You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > animal rights?
November 21 2026 10.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

animal rights?


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Aug 16 9.41am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Good grief, it must been boring at your end today.

Four and a half hours of meetings I should not be in kind of boring.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Aug 16 9.46am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Good grief, it must been boring at your end today.

A lot of what you say is reasonable but the fact is that we are here today in this society where meat is plentiful and for many, desirable.
Like rape, to use your example, eating meat is caused a biological urge but the difference is that rape is illegal. Our society could not function as it does if that were not the case. Meat eating, on the other hand is legal and will continue to be so, no doubt, until technology allows us to fabricate a substitute that is acceptable to the consumer and ethical in it's manner of creation.
I'm not sure that we can know the exact diet of our ancestors as you suggest but tribes living now would surely eat more meat if it were readily available. To suggest that eating more meat is undesirable is a little premature. We won't know the full effects of our modern day habits for many years into the future. The consumption of meat and bowel cancer relationship probably has more to do with the preparation of cured meats rather than with the meat itself however, since science changes it's mind every decade about relationships, I would reserve judgment.

I don't think its undesirable. Just that its something we do, more out of pleasure, convenience etc that's not necessarily good for us. A bit like smoking and drinking, but without the 'warnings' of the effects. We don't really make an informed decision. Certainly I wouldn't stop eating bacon because it increased rates of bowel and stomach cancer (especially as I smoke).

But like sugar, the amount of meat people eat is unlikely to be good for them, and we have whole industries that profit greatly. The Sugar and Meat industries are the tobacco companies of our age.

Of course I still smoke...

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Aug 16 11.14am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I don't think its undesirable. Just that its something we do, more out of pleasure, convenience etc that's not necessarily good for us. A bit like smoking and drinking, but without the 'warnings' of the effects. We don't really make an informed decision. Certainly I wouldn't stop eating bacon because it increased rates of bowel and stomach cancer (especially as I smoke).

But like sugar, the amount of meat people eat is unlikely to be good for them, and we have whole industries that profit greatly. The Sugar and Meat industries are the tobacco companies of our age.

Of course I still smoke...

I knew it.

This is just your way of spreading the guilt.

The thing is that most food stuffs are probably harmless in their natural form but what we do in the processing is what makes them harmful.
Sugar is a good example. Until we started processing sugar, people had good teeth and I doubt if many had diabetes. Meat in itself is probably harmless. Currently, there is no relationship found between eating poultry and premature death even though it often contains high levels of fat. Cured meats seem to be the problem according to recent findings. The meat industry will continue to sell such products until they are stopped by law or incentivised not to. I would not hold my breath for that.
Drugs like nicotine are clearly a problem since they appear to have no benefits other than a pleasure sensation and are addictive and harmful to health. Sadly, the booze and cigarette trade make the government money and could not be effectively banned anyway. Only education and willpower can help there.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Aug 16 11.51am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I knew it.

This is just your way of spreading the guilt.

The thing is that most food stuffs are probably harmless in their natural form but what we do in the processing is what makes them harmful.
Sugar is a good example. Until we started processing sugar, people had good teeth and I doubt if many had diabetes. Meat in itself is probably harmless. Currently, there is no relationship found between eating poultry and premature death even though it often contains high levels of fat. Cured meats seem to be the problem according to recent findings. The meat industry will continue to sell such products until they are stopped by law or incentivised not to. I would not hold my breath for that.
Drugs like nicotine are clearly a problem since they appear to have no benefits other than a pleasure sensation and are addictive and harmful to health. Sadly, the booze and cigarette trade make the government money and could not be effectively banned anyway. Only education and willpower can help there.

True that. I personally feel that people should have the right to make decisions for themselves, where ever possible and that sufficient education and knowledge is important. I smoke, but I know its going to probably f**k me, but f**k it, we all die one way or another.

Sugar is a f**king beast. Few people seem to know that its actually a central nervous stimulant, and an incredibly addictive drug (that's on top of its role in diabeties and other long term health problems).

