This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| Pussay Patrol |
|
|---|---|
|
How will he rank as one of the best midfielders in the Premiership and for England?
Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah |
|
|
Now he can finally settle down with James Corden in a big pit of unfunny TV. Good luck Lamps.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
How will he rank as one of the best midfielders in the Premiership and for England? A bit of a leading question? In terms of the comparison that is normally made (i.e. Gerrard and Lampard), I think Gerrard is consistently overrated and Lampard consistently underrated. For the supposed golden generation, he would still have probably ranked below both the others though (including Scholes). He contributed a much bigger goal threat, and offered more assists as well. But I think the other two were overall better footballers. Edited by OknotOK (02 Feb 2017 12.11pm)
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show |
|
|
Originally posted by OknotOK
A bit of a leading question? In terms of the comparison that is normally made (i.e. Gerrard and Lampard), I think Gerrard is consistently overrated and Lampard consistently underrated. For the supposed golden generation, he would still have probably ranked below both the others though (including Scholes). He contributed a much bigger goal threat, and offered more assists as well. But I think the other two were overall better footballers. Edited by OknotOK (02 Feb 2017 12.11pm) Very well summed up, agree with all of that. Worth noting that Lampard reached double figures in 10 consecutive Premier League seasons for Chelsea including his 22 goal haul in 09/10. By contrast Gerrard only managed that feat 4 times in total, so it can't be understated what a fantastic achievement that is for a midfielder.
We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold... |
|
|
He will do well as a coach given time - there are some of the best in the Prem right now to learn from.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
Not sure why we always need to play one player off against another like the Messi / Ronaldo argument. Why can't we accept they are brilliant individuals in their own right? In any case re: the Lamps / Gerrard comparison. Although Lampard scored more and won more honours, Lampard was a cog in a very good team but Chelsea would have still been succesfull without him. Gerrard carried that Liverpool team for years and his performances in 04/05 winning the champions league were sublime, i'd go as far as to say he won the champions league single handed, that was a bang average Liverpool team. Scholes was the overrated one Xabi Alonso anyone? It wasn't stuffed with top quality (Hyppia and Carragher were the best of the rest) but there were some quality players in there. But the rest is probably right. Gerrard carried a mostly average team most years to in/around the top 4. Whereas Lampard and Scholes were vital parts of teams stuffed full of talent. But Scholes was the best of them Edited by OknotOK (02 Feb 2017 2.26pm)
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show |
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
Not sure why we always need to play one player off against another like the Messi / Ronaldo argument. Why can't we accept they are brilliant individuals in their own right? In any case re: the Lamps / Gerrard comparison. Although Lampard scored more and won more honours, Lampard was a cog in a very good team but Chelsea would have still been succesfull without him. Gerrard carried that Liverpool team for years and his performances in 04/05 winning the champions league were sublime, i'd go as far as to say he won the champions league single handed, that was a bang average Liverpool team. Scholes was the overrated one I couldn't disagree with this any more. For starters, Lampard and Gerrard have been the pair that for me ultimately demonstrate the myth of the Premier League. Massive stars at their clubs, banging goals in for fun, winning trophies. Yet takeaway the likes of Alonso, Ballack, Makelele etc and come international tournament time they're exposed. England can't keep the ball and we're reduced to watching Lampard unable to influence the game, and Gerrard spunking it 80 yards into the front row or shooting every time he gets the ball. Scholes on the other hand had class, vision and an ability to play the game that few English players have. His reward for this was to be shunted out to the left in Euro 2004 because he didn't have the profile that the others did. Lampard and Gerrard were the icons of their teams so got way more attention in the media. Scholes is the only one who would compare to someone like Xavi. I wish we could have seen more of an England midfield which had Scholes and a fully fit Owen Hargreaves together. That would have been a combination miles better than Gerrard and Lampard. Edit: Also worth noting that Liverpool were 3-0 down to Milan in that final before Dietmar Hamann came on to partner Alonso. Edited by Username (03 Feb 2017 3.29pm)
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
I couldn't disagree with this any more. For starters, Lampard and Gerrard have been the pair that for me ultimately demonstrate the myth of the Premier League. Massive stars at their clubs, banging goals in for fun, winning trophies. Yet takeaway the likes of Alonso, Ballack, Makelele etc and come international tournament time they're exposed. England can't keep the ball and we're reduced to watching Lampard unable to influence the game, and Gerrard spunking it 80 yards into the front row or shooting every time he gets the ball. Scholes on the other hand had class, vision and an ability to play the game that few English players have. His reward for this was to be shunted out to the left in Euro 2004 because he didn't have the profile that the others did. Lampard and Gerrard were the icons of their teams so got way more attention in the media. Scholes is the only one who would compare to someone like Xavi. I wish we could have seen more of an England midfield which had Scholes and a fully fit Owen Hargreaves together. That would have been a combination miles better than Gerrard and Lampard. Edit: Also worth noting that Liverpool were 3-0 down to Milan in that final before Dietmar Hamann came on to partner Alonso. Edited by Username (03 Feb 2017 3.29pm) Agreed. Scholes was the only one who actually believed in possession of the football rather than typical "blood and thunder" English style football. Could have played in any country and would have been successful. Tiny winky though and ginger to boot.
