This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Battle of the left backs
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Woolsy Essex 19 Apr 17 10.33am |
|
|
Next season we'll have 3 quality left backs. Patrick van Aanholt, Pape Souaré, Jeffrey Schlupp
Who should be first choice?
|
chateauferret 19 Apr 17 1.24pm |
|
|
After that horrible injury there must be at least a chance that Souare won't get back to where he was. Hope that's not the case, obviously.
============ The Ferret ============
|
CPFC9404 Portland,Maine 19 Apr 17 1.33pm |
|
|
I think Souare would be first choice and if Zaha goes(hopefully not) Van Aanholt or Schlupp can play on the left wing.
Speroni would've saved it!
|
Direwolf Lincoln 19 Apr 17 1.37pm |
|
|
I think Sam favours VA and will continue to do so even if Papa returns.
|
Crystal_Clear Belfast 19 Apr 17 6.35pm |
|
|
I would say :-
1. Van Aanholt 2. Schlupp 3. Souare
However, I think Souare maybe finished at the top level. I was in a car accident last year, and broke my leg and ankle. They have never been as strong as they were before.
I see that he broke his thigh bone and having to be airlifted to hospital means it was bad. With lesser injuries (i.e. hamstring), some players never come back as before.
|
coulsdoneagle London 19 Apr 17 7.07pm |
|
|
Might not be the most popular view but I'm a little disappointed with Schlupp. He definitely seems second choice and is a very decent back up, but I was hoping he would have more of an offensive impact. And he looks pretty light in the tackle. For me PVA is number one with Schlupp a backup, doubt we will see papa for a while.
Still left back looks healthy. It's the other flank that really is the major concern.
|
pssguy 19 Apr 17 7.16pm |
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Might not be the most popular view but I'm a little disappointed with Schlupp. He definitely seems second choice and is a very decent back up, but I was hoping he would have more of an offensive impact. And he looks pretty light in the tackle. For me PVA is number one with Schlupp a backup, doubt we will see papa for a while.
Still left back looks healthy. It's the other flank that really is the major concern.
I'd agree. He turns the ball over too often. If (a big if) Souare is looking good pre-season I would definitely think they should look to ship Schlupp -if we could get back his transfer price - and use the money elsewhere
|
Y Ddraig Goch In The Crowd 19 Apr 17 9.37pm |
|
|
I think PVA is a Left Back whereas Schlupp is more of a winger who can play left back.
the dignified don't even enter in the game
|
rawpalace05 Saltdean 19 Apr 17 10.58pm |
|
|
Haven't read through the posts, however my very brief summary. IMO neither schlupp or pva are complete players, it's like we've spent 25M on two winger-come-full-backs, niether of whom have proved they are defensively sound and niether of whom are likely to ever keep wilf or andros out the wide spots. The signings of both were ways to a means of us staying up, a slight overkill imo with the added bonus of versitilty. I'm not saying neither cannot be decent, or that we were wrong to get them both in(we are after all looking like staying up) however in terms of a left back, pape is superior to both by some margin and a snip at the 3M(?) we paid Lille for him, especially given the fee for the other two! Pape all day in my book, without question. What's the latest on his recovery btw?
1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.
palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
coulsdoneagle London 19 Apr 17 11.29pm |
|
Originally posted by rawpalace05
Haven't read through the posts, however my very brief summary. IMO neither schlupp or pva are complete players, it's like we've spent 25M on two winger-come-full-backs, niether of whom have proved they are defensively sound and niether of whom are likely to ever keep wilf or andros out the wide spots. The signings of both were ways to a means of us staying up, a slight overkill imo with the added bonus of versitilty. I'm not saying neither cannot be decent, or that we were wrong to get them both in(we are after all looking like staying up) however in terms of a left back, pape is superior to both by some margin and a snip at the 3M(?) we paid Lille for him, especially given the fee for the other two! Pape all day in my book, without question. What's the latest on his recovery btw?
I actually rate PVA as a full back but agree re Schlupp. We haven't seen Souare in a while but I always felt him to be a bit rash and again like the other two, better going forward as well. Hopefully with PVA fit, Schlupp can have a chance to impress as a winger hopefully he makes a better winger than fullback.
If only we had the same depth of choice for right back, rather than one who is probably just about good enough for back up.
|
Mstrobez 19 Apr 17 11.32pm |
|
Originally posted by rawpalace05
Haven't read through the posts, however my very brief summary. IMO neither schlupp or pva are complete players, it's like we've spent 25M on two winger-come-full-backs, niether of whom have proved they are defensively sound and niether of whom are likely to ever keep wilf or andros out the wide spots. The signings of both were ways to a means of us staying up, a slight overkill imo with the added bonus of versitilty. I'm not saying neither cannot be decent, or that we were wrong to get them both in(we are after all looking like staying up) however in terms of a left back, pape is superior to both by some margin and a snip at the 3M(?) we paid Lille for him, especially given the fee for the other two! Pape all day in my book, without question. What's the latest on his recovery btw?
IMO I think pretty much every Full back in the world is like that. It's very rare to find one that is very good at doing both the attacking and defensive roles as (like Jamie Carragher once said), a full back is either a failed winger or failed centre half.. I think it's always weighing up what and how much you are willing to sacrifice each ability..
We're the Arthur over ere!
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 20 Apr 17 3.48am |
|
|
Said it before we signed him and repeat gladly - 12 mill. for Schlupp was madness. Big, quick but very little football brain and runs into trouble again and again. PVA any given time...
|
twist Miami, Florida 20 Apr 17 3.53am |
|
|
I think when PVA is given a good run of games, his class is going to show. He has had some good games for us, but others where hes been missing at important times. The Leicester game he had me confused several times.
Souare will fight back for his spot, and will get a good shot at it at some point i am sure.
Schlupp is just a speed merchant with nothing else.
|
crvenaeagle 20 Apr 17 4.19am |
|
|
I think it's safe to say that Pape Soures career, at least at this level of football, is over. Which is a real shame because he truly was a fantastic player for us.
|
sprites Auckland 20 Apr 17 5.01am |
|
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
I think it's safe to say that Pape Soures career, at least at this level of football, is over. Which is a real shame because he truly was a fantastic player for us.
How is it safe to say that at all? We have no idea.
He'd still be by #1 if he came back at the same level. PVA very handy bench player to cover the whole left hand side.
|
Eustace H. Plimsoll Aldershot 20 Apr 17 6.50am |
|
Originally posted by pssguy
I'd agree. He turns the ball over too often. If (a big if) Souare is looking good pre-season I would definitely think they should look to ship Schlupp -if we could get back his transfer price - and use the money elsewhere
Ship sloppy Schlupp?
As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game...
|
Y Ddraig Goch In The Crowd 20 Apr 17 8.33am |
|
Originally posted by twist
I think when PVA is given a good run of games, his class is going to show. He has had some good games for us, but others where hes been missing at important times. The Leicester game he had me confused several times.
Souare will fight back for his spot, and will get a good shot at it at some point i am sure.
Schlupp is just a speed merchant with nothing else.
Souare is the archetypal better he gets the longer he doesn't play.
He did a decent job for us but a lot of fans were calling fro an upgrade before his crash. Him and Schlupp are very similar. PVA a class apart
the dignified don't even enter in the game
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 20 Apr 17 10.04am |
|
|
PVA will be the first choice I think. Souare will be the back up if he can return to his previous level. Schlupp won't be sold because there is a doubt over Souare and whether Wilf will stay in the summer.
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|