You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Kelly
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Kelly


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
Dangermouse Flag Hastings 20 Nov 16 11.22am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Both Kelly and Townsend are being played out of their natural positions. We crucified Ward when he was also played out of position. Can't help feeling the blame is not wholly theirs!!!

A left footed winger playing on the left is hardly out of position. Yes we all know he likes to cut in from the right and shoot, but all wingers like to play on the "wrong" side occasionally and do that. Remember Townsend's one goal was cutting in from the left and scoring with his right foot. He's not playing well right now and I don't know why, but if we shift him then Wilf will actually be playing on the wrong side. The wingers should keep switching IMO anyway.
Is it true Tompkins can play right back? If so maybe time to play him there and Ward on the left as we know he can do a job there.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

cpj Flag Kent 20 Nov 16 11.32am

Originally posted by rossboss29

Shame we dont have anyone coming through the academy at left back. As someone else said, and spot on in my opinion, albeit kelly is out of position, he is offering nothing going forward and he is not defending well, - a limited defender who cannot defend. Should be used as a centre back in my opinion. Id stick fryers in- if he is not starting games he has no chance of a contract extension, also if someone is consistently bad you'd expect a bit of rotation.

At Fulham pre-season Croll played the last 20 mins at left-back and looked OK. Perhaps get him back from his loan at Exeter. Failing that, throw in the U23s LB - can't be any worse. Remember when Clyne came in under NW - nobody had heard of him and he did OK!

 

OldFella Flag London 20 Nov 16 12.01pm

Originally posted by comeonlad

Personally i think the lad is getting slated for one mistake , was our best player against Everton and i thought our best defender against Liverpool.
He is playing out of position which at this level against a team who just beat Barcelona with class in every department is immensely difficult ,come on get a grip.
Wardy had a terrible run of form , was shocking at left back but was defended by his fan club on here , a lot with short memories on here who know f*** all about football and spout through their arses.
End of the day were palace and just coming up short against the future League winners so get your feet back on the ground and lets get a few wins and stay up !!!

You've got to be a member of his immediate family...

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

m/k mick Flag milton keynes 20 Nov 16 12.24pm

There is a lot of criticism of kelly, but is it justified, in my opinion it is the midfielders that are causing the problems, great at attacking, at Burnley, puncheons mistakes and terrible corners led to thier goals, cabayes awful crosses put us under pressure, townsends dropped kelly in it yesterday, our midfielders are putting the defence under pressure, sort that out, but going forward they are as good as we have ever had

 

Reknaw Flag 20 Nov 16 1.18pm

Useless, out of his depth, cost us many-a-times already this season.

Can't wait for Pape's return.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 20 Nov 16 1.52pm

Originally posted by m/k mick

There is a lot of criticism of kelly, but is it justified, in my opinion it is the midfielders that are causing the problems, great at attacking, at Burnley, puncheons mistakes and terrible corners led to thier goals, cabayes awful crosses put us under pressure, townsends dropped kelly in it yesterday, our midfielders are putting the defence under pressure, sort that out, but going forward they are as good as we have ever had

Yes Townsend sold him out, but exactly what was he trying to do to remedy the situation?

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Inapickle Flag South West 20 Nov 16 4.05pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

Kelly not Exactly pulling up trees but two things to consider.

His only meant to be cover

He gets zero support from Townsend, who just so happened to shaft him today.

We certainly need an upgrade at LB, personally would consider Ledley until January but he his giving his all in tough circumstances

..yes, Townsend did him no favours, but City still had a lot to do to eventually score, that Toure bloke is a flipping tank (reminds me of that quite fast runner who keeps on winning the 100m) how do you stop him? once his mind is made up that's it, but we had three good opportunities to clear this ball and we paid the price, thinking about the game City really really put us under huge pressure during their goals and we just have to accept that yesterday they caused us to make them.

 

Username Flag Horsham 20 Nov 16 9.48pm

The biggest problem is Kelly's mistakes are caused by his lack of composure with the ball, not from bad defending. Both goals yesterday would have been averted if he was comfortable with the ball in tight situations.

In my opinion, he's a patch/squad player. He's the sort of guy who we can have on the bench and know that he'll come on when needed to shore things up, or manage for a couple of weeks to hold down a decent run of form. A couple of months as first choice left back though, and his deficiencies get more and more exposed.

I know Townsend is in a bad run of form at the moment, but I'd honestly consider playing him at left back (or even Sako after his 10 minute cameo included looking after Sterling quite well). At the very least, the two of them have the pace to a) get themselves out of trouble if their positioning isn't spot on and b) cover the rest of the back four like Souare does.

Both are also able to use the ball well and it gives us another option to supply Benteke/Wickham.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 21 Nov 16 8.23am

Against everton 6.2/10, only ledley and mandanda performed worse according to whoscored.com

Against liverpool 6.4/10, only chung and dann performed worse. Over the whole season kelly's performance has rated at 6.36, only mandanda and chungy out of the regular players have a worse overall score season to date.
[Link]

 

Skip Flag 21 Nov 16 12.34pm

Nowhere near good enough. At fault for their first goal and should have prevented the corner for their second. His airshot/miskick in front of the Holmesdale in the first half was embarrassing. Teams are now targeting him which is putting him under even more pressure.

He's been subbed quite a few times since his reintroduction to the side. Normally sprints off so quickly as if he appreciates being rescued.

Quite a few people on here criticize the decision to move on Murray, Gayle and Jedinak. At the moment I think we're missing Mariappa far more. Good squad player and would have slotted into this defence without letting anybody down.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 Nov 16 2.48pm

Originally posted by Skip

Nowhere near good enough. At fault for their first goal and should have prevented the corner for their second
. His airshot/miskick in front of the Holmesdale in the first half was embarrassing. Teams are now targeting him which is putting him under even more pressure.

He's been subbed quite a few times since his reintroduction to the side. Normally sprints off so quickly as if he appreciates being rescued.

Quite a few people on here criticize the decision to move on Murray, Gayle and Jedinak. At the moment I think we're missing Mariappa far more. Good squad player and would have slotted into this defence without letting anybody down.

His mistake didn't help but Townsend was more at fault. Also as was mentioned earlier we had plenty of opportunity to recover from his mistake.

Also what about the mistakes leading up to Townsend's stitch up? There were several contributing factors.

As for Mariappa I said the same at the weekend, given how Pards wants to play he would have been a good back up to keep.

That said, I don't think Kelly really deserves all the stick he is getting

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Kelly