This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
There will be a gaggle of lawyers itching to make a legal aid killing on every minor restriction of human rights the poor thing may suffer whilst inside :-( Quite right to. And the state should be absolute in establishing that his legal rights are met to the letter of the law, and that he receives exactly the same treatment as any other prisoner. After all if he 'hangs himself' inside, its much better that it doesn't come back to haunt those responsible.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Here's hoping the Americans have extradition proceedings under way. That'll wipe the smirk off his face.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Alexi_the_Eagle
5 years is an absolute joke. Should of been 10 years max and with solitary with an extra year added for contempt of court. Words can't describe how much I despise this hypocritical piece of sh!t.
Moreover, there is a certain whiff of hypocrisy about. On the one hand he was targeted as a person who challenged this country's values and way of life. Presumably, this would include what is a relatively modern criminal justice system consistent with an advanced liberal democracy? On the other, there are those baying for his blood demanding - and here's the irony - the sort of sentence that this man would hand out if he were the judge and his version of Sharia law were in force. By all means despise the man and what he stands for; but we should not expect [and indeed we should demand] that he receives a fair trial and a sentence consistent with the proven harm he has actually done. In my view that is not beardy, tree-hugging, sandal-wearing, weak-kneed liberalism - although it would be painted as such by our friends over the pond - it is being British.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 07 Sep 16 10.36am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Been reading the Express have we? You can get only 4 years for aggravated rape; but in this case we get a year more for just supporting terrorism. Remember, this is a case where the prosecution failed to make a connection between his preaching and any actual act of terrorism. This conviction smacks more of example setting than a proper tariff to fit the offence. Moreover, there is a certain whiff of hypocrisy about. On the one hand he was targeted as a person who challenged this country's values and way of life. Presumably, this would include what is a relatively modern criminal justice system consistent with an advanced liberal democracy? On the other, there are those baying for his blood demanding - and here's the irony - the sort of sentence that this man would hand out if he were the judge and his version of Sharia law were in force. By all means despise the man and what he stands for; but we should not expect [and indeed we should demand] that he receives a fair trial and a sentence consistent with the proven harm he has actually done. In my view that is not beardy, tree-hugging, sandal-wearing, weak-kneed liberalism - although it would be painted as such by our friends over the pond - it is being British. Sorry silvertop but from my perspective that is EXACTLY what it is. He has received a fair trial but the sentence does not reflect the harm his preaching has done not only here but across the world... he's a dangerously bad influence to young minds. As Stuk pointed out his refusal to stand in the dock to hear his sentence and his supporters shouting "Alan's Snack Bar" or whatever their rallying cry is shows his utter contempt of our society and effect on other impressionable followers. I don't expect you or others like you to change your minds anytime soon... that is how people like Choudary are able to get away with it for so long, but I'll bet that public pressure will mean this ridiculously short sentence is reviewed and increased to 10 years to act as a proper deterrent to other muslim hate preachers peddling their venomous jihadi dialogue whilst enjoying the lifestyle that the UK affords them, with many actually on huge benefits supporting them and their families!
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Sorry silvertop but from my perspective that is EXACTLY what it is. He has received a fair trial but the sentence does not reflect the harm his preaching has done not only here but across the world... he's a dangerously bad influence to young minds. As Stuk pointed out his refusal to stand in the dock to hear his sentence and his supporters shouting "Alan's Snack Bar" or whatever their rallying cry is shows his utter contempt of our society and effect on other impressionable followers. I don't expect you or others like you to change your minds anytime soon... that is how people like Choudary are able to get away with it for so long, but I'll bet that public pressure will mean this ridiculously short sentence is reviewed and increased to 10 years to act as a proper deterrent to other muslim hate preachers peddling their venomous jihadi dialogue whilst enjoying the lifestyle that the UK affords them, with many actually on huge benefits supporting them and their families! Its a very fine line though between freedom of speech. Sentencing has to be on the strength of the case, and the degree to which the support could be show to be material and contributory, rather than just personal views and idea. Problem of Free Speech, is if you're going to have it, it does mean having to accept speech you find abhorrent, inflammatory and potentially inciteful - rather than actually inciteful. Its just one reason why free speech is bollocks. People really only support it when it 'suits them'
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Should have hung the c**t.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
