You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player Ratings vs Bournemouth
November 16 2026 10.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player Ratings vs Bournemouth


Jules111 Flag Preston, Lancashire 31 Jan 17 10.16pm

Hennesey - 7
Solid performance, handling and kicking were decent.

Ward - 7
Put in a good shift on the right and worked tirelessly all evening.

Dann - 8
Quality performance from the skipper. Great finish for the goal as well. Looked like the Scott Dann of old.

Tomkins - 8
Superb display, was throwing himself into tackles and wore his heart on his sleeve.

Delaney - 8
Damo was also class this evening, marshalling the defence and leading by example.

PVA - 7
Steady debut, has plenty of pace and looks great going forward. Gives us that natural balance again.

Macca - 7
Put in a great shift and worked his socks off for the team. Unlucky with a curling effort 2nd half.

Cabaye - 7
Calm and composed on the ball and did well alongside punch

Puncheon - 7
Deployed in a deeper role and had his best game for months. Worked well with YC.

Zaha - 8
Outstanding again. Makes such a difference when he plays. Tormented the left back, time and time again. Unlucky not to score a couple.

Benteke - 8
Led the line well, first touch was class and deserved his goal.

Subs
Townsend - 8
Worked his socks off when he came on, and delivered a great cross for the goal.

Ledley - 7
Solid, no nonense display. Tightened things up in the last 15.

Flamini -
Not on long enough to mark

All in all a superb away performance, defended well and looked threatening going forward. Finally Big Sam is leaving his mark on the team. Fully deserved 3 points.

The palace rollercoaster back underway!!

 

merganser Flag 31 Jan 17 10.23pm

Thanks for that, Jules.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 01 Feb 17 12.43am

Listen the lads played better today but I think they are still way off their best so 7's and 8's for that many? No chance. I'm buzzing with the result but mate I was nervous as hell the last 20 mins we sat back so deep and lucky enough Bournemouth didn't do anything with possession they had.

Hennesey - 6

Ward - 6

Dann - 8

Tomkins - 6

Delaney - 6

PVA - 6

Macca - 6

Cabaye - 6

Puncheon - 6

Zaha - 8

Benteke - 7

 

Mad4palace Flag 01 Feb 17 12.48am

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

Listen the lads played better today but I think they are still way off their best so 7's and 8's for that many? No chance. I'm buzzing with the result but mate I was nervous as hell the last 20 mins we sat back so deep and lucky enough Bournemouth didn't do anything with possession they had.

They didn't do anything with their possession because we contained them well and Sam's game plan worked. Thought it was a little more nervy with Ledley in there but we did well defending.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 01 Feb 17 12.54am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

They didn't do anything with their possession because we contained them well and Sam's game plan worked. Thought it was a little more nervy with Ledley in there but we did well defending.

King had a free header that he should have scored and the ball fell to one of their players at the back post but it bounced off his thigh...for me that was Bournemouth wasting chances rather than being contained.

I think we deserved the 3pts though. Wilf was dangerous, they seemed to double up on him as well. Dann made the difference at the back today. His organising of the defence was key.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 01 Feb 17 3.07am

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

Listen the lads played better today but I think they are still way off their best so 7's and 8's for that many? No chance. I'm buzzing with the result but mate I was nervous as hell the last 20 mins we sat back so deep and lucky enough Bournemouth didn't do anything with possession they had.

Hennesey - 6

Ward - 6

Dann - 8

Tomkins - 6

Delaney - 6

PVA - 6

Macca - 6

Cabaye - 6

Puncheon - 6

Zaha - 8

Benteke - 7

6 for Macca is well harsh. He was everywhere and kept things ticking brilliantly I thought.

 

The_Aviator Flag Rochester 01 Feb 17 3.29am

Originally posted by sprites 6 for Macca is well harsh. He was everywhere and kept things ticking brilliantly I thought.

Agreed! Jimmy put in such a shift today he was totally spent when he was subbed off... could hardly walk.

Agree with the OP's performance assessments overall.

Townsend was clearly trying hard when he came on. I'm glad he's not going back to the Geordies now. Good show!

 

twist Flag Miami, Florida 01 Feb 17 4.55am

yeah anyone giving Macca a 6 for that is fookin blind, ran his nutz off, in a good way (if thats possible).