Booze and cigs, you pay your money, and you take your choices. Like drugs, which they and sugar are, its your choice, and they're your consequences and the information is pretty clear to people. Its immoral, definitely, but its fun and the harm is relatively restricted to the individual when used reasonably.

Meat, especially processed meat and additive meat, gets a massive pass. White meat in general doesn't seem to be a problem. But red meat is (the human body really struggles to break down red meat).

Of course, its still immoral to eat meat, philosophically speaking, its not really defendable. Of course its not a big issue either. Certainly I believe that meat produced for market should be raised in reasonable conditions and slaughtered in a manner that's as humane as possible.

But I'm pretty sure that's not the case for the contents of that Greggs legally defined Steak bake. This is the stuff that's going to kill us, not the meat per se, but the s**ty meat products.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Bubbs Flag Edinburgh 25 Aug 16 3.41am

Haven't eaten an animal for 26 years now. Just woke up one day, looked at my cat, and something in my head just clicked and thought, 'What the f**k am I doing?'. Was as simple as that. Never craved it.

I don't know what makes one person more or less empathetic when it comes to other species? I'm kind of at a place where I think 'well, who am I to say it's right or wrong for someone else?', despite every cell in my body screaming that it just isn't right. It's a tough one to debate and tends to go round in circles when you do.

Of course I wish there was no such thing as the meat industry and animal slaughter, but I also wish Palace would win every fecking cup going - neither are going to happen, so to avoid mental torture I've just learnt to just live by my conscience and accept others have a different outlook.

It does make me laugh though - well not laugh - when devout religious folk use their religions as an excuse to commit the most heinous acts on another living being that feels pain, fear and love just like the rest of us. Just happens to exist in a different type of vessel that's all. How very loving/God conscious is that??? Yes I'm looking at you Jews and Muslims....funnily enough the first to cry persecution. Funny world ain't it.

 


'Better stop dreaming of the quiet life 'cos it's the one we'll never know'

sitdownstandup Flag 25 Aug 16 12.45pm

Originally posted by Bubbs

Haven't eaten an animal for 26 years now. Just woke up one day, looked at my cat, and something in my head just clicked and thought, 'What the f**k am I doing?'. Was as simple as that. Never craved it.

I don't know what makes one person more or less empathetic when it comes to other species? I'm kind of at a place where I think 'well, who am I to say it's right or wrong for someone else?', despite every cell in my body screaming that it just isn't right. It's a tough one to debate and tends to go round in circles when you do.

Of course I wish there was no such thing as the meat industry and animal slaughter, but I also wish Palace would win every fecking cup going - neither are going to happen, so to avoid mental torture I've just learnt to just live by my conscience and accept others have a different outlook.

It does make me laugh though - well not laugh - when devout religious folk use their religions as an excuse to commit the most heinous acts on another living being that feels pain, fear and love just like the rest of us. Just happens to exist in a different type of vessel that's all. How very loving/God conscious is that??? Yes I'm looking at you Jews and Muslims....funnily enough the first to cry persecution. Funny world ain't it.

Agree with your post... as for religious folk, it's strange because many are hoping for a peaceful world but think that animals will still be slaughtered by the millions in it. Some religious people are so closed minded it can be frustrating discussing the issue with them.... in spite of the environmental effects (even friends of the earth are running a meat free month now) and most environmentalists being ether vegetarian, vegan or eating very little meat a lot of religious people think that it's fine to eat animals (but by whose interpretation??) and will carry on eating them regardless of the consequences for animals, human health or the environment... it would make sense to include animals in any attempts to create a fairer and more peaceful world whether you are a follower of a particular religion or not.