"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show |
|
| Pussay Patrol |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Username
I couldn't disagree with this any more. For starters, Lampard and Gerrard have been the pair that for me ultimately demonstrate the myth of the Premier League. Massive stars at their clubs, banging goals in for fun, winning trophies. Yet takeaway the likes of Alonso, Ballack, Makelele etc and come international tournament time they're exposed. England can't keep the ball and we're reduced to watching Lampard unable to influence the game, and Gerrard spunking it 80 yards into the front row or shooting every time he gets the ball. Scholes on the other hand had class, vision and an ability to play the game that few English players have. His reward for this was to be shunted out to the left in Euro 2004 because he didn't have the profile that the others did. Lampard and Gerrard were the icons of their teams so got way more attention in the media. Scholes is the only one who would compare to someone like Xavi. I wish we could have seen more of an England midfield which had Scholes and a fully fit Owen Hargreaves together. That would have been a combination miles better than Gerrard and Lampard. Edit: Also worth noting that Liverpool were 3-0 down to Milan in that final before Dietmar Hamann came on to partner Alonso. Edited by Username (03 Feb 2017 3.29pm) Some contradictions there, surely Scholes wouldn't have been as effective without Roy Keane alongside? and where was Scholes in Man Utd's finest hour ? Oh yes suspended. They still won it Not knocking him, a class player no doubt but people hold him in the same regard as players like Pirlo - sorry but he was not quite on that level. Pirlo dominated the midfield and ran the game. Don't remember Scholes doing that
Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah |
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
Some contradictions there, surely Scholes wouldn't have been as effective without Roy Keane alongside? and where was Scholes in Man Utd's finest hour ? Oh yes suspended. They still won it Not knocking him, a class player no doubt but people hold him in the same regard as players like Pirlo - sorry but he was not quite on that level. Pirlo dominated the midfield and ran the game. Don't remember Scholes doing that Different positions. Today Scholes would be a number 10, Pirlo def mid.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Pussay Patrol
Some contradictions there, surely Scholes wouldn't have been as effective without Roy Keane alongside? and where was Scholes in Man Utd's finest hour ? Oh yes suspended. They still won it Not knocking him, a class player no doubt but people hold him in the same regard as players like Pirlo - sorry but he was not quite on that level. Pirlo dominated the midfield and ran the game. Don't remember Scholes doing that Point is, Lampard and Gerrard have always been picked out as the stars and the heartbeat of their team. Scholes rarely was. In fact, Roy Keane was probably more celebrated as a player when they played together, and was also missing in the final. As good as Pirlo? It's a matter of opinion, and there positions have never really been the same, but I'd rephrase it and say that even if not quite as good as their continental counterparts, of various England midfielders in the last 25 years Scholes is probably the only one who could have done a decent job of playing with Pirlo/Xavi/Iniesta etc.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
Point is, Lampard and Gerrard have always been picked out as the stars and the heartbeat of their team. Scholes rarely was. In fact, Roy Keane was probably more celebrated as a player when they played together, and was also missing in the final. As good as Pirlo? It's a matter of opinion, and there positions have never really been the same, but I'd rephrase it and say that even if not quite as good as their continental counterparts, of various England midfielders in the last 25 years Scholes is probably the only one who could have done a decent job of playing with Pirlo/Xavi/Iniesta etc. I think its very hard to properly evaluate our best players as so few have tested themselves abroad. Beckham did it with a modicum of success, Steve Macmanaman (apologies hol spelling police) a little more so imo. Kudos to Joe Hart for giving it a go. I wish more would.
|
|
| Pussay Patrol |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Username
Point is, Lampard and Gerrard have always been picked out as the stars and the heartbeat of their team. Scholes rarely was. In fact, Roy Keane was probably more celebrated as a player when they played together, and was also missing in the final. As good as Pirlo? It's a matter of opinion, and there positions have never really been the same, but I'd rephrase it and say that even if not quite as good as their continental counterparts, of various England midfielders in the last 25 years Scholes is probably the only one who could have done a decent job of playing with Pirlo/Xavi/Iniesta etc. Although not the same type of player I used Pirlo as he is so good he can dominate a midfield and dictate a game, likewise Xavi and Zidane. People talking about Scholes in the same light are way off the mark. He was a fantastic passer and weighed in with goals but he had just as many flaws. Maybe cos he was a mainstay during Man Utd's zenith years people elevate him a little too highly. As I said before Liverpool would have got nowhere near their Champs league triumph without Gerrard, Man Utd would have prospered with or without Scholes, in fact they did!
Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.