You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Star players that aren't good enough for us
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Star players that aren't good enough for us


leejaneagles Flag 19 Aug 16 1.04pm

Starting this topic because of something I posted over in Transfer Talk. In the Marcus Rashford loan suggestion thread I mentioned he is there only viable option as a second striker to Ibrahimovic because Rooney is so bad now you couldn't trust him up-front alone.

My exact post was: "I know this probably sounds dramatic but I wouldn't even have Rooney at Palace as one of our striker options as he has a worse first touch than Frazier Campbell, less athleticism than Wickham and worse finishing than Benteke. He really is a nothing player that the press are refusing to tear to shreds for some reason."

This got me thinking, what players are there that despite playing for a top club they actually wouldn't be wanted by lesser clubs such as ourselves or perhaps even lower.

I really do believe that Rooney wouldn't be an improvement for Palace and still wouldn't be able to pass or finish anymore. When Ronaldo or someone of genuine class goes into a worse team they shine and make it better. See Ronaldo playing for Portugal.

When Rooney plays for England, he should be elevating that team and yet he's still one of the worst players on the pitch, which is why I don't think he'd help even us.

It's such an odd circumstance that a player can be seen as such a vital part of a top European squad and a non-droppable starting 11 player for a team like Manchester United and yet no one else would want him because he's only there because of reputation and wage/image rights.

I tried to think of others but not many sprung to mind. A 35 year old John Terry would still improve all bottom half defenses.

One i can remember from a few years ago was Robert Pires to Aston Villa who was dreadful but did he join them at a time when everyone was expecting him to lift them up (like people would expect Rooney to do for us).

Alberto Moreno is perhaps another undroppable at a top club that wouldn't improve bottom half teams because he's terrible but that's still a stretch as I think he could do a job for us and perhaps be better than Soure.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 19 Aug 16 2.28pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

Starting this topic because of something I posted over in Transfer Talk. In the Marcus Rashford loan suggestion thread I mentioned he is there only viable option as a second striker to Ibrahimovic because Rooney is so bad now you couldn't trust him up-front alone.

My exact post was: "I know this probably sounds dramatic but I wouldn't even have Rooney at Palace as one of our striker options as he has a worse first touch than Frazier Campbell, less athleticism than Wickham and worse finishing than Benteke. He really is a nothing player that the press are refusing to tear to shreds for some reason."

This got me thinking, what players are there that despite playing for a top club they actually wouldn't be wanted by lesser clubs such as ourselves or perhaps even lower.

I really do believe that Rooney wouldn't be an improvement for Palace and still wouldn't be able to pass or finish anymore. When Ronaldo or someone of genuine class goes into a worse team they shine and make it better. See Ronaldo playing for Portugal.

When Rooney plays for England, he should be elevating that team and yet he's still one of the worst players on the pitch, which is why I don't think he'd help even us.

It's such an odd circumstance that a player can be seen as such a vital part of a top European squad and a non-droppable starting 11 player for a team like Manchester United and yet no one else would want him because he's only there because of reputation and wage/image rights.

I tried to think of others but not many sprung to mind. A 35 year old John Terry would still improve all bottom half defenses.

One i can remember from a few years ago was Robert Pires to Aston Villa who was dreadful but did he join them at a time when everyone was expecting him to lift them up (like people would expect Rooney to do for us).

Alberto Moreno is perhaps another undroppable at a top club that wouldn't improve bottom half teams because he's terrible but that's still a stretch as I think he could do a job for us and perhaps be better than Soure.

He is an awful player. I swear he changed the name on his shirt from Moreno, to Alberto M, after he got torn apart by us in his first season for Liverpool.

 


Optimistic as ever

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 19 Aug 16 2.38pm

I stopped reading when you said you wouldn't have Rooney at Palace - no offence, but that's total bollocks.

 

leejaneagles Flag 19 Aug 16 4.20pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I stopped reading when you said you wouldn't have Rooney at Palace - no offence, but that's total bollocks.