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

sitdownstandup Flag 25 Aug 16 12.49pm

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

Agree with your post and especially each to their own philosophy although I do think it's important that people have an understanding of what does go into the process of how food gets on the plate and the effect on the environment... as for religious folk, it's strange because many are hoping for a peaceful world but think that animals will still be slaughtered by the millions in it. Some religious people are so closed minded it can be frustrating discussing the issue with them.... in spite of the environmental effects (even friends of the earth are running a meat free month now) and most environmentalists being ether vegetarian, vegan or eating very little meat a lot of religious people think that it's fine to eat animals (but by whose interpretation??) and will carry on eating them regardless of the consequences for animals, human health or the environment... it would make sense to include animals in any attempts to create a fairer and more peaceful world whether you are a follower of a particular religion or not.

 


Man is the most insane species. He worships an invisible God and destroys a visible Nature. Unaware that this Nature he’s destroying is this God he’s worshipping.

Hubert Reeves

Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 Aug 19 1.15am

This Youtuber releases ultra bubbly upbeat videos of her and her dog - [Link]

But this is how she actually behaves in an unedited video that she accidentally uploaded [Link] Not quite so bubbly there I see. Tut tut.


Edited by dollardays (08 Aug 2019 1.16am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 08 Aug 19 10.00pm

Originally posted by sitdownstandup

Oh gawd..... well I thought this this thread would be a bit more divisive than it was ... obvsly I was wrong... animals deserve the right to live free of pain... and that entails not eating them ( in my opinion anyways) ... opposing opinions welcomed... ps I dont like arguing but yep opposing opinions are still welcomed.

I have never understood the argument that to be kind to animals we should not eat them.

Animals eat each other in the wild all the time.

Most farm animals wouldn't have any life at all unless we ate them. We cannot ask them if they would prefer not to be born rather than be born to be eaten but I would hazard a guess it would be the latter.

A stronger argument for not eating meat is that it's a more efficient use of land resources to concentrate on vegetables and when there is a need to feed the hungry we ought to think about that.

I am also passionately against the organic movement as a totally wrong direction. Sustainable farming in underdeveloped countries makes good sense but to indulge in going organic is just the "yuppy mummy" guilt response to using convenience foods. It's scientifically unsound and a pointless waste of knowledge.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 08 Aug 19 10.29pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I have never understood the argument that to be kind to animals we should not eat them.

Animals eat each other in the wild all the time.

Most farm animals wouldn't have any life at all unless we ate them. We cannot ask them if they would prefer not to be born rather than be born to be eaten but I would hazard a guess it would be the latter.

A stronger argument for not eating meat is that it's a more efficient use of land resources to concentrate on vegetables and when there is a need to feed the hungry we ought to think about that.

I am also passionately against the organic movement as a totally wrong direction. Sustainable farming in underdeveloped countries makes good sense but to indulge in going organic is just the "yuppy mummy" guilt response to using convenience foods. It's scientifically unsound and a pointless waste of knowledge.

Well that's a first.
I find myself agreeing.
Apart from swapping the land for veg that is.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Aug 19 10.34pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I have never understood the argument that to be kind to animals we should not eat them.

Animals eat each other in the wild all the time.

Most farm animals wouldn't have any life at all unless we ate them. We cannot ask them if they would prefer not to be born rather than be born to be eaten but I would hazard a guess it would be the latter.

A stronger argument for not eating meat is that it's a more efficient use of land resources to concentrate on vegetables and when there is a need to feed the hungry we ought to think about that.

I am also passionately against the organic movement as a totally wrong direction. Sustainable farming in underdeveloped countries makes good sense but to indulge in going organic is just the "yuppy mummy" guilt response to using convenience foods. It's scientifically unsound and a pointless waste of knowledge.

As humans, we are capable of compassion.
We might like to eat our furry friends but the least we can do is limit their suffering to a minimum.

 

Invalid user 2019 Flag 08 Aug 19 11.04pm

Some good points by all. A future moral quandary could be if lab grown meat is eventually as sustainable and cost effective as actually killing animals. Like other dietary choices though, it would be down to how the individual feels.

On its surface 'lab grown' doesn't have a particularly appetising ring to it, but then I doubt slaughtered would either outside of being accustomed to it throughout life. Technology of course raises many questions that we wouldn't otherwise anticipate having to answer.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > animal rights?