) the support would fade away. The whole system is built on a false premis, that lethal injection is humane. Oddly, the only really humane ways of killing people are fairly brutal - A quick and relatively painless death generally requires a catastrophic amount of damage in a very short space of time). Whilst some people would support cruel and unusual methods, they're not sufficient in numbers, to maintain system of execution.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by glory
Clearly even US drug companies are uncomfortable with their drugs being used for lethal injections so, if what you say is true, it's not all that unusual that others would feel the same way. The US don't give two s***s about what the EU thinks about the death penalty there. It just so happens that it's something that's very polarising within US society, so what has happened with Pfizer isn't surprising. it's not really polarising. wifey is all against it and then some pedder is on the news for doing awful stuff and she says, "fry the ###er." the main problem here is that loads of people on death row are completely innocent. the other issue is that it's not a deterrent to violent crime. so you're executing someone purely for spite/revenge/justice reasons. that's fine if it's your stance but can't be hiding behind some veil that more executions are going to lower crime rates.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
Very few drugs I haven't tried in my debauched youth old son. Angry moi? your the one who seems to rant and rave at all and sundry. Maybe therapy would benefit you? No I'll go for the drugs thanks, therapy sounds crap to me.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by nairb75
it's not really polarising. wifey is all against it and then some pedder is on the news for doing awful stuff and she says, "fry the ###er." the main problem here is that loads of people on death row are completely innocent. the other issue is that it's not a deterrent to violent crime. so you're executing someone purely for spite/revenge/justice reasons. that's fine if it's your stance but can't be hiding behind some veil that more executions are going to lower crime rates. I think there are people, who probably deserve to die for their crimes, but that's the emotion speaking. Some people commit truly horrific crimes. But I don't feel that making them live in prison, awaiting the day they are marched into a room, strapped down in front of a crowd of witnesses and then executed for something they probably did 12 years ago is any more just. Especially when that system makes no provision for rehabilitation in the mean time or their current threat to society. Stokie Williams, a gang founder, spent most of his life in prison trying to break the cycle of gangs and spent 10-15 years try to discourage black youth from gangs. By the time he was executed he was blind from diabetes and had to be physically carried from his wheelchair to the gurney. The guy wasn't innocent, he almost certainly was responsible for four murders in the 70s, and convicted in 1979. But by 2005 when they finally got around to executing him, he was an old, blind man, dependent on a wheel chair to get around.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by nairb75
it's not really polarising. wifey is all against it and then some pedder is on the news for doing awful stuff and she says, "fry the ###er." the main problem here is that loads of people on death row are completely innocent. the other issue is that it's not a deterrent to violent crime. so you're executing someone purely for spite/revenge/justice reasons. that's fine if it's your stance but can't be hiding behind some veil that more executions are going to lower crime rates. All good points. I get your wife's way of thinking. I too get caught up in thinking that some deserve to fry but if it came down to ticking a box to approve of capital punishment, or flicking a switch to carry one out, I wouldn't be able to do so. Nor do I think governments should kill their own citizens, partially for the reasons you highlight.
|
|
|
Originally posted by glory
All good points. I get your wife's way of thinking. I too get caught up in thinking that some deserve to fry but if it came down to ticking a box to approve of capital punishment, or flicking a switch to carry one out, I wouldn't be able to do so. Nor do I think governments should kill their own citizens, partially for the reasons you highlight. yeah, it's like me hitting my son for hitting his little brother. violence begets violence. and our criminal system is rigged against poor and/or minorities. have to hold a higher standard for me. yeah, some creeps who probably should be meeting their maker but if keeping them saves one innocent guy, then i go with that plan. american society has a passive comfort with killing; or maybe a lack of respect for life. either way, i try to combat where i can.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nairb75
yeah, it's like me hitting my son for hitting his little brother. violence begets violence. and our criminal system is rigged against poor and/or minorities. have to hold a higher standard for me. yeah, some creeps who probably should be meeting their maker but if keeping them saves one innocent guy, then i go with that plan. american society has a passive comfort with killing; or maybe a lack of respect for life. either way, i try to combat where i can. 100% agree.
|
|
|
Originally posted by fed up eagle
What a pleasant fellow you are. I get more fresh air than you probably do. My view is my view and if you don't like it fair enough, but I wouldn't result in calling someone a moron because I disagree with them. You seem pretty angry, maybe one of these drug companies could supply you with some Valium or something. But "total bellend" on the other hand, is OK?
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
|
Originally posted by fed up eagle
I wouldn't result in calling someone a moron because I disagree with them. It seems that whilst you wouldn't call someone a moron just because you disagree with them you are happy to call people deluded cretins
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
It seems that whilst you wouldn't call someone a moron just because you disagree with them you are happy to call people deluded cretins Only Angelina Jollie MD, and she is in the public eye.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.