You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bizarrely.......
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bizarrely.......


Jules111 Flag Preston, Lancashire 07 Mar 17 1.44pm

We seem a much better side without James Mcarthur in the team, and I really rate him as one of our best players.

I suppose it goes to show the best individual players don't always make the best team.

Thoughts?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Mar 17 1.48pm

Yeah a bit of a balance issue but when we're playing 3 in the middle who need to be more defensive than Puncheon then he'll be invaluable. We'll also need fresh legs and cover for any with injuries and suspensions. Plus they have to earn to keep their place or win it back. Very healthy situation rather than before, knackering the same players out, and it's possible Jimmy has been overused and rushed back too soon last season.

 


COYP

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 07 Mar 17 1.49pm

Yeah really rate him also but Cabaye was very good on Saturday p and great to bring McCarthur off the bench for him when he tires. Think having the two of them competing for one position is a very good thing. Fortunately Luka has allowed us to do that.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 07 Mar 17 2.03pm

Just goes to show you what a good Manager Sam is.
Major decisions already made with Dann,Delanay and Jimmy Mac.
Nobody on Hol would have replaced Jimmy Mac.
Still early days need to do it week in week out.
Watford next.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 07 Mar 17 2.44pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Just goes to show you what a good Manager Sam is.
Major decisions already made with Dann,Delanay and Jimmy Mac.
Nobody on Hol would have replaced Jimmy Mac.
Still early days need to do
it week in week out.
Watford next.

Exactly what I was thinking. He can actually suss things out in training that the previous incumbent had no clue about.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

chateauferret Flag 07 Mar 17 3.12pm

He has of course not "dropped" McArthur but is playing to his strengths. Him coming off the bench with fresh legs and not getting tired out is a marked imprivement in closing games out compared with Ledley, say, and is possible with Cabaye and Milivojevic available. Compared with the Pardew era of shipping goals after having to take McArthur off.

 


============
The Ferret
============

twist Flag Miami, Florida 07 Mar 17 3.41pm

What is JP giving us at the moment that JM cannot ? JP does pass the ball around better up front, agreed but JM is not far behind in this regard. JM also rarely loses the ball in possession, and this is JP's biggest weakness.
JM is also much better than JP defensively.

So why JP>JM in BS's mind ?

 

A89M Flag Streatham 07 Mar 17 3.48pm

Originally posted by twist

What is JP giving us at the moment that JM cannot ? JP does pass the ball around better up front, agreed but JM is not far behind in this regard. JM also rarely loses the ball in possession, and this is JP's biggest weakness.
JM is also much better than JP defensively.

So why JP>JM in BS's mind ?

This is the very same question I have been asking myself.. But we've won the last two games and kept clean sheets in both, so I can't complain..

 

bodge Flag 07 Mar 17 4.34pm

With Luka in the team its perm two from three. As Punch has been made captain its probaly 50/50 very unlucky for either player but healthy for our squad.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 07 Mar 17 5.46pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

He has of course not "dropped" McArthur but is playing to his strengths. Him coming off the bench with fresh legs and not getting tired out is a marked imprivement in closing games out compared with Ledley, say, and is possible with Cabaye and Milivojevic available. Compared with the Pardew era of shipping goals after having to take McArthur off.

McArthur has been dropped along with Ledley, McArthur has made the bench. I like McArthur he is a 100% player, but does he fit into the team shape now? Wouldn't be surprised to see him go in the summer.

It has been proven in the past the best 11 players you have got, don't usually make the best team. 66 world cup is easiest example, Greaves who was the best striker, but was left out as didn't fit team pattern.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 07 Mar 17 5.49pm

Originally posted by Painter

McArthur has been dropped along with Ledley, McArthur has made the bench. I like McArthur he is a 100% player, but does he fit into the team shape now? Wouldn't be surprised to see him go in the summer.

It has been proven in the past the best 11 players you have got, don't usually make the best team. 66 world cup is easiest example, Greaves who was the best striker, but was left out as didn't fit team pattern.

Can't see James McArthur going in the summer. He is an integral part of the team/squad. He could be back as a regular starter before the end of the season if for either an injury or loss of form.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Mar 17 6.07pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Can't see James McArthur going in the summer. He is an integral part of the team/squad. He could be back as a regular starter before the end of the season if for either an injury or loss of form.

Precisely. People forget it's a squad game now and 20-30 league games is possible on stand by. He's already played nearly every game so far anyway.

 


COYP

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 07 Mar 17 9.27pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

He has of course not "dropped" McArthur but is playing to his strengths. Him coming off the bench with fresh legs and not getting tired out is a marked imprivement in closing games out compared with Ledley, say, and is possible with Cabaye and Milivojevic available. Compared with the Pardew era of shipping goals after having to take McArthur off.

THIS!

Pardew left our midfield wafer thin. Sam has beefed it up. We are a better team as a result, and the results are bearing that out.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 08 Mar 17 11.33am

Drop Puncheon!

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 08 Mar 17 11.43am

Originally posted by chateauferret

He has of course not "dropped" McArthur but is playing to his strengths. Him coming off the bench with fresh legs and not getting tired out is a marked imprivement in closing games out compared with Ledley, say, and is possible with Cabaye and Milivojevic available. Compared with the Pardew era of shipping goals after having to take McArthur off.

Perhaps we can go all Eddie Jones, and call McArthur a "Finisher"

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Palace Down Under Flag Sydney 08 Mar 17 11.50am

Originally posted by Rogers Don

Drop Puncheon!

I would possibly have agreed a month ago, but this mini-resurgence has definitely convinced me otherwise. Whilst we're used to seeing Jimmy Mac in the heart of midfield, and he's been an unsung hero in many games, Punch offers more of a threat going forward - just look at the WBA match, where he's having a go from in and around the box with regularity. Now that we've got Luka, Punch has got a bit more freedom to roam. Having JM on the bench is brilliant - and if Cabaye goes back to forgetting how to play, he's a more than capable replacement.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Mar 17 12.21pm

Jimmy hasn't been dropped due to form and I'm sure he knows that if not told so, which I reckon Sam would do. He makes sure there's communication going on in his squads. I read that if a player isn't pulling his weight he makes sure the captain and 1 or 2 strivers get him to up his game.

Really surprising how 2 underperforming players in Townsend and Punch improve significantly and one just about delivering in Cabaye as well yet one of 2 our most consistent performers in Jimmy is dropped/rested/ready for later or when required. Nobody saw all of that coming. I expect we've become so used to the same team all season.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 08 Mar 17 12.23pm

Originally posted by Palace Down Under

I would possibly have agreed a month ago, but this mini-resurgence has definitely convinced me otherwise. Whilst we're used to seeing Jimmy Mac in the heart of midfield, and he's been an unsung hero in many games, Punch offers more of a threat going forward - just look at the WBA match, where he's having a go from in and around the box with regularity. Now that we've got Luka, Punch has got a bit more freedom to roam. Having JM on the bench is brilliant - and if Cabaye goes back to forgetting how to play, he's a more than capable replacement.

Yeah and wouldn't be surprised to see Punch rested for big games with 3 tackling interceptors in the middle with Punch coming on later if needed. Bold decision making.

 


COYP

slubglurge Flag welling 08 Mar 17 12.30pm

Since hes been here im sure Sam would have watched footage of every goal we have conceded and he would have noticed that in three home games Macca lost his runner who scored each time. Lanzini(W Ham) Can(Liverpool) and Toure(City) he may feel that he doesn't track back well enough

 


You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bizarrely.......