No offense but I don't value an opinion that just writes off somebody elses without any valid argument to back them up.

What would Rooney bring to the team? A first touch far, far worse than Puncheon's and dreadful finishing. No pace either.

So we look to his leadership skills and he doesn't look good at motivating either judging by England's display in the Euro's and Man Utd's last 3 seasons.

At United, he's looked amazing and to be fair was very good in his prime but was always the second brightest star to Ronaldo and then Van Persie.

Just look how well he coped with being the main man these last few years. He'll probably look okay again now Mourinho has brought in Zlatan to be the star that Rooney couldn't be.

We'd get a few more decisions our way with his screaming red in the face at the ref though I'll give you that.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 19 Aug 16 6.41pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

No offense but I don't value an opinion that just writes off somebody elses without any valid argument to back them up.

What would Rooney bring to the team? A first touch far, far worse than Puncheon's and dreadful finishing. No pace either.

So we look to his leadership skills and he doesn't look good at motivating either judging by England's display in the Euro's and Man Utd's last 3 seasons.

At United, he's looked amazing and to be fair was very good in his prime but was always the second brightest star to Ronaldo and then Van Persie.

Just look how well he coped with being the main man these last few years. He'll probably look okay again now Mourinho has brought in Zlatan to be the star that Rooney couldn't be.

We'd get a few more decisions our way with his screaming red in the face at the ref though I'll give you that.

So your argument is that because Rooney isn't/wasn't as good as Ronaldo or Ibrahimovic, he wouldn't get in to a team who most recently started Chung Yung Lee as the number 10.

You're arguing that England's all time top scorer, and one of the highest goal scorers in Premiership (and Man Utd) history, wouldn't get into a team ahead of Jason Puncheon.

 

leejaneagles Flag 19 Aug 16 7.33pm

You don't have to agree with me but I just think Rooney's past form and achievements should have no bearing on how he would perform now in any team.

He isn't like your normal player that can be a top level, then when he reaches his 30's, drops down to middling Premier League level and then finally can still do a job at a bottom club or Championship club.

His ceiling was so high and his lowest level is really, really low and he's spent almost no time in the middle.

I'm not arguing that Rooney will go down as a great for England and legend for Man Utd. Of course we'd love a Rooney of a few years ago in our Palace team but he wouldn't have come because he was so good. Now he's so bad.

That's what this topic is about really, how can someone go from that great to that bad so quickly?

If you go and watch the Bournemouth game from the weekend or any of the England matches in France, in my opinion you can't make a case why he should be able to displace Jason Puncheon in our team.

 

chandlem68 Flag Beckenham 19 Aug 16 7.57pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

You don't have to agree with me but I just think Rooney's past form and achievements should have no bearing on how he would perform now in any team.

He isn't like your normal player that can be a top level, then when he reaches his 30's, drops down to middling Premier League level and then finally can still do a job at a bottom club or Championship club.

His ceiling was so high and his lowest level is really, really low and he's spent almost no time in the middle.

I'm not arguing that Rooney will go down as a great for England and legend for Man Utd. Of course we'd love a Rooney of a few years ago in our Palace team but he wouldn't have come because he was so good. Now he's so bad.

That's what this topic is about really, how can someone go from that great to that bad so quickly?

If you go and watch the Bournemouth game from the weekend or any of the England matches in France, in my opinion you can't make a case why he should be able to displace Jason Puncheon in our team.

I recommend booking an appointment with your doctor next week. Looks like the funny turn you are having has seriously affected your football judgement!

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 19 Aug 16 8.37pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I stopped reading when you said you wouldn't have Rooney at Palace - no offence, but that's total bollocks.

I only kept reading to see if it was a pi55 take.It wasn't

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 19 Aug 16 8.49pm

granted he's not half as good as he was 7 years ago. But He'd still walk into the palace side...

