You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Some thoughts on the West Ham game
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Some thoughts on the West Ham game


victor43 Flag St. Albans 18 Oct 16 5.59pm

Had some thoughts on the West Ham game about how we were slightly unlucky but have been punished by our habit of conceding the first goal this season. I also think the second half improvement was not just down to Cabaye/ Pardew, and we should be careful before jumping to any conclusions about how we'll do with Yohan instead of Ledley.

Short article - have a read here:
[Link]

I also discussed how Benteke is getting on with his penalty miss in mind.

Appreciate any comments - thanks!

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

OldFella Flag London 18 Oct 16 7.42pm

Originally posted by victor43

Had some thoughts on the West Ham game about how we were slightly unlucky but have been punished by our habit of conceding the first goal this season. I also think the second half improvement was not just down to Cabaye/ Pardew, and we should be careful before jumping to any conclusions about how we'll do with Yohan instead of Ledley.

Short article - have a read here:
[Link]

I also discussed how Benteke is getting on with his penalty miss in mind.

Appreciate any comments - thanks!

Enjoyed that - a very good read/thoughtful analysis. Particularly interested re the 0.76 penalty probability stat, and Benteke's record being broadly in line with that.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 18 Oct 16 7.44pm

Good read thanks for posting !

 

Noz Flag North Hampshire 18 Oct 16 8.31pm

I'm assuming those are "game stats" rather than " game states"?

 

Dan1994 Flag Wallington 18 Oct 16 8.46pm

You've got yourself a new follower, I really enyoed that (y)

 


[Link]

glaziermart Flag 18 Oct 16 9.09pm

Fantastic post. Love to see an intelligent analysis, instead of the usual knee jerk reactions like 'sack Pardew' 'this player is s**t' and so on. We are actually 9th in the Premier, and this was our first defeat in six games!!!

I tried on another thread to explain that our home form is actually improving, not in this game, although the weather conditions also played a part, but overall we had played well against Bournemouth and Stoke (we simply took our chances against Stoke) and our only other defeat apart from Wet Spam, was against Pulis and his baggies, in which we had half a team missing through a combination of injuries and players returning late from the Euros. Sometimes the stats do not fully tell the story.

But this OP has put together his analysis far better than i could, so i admire the considered way he has presented the facts.

 

PA Flag Bedfordshire 18 Oct 16 9.43pm

Originally posted by Noz

I'm assuming those are "game stats" rather than " game states"?

If you read the article, it's 'game states'

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 19 Oct 16 3.10am

Well written, good thinking and I welcome you back anytime. Possible to subscribe?

 

Holmesdale Hibs Flag Sydenham Hill 19 Oct 16 5.32am

Good article, thanks for posting. I'm quite surprised a penalty is 0.76 of an expected goal, I'd have thought it would be higher although not sure why being a Palace fan.

We should also remember that West Ham are a decent team. They might be on a bad run but they have good players and they were always going to sort out their form at some point.

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 19 Oct 16 9.24am

Thanks for the kind comments guys! Glad this kind of stuff gets people interested.

Re subscribing - the easiest way is probably my twitter account (if you have Twitter that is), but if not you can 'follow' the blog if you have an account on Wordpress. I may start up a facebook account as I know quite a few Palace fans use that to get their news etc...

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

victor43 Flag St. Albans 19 Oct 16 9.25am

Originally posted by PA

If you read the article, it's 'game states'

Yes it is game states. Perhaps not the most intuitive expression - some people refer to it as 'score effects', i.e. the effect the score has on the pattern of the game.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

victor43 Flag St. Albans 19 Oct 16 9.28am

Originally posted by Holmesdale Hibs

Good article, thanks for posting. I'm quite surprised a penalty is 0.76 of an expected goal, I'd have thought it would be higher although not sure why being a Palace fan.

We should also remember that West Ham are a decent team. They might be on a bad run but they have good players and they were always going to sort out their form at some point.

Yes that 0.76 value is the average conversion rate of penalties taken from thousands of penalties. So you might see a temporary phase of people missing a lot of pens, but in the long run it settles down about 3 in 4.

Definitely, West Ham are a good team, especially attacking wise. They just happened to sort out their defence for this game as well!

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 19 Oct 16 10.06am

decent read that , but wouldn't the analysis be skewed when the oppo goes down to 10 like Saturday

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

Aray Flag South London 19 Oct 16 10.10am

Thanks for a good read. much better than most.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 19 Oct 16 10.12am

Interesting read Victor albeit a little mind boggling!

Do you have any stats to say how many miles Benteke covered as opposed to ZaZa and the team generally against West Ham's?

 


Bring back Brolin

victor43 Flag St. Albans 19 Oct 16 10.21am

Originally posted by richard shaw (og)65

decent read that , but wouldn't the analysis be skewed when the oppo goes down to 10 like Saturday

Yes that is a good point, didn't mention that. Teams that go down to 10 also have less shots/ face more shots, so that may have added to us coming back in to the game.

But in general, with or without 10 men, teams tend to shoot more than the opposition if they are trailing by 1 goal.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

victor43 Flag St. Albans 19 Oct 16 10.24am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Interesting read Victor albeit a little mind boggling!

Do you have any stats to say how many miles Benteke covered as opposed to ZaZa and the team generally against West Ham's?

No I don't actually - not sure where these are captured. I would be wary of reading too much into those kind of stats, there is no evidence that distance run has any positive effect on goals/ shots/ points etc. Distance run tends to give a bit more information about the style.

You can still play with intensity and put in 100% effort and run less, so it doesn't prove anything on its own.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 19 Oct 16 11.28am

Originally posted by victor43

Yes that is a good point, didn't mention that. Teams that go down to 10 also have less shots/ face more shots, so that may have added to us coming back in to the game.

But in general, with or without 10 men, teams tend to shoot more than the opposition if they are trailing by 1 goal.

yep agree , Saturday was a classic "down to 10 men " scenario , teams will stay the same shape in defence and midfield just less up front . ive seen it where the away team is one up and go to a 4-5-0 formation

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 19 Oct 16 11.55am

Really good article. Feel better about the next few games knowing that statistically we played well enough to win that game.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 19 Oct 16 12.42pm

Originally posted by victor43

No I don't actually - not sure where these are captured. I would be wary of reading too much into those kind of stats, there is no evidence that distance run has any positive effect on goals/ shots/ points etc. Distance run tends to give a bit more information about the style.

You can still play with intensity and put in 100% effort and run less, so it doesn't prove anything on its own.

It's a pretty good marker though!

 


Bring back Brolin


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Some thoughts on the West Ham game