Sorry silvertop but from my perspective that is EXACTLY what it is. He has received a fair trial but the sentence does not reflect the harm his preaching has done not only here but across the world... he's a dangerously bad influence to young minds. As Stuk pointed out his refusal to stand in the dock to hear his sentence and his supporters shouting "Alan's Snack Bar" or whatever their rallying cry is shows his utter contempt of our society and effect on other impressionable followers. I don't expect you or others like you to change your minds anytime soon... that is how people like Choudary are able to get away with it for so long, but I'll bet that public pressure will mean this ridiculously short sentence is reviewed and increased to 10 years to act as a proper deterrent to other muslim hate preachers peddling their venomous jihadi dialogue whilst enjoying the lifestyle that the UK affords them, with many actually on huge benefits supporting them and their families! Nothing in my post said I supported what he did. Everything I said aggressively advocated our way of life enshrined in fair liberal sentencing. If our security forces and criminal justice system are there to support anything, it is such rights and freedoms built up over millennia that is threatened by the spread of radical Islam. Btw, the call means God is Great and is the Islamic equivalent to, say, amen. That it has been hijacked as a rallying cry for daish [or whatever] and that he did not stand to hear his sentence should have no bearing on the sentence which I understood to be the subject matter of my post. Then again, you are one of the clever posters on this site and I suspect you know both points full well. Indeed, I think you may be trying to tweak my tail you scamp. On topic, Mr Choudary is indeed a c**t. If we can agree on nothing else I suspect we can agree on that.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by wombat84
Should have hung the c**t. We'd have to set the bar for capital punishment really low, we'd be hanging a lot of people.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Nothing in my post said I supported what he did. Everything I said aggressively advocated our way of life enshrined in fair liberal sentencing. If our security forces and criminal justice system are there to support anything, it is such rights and freedoms built up over millennia that is threatened by the spread of radical Islam. Btw, the call means God is Great and is the Islamic equivalent to, say, amen. That it has been hijacked as a rallying cry for daish [or whatever] and that he did not stand to hear his sentence should have no bearing on the sentence which I understood to be the subject matter of my post. Then again, you are one of the clever posters on this site and I suspect you know both points full well. Indeed, I think you may be trying to tweak my tail you scamp. On topic, Mr Choudary is indeed a c**t. If we can agree on nothing else I suspect we can agree on that. Allah Akbar, simply means god is great. Its part of the call to prayer, and as central to prayer as Amen or Our Father. I don't think you can really make that a 'crime'.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its a very fine line though between freedom of speech. Sentencing has to be on the strength of the case, and the degree to which the support could be show to be material and contributory, rather than just personal views and idea. Problem of Free Speech, is if you're going to have it, it does mean having to accept speech you find abhorrent, inflammatory and potentially inciteful - rather than actually inciteful. Its just one reason why free speech is bollocks. People really only support it when it 'suits them' I think the quote regarding freedom of speech along the lines of "freedom of speech does not protect a man from falsely shouting 'fire' in a crowded theatre to cause panic" is a pretty good one.
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
We'd have to set the bar for capital punishment really low, we'd be hanging a lot of people. You make that sound like a bad thing.....
|
|
|
Originally posted by wombat84
Should have hung the c**t. Forget hanging. A bullet in his head would solve everything.
"Look at that. Accident blackspot? These aren't accidents! They're throwing themselves into the road gladly! Throwing themselves into the road to escape all this hideousness!" |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Nothing in my post said I supported what he did. Everything I said aggressively advocated our way of life enshrined in fair liberal sentencing. If our security forces and criminal justice system are there to support anything, it is such rights and freedoms built up over millennia that is threatened by the spread of radical Islam. Btw, the call means God is Great and is the Islamic equivalent to, say, amen. That it has been hijacked as a rallying cry for daish [or whatever] and that he did not stand to hear his sentence should have no bearing on the sentence which I understood to be the subject matter of my post. Then again, you are one of the clever posters on this site and I suspect you know both points full well. Indeed, I think you may be trying to tweak my tail you scamp. On topic, Mr Choudary is indeed a c**t. If we can agree on nothing else I suspect we can agree on that. can I ask how you managed to combine fair with "liberal" in a comment about sentencing. Furthermore why should sentencing be Liberal or fair, and who decides (surely not you) what is fair, the respondent of the crime ? the Judge Advocat ? the Jury ? or as is the system at present (clearly unfit for purpose) that gives guidelines on sentencing, i.e. a start point of sorts, that then allows for mitigating or aggravating factors. A system which gives convicted rapists (on average)only 5 years, and yet someone like Choudary who has incited the deaths of weak willed Muslims by getting them all "jihady John" and in kind responsible for the murder of people like Lee Rigby (whose cold bloodied murder he supported by the way) a similar figure. Actually your right it is bloody Liberal and fair, to the criminals not the Victims !
