You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew team selection and substitutions
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pardew team selection and substitutions


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
fan Flag Caterham 15 Dec 16 12.09am

When you make a substitution you need to tell the players what their roles will be. Bringing on a striker for a midfield player does alter the team and they switch off So the last sub did have an impact albeit a negative one. I cannot understand these changes and how many goals are we going to concede in the last 5/10 mins of games.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Dec 16 12.23am

Originally posted by DJ_NG

Yeah because our squad is so deep and we dont have another game in 3 days time...

So you risk a valuable point you almost have thinking about a game in 3 days time you're even more likely to lose? Of course you do. I suppose you ran over to the corner to clap and wave P45dew off.

 


COYP

Cy Bais Flag Minneapolis MN 15 Dec 16 12.27am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Flamini was decent in the first half actually.

McArthur was downright excellent. Taking him off was beyond stupid and sums up why he needs to be fired.

 

Blue'n'red Flag Field of Chels (Orpington) 15 Dec 16 12.41am

Isn't flamini off in January? Wouldn't be surprised to see Chungy go to ... playing them tonight was to put them in the shop window ... wrong game to do it though

 


They say hard work never hurt anyone ... but why take a chance?

DJ_NG Flag Torquay 15 Dec 16 12.45am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

So you risk a valuable point you almost have thinking about a game in 3 days time you're even more likely to lose? Of course you do. I suppose you ran over to the corner to clap and wave P45dew off.

would have been a long run from Torquay

My thinking is this JM is one of our best players,We were unlikely to win against UTD, we have a lot of games coming thick and fast, we have a paper thin squad. Silly risking a long term injury(muscle tear or other fatigue injury) and have him out till feb/march. He worked his gonads off for 85 mins tonight and will do the same saturday(another game where we are unlikely to win). We need to stay in touch until Jan when we can add to the squad and get some decent cover in.

 

cpj Flag Kent 15 Dec 16 9.03am

Originally posted by DJ_NG

would have been a long run from Torquay

My thinking is this JM is one of our best players,We were unlikely to win against UTD, we have a lot of games coming thick and fast, we have a paper thin squad. Silly risking a long term injury(muscle tear or other fatigue injury) and have him out till feb/march. He worked his gonads off for 85 mins tonight and will do the same saturday(another game where we are unlikely to win). We need to stay in touch until Jan when we can add to the squad and get some decent cover in.

Three minutes isn't going to make much difference in his fitness for Saturday. AP was going for Campbell scoring against a former club for the second game in a row (however unlikely that would be) so he could say he'd had a hunch he would do that, like on Saturday.

Thought the whole shape of the team was wrong. Zaha up front was ridiculous, as was playing McArthur out wide. Football is a simple game made complicated by people like Pardew. Play to our strengths and play people in their proper positions, and press the opposition rather than letting them have the ball whenever they want it.

 

beer man Flag Kent 15 Dec 16 9.18am

Originally posted by DJ_NG

would have been a long run from Torquay

My thinking is this JM is one of our best players,We were unlikely to win against UTD, we have a lot of games coming thick and fast, we have a paper thin squad. Silly risking a long term injury(muscle tear or other fatigue injury) and have him out till feb/march. He worked his gonads off for 85 mins tonight and will do the same saturday(another game where we are unlikely to win). We need to stay in touch until Jan when we can add to the squad and get some decent cover in.


And you think we're more likely to do so against Chelsea? We had, what would have been, a very good point in the bag until we were Pardewed again.

 

eagle184 Flag Sutton 15 Dec 16 9.23am

Taking McArthur off, who was playing his socks off and subbing him with a centre forward with 10 minutes-ish to go when we playing a team of Manure quality utter madness and IMO lost us the match!!

 

TopBoon Flag 15 Dec 16 9.36am

Flamini was injured. That's why he was subbed at HT.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Dec 16 9.42am

Originally posted by DJ_NG

Yeah because our squad is so deep and we dont have another game in 3 days time...