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 01 Feb 17 8.43am

Originally posted by twist

yeah anyone giving Macca a 6 for that is fookin blind, ran his nutz off, in a good way (if thats possible).

Depends what you expect from your best centre mid I guess. For effort its a 10 but for overall play it was not.

He was totally knackered at the end I will give you that. The lads did what they needed to do to contain Bournemouth. I thought the first half we were better on the ball. Second half, after taking the lead we were generally poor in possession but I thought we were solid at the back.

It was interesting to watch Bournemouth who perhaps were having an off day, but apart from Wilshere, would a single of their team have got into our 1st 11? They played the ball about with ease, always looked comfortable in possession, but had no cutting edge...and yet not one player stood out as better than ours except for Wilshere.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 01 Feb 17 8.56am

Harry Redknapp on talksport said 'we looked strong and there was only one winner with Bournemouth crosses. Bournemouth ran out of ideas'

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Part Time James Flag 01 Feb 17 9.25am

Pleased to see the ratings after a win! Agree with Zaha getting one of your higher ratings. Was MotM for me. Often unfairly maligned by the pundits, I thought he showed he was truly up for the fight last night and in my opinion he almost always is, just doesn't always get the chance to play his game.

 




Sportyteacher Flag London 01 Feb 17 9.35am

Delighted and really encouraged by last night's result. 'Team Palace' very much prepped and playing with concentrated, tuned-in vigour. The team will need the same degree of application for Saturday's game vs. Sunderland who pulled off commendable defensive display against Spurs last night.

My one nagging concern is the number of needless yellow cards being picked up by CPFC players.

 

Part Time James Flag 01 Feb 17 9.42am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Delighted and really encouraged by last night's result. 'Team Palace' very much prepped and playing with concentrated, tuned-in vigour. The team will need the same degree of application for Saturday's game vs. Sunderland who pulled off commendable defensive display against Spurs last night.

My one nagging concern is the number of needless yellow cards being picked up by CPFC players.

Agreed, but I was amazed to see that Bournemouth didn't get any. In the first half most of the stupid fouls were Bournemouth, but the ref let them go. Not having a go at the ref, but I think by the time he saw the need to start booking players, it was Palace on the back foot and making all the niggly fouls.

 




We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 01 Feb 17 9.44am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Delighted and really encouraged by last night's result. 'Team Palace' very much prepped and playing with concentrated, tuned-in vigour. The team will need the same degree of application for Saturday's game vs. Sunderland who pulled off commendable defensive display against Spurs last night.

My one nagging concern is the number of needless yellow cards being picked up by CPFC players.

Disagree. Last night we made the type of cynical fouls that broke up Bournemouth's play that they have done to us a few times. We desperately needed to get a bit more nasty/clever (depends which way you look at it).

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

OneWayTicketToMars Flag Selsdon 01 Feb 17 9.55am

All I know is what a f******* difference Wilf makes ... looked to me like the team was wanting to play and win. Confidence just confident can do it.
Magic Wilf just magic.

 


Record crowd 51,482 - The Whitehorse was rocking - Second Div Champs 1978 - 79 ... 'wot a night !

paperhat Flag croydon 01 Feb 17 10.01am

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Delighted and really encouraged by last night's result. 'Team Palace' very much prepped and playing with concentrated, tuned-in vigour. The team will need the same degree of application for Saturday's game vs. Sunderland who pulled off commendable defensive display against Spurs last night.

My one nagging concern is the number of needless yellow cards being picked up by CPFC players.

we were playing 'smart' as so many other teams have done to us. the good thing about it is that we do now have a little depth so if someone does get a onematch ban, we have someone else to slot into their spot.

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Sportyteacher Flag London 01 Feb 17 1.45pm

Originally posted by paperhat

we were playing 'smart' as so many other teams have done to us. the good thing about it is that we do now have a little depth so if someone does get a onematch ban, we have someone else to slot into their spot.

Irrespective of the reason for incurring yellow cards, the reality is that they do mount with eventual players' suspension on top of the risk of other players being injured, seriously affecting us within remaining key games.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 01 Feb 17 1.55pm

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Disagree. Last night we made the type of cynical fouls that broke up Bournemouth's play that they have done to us a few times. We desperately needed to get a bit more nasty/clever (depends which way you look at it).

Agree Bournemouth were very physical at SP and we were a bit timid. Got a feeling new boy Luka will toughen us up

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player Ratings vs Bournemouth