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 20 Aug 16 11.33am

An I reading this right......you'd rather have puncheon playing no.10 than rooney?

What's happened to palace fans recently, fourth season in the premiership, 15th last season and we think rooney s not good enough for us.

Unbelievable

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 23 Aug 16 11.57am

Originally posted by leejaneagles

You don't have to agree with me but I just think Rooney's past form and achievements should have no bearing on how he would perform now in any team.

He isn't like your normal player that can be a top level, then when he reaches his 30's, drops down to middling Premier League level and then finally can still do a job at a bottom club or Championship club.

His ceiling was so high and his lowest level is really, really low and he's spent almost no time in the middle.

I'm not arguing that Rooney will go down as a great for England and legend for Man Utd. Of course we'd love a Rooney of a few years ago in our Palace team but he wouldn't have come because he was so good. Now he's so bad.

That's what this topic is about really, how can someone go from that great to that bad so quickly?

If you go and watch the Bournemouth game from the weekend or any of the England matches in France, in my opinion you can't make a case why he should be able to displace Jason Puncheon in our team.

I can sort of see where you're coming from but you are unquestionably wrong about Rooney.

Best player on the pitch in the cup final for example and dragged them past us and up the steps to lift the trophy (still hurts thinking about it).

There should be absolutely not a doubt in any person's mind that even the slightly overweight and definitely on the decline Rooney would walk into our team. Every single game.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

paperhat Flag croydon 26 Aug 16 1.52pm

Originally posted by leejaneagles

No offense but I don't value an opinion that just writes off somebody elses without any valid argument to back them up.

What would Rooney bring to the team? A first touch far, far worse than Puncheon's and dreadful finishing. No pace either.

Without the comparison to Puncheon you are wrong, with the comparison, utterly delusional.

I included the opening of your post as you defeated your own argument immediately.

A touch worse than Puncheon and dreadful finishing? I had to re-type that just to see if it was actually what you'd put.......

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 26 Aug 16 1.56pm

Also would definitely have Rooney in the team. However, in answer to the original question I think Branislav Ivanovic is an absolute liability these days and wouldn't really want him. Baffled how Chelsea haven't replaced him by now.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

ultra_combo Flag croydon 26 Aug 16 4.49pm

Rooney won't make the palace team.....hahahaha this is why drugs are bad. Makes you talk crazy. He is good enough for every single manager that had him on thier team but not good enough for palace. Wow. Just wow.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 26 Aug 16 5.01pm

Sorry but that's a load of bollocks. If we had Rooney in the current team we would be comfortably top 10. He is the type of number 10 we need, great on the ball can spray long balls around or support the striker and be dangerous in front of goal. He may well be out of form, but to suggest that he is anything other than a great player who we couldn't get in a million years is laughable.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 26 Aug 16 6.02pm

I can think of hundred's of star players over 40 that are not good enough for palace.

 

Lombardinho Flag London 26 Aug 16 6.40pm

Go easy on the OP, boys and gals!

He may be potificating but I'm almost inclined to back him up.

England and Palace players are so far apart they almost play on a different planet even though 99% of the ones who are picked play in the very same league as CPFC.

Now Sam's in charge will he go against the grain and pick the one player we've been crying out for, for years? Scotty Dann, of course. I doubt it.

And although Harry Redknapp, no less, has stated the one player missing from our squad in France this summer was Andros Townsend. This Palace fan, for one, won't be surprised if his name is absent from the upcoming squad for England's 2018 World Cup qualifiers.

Please explain to me why Ian Wright played 6 seasons for Palace but only really got selected for his country after he left for Arsenal at the age of 28. The list goes on, Sansome, Johnson and Clyne etc.

Back on topic, Rooney and Palce on paper do not mix. He probably would be s***. We all know it'll never happen. But we do have SEVEN internationals who are deemed integral players in their own national squads.

In summary, I like to say Palace players don't play for England because they're just too damned classy!

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Star players that aren't good enough for us