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
can I ask how you managed to combine fair with "liberal" in a comment about sentencing. Furthermore why should sentencing be Liberal or fair, and who decides (surely not you) what is fair, the respondent of the crime ? the Judge Advocat ? the Jury ? or as is the system at present (clearly unfit for purpose) that gives guidelines on sentencing, i.e. a start point of sorts, that then allows for mitigating or aggravating factors. A system which gives convicted rapists (on average)only 5 years, and yet someone like Choudary who has incited the deaths of weak willed Muslims by getting them all "jihady John" and in kind responsible for the murder of people like Lee Rigby (whose cold bloodied murder he supported by the way) a similar figure. Actually your right it is bloody Liberal and fair, to the criminals not the Victims ! Liberal and fair have a vague common ground, in so much as they present the ideology of a trial that is exempt from political or social bias or interference. The Liberal movement, typically is based around the concept of the pragmatic and unbiased, rather than being ideological (not to be mistaken for Liberal Democrats). However the fair trial is not a liberal thing The idea of the fair trial, however isn't a liberal concept. Its basis lies in the Magna Carta, and has been contributed to by both left and right wing politics to establish a concept of what defines a fair trial - Which is for the state to prove, to an random sample of the populace, guilt beyond reasonable doubt or otherwise dismiss charges. So whilst liberals tend to assume they're responsible for the idea of a free and fair trial, its really has its basis in the ideology that justice must be impartial, proportional and above all fairly dispensed. The history of UK law really is about establishing an effective system of determining guilt, rather than being liberal. It long predates liberalism. The importance of ensuring that you have the right person, outweighs ideological arguments of politics. Which is something generally accepted by all parties. Even the more extreme parties tend towards only wanting to 'add certain crimes'.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
can I ask how you managed to combine fair with "liberal" in a comment about sentencing. Furthermore why should sentencing be Liberal or fair, and who decides (surely not you) what is fair, the respondent of the crime ? the Judge Advocat ? the Jury ? or as is the system at present (clearly unfit for purpose) that gives guidelines on sentencing, i.e. a start point of sorts, that then allows for mitigating or aggravating factors. A system which gives convicted rapists (on average)only 5 years, and yet someone like Choudary who has incited the deaths of weak willed Muslims by getting them all "jihady John" and in kind responsible for the murder of people like Lee Rigby (whose cold bloodied murder he supported by the way) a similar figure. Actually your right it is bloody Liberal and fair, to the criminals not the Victims ! There are laws that cover that under Anti-Terrorist legislation - the problem though would be proving that beyond reasonable doubt. Incitement or conspiracy to murder for example (both can carry whole life sentences). Problem is, judicially, its about what you can prove, not who the person is, or what he might be associated to. Slight exception, in that conspiracy cases you have to prove your innocence (which is why people tend to be convicted of conspiracy to cause explosions or conspiracy to facilitate terrorism). So whilst we can all say its because of people like him that Lee Rigby was murdered, in court you have to prove that it was because of his actions that Lee Rigby was murdered. It aint fair, because the guilty tend to walk. But many women can tell you how unfair the law can be.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Alexi_the_Eagle
Forget hanging. A bullet in his head would solve everything. No, what you want, is him to 'hang himself in prison' or be 'killed in an altercation with another Muslim prisoner' or by someone he's 'sexually assaulted' in prison. Plus, now, with five years on his cards, it becomes a lot easier to get further convictions etc. The last thing you want is some martyr.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| Hoof Hearted 07 Sep 16 4.38pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Nothing in my post said I supported what he did. Everything I said aggressively advocated our way of life enshrined in fair liberal sentencing. If our security forces and criminal justice system are there to support anything, it is such rights and freedoms built up over millennia that is threatened by the spread of radical Islam. Btw, the call means God is Great and is the Islamic equivalent to, say, amen. That it has been hijacked as a rallying cry for daish [or whatever] and that he did not stand to hear his sentence should have no bearing on the sentence which I understood to be the subject matter of my post. Then again, you are one of the clever posters on this site and I suspect you know both points full well. Indeed, I think you may be trying to tweak my tail you scamp. On topic, Mr Choudary is indeed a c**t. If we can agree on nothing else I suspect we can agree on that. We certainly can agree. I did know what they were shouting and what it means - it was just an excuse for a bit of comedy.... You know me better than I know myself... LOL Gert lush me babber!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.