Realistically, the only bad substitution was Campbell for McArthur. I don't think it would have prevented the goal, that was just a piece of class, but it might have meant that Cabaye alone wasn't dealing with Pogba, and some cover was in place.

Otherwise I think our set up and play was excellent - First half Flamini and Cabaye worked really well togeather, and I thought we looked solid, though lacking offensive threat (which when you're playing a top team is acceptable).

Ledley for Flamini, reasonable, but our 'solidity' suffered, and we became looser, but did score (not to mention Ledley should have been booked for a handball and a penalty given).

Fryers, reasonable enough, defensive and at 1-1 holding on makes sense.

But McArthur for Campbell was just absurd. Zaha or Beneteke, yes, but we were being overrun in midfield, taking out a midfielder for an attacker looked like he was thinking we might nick it (it was a gamblers choice, not a tactical one).

Either way, I don't think the substitutions realistically affected the result, but that last one, with five minutes or so to go, 1-1 against a United side that have been dominating the game, was inept - A point would have been a good result for us, and for Pardew - We're far less likely to gain a point at the weekend, and preserving players for the Chelsea game is stupid.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 15 Dec 16 9.44am

Originally posted by TopBoon

Flamini was injured. That's why he was subbed at HT.

Finally, the truth reaches this thread. Seriously there's enough reason to dump him without making s*** up.
I can only think he subbed Macca to save him, but I never understand how not playing 7 minutes could be of any real benefit to a player. If it was to run down the clock, you don't sub Macca, surely. I'm baffled by the decision. It's so bloody frustrating losing by one goal every time. We actually needed a few hammering and he would of been gone by now.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Dec 16 9.46am

Originally posted by DJ_NG

Yeah because our squad is so deep and we dont have another game in 3 days time...

Which do you think we were most likely to get something out of. A game where we're 1-1 with Man Utd already, or one where we're going to be playing Chelsea who are utterly rampant at the minute, for 90 minutes.

Flamini and Fryers substitution make sense. But Campbell for McArthur really doesn't, 4 minutes on the clock, 1-1 and we've barely threatened them and they're overrunning our midfield....

Either way, I don't think having McArthur on prevents the goal, it was pure class (and something like 120m in transfer fees and 450k a week in wages in the making).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

CJr94 Flag Holmesdale Road 15 Dec 16 9.56am

Originally posted by Hutchyeagle

Pardew lost us that game tonight...How can Flamini play Premier league football ..he was useless in his pomp ...let alone now
And as for the subs....should have left Lee on, he was working hard. Not creating a lot but defending well. And taking McArthur off...only a madman would do that..and maybe that's what he is...he's certainly deluded and far too arrogant
Every time he makes a non enforced sub the whole team and even us fans panic !

That is key. He is a key player for us. Only god knows why he took him off. Too scared to take Cabaye off.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 15 Dec 16 10.28am

Yet not afraid to not play him. Sorry stop with that bulls***, Pardew is many things, but afraid to upset big players is not one of his problems. He may of had a very good reason for the sub and man would I like to hear it. Should of been a midfielder if Macca had to go off, but we are paper thin squad wise it seems.
What we have though is far better than our points tally IMO, just have to be managed better. I'd take Rowett today if offered, prem experience or not.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

TopBoon Flag 15 Dec 16 11.28am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Finally, the truth reaches this thread. Seriously there's enough reason to dump him without making s*** up.
I can only think he subbed Macca to save him, but I never understand how not playing 7 minutes could be of any real benefit to a player. If it was to run down the clock, you don't sub Macca, surely. I'm baffled by the decision. It's so bloody frustrating losing by one goal every time. We actually needed a few hammering and he would of been gone by now.

Yes, according to the journalists that he spoke to, Flamini has a tight groin due to lack of game time, but hopes to be ok for Chelsea on Sat.

 

The Dolphin Flag 15 Dec 16 1.27pm

In my eyes Flamini was good given he was verry match rusty and I hope he plays from now on - much moresolid with him and Cabaye lookedbetter as wel.
The late sub was a shockr though - a real shocker1

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew team selection and substitutions