You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: L'pool v Palace
November 16 2026 9.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref: L'pool v Palace


Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2
BarEagle Flag Monmouth 24 Apr 17 11.01am

Originally posted by Willo

No two incidents are identical in every shape or form and the referees positioning and sight lines can be different as well.
Also at times Assistants get involved and others they do not depending on how far they are from the incident.

It's also dark at night

 

Littlebogreek Flag 24 Apr 17 12.02pm

Originally posted by peterg

Thought he had a good game overall. The penalty claim when Kelly clipped Coutinho was marginal and it would have been a harsh call if he had given it. It looks like the luck with penalties is running our way at last. We're not getting them, but they're not being given against us either - we were lucky to get away with the Townsend handball at Chelsea. We did get the Arsenal pen which looked 100% at first sight - although Cluttenfunt would have booked Townsend for a dive.

Personally I thought it was a nailed on pen and we were lucky to get away with it. Can't for the life of me see why Coutinho doesn't go down (fair play to him that he didn't) If he does, its a pen all day long. We get angry when players go down easily but if they don't you end up with situations like this.

 

Eltham Eagle Flag 24 Apr 17 12.11pm

I thought the officials had a pretty decent game. Few mistakes, but let the game flow.

I was more annoyed the Carra was in the commentary box. There was a lot more bias there!

 


Now here's Wright, his first chance to see what he can do, and he's through, it's Wright, ohhhh what an impact by the substitute. And it's Ian Wright who's sent the Palace fans into ecstasy!

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 24 Apr 17 12.18pm

I have just re-watched the foul on Tomkins. That was outrageously bad.

That was a poor refereeing decision.
Coutinho should have had a pen.
Bent eke should not have had a card.

The reffing was poor imo. Problem is it was better than normal. At least Clattenburg is leaving - he is the pits.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 24 Apr 17 12.21pm

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

Personally I thought it was a nailed on pen and we were lucky to get away with it. Can't for the life of me see why Coutinho doesn't go down (fair play to him that he didn't) If he does, its a pen all day long. We get angry when players go down easily but if they don't you end up with situations like this.

My thoughts exactly. also, It's these kinds of decisions that need to be given if diving is to be eradicated from the game.

Unfortunately, I had to watch the highlights on MOTD, so I can't comment on any other incident!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Apr 17 12.21pm

Originally posted by BarEagle

I have just re-watched the foul on Tomkins. That was outrageously bad.

That was a poor refereeing decision.
Coutinho should have had a pen.
Bent eke should not have had a card.

The reffing was poor imo. Problem is it was better than normal. At least Clattenburg is leaving - he is the pits.

Considered as one of the world's best referees by those who know much more about these things than both you or I.He will be a sad loss to the PL.

NOT commenting any more about Mark on this thread as it will only go one way and will get de-railed from the matter under discussion.

Edited by Willo (24 Apr 2017 12.22pm)

 

peterg Flag Anerley 24 Apr 17 12.29pm

Considered by one of the world's worst referees by those who have actually watched him screw up match after match.

 


The right place at the right time

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 12.44pm

Originally posted by Willo

Considered as one of the world's best referees by those who know much more about these things than both you or I.He will be a sad loss to the PL.

Depends what you think are success criteria for referees.

Ensuring Man U and their ilk get favourable decisions? Excellent.
Keeping teams lower down the league where they belong? Quite good, although Leiceister shouldn't have been allowed to win the league.
Letting so-called elite players get away with blue murder? Excellent.
Licking the bottoms of senior members of the world football establishments? Excellent.
Courting the media and getting his name in the papers? Excellent.
Ensuring fair play and correct decision making on the field? Errrm....
Recognised by fans of all clubs as impartial, dispassionate and fair? Aye, right.

If he were the paragon you make him out to be his departure would not have been greeted with the joy that it has been. The sooner he and his like are gone the better.


Edited by chateauferret (24 Apr 2017 12.47pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

peterg Flag Anerley 24 Apr 17 4.58pm

Totally up himself? Tick

Originally posted by chateauferret

Depends what you think are success criteria for referees.

Ensuring Man U and their ilk get favourable decisions? Excellent.
Keeping teams lower down the league where they belong? Quite good, although Leiceister shouldn't have been allowed to win the league.
Letting so-called elite players get away with blue murder? Excellent.
Licking the bottoms of senior members of the world football establishments? Excellent.
Courting the media and getting his name in the papers? Excellent.
Ensuring fair play and correct decision making on the field? Errrm....
Recognised by fans of all clubs as impartial, dispassionate and fair? Aye, right.

If he were the paragon you make him out to be his departure would not have been greeted with the joy that it has been. The sooner he and his like are gone the better.


Edited by chateauferret (24 Apr 2017 12.47pm)

 


The right place at the right time

npn Flag Crowborough 24 Apr 17 5.03pm

Liverpool missed out on a nailed on penalty, which surely would have been given if he'd gone down (when will the refs realise that awarding the foul even if the player stays on his feet is the best way to combat diving).

Benteke's card was harsh, but I understand why he gave it.

Fouls on Tomkins was nasty, but I'm also forgiving him just giving the yellow as it didn't look that bad in full speed (nailed on yellow, of course, but at that stage in the game, we would have rolled around in agony for a bad case of split ends, as would every other team)

 

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 7.30pm

Meanwhile over in the FA Cup Pawson was f***ing up one of the semi-finals.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 2 of 2 << First< 1 2

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref: L'pool v Palace