You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jimmy yellow card
November 16 2026 10.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jimmy yellow card


n wales eagles Flag llandudno 27 Feb 17 7.38am

Having viewed this several times was certainly not a dive does the ref have the option to review his decision and cancel the card

 

pink Flag Northfleet, Kent 27 Feb 17 7.44am

Sadly no.

 


" I hate those f@cking northern monkeys " The late Lenny Mclean.

chateauferret Flag 27 Feb 17 7.59am

F***ing ridiculous.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Littlebogreek Flag 27 Feb 17 8.21am

Really poor decision. You know it's a really bad decision when even Shearer is saying its bad.

 

leejaneagles Flag 27 Feb 17 8.32am

Why can you get red cards overturned but not yellows? You can't even argue it's because a red is more impactful because if you get 2 wrong yellows in a game you get a red and that red can't be contested.

That's just odd. Either referee's decision is final or you can appeal all cards. Everyone knows it was the wrong decision but now we could be without McCarthur at a crucial game towards the end of the season because if this yellow.

 

Face in Wetherspoons Flag 27 Feb 17 8.53am

Do Referee Assessors not have a role to play in this when sending in their match reports ? If blatantly wrong decisions in respect of disciplinary actions cannot be corrected then what is the point in having an Assessor in the first place ? The referee on Saturday was so poor in respect of his decision making that it was embarrassing but, Assessor or not, nothing will be done about it.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 27 Feb 17 9.18am

Originally posted by Face in Wetherspoons

Do Referee Assessors not have a role to play in this when sending in their match reports ? If blatantly wrong decisions in respect of disciplinary actions cannot be corrected then what is the point in having an Assessor in the first place ? The referee on Saturday was so poor in respect of his decision making that it was embarrassing but, Assessor or not, nothing will be done about it.

Willo will tell you that the ref will be forensically assessed (whatever that means), told he had a great game and probably given a bonus! Cant have refs being told theyre useless can we?

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 27 Feb 17 9.34am

Originally posted by the silurian

Willo will tell you that the ref will be forensically assessed (whatever that means), told he had a great game and probably given a bonus! Cant have refs being told theyre useless can we?

His response might take a while - I hear he's on holiday in Saudi Arabia at the moment

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jimmy yellow card