You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Match analysis
November 16 2026 11.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Match analysis


midpalace Flag hinckley 23 Oct 16 4.27pm

I'm assuming as most people would that when a post is made regarding the performance of a player good or bad that they've actually been to the game.this assumption cannot be true however as the posts regarding cabaye yesterday are so negative.yes of course he hasn't delivered for what ever reason in recent times but at Leicester he from kick off to full time which I watched every second looking at the pitch not looking at the home fans or in the the bar/toilet etc Johan was an inspiration showing great quality and never stopped running for the cause,a great positive come on palace

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 23 Oct 16 4.32pm

Originally posted by midpalace

I'm assuming as most people would that when a post is made regarding the performance of a player good or bad that they've actually been to the game.this assumption cannot be true however as the posts regarding cabaye yesterday are so negative.yes of course he hasn't delivered for what ever reason in recent times but at Leicester he from kick off to full time which I watched every second looking at the pitch not looking at the home fans or in the the bar/toilet etc Johan was an inspiration showing great quality and never stopped running for the cause,a great positive come on palace

Every second?

Just another opinion, no analysis

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Oct 16 5.01pm

Wow we must have different ideas of quality.

 

chateauferret Flag 23 Oct 16 5.26pm

Originally posted by midpalace

I'm assuming as most people would that when a post is made regarding the performance of a player good or bad that they've actually been to the game.this assumption cannot be true however as the posts regarding cabaye yesterday are so negative.yes of course he hasn't delivered for what ever reason in recent times but at Leicester he from kick off to full time which I watched every second looking at the pitch not looking at the home fans or in the the bar/toilet etc Johan was an inspiration showing great quality and never stopped running for the cause,a great positive come on palace

Translation: "I was at the match therefore I am right and you are wrong".

I wasn't at the match but Cabaye and the rest of the midfield were still slow, inflexible and predictable.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 23 Oct 16 5.54pm

Frustratingly in 2016 we've been "In" practically every match we've played in, but the results have been awful. No matter how well we seem to play you're just waiting for the inevitable to happen and being inevitable it does. We seem to be so very, very close to being an established team. Predictably it is almost always a self inflicted wound that undoes us, due to poor technique or more regularly poor concentration, switching off.
Only real cure is better quality players, especially at the back IMO.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

bicycle repair man 23 Oct 16 9.06pm

I wasn't at the Leicester game and a lot of people seem to be criticising Cabaye.
However I have read two Sunday paper match reports,one made him man of the match overall and put him in their team of the day,and the other rated him Palace's best player.So it seems like he had a decent game to me.

 

Aray Flag South London 23 Oct 16 9.12pm

He did play quite well - but he really is not delivering as many goals as he should. Maybe that's the reason why some people don't rate him.

 

glaziermart Flag 23 Oct 16 9.18pm

I'm sick and tired of the same old criticism after a defeat. We actually had 55% of the possession and controlled large parts of the game. You get the usual suspects, one of them constantly says exactly the same thing after each defeat like 'what do you expect with only 25% possession' and things like 'we cannot find our own players'!!! That is totally unfair. It is like he still thinks we are managed by Pulis!!!! If anyone saw Danny Murphy talking about Okazaki closing us down, the analysis clips actually showed us having long periods of keeping the ball. Look at the link below and get your facts right before posting crap comments all the time

[Link]

 

palace-metros Flag Redhill 23 Oct 16 9.27pm

Good post GM but you don't need to shout!

 


Before you criticise someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticise them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes.

PA Flag Bedfordshire 24 Oct 16 9.53am

I was at the game and also spent some minutes just watching Cabaye. He did play quite well.

I hope that helps.

 

Part Time James Flag 24 Oct 16 9.56am

I wasn't at the game, nor did I watch it on TV or watch any of the highlights. However, don't pick on Cabaye just because he's black.

 




twist Flag Miami, Florida 24 Oct 16 2.34pm

I have slagged Cabaye off alot these past 10 months or so, but his most recent performance against Leicester was of a different caliber.
His goal was somewhat lucky, though his earier effort he scuffed he should have scored.
But its what he did in the middle, and the threat he created from in there that gave us so much possession.

 

chateauferret Flag 24 Oct 16 3.56pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

I wasn't at the Leicester game and a lot of people seem to be criticising Cabaye.
However I have read two Sunday paper match reports,one made him man of the match overall and put him in their team of the day,and the other rated him Palace's best player.So it seems like he had a decent game to me.

Whatever one might have seen or not seen it doesn't to me make sense that a "creative midfielder" could be man of the match when his team lost 3 - 1 basically because they were overstretched in midfield for three-quarters of the match.

Whatever happened on Saturday though I do like the idea of Cabaye being played further forward and think he can influence the game more there provided we aren't being forced to play deep. Whether I'd willingly sacrifice Puncheon for him on a regular basis I don't know though - he was only there because Puncheon was out.

 


============
The Ferret
============

cpj Flag Kent 24 Oct 16 4.14pm

If the midfield was that bad, how come we had 55% possession? Surely the worrying fact is that we had 23 attempts on goal, 7 on target, yet only scored once. They had 4 shots on target and scored 3! The worry for me is at the ends of the pitch - not the middle.

 

Aray Flag South London 24 Oct 16 7.40pm

Originally posted by cpj

If the midfield was that bad, how come we had 55% possession? Surely the worrying fact is that we had 23 attempts on goal, 7 on target, yet only scored once. They had 4 shots on target and scored 3! The worry for me is at the ends of the pitch - not the middle.

Yup. Nailed on. Defence is porous and we're still not scoring

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